Dehydration-enhanced ion-pore interactions dominate anion transport and selectivity in nanochannels

Toward Molecular Simulation Guided Design of Next-Generation Membranes: Challenges and Opportunities

Membranes provide energy-efficient solutions for separating ions from water, ion-ion separation, neutral or charged molecules, and mixed gases. Understanding the fundamental mechanisms and design principles for these separation challenges has significant applications in the food and agriculture, energy, pharmaceutical, and electronics industries and environmental remediation. In situ experimental probes to explore Angstrom-nanometer length-scale and pico-nanosecond time-scale phenomena remain limited. Currently, molecular simulations such as density functional theory, ab initio molecular dynamics (MD), all-atom MD, and coarse-grained MD provide physics-based predictive models to study these phenomena. The status of molecular simulations to study transport mechanisms and state-of-the-art membrane separation is discussed. Furthermore, limitations and open challenges in molecular simulations are discussed. Finally, the importance of molecular simulations in generating data sets for machine learning and exploration of membrane design space is addressed.

Chemistry for water treatment under nanoconfinement

The global freshwater crisis, exacerbated by escalating pollution, poses a significant threat to human health. Addressing this challenge required innovative strategies to develop highly efficient and process-adaptable materials for water decontamination. In this regard, nanomaterials with confinement structures have emerged as a promising solution, outperforming traditional nanomaterials in terms of efficiency, selectivity, stability, and process adaptability, thereby serving as an ideal platform for designing novel functional materials for sustainable water treatment. This Review focuses on recent advancements and employment of nanoconfinement effects in various water treatment processes, emphasizing the fundamental chemistry underlying nanoconfinement effects. Also, the existing knowledge gaps related to nanoconfinement effects and future prospects for expanding their applications in diverse water treatment scenarios are discussed.

Selective acid recovery and metal separation from acid mine drainage using a highly stable vermiculite membrane

Selective ion separation from acid mine drainage (AMD) under extreme acidic conditions presents a critical environmental challenge. While membrane-based technologies show promise for advancing water treatment processes, implementation in AMD treatment requires membranes that combine exceptional acid stability with precise ion sieving capabilities. Inspired by the ion retention characteristics of natural clay minerals, we have developed cation-selective membranes using vermiculite nanosheets as building blocks. The vermiculite membranes (VM) featured high acid stability and well-ordered two-dimensional nanochannels (2 Å), achieving a high H+ permeation rate of 3.24 mol m-2 h-1. The VM demonstrated exceptional selectivity between monovalent and metals ions, with a H+/Fe3+ selectivity factor of 1284 in single-cation transport process. In complex multi-ion environments, the VM maintained stable separation performance, achieving a H+/Fe3+ selectivity of 1000 in mixed solutions containing H+, K+, Na+, Ca2+, Mg2+ and Fe3+. Additionally, VM effectively blocked other common AMD metals, including Cu2+, Co2+, Ni2+ and Mn2+, while maintaining stable separation performance even at extreme low pH values (pH = 1). Through integrated theoretical calculations and experiments, we revealed that the synergistic effects of ultra-confined nanochannels (4∼5 Å) and surface charge created enhanced energy barriers for trivalent ion transport, resulting in high ion selectivity. Beyond providing an effective solution for AMD remediation, this work establishes vermiculite-based membranes as promising candidates for ion separation applications.

Insights into the Electrolyte Hydrolysis and Its Impacts on the Interfacial Chemistry of a Li+-Intercalated Anode during High-Temperature Calendar Aging

Calendar aging occurring during high-temperature storage has long plagued practical realization of long-life, high-safety lithium-ion batteries (LIBs). Generally, the aging process is ascribed to the hydrolysis reaction of fluorine-containing electrolyte salt that generates hydrofluoric acid and chemically corrodes the anode surface. Nevertheless, the underlying mechanism about electrolyte degradation, HF generation and surface corrosion remains concealed for various electrolytes. In this work, we employed in situ liquid time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectroscopy to resolve the chemical evolution during high-temperature calendar aging in the bulk of the electrolyte and at the anode/electrolyte interface. Two conventional salts, LiPF6 and Li bis(fluorosulfonyl)imide (LiFSI), were employed for comparison. We identify that the high-temperature hydrolysis of LiPF6 preferentially occurs when the anion aggregates ([PF6+LiPF6]-) are attacked by trace H2O. HPO2F2, HF and LiF are generated and assist formation of an inorganics-rich solid electrolyte interphase (SEI), improving anode stability against parasitic reactions. The LiFSI-based electrolyte does not involve hydrolysis, which facilities the formation of an organics-rich SEI. Nevertheless, the SEI does not passivate the anode surface and could induce severe corrosions via electron tunneling at a high temperature. Our work offers original insights into rational design of electrolyte and interface for high-energy, long-calendar-life LIBs.

Nanoconfinement Effects in Electrocatalysis and Photocatalysis

Recently, the enzyme-inspired nanoconfinement effect has garnered significant attention for enhancing the efficiency of electrocatalysts and photocatalysts. Despite substantial progress in these fields, there remains a notable absence of comprehensive and insightful articles providing a clear understanding of nanoconfined catalysts. This review addresses this gap by delving into nanoconfined catalysts for electrocatalytic and photocatalytic energy conversion. Initially, the effect of nanoconfinement on the thermodynamics and kinetics of reactions is explored. Subsequently, the primary and secondary structures of nanoconfined catalysts are categorized, their properties are outlined, and typical methods for their construction are summarized. Furthermore, an overview of the state-of-the-art applications of nanoconfined catalysts is provided, focusing on reactions of hydrogen and oxygen evolution, oxygen reduction, carbon dioxide reduction, hydrogen peroxide production, and nitrogen reduction. Finally, the current challenges and future prospects in nanoconfined catalysts are discussed. This review aims to provide in-depth insights and guidelines to advance the development of electrocatalytic and photocatalytic energy conversion technology by nanoconfined catalysts.

Pulsatile Ion Transport in Nanofiltration Membranes Coupled with Electrically Tunable Pore and Hydroxyl Electrostatic Interactions

Pulsatile ion transport facilitates the adjusted transfer of substances, meeting the requirements for the gradient and timed separation of multiple components in membrane processes. Responsive nanofiltration membranes are thus currently receiving widespread attention but face limitations due to their narrow performance adjustment range. Herein, hydroxyl functional groups were introduced into electrically responsive nanofiltration membranes to broaden the adjustment range of separation performance through a combination of pore size sieving and functional group interactions, resulting in a greater change in rejection and flux compared to the original membrane. Membrane pore size is regulated by polypyrrole volume changes and becomes more variable when the cation's hydration radius is smaller. Although the hydroxyl group did not affect the charge transfer or volume change capacity of polypyrrole, it enhanced ion-pore interactions during ion transport, which was particularly pronounced in smaller nanochannels. The size effect of functional group interactions more strongly enhances the transmembrane energy barrier in the reduced state compared with the oxidized state, ultimately resulting in greater modulation of performance. This coupling strategy provides insights into the design of responsive membranes, offering the potential to achieve gradient separation of various solutes.

Advanced characterization of confined electrochemical interfaces in electrochemical capacitors

The advancement of high-performance fast-charging materials has significantly propelled progress in electrochemical capacitors (ECs). Electrochemical capacitors store charges at the nanoscale electrode material-electrolyte interface, where the charge storage and transport mechanisms are mediated by factors such as nanoconfinement, local electrode structure, surface properties and non-electrostatic ion-electrode interactions. This Review offers a comprehensive exploration of probing the confined electrochemical interface using advanced characterization techniques. Unlike classical two-dimensional (2D) planar interfaces, partial desolvation and image charges play crucial roles in effective charge storage under nanoconfinement in porous materials. This Review also highlights the potential of zero charge as a key design principle driving nanoscale ion fluxes and carbon-electrolyte interactions in materials such as 2D and three-dimensional (3D) porous carbons. These considerations are crucial for developing efficient and rapid energy storage solutions for a wide range of applications.

