How a mutation in the gene encoding sigma 70 suppresses the defective heat shock response caused by a mutation in the gene encoding sigma 32

Modulation of the E. coli rpoH Temperature Sensor with Triptycene-Based Small Molecules

Regulation of the heat shock response (HSR) is essential in all living systems. In E. coli, the HSR is regulated by an alternative σ factor, σ(32) , which is encoded by the rpoH gene. The mRNA of rpoH adopts a complex secondary structure that is critical for the proper translation of the σ(32) protein. At low temperatures, the rpoH gene transcript forms a highly structured mRNA containing several three-way junctions, including a rare perfectly paired three-way junction (3WJ). This complex secondary structure serves as a primitive but highly effective strategy for the thermal control of gene expression. In this work, the first small-molecule modulators of the E. coli σ(32) mRNA temperature sensor are reported.

A model for sigma factor competition in bacterial cells

Sigma factors control global switches of the genetic expression program in bacteria. Different sigma factors compete for binding to a limited pool of RNA polymerase (RNAP) core enzymes, providing a mechanism for cross-talk between genes or gene classes via the sharing of expression machinery. To analyze the contribution of sigma factor competition to global changes in gene expression, we develop a theoretical model that describes binding between sigma factors and core RNAP, transcription, non-specific binding to DNA and the modulation of the availability of the molecular components. The model is validated by comparison with in vitro competition experiments, with which excellent agreