Simple synthetic protein scaffolds can create adjustable artificial MAPK circuits in yeast and mammalian cells

Engineering signalling pathways in mammalian cells

In mammalian cells, signalling pathways orchestrate cellular growth, differentiation and survival, as well as many other processes that are essential for the proper functioning of cells. Here we describe cutting-edge genetic-engineering technologies for the rewiring of signalling networks in mammalian cells. Specifically, we describe the recombination of native pathway components, cross-kingdom pathway transplantation, and the development of de novo signalling within cells and organelles. We also discuss how, by designing signalling pathways, mammalian cells can acquire new properties, such as the capacity for photosynthesis, the ability to detect cancer and senescent cell markers or to synthesize hormones or metabolites in response to chemical or physical stimuli. We also review the applications of mammalian cells in biocomputing. Technologies for engineering signalling pathways in mammalian cells are advancing basic cellular biology, biomedical research and drug discovery.

Scaffold proteins as dynamic integrators of biological processes

Scaffold proteins act as molecular hubs for the docking of multiple proteins to organize efficient functional units for signaling cascades. Over 300 human proteins have been characterized as scaffolds, acting in a variety of signaling pathways. While the term scaffold implies a static, supportive platform, it is now clear that scaffolds are not simply inert docking stations but can undergo conformational changes that affect their dependent signaling pathways. In this review, we catalog scaffold proteins that have been shown to undergo actionable conformational changes, with a focus on the role that conformational change plays in the activity of the classic yeast scaffold STE5, as well as three human scaffold proteins (KSR, NEMO, SHANK3) that are integral to well-known signaling pathways (RAS, NF-κB, postsynaptic density). We also discuss scaffold protein conformational changes vis-à-vis liquid-liquid phase separation. Changes in scaffold structure have also been implicated in human disease, and we discuss how aberrant conformational changes may be involved in disease-related dysregulation of scaffold and signaling functions. Finally, we discuss how understanding these conformational dynamics will provide insight into the flexibility of signaling cascades and may enhance our ability to treat scaffold-associated diseases.

Switchable Control of Scaffold Protein Activity via Engineered Phosphoregulated Autoinhibition

Scaffold proteins operate as organizing hubs to enable high-fidelity signaling, fulfilling crucial roles in the regulation of cellular processes. Bottom-up construction of controllable scaffolding platforms is attractive for the implementation of regulatory processes in synthetic biology. Here, we present a modular and switchable synthetic scaffolding system, integrating scaffold-mediated signaling with switchable kinase/phosphatase input control. Phosphorylation-responsive inhibitory peptide motifs were fused to 14-3-3 proteins to generate dimeric protein scaffolds with appended regulatory peptide motifs. The availability of the scaffold for intermolecular partner protein binding could be lowered up to 35-fold upon phosphorylation of the autoinhibition motifs, as demonstrated using three different kinases. In addition, a hetero-bivalent autoinhibitory platform design allowed for dual-kinase input regulation of scaffold activity. Reversibility of the regulatory platform was illustrated through phosphatase-controlled abrogation of autoinhibition, resulting in full recovery of 14-3-3 scaffold activity.

The optimal docking strength for reversibly tethered kinases

Many kinases use reversible docking interactions to augment the specificity of their catalytic domains. Such docking interactions are often structurally independent of the catalytic domain, which allow for a flexible combination of modules in evolution and in bioengineering. The affinity of docking interactions spans several orders of magnitude. This led us to ask how the affinity of the docking interaction affects enzymatic activity and how to pick the optimal interaction module to complement a given substrate. Here, we develop equations that predict the optimal binding strength of a kinase docking interaction and validate it using numerical simulations and steady-state phosphorylation kinetics for tethered protein kinase A. We show that a kinase-substrate pair has an optimum docking strength that depends on their enzymatic constants, the tether architecture, the substrate concentration, and the kinetics of the docking interactions. We show that a reversible tether enhances phosphorylation rates most when 1) the docking strength is intermediate, 2) the substrate is nonoptimal, 3) the substrate concentration is low, 4) the docking interaction has rapid exchange kinetics, and 5) the tether optimizes the effective concentration of the intramolecular reaction. This work serves as a framework for interpreting mutations in kinase docking interactions and as a design guide for engineering enzyme scaffolds.

Programmable protein circuit design

A fundamental challenge in synthetic biology is to create molecular circuits that can program complex cellular functions. Because proteins can bind, cleave, and chemically modify one another and interface directly and rapidly with endogenous pathways, they could extend the capabilities of synthetic circuits beyond what is possible with gene regulation alone. However, the very diversity that makes proteins so powerful also complicates efforts to harness them as well-controlled synthetic circuit components. Recent work has begun to address this challenge, focusing on principles such as orthogonality and composability that permit construction of diverse circuit-level functions from a limited set of engineered protein components. These approaches are now enabling the engineering of circuits that can sense, transmit, and process information; dynamically control cellular behaviors; and enable new therapeutic strategies, establishing a powerful paradigm for programming biology.

A platform for post-translational spatiotemporal control of cellular proteins

Mammalian cells process information through coordinated spatiotemporal regulation of proteins. Engineering cellular networks thus relies on efficient tools for regulating protein levels in specific subcellular compartments. To address the need to manipulate the extent and dynamics of protein localization, we developed a platform technology for the target-specific control of protein destination. This platform is based on bifunctional molecules comprising a target-specific nanobody and universal sequences determining target subcellular localization or degradation rate. We demonstrate that nanobody-mediated localization depends on the expression level of the target and the nanobody, and the extent of target subcellular localization can be regulated by combining multiple target-specific nanobodies with distinct localization or degradation sequences. We also show that this platform for nanobody-mediated target localization and degradation can be regulated transcriptionally and integrated within orthogonal genetic circuits to achieve the desired temporal control over spatial regulation of target proteins. The platform reported in this study provides an innovative tool to control protein subcellular localization, which will be useful to investigate protein function and regulate large synthetic gene circuits.

Designed Asymmetric Protein Assembly on a Symmetric Scaffold

Cellular signaling is regulated by the assembly of proteins into higher-order complexes. Bottom-up creation of synthetic protein assemblies, especially asymmetric complexes, is highly challenging. Presented here is the design and implementation of asymmetric assembly of a ternary protein complex facilitated by Rosetta modeling and thermodynamic analysis. The wild-type symmetric CT32-CT32 interface of the 14-3-3-CT32 complex was targeted, ultimately favoring asymmetric assembly on the 14-3-3 scaffold. Biochemical studies, supported by mass-balance models, allowed characterization of the parameters driving asymmetric assembly. Importantly, our work reveals that both the individual binding affinities and cooperativity between the assembling components are crucial when designing higher-order protein complexes. Enzyme complementation on the 14-3-3 scaffold highlighted that interface engineering of a symmetric ternary complex generates asymmetric protein complexes with new functions.

Conjugated Protein Domains as Engineered Scaffold Proteins

Assembly of proteins into higher-order complexes generates specificity and selectivity in cellular signaling. Signaling complex formation is facilitated by scaffold proteins that use modular scaffolding domains, which recruit specific pathway enzymes. Multimerization and recombination of these conjugated native domains allows the generation of libraries of engineered multidomain scaffold proteins. Analysis of these engineered proteins has provided molecular insight into the regulatory mechanism of the native scaffold proteins and the applicability of these synthetic variants. This topical review highlights the use of engineered, conjugated multidomain scaffold proteins on different length scales in the context of synthetic signaling pathways, metabolic engineering, liquid-liquid phase separation, and hydrogel formation.

The Relationship between Effective Molarity and Affinity Governs Rate Enhancements in Tethered Kinase-Substrate Reactions

Scaffold proteins are thought to accelerate protein phosphorylation reactions by tethering kinases and substrates together, but there is little quantitative data on their functional effects. To assess the contribution of tethering to kinase reactivity, we compared intramolecular and intermolecular kinase reactions in a minimal model system. We found that tethering can enhance reaction rates in a flexible tethered kinase system and that the magnitude of the effect is sensitive to the structure of the tether. The largest effective molarity we obtained was ∼0.08 μM, which is much lower than the effects observed in small molecule model systems and other tethered protein reactions. We further demonstrated that the tethered intramolecular reaction only makes a significant contribution to the observed rates when the scaffolded complex assembles at concentrations below the effective molarity. These findings provide a quantitative framework that can be applied to understand endogenous protein scaffolds and engineer synthetic networks.

Engineering Synthetic Signaling in Plants

Synthetic signaling is a branch of synthetic biology that aims to understand native genetic regulatory mechanisms and to use these insights to engineer interventions and devices that achieve specified design parameters. Applying synthetic signaling approaches to plants offers the promise of mitigating the worst effects of climate change and providing a means to engineer crops for entirely novel environments, such as those in space travel. The ability to engineer new traits using synthetic signaling methods will require standardized libraries of biological parts and methods to assemble them; the decoupling of complex processes into simpler subsystems; and mathematical models that can accelerate the design-build-test-learn cycle. The field of plant synthetic signaling is relatively new, but it is poised for rapid advancement. Translation from the laboratory to the field is likely to be slowed, however, by the lack of constructive dialogue between researchers and other stakeholders.

Hysteretic Genetic Circuit for Detection of Proteasomal Degradation in Mammalian Cells

Synthetic hysteretic mammalian gene circuits generating sustained cellular responses to transient perturbations provide important tools to investigate complex cellular behaviors and reprogram cells for a variety of applications, ranging from protein production to cell fate decisions. The design rules of synthetic gene circuits with controlled hysteretic behaviors, however, remain uncharacterized. To identify the criteria for achieving predictable control of hysteresis, we built a genetic circuit for detection of proteasomal degradation (Hys-Deg). The Hys-Deg circuit is based on a tetracycline-controlled transactivator (tTA) variant engineered to interface with the ubiquitin proteasome system (UPS). The tTA variant activates its own expression, generating a positive feedback loop that is triggered by expression of another tTA gene that is constitutively regulated. Guided by predictive modeling, we characterized the hysteretic response of the Hys-Deg circuit. We demonstrated that control of the hysteretic response is achieved by modulating the ratio of expression of constitutive to inducible tTA. We also showed that the system can be finely tuned through dosage of the inducer tetracycline to calibrate the circuit for detection of the desired levels of UPS activation. This study establishes the design rules for building a hysteretic genetic circuit with an autoregulatory feedback loop and provides a synthetic memory module that could be easily integrated into regulatory gene networks to study and engineer complex cellular behaviors.

Dynamic metabolic solutions to the sessile life style of plants

Plants are sessile organisms. To compensate for not being able to escape when challenged by unfavorable growth conditions, pests or herbivores, plants have perfected their metabolic plasticity by having developed the capacity for on demand dynamic biosynthesis and storage of a plethora of phytochemicals.

Covering: up to 2018

Plants are sessile organisms. To compensate for not being able to escape when challenged by unfavorable growth conditions, pests or herbivores, plants have perfected their metabolic plasticity by having developed the capacity for on demand synthesis of a plethora of phytochemicals to specifically respond to the challenges arising during plant ontogeny. Key steps in the biosynthesis of phytochemicals are catalyzed by membrane-bound cytochrome P450 enzymes which in plants constitute a superfamily. In planta, the P450s may be organized in dynamic enzyme clusters (metabolons) and the genes encoding the P450s and other enzymes in a specific pathway may be clustered. Metabolon formation facilitates transfer of substrates between sequential enzymes and therefore enables the plant to channel the flux of general metabolites towards biosynthesis of specific phytochemicals. In the plant cell, compartmentalization of the operation of specific biosynthetic pathways in specialized plastids serves to avoid undesired metabolic cross-talk and offers distinct storage sites for molar concentrations of specific phytochemicals. Liquid–liquid phase separation may lead to formation of dense biomolecular condensates within the cytoplasm or vacuole allowing swift activation of the stored phytochemicals as required upon pest or herbivore attack. The molecular grid behind plant plasticity offers an endless reservoir of functional modules, which may be utilized as a synthetic biology tool-box for engineering of novel biological systems based on rational design principles. In this review, we highlight some of the concepts used by plants to coordinate biosynthesis and storage of phytochemicals.

Ultrahigh specificity in a network of computationally designed protein-interaction pairs

Protein networks in all organisms comprise homologous interacting pairs. In these networks, some proteins are specific, interacting with one or a few binding partners, whereas others are multispecific and bind a range of targets. We describe an algorithm that starts from an interacting pair and designs dozens of new pairs with diverse backbone conformations at the binding site as well as new binding orientations and sequences. Applied to a high-affinity bacterial pair, the algorithm results in 18 new ones, with cognate affinities from pico- to micromolar. Three pairs exhibit 3-5 orders of magnitude switch in specificity relative to the wild type, whereas others are multispecific, collectively forming a protein-interaction network. Crystallographic analysis confirms design accuracy, including in new backbones and polar interactions. Preorganized polar interaction networks are responsible for high specificity, thus defining design principles that can be applied to program synthetic cellular interaction networks of desired affinity and specificity.

The molecular basis of ultrahigh specificity in protein-protein interactions remains obscure. The authors present a computational method to design atomically accurate new pairs exhibiting >100,000-fold specificity switches, generating a large and complex interaction network.

Synthetic biology toolkits and applications in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Synthetic biologists construct biological components and systems to look into biological phenomena and drive a myriad of practical applications that aim to tackle current global challenges in energy, healthcare and the environment. While most tools have been established in bacteria, particularly Escherichia coli, recent years have seen parallel developments in the model yeast strain Saccharomyces cerevisiae, one of the most well-understood eukaryotic biological system. Here, we outline the latest advances in yeast synthetic biology tools based on a framework of abstraction hierarchies of parts, circuits and genomes. In brief, the creation and characterization of biological parts are explored at the transcriptional, translational and post-translational levels. Using characterized parts as building block units, the designing of functional circuits is elaborated with examples. In addition, the status and potential applications of synthetic genomes as a genome level platform for biological system construction are also discussed. In addition to the development of a toolkit, we describe how those tools have been applied in the areas of drug production and screening, study of disease mechanisms, pollutant sensing and bioremediation. Finally, we provide a future outlook of yeast as a workhorse of eukaryotic genetics and a chosen chassis in this field.

Molecular tools for pathway engineering in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Molecular tools for the regulation of protein expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae have contributed to rapid advances in pathway engineering for this yeast. This review considers new and enhanced additions to this toolbox, focusing on experimental approaches to modulate enzyme synthesis and enzyme fate. Methods for genome engineering, regulation of transcription, post-translational protein localization, and combinatorial screening and sensing in S. cerevisiae are highlighted, and promising new approaches are introduced.

Synthetic Gene Expression Circuits for Designing Precision Tools in Oncology

Precision medicine in oncology needs to enhance its capabilities to match diagnostic and therapeutic technologies to individual patients. Synthetic biology streamlines the design and construction of functionalized devices through standardization and rational engineering of basic biological elements decoupled from their natural context. Remarkable improvements have opened the prospects for the availability of synthetic devices of enhanced mechanism clarity, robustness, sensitivity, as well as scalability and portability, which might bring new capabilities in precision cancer medicine implementations. In this review, we begin by presenting a brief overview of some of the major advances in the engineering of synthetic genetic circuits aimed to the control of gene expression and operating at the transcriptional, post-transcriptional/translational, and post-translational levels. We then focus on engineering synthetic circuits as an enabling methodology for the successful establishment of precision technologies in oncology. We describe significant advancements in our capabilities to tailor synthetic genetic circuits to specific applications in tumor diagnosis, tumor cell- and gene-based therapy, and drug delivery.

Small-Molecule-Induced and Cooperative Enzyme Assembly on a 14-3-3 Scaffold

Scaffold proteins regulate cell signalling by promoting the proximity of putative interaction partners. Although they are frequently applied in cellular settings, fundamental understanding of them in terms of, amongst other factors, quantitative parameters has been lagging behind. Here we present a scaffold protein platform that is based on the native 14-3-3 dimeric protein and is controllable through the action of a small-molecule compound, thus permitting study in an in vitro setting and mathematical description. Robust small-molecule regulation of caspase-9 activity through induced dimerisation on the 14-3-3 scaffold was demonstrated. The individual parameters of this system were precisely determined and used to develop a mathematical model of the scaffolding concept. This model was used to elucidate the strong cooperativity of the enzyme activation mediated by the 14-3-3 scaffold. This work provides an entry point for the long-needed quantitative insights into scaffold protein functioning and paves the way for the optimal use of reengineered 14-3-3 proteins as chemically inducible scaffolds in synthetic systems.

Mammalian synthetic biology for studying the cell

Synthetic biology is advancing the design of genetic devices that enable the study of cellular and molecular biology in mammalian cells. These genetic devices use diverse regulatory mechanisms to both examine cellular processes and achieve precise and dynamic control of cellular phenotype. Synthetic biology tools provide novel functionality to complement the examination of natural cell systems, including engineered molecules with specific activities and model systems that mimic complex regulatory processes. Continued development of quantitative standards and computational tools will expand capacities to probe cellular mechanisms with genetic devices to achieve a more comprehensive understanding of the cell. In this study, we review synthetic biology tools that are being applied to effectively investigate diverse cellular processes, regulatory networks, and multicellular interactions. We also discuss current challenges and future developments in the field that may transform the types of investigation possible in cell biology.

Rewiring MAP kinases in Saccharomyces cerevisiae to regulate novel targets through ubiquitination

Evolution has often copied and repurposed the mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK) signaling module. Understanding how connections form during evolution, in disease and across individuals requires knowledge of the basic tenets that govern kinase-substrate interactions. We identify criteria sufficient for establishing regulatory links between a MAPK and a non-native substrate. The yeast MAPK Fus3 and human MAPK ERK2 can be functionally redirected if only two conditions are met: the kinase and substrate contain matching interaction domains and the substrate includes a phospho-motif that can be phosphorylated by the kinase and recruit a downstream effector. We used a panel of interaction domains and phosphorylation-activated degradation motifs to demonstrate modular and scalable retargeting. We applied our approach to reshape the signaling behavior of an existing kinase pathway. Together, our results demonstrate that a MAPK can be largely defined by its interaction domains and compatible phospho-motifs and provide insight into how MAPK-substrate connections form.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.15200.001

Nature has evolved a number of ways to link signals from a cell’s environment, like the concentration of a hormone, to the behavior of that cell. These new connections often form by reusing certain common signaling components, such as mitogen-activated protein kinases. These enzymes – referred to as MAPKs for short – are activated by specific signals and alter the activity of target proteins in the cell by adding a phosphate group to them: a process called phosphorylation. These connections thus dictate how cells respond to their environments – and consequently, disruptions to the connections are a common source of disease.

Groves, Khakhar et al. set out to understand how connections can be made between a MAPK and a new target protein to gain insights into how these links emerge through evolution and how they might break in disease. Their approach focused on one of the ways that phosphorylation can alter the activity of a target protein: marking it for degradation. Experiments with budding yeast showed that a MAPK could only achieve this if two conditions are met. First, the target protein and kinase need to bind to each other. Second, the target needs to contain a site that when phosphorylated is subsequently recognized by the cell’s protein degradation machinery.

By engineering proteins so that they fulfilled these two criteria, Groves, Khakhar et al. created new connections between a yeast MAPK called Fus3 or a human MAPK called ERK2 and a variety of targets. The results showed that the parts of the proteins involved in the interaction step could be completely separate from the parts that are involved in the phosphorylation step. This suggests that connections between kinases and their targets can be rewired simple by mixing together parts of other existing proteins. Finally, Groves, Khakhar et al. confirmed that engineered connections between kinases and targets could predictably change how yeast cells responded to a hormone that normally controls the yeast’s reproductive cycle.

Together these results bring us one step closer to understanding how cells assemble the signaling pathways that they use to process information. However further work is needed to see if these findings can be generalized to other signaling components, and if so, to explore if new connections can be built to yield more complicated cellular behaviors.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.15200.002

Modular engineering of cellular signaling proteins and networks

Living cells respond to their environment using networks of signaling molecules that act as sensors, information processors, and actuators. These signaling systems are highly modular at both the molecular and network scales, and much evidence suggests that evolution has harnessed this modularity to rewire and generate new physiological behaviors. Conversely, we are now finding that, following nature's example, signaling modules can be recombined to form synthetic tools for monitoring, interrogating, and controlling the behavior of cells. Here we highlight recent progress in the modular design of synthetic receptors, optogenetic switches, and phospho-regulated proteins and circuits, and discuss the expanding role of combinatorial design in the engineering of cellular signaling proteins and networks.

RNA and RNP as Building Blocks for Nanotechnology and Synthetic Biology

Recent technologies that aimed to elucidate cellular function have revealed essential roles for RNA molecules in living systems. Our knowledge concerning functional and structural information of naturally occurring RNA and RNA-protein (RNP) complexes is increasing rapidly. RNA and RNP interaction motifs are structural units that function as building blocks to constitute variety of complex structures. RNA-central synthetic biology and nanotechnology are constructive approaches that employ the accumulated information and build synthetic RNA (RNP)-based circuits and nanostructures. Here, we describe how to design and construct synthetic RNA (RNP)-based devices and structures at the nanometer-scale for biological and future therapeutic applications. RNA/RNP nanostructures can also be utilized as the molecular scaffold to control the localization or interactions of target molecule(s). Moreover, RNA motifs recognized by RNA-binding proteins can be applied to make protein-responsive translational "switches" that can turn gene expression "on" or "off" depending on the intracellular environment. This "synthetic RNA and RNP world" will expand tools for nanotechnology and synthetic biology. In addition, these reconstructive approaches would lead to a greater understanding of building principle in naturally occurring RNA/RNP molecules and systems.

Adjustable under-expression of yeast mating pathway proteins in Saccharomyces cerevisiae using a programmed ribosomal frameshift

Experimental research in molecular biology frequently relies on the promotion or suppression of gene expression, an important tool in the study of its functions. Although yeast is among the most studied model systems with the ease of maintenance and manipulation, current experimental methods are mostly limited to gene deletion, suppression or overexpression of genes. Therefore, the ability to reduce protein expressions and then observing the effects would promote a better understanding of the exact functions and their interactions. Reducing protein expression is mainly limited by the difficulties associated with controlling the reduction level, and in some cases, the initial endogenous abundance is too low. For the under-expression to be useful as an experimental tool, repeatability and stability of reduced expression is important. We found that cis-elements in programmed -1 ribosomal frameshifting (-1RFS) of beet western yellow virus (BWYV) could be utilized to reduced protein expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The two main advantages of using -1RFS are adjustable reduction rates and ease of use. To demonstrate the utility of this under-expression system, examples of reduced protein abundance were shown using yeast mating pathway components. The abundance of MAP kinase Fus3 was reduced to approximately 28-75 % of the wild-type value. Other MAP kinase mating pathway components, including Ste5, Ste11, and Ste7, were also under-expressed to verify that the -1RFS system works with different proteins. Furthermore, reduced Fus3 abundance altered the overall signal transduction outcome of the mating pathway, demonstrating the potential for further studies of signal transduction adjustment via under-expression.

Science Signaling Podcast for 5 January 2016: New directions in signaling research

Science Signaling editors discuss the current state of signal transduction research and the journal's place in this dynamic landscape.