Enhancing Ion Selectivity of Nanofiltration Membranes via Heterogeneous Charge Distribution

Nanofiltration technology holds significant potential for precisely separating monovalent and multivalent ions, such as lithium (Li) and magnesium (Mg) ions, during lithium extraction from salt lakes. This study bridges a crucial gap in understanding the impact of the membrane spatial charge distribution on ion-selective separation. We developed two types of mixed-charge membranes with similar pore sizes but distinct longitudinal and horizontal distributions of oppositely charged domains. The charge-mosaic membrane, synthesized and utilized for ion fractionation for the first time, achieved an exceptional water permeance of 15.4 LMH/bar and a Li/Mg selectivity of 108, outperforming the majority of published reports. Through comprehensive characterization, mathematical modeling, and machine learning methods, we provide evidence that the spatial charge distribution dominantly determines ion selectivity. The charge-mosaic structure excels by substantially promoting ion selectivity through locally enhanced Donnan effects while remaining unaffected by variations in feedwater concentration. Our findings not only demonstrate the applicability of charge-mosaic membranes to precise nanofiltration but also have profound implications for technologies demanding advanced ion selectivity, including those in the sustainable water treatment and energy storage industries.

Sodium-Ion Traps in a Two-Dimensional Confined Channel for Effective Water and Ion Selective Transport

Nanoconfined interlayer channels in two-dimensional (2D) laminates are promising for the construction of novel permselective membranes. Controlling the interlayer spacing and modifying the interlayer chemical microenvironment are effective for high-efficiency separation. However, manipulating ion-diffusion energy barriers in confined channels is challenging, and their role in selective water-ion transport is unclear. This study engineered sodium-ion traps (SITs) in confined graphene oxide (GO) interlayer channels by incorporating N-phenylaza-15-crown-5 (NPCE) to regulate the ion-diffusion energy barriers. Partial reduction of GO enhanced membrane stability and enabled precise adjustment of interlayer spacing, while the addition of NPCE further constricted the free space and entrapped sodium ions by increasing their transport energy barriers. The optimized membrane with NPCE-dominated SITs achieved mono/monovalent-ion efficient sieving (K+/Na+ ≈ 10.2, and Li+/Na+ ≈ 6.7) and rejection of Na2SO4 (∼99.0%) and NaCl (∼90.0%), while maintaining stable performance for >1500 h. The findings provide new insights into manipulating transport energy barriers and modifying other 2D material laminates.

Simultaneous Manipulation of Membrane Enthalpy and Entropy Barriers towards Superior Ion Separations

Sub-nanoporous membranes with ion selective transport functions are important for energy utilization, environmental remediation, and fundamental bioinspired engineering. Although mono/multivalent ions can be separated by monovalent ion selective membranes (MISMs), the current theory fails to inspire rapid advances in MISMs. Here, we apply transition state theory (TST) by regulating the enthalpy barrier (ΔH) and entropy barrier (ΔS) for designing next-generation monovalent cation exchange membranes (MCEMs) with great improvement in ion selective separation. Using a molecule-absorbed porous material as an interlayer to construct a denser selective layer can achieve a greater absolute value of ΔS for Li+ and Mg2+ transport, greater ΔH for Mg2+ transport and lower ΔH for Li+ transport. This recorded performance with a Li+/Mg2+ perm-selectivity of 25.50 and a Li+ flux of 1.86 mol ⋅ m-2 ⋅ h-1 surpasses the contemporary "upper bound" plot for Li+/Mg2+ separations. Most importantly, our synthesized MCEM also demonstrates excellent operational stability during the selective electrodialysis (S-ED) processes for realizing scalability in practical applications.

The Hidden Role of the Dielectric Effect in Nanofiltration: A Novel Perspective to Unravel New Ion Separation Mechanisms

Nanofiltration (NF) membranes play a critical role in separation processes, necessitating an in-depth understanding of their selective mechanisms. Existing NF models predominantly include steric and Donnan mechanisms as primary mechanisms. However, these models often fail in elucidating the NF selectivity between ions of similar dimensions and the same valence. To address this gap, an innovative methodology was proposed to unravel new selective mechanisms by quantifying the nominal dielectric effect isolated from steric and Donnan exclusion through fitted pore dielectric constants by regression analysis. We demonstrated that the nominal dielectric effect encompassed unidentified selective mechanisms of significant relevance by establishing the correlation between the fitted pore dielectric constants and these hindrance factors. Our findings revealed that dehydration-induced ion-membrane interaction, rather than ion dehydration, played a pivotal role in ion partitioning within NF membranes. This interaction was closely linked to the nondeformable fraction of hydrated ions. Further delineation of the dielectric effect showed that favorable interactions between ions and membrane functional groups contributed to entropy-driven selectivity, which is a key factor in explaining ion selectivity differences between ions sharing the same size and valence. This study deepens our understanding of NF selectivity and sheds light on the design of highly selective membranes for water and wastewater treatment.

Ion-Ion Selectivity of Synthetic Membranes with Confined Nanostructures

Synthetic membranes featuring confined nanostructures have emerged as a prominent category of leading materials that can selectively separate target ions from complex water matrices. Further advancements in these membranes will pressingly rely on the ability to elucidate the inherent connection between transmembrane ion permeation behaviors and the ion-selective nanostructures. In this review, we first abstract state-of-the-art nanostructures with a diversity of spatial confinements in current synthetic membranes. Next, the underlying mechanisms that govern ion permeation under the spatial nanoconfinement are analyzed. We then proceed to assess ion-selective membrane materials with a focus on their structural merits that allow ultrahigh selectivity for a wide range of monovalent and divalent ions. We also highlight recent advancements in experimental methodologies for measuring ionic permeability, hydration numbers, and energy barriers to transport. We conclude by putting forth the future research prospects and challenges in the realm of high-performance ion-selective membranes.

Built-in Electric Fields in Heterostructured Lamellar Membranes Enable Highly Efficient Rejection of Charged Mass

Separation membranes with homogeneous charge channels are the mainstream to reject charged mass by forming electrical double layer (EDL). However, the EDL often compresses effective solvent transport space and weakens channel-ion interaction. Here, built-in electric fields (BIEFs) are constructed in lamellar membranes by assembling the heterostructured nanosheets, which contain alternate positively-charged nanodomains and negatively-charged nanodomains. We demonstrate that the BIEFs are perpendicular to horizontal channel and the direction switches alternately, significantly weakening the EDL effect and forces ions to repeatedly collide with channel walls. Thus, highly efficient rejection for charged mass (salts, dyes, and organic acids/bases) and ultrafast water transport are achieved. Moreover, for desalination on four-stage filtration option, salt rejection reaches 99.9 % and water permeance reaches 19.2 L m-2 h-1 bar-1. Such mass transport behavior is quite different from that in homogeneous charge channels. Furthermore, the ion transport behavior in nanochannels is elucidated by validating horizontal projectile motion model.

Response of Ionic Hydration Structure and Selective Transport Behavior to Aqueous Solution Chemistry during Nanofiltration

The effect of aqueous solution chemistry on the ionic hydration structure and its corresponding nanofiltration (NF) selectivity is a research gap concerning ion-selective transport. In this study, the hydration distribution of two typical monovalent anions (Cl- and NO3-) under different aqueous solution chemical conditions and the corresponding transmembrane selectivity during NF were investigated by using in situ liquid time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry in combination with molecular dynamics simulations. We demonstrate the inextricable link between the ion hydration structure and the pore steric effect and further find that ionic transmembrane transport can be regulated by breaking the balance between the hydrogen bond network (i.e., water-water) and ion hydration (i.e., ion-water) interactions of hydrated ion. For strongly hydrated (H2O)nCl- with more intense ion-water interactions, a higher salt concentration and coexisting ion competition led to a larger hydrated size and, thus, a higher ion rejection by the NF membrane, whereas weakly hydrated (H2O)nNO3- takes the reverse under the same conditions. Stronger OH--anion hydration competition resulted in a smaller hydrated size of (H2O)nCl- and (H2O)nNO3-, showing a lower observed average hydration number at pH 10.5. This study deepens the long-overlooked understanding of NF separation mechanisms, concerning the hydration structure.

Electrostatic-induced ion-confined partitioning in graphene nanolaminate membrane for breaking anion-cation co-transport to enhance desalination

Constructing nanolaminate membranes made of two-dimensional graphene oxide nanosheets has gained enormous interest in recent decades. However, a key challenge facing current graphene-based membranes is their poor rejection for monovalent salts due to the swelling-induced weak nanoconfinement and the transmembrane co-transport of anions and cations. Herein, we propose a strategy of electrostatic-induced ion-confined partitioning in a reduced graphene oxide membrane for breaking the correlation of anions and cations to suppress anion-cation co-transport, substantially improving the desalination performance. The membrane demonstrates a rejection of 95.5% for NaCl with a water permeance of 48.6 L m-2 h-1 bar-1 in pressure-driven process, and it also exhibits a salt rejection of 99.7% and a water flux of 47.0 L m-2 h-1 under osmosis-driven condition, outperforming the performance of reported graphene-based membranes. The simulation and calculation results unveil that the strong electrostatic attraction of membrane forces the hydrated Na+ to undergo dehydration and be exclusively confined in the nanochannels, strengthening the intra-nanochannel anion/cation partitioning, which refrains from the dynamical anion-cation correlations and thereby prevents anions and cations from co-transporting through the membrane. This study provides guidance for designing advanced desalination membranes and inspires the future development of membrane-based separation technologies.

Precision ion separation via self-assembled channels

Selective nanofiltration membranes with accurate molecular sieving offer a solution to recover rare metals and other valuable elements from brines. However, the development of membranes with precise sub-nanometer pores is challenging. Here, we report a scalable approach for membrane fabrication in which functionalized macrocycles are seamlessly oriented via supramolecular interactions during the interfacial polycondensation on a polyacrylonitrile support layer. The rational incorporation of macrocycles enables the formation of nanofilms with self-assembled channels holding precise molecular sieving capabilities and a threshold of 6.6 ångström, which corresponds to the macrocycle cavity size. The resulting membranes provide a 100-fold increase in selectivity for Li+/Mg2+ separation, outperforming commercially available and state-of-the-art nanocomposite membranes for lithium recovery. Their performance is further assessed in high-recovery tests under realistic nanofiltration conditions using simulated brines or concentrated seawater with various Li+ levels and demonstrates their remarkable potential in ion separation and Li+ recovery applications.

Advancing Ion Selective Membranes with Micropore Ion Channels in the Interaction Confinement Regime

Ion exchange membranes allowing the passage of charge-carrying ions have established their critical role in water, environmental, and energy-relevant applications. The design strategies for high-performance ion exchange membranes have evolved beyond creating microphase-separated membrane morphologies, which include advanced ion exchange membranes to ion-selective membranes. The properties and functions of ion-selective membranes have been repeatedly updated by the emergence of materials with subnanometer-sized pores and the understanding of ion movement under confined micropore ion channels. These research progresses have motivated researchers to consider even greater aims in the field, i.e., replicating the functions of ion channels in living cells with exotic materials or at least targeting fast and ion-specific transmembrane conduction. To help realize such goals, we briefly outline and comment on the fundamentals of rationally designing membrane pore channels for ultrafast and specific ion conduction, pore architecture/chemistry, and membrane materials. Challenges are discussed, and perspectives and outlooks are given.

In situ regulation of selectivity and permeability by electrically tuning pore size in trans-membrane ion process

Regulating ion transport behavior through pore size variation is greatly attractive for membrane to meet the need for precise separation, but fabricating nanofiltration (NF) membranes with tunable pore size remains a huge challenge. Herein, a NF membrane with electrically tunable pores was fabricated by intercalating polypyrrole into reduced graphene oxide interlayers. As the potential switches from reduction to oxidation, the membrane pore size shrinks by 11%, resulting in a 16.2% increase in salt rejection. The membrane pore size expands/contracts at redox potentials due to the polypyrrole volume swelling/shrinking caused by the insertion/desertion of cations, respectively. In terms of the inserted cation, Na+ and K+ induce larger pore-size stretching range for the membrane than Ca2+ due to greater binding energy and larger doping amount. Such an electrical response characteristic remained stable after multiple cycles and enabled application in ion selective separation; e.g., the Na+/Mg2+ separation factor in the reduced state is increased by 41% compared to that in the oxide state. This work provides electrically tunable nanochannels for high-precision separation applications such as valuable substance purification and resource recovery from wastewater.