Does Addition of Protein to Hepatocyte or Microsomal In Vitro Incubations Provide a Useful Improvement in In Vitro-In Vivo Extrapolation Predictability?

Introducing the Dynamic Well-Stirred Model for Predicting Hepatic Clearance and Extraction Ratio

The well-stirred model (WSM) incorporating the fraction of unbound drug (fu) to account for the effect of plasma binding on intrinsic clearance has been widely used for predicting hepatic clearance under the assumption that drug protein binding reaches equilibrium instantaneously. Our theoretical analysis reveals that the effect of protein binding on intrinsic clearance is better accounted for with the dynamic free fraction (fD), a measure of drug protein binding affinity, which leads to a putative dynamic well-stirred model (dWSM) without the instantaneous equilibrium assumption. Using recombinant CYP3A4 as the in vitro clearance system, we demonstrate that the binding effect of albumin on the intrinsic clearance of both highly bound midazolam and highly free verapamil is fully corrected by their corresponding fD values, respectively. On the other hand, fu only corrects the binding effect of albumin on the intrinsic clearance of verapamil, and yields severe over-correction of the intrinsic clearance of midazolam. The results suggest that the traditional WSM is suitable for highly free drugs like verapamil but not necessarily for highly bound drugs such as midazolam due to the violation of the instantaneous equilibrium assumption or under-estimating the true free drug concentration. In comparison, the dWSM incorporating fD holds true as long as drug elimination follows steady-state kinetics, and hence, it is more broadly applicable to drugs with different protein binding characteristics. Here we demonstrate with 36 diverse drugs, that the dWSM significantly improves the accuracy of predicting human hepatic clearance and liver extraction ratio from in vitro microsomal clearance data, highlighting the importance of drug plasma protein binding kinetics in addressing the under-prediction of hepatic clearance by the WSM.

Prediction of Human Clearance Using In Silico Models with Reduced Bias

Predicting human clearance with high accuracy from in silico-derived parameters alone is highly desirable, as it is fast, saves in vitro resources, and is animal-sparing. We derived random forest (RF) models from 1340 compounds with human intravenous pharmacokinetic (PK) data, the largest data set publicly available today. To assess the general applicability of the RF models, we systematically removed structural-therapeutic class analogues and other compounds with structural similarity from the training sets. For a quasi-prospective test set of 343 compounds, we show that RF models devoid of structurally similar compounds in the training set predict human clearance with a geometric mean fold error (GMFE) of 3.3. While the observed GMFE illustrates how difficult it is to generate a useful model that is broadly applicable, we posit that our RF models yield a more realistic assessment of how well human clearance can be predicted prospectively. We deployed the conformal prediction formalism to assess the model applicability and to determine the prediction confidence intervals for each prediction. We observed that clearance can be predicted better for renally cleared compounds than for other clearance mechanisms. We show that applying a classification model for predicting renal clearance identifies a subset of compounds for which clearance can be predicted with higher accuracy, yielding a GMFE of 2.3. In addition, our in silico RF human clearance models compared well to models derived from scaling human hepatocytes or preclinical in vivo data.

Plasma Protein-Mediated Uptake and Contradictions to the Free Drug Hypothesis: A Critical Review

According to the free drug hypothesis (FDH), only free, unbound drug is available to interact with biological targets. This hypothesis is the fundamental principle that continues to explain the vast majority of all pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic processes. Under the FDH, the free drug concentration at the target site is considered the driver of pharmacodynamic activity and pharmacokinetic processes. However, deviations from the FDH are observed in hepatic uptake and clearance predictions, where observed unbound intrinsic hepatic clearance (CL_int,u) is larger than expected. Such deviations are commonly observed when plasma proteins are present and form the basis of the so-called plasma protein-mediated uptake effect (PMUE). This review will discuss the basis of plasma protein binding as it pertains to hepatic clearance based on the FDH, as well as several hypotheses that may explain the underlying mechanisms of PMUE. Notably, some, but not all, potential mechanisms remained aligned with the FDH. Finally, we will outline possible experimental strategies to elucidate PMUE mechanisms. Understanding the mechanisms of PMUE and its potential contribution to clearance underprediction is vital to improving the drug development process.