Critique of extracellular space measurements with small ions: Na24 and Br82 spaces

The 'third space'--fact or fiction?

For decades, the 'third space' was looked upon as an actively consuming compartment. Therefore, perioperative fluid regimens were traditionally based on a generous replacement of this assumed primary loss, in addition to deficits due to insensible perspiration and fasting. The practical consequence was an extremely positive fluid balance in order to maintain blood volume during major surgery. Whereas the insensible perspiration and the preoperative deficits are in fact often negligible, and the third space appears to be only a fictional construct, the excess fluid most likely accumulates interstitially. Such shifting is related to a destruction of the endothelial glycocalyx, a key structure of the vascular barrier, by traumatic inflammation and iatrogenic hypervolaemia. This explains why patients undergoing major surgical interventions benefit significantly from an infusion regimen which does not substitute but avoids 'third-space shifting'. In summary, eradicating this notion from our minds could be a further key to achieving perioperative fluid optimisation.

Hemorrhage and operation cause a contraction of the extracellular space needing replacement—evidence and implications? A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Hemorrhagic hypotension or operative trauma is believed to cause a contraction of the extracellular fluid volume (ECV) beyond the measured fluid losses. The aim of this review was to explore the evidence and implications of ECV loss.

METHODS

We performed a systematic review of original trials measuring ECV changes during hemorrhage or operation. PubMed, relevant periodicals, and reference lists were searched until no further original articles appeared. The quality of both the scientific and the technical methods of the trials were evaluated.

RESULTS

A total of 61 original articles were found. The pattern appeared that all investigators reporting shock or operation to cause a disparate reduction of the ECV had measured the ECV with the same method. The ECV was calculated from very few blood samples that were withdrawn after 20 to 30 minutes of equilibration of a tracer (the (35)SO(4)-tracer). Trials calculating ECV from multiple blood samples, after longer equilibration times, or using other tracers did not find a contraction of the ECV. On the contrary, trials using a bromide tracer found the ECV to be expanded after operation.

CONCLUSIONS

The evidence supporting the idea that hemorrhage or operation cause a contraction of the ECV is weak, and probably a result of flawed methodology.

Total body electrolyte composition and distribution of body water in uremia

Total body sodium and chloride were measured by neutron activation analysis, and total body potassium was measured by whole body counting in ten male patients with endstage renal disease requiring chronic maintenance hemodialysis. The extracellular fluid volume was estimated from the simultaneously measured volume of distribution of bromine 77 and sodium 24. Total body water was estimated from the volume of distribution of triated water. Total body sodium and chloride were significantly increased above normal measured values, but total body potassium was not significantly different from normal. The increase in total body sodium could be attributed to an increase in exchangeable sodium because no significant change in the nonexchangeable portion of total body sodium could be detected. Extracellular fluid volume, estimated fro three different techniques (total body chloride, sodium 24, and bromine 77), and total body water were increased significantly above normal values. Extracellular fluid volume was correlated with exchangeable sodium, and total body water was closely correlated with total cation content (exchangeable sodium and total body potassium). The calculated intracellular fluid volume was decreased and was closely correlated with total body potassium. Despite adequate control of uremia by chronic maintenance hemodijalysis, body electrolyte composition and the distribution of body water remain significantly different from normal.

Nutritional aspects of body water dislocations in postoperative and depleted patients

Measurements of plasma volume with 125I human serum albumin, extracellular water (ECW) with 82Br-minus, and total body water (TBW) with 3-H2O were made on 16 postoperative patients, 15 depleted patients, and three control subjects. Intracellular water (ICW) was calculated as the difference between TBW and ECW. The observed findings for the series as a whole showed no change in blood volume, an increase of 3.7 I in ECW, and a decrease of 1.5 I in ICW as compared to predicted values based on current weight. Compared to predicted values based on normal (pre-illness) weight, the observed body weight decreased 16% and ICW decreased 22%; this suggests that body weight consistently under-estimates the extent of nutritional depletion. Severe depletion seen in postoperative patients indicates that frequently earlier use of total parenteral nutrition would be beneficial. ICW was found to be the most reliable single index of moderate or severe nutritional depletion; errors in estimating normal values interfere with its use in mild depletion. The ratio of ECW:TBW best reflects distortion of body water composition; it is largely independent of weight, and is a more sensitive index than absolute values of ICW. Repeat measurements of body composition were made on 9 patients given total parenteral nutrition for an average period of 18 days. On the average, there was an ECW decrease of 1.8 I, a body weight increase of 2 kg, and an ICW increase of 3.2 I after parenteral nutrition. The increased ICW represents the repletion of half of the average initial deficit of 6.1 The initial ratio of ECW:TBW of 0.58 was reduced to 0.50, returning it about three-quarters of the way to the expected normal value of 0.48. Intravenous administration of 5% glucose as sole source of calories may be a factor in distortion of body water compartments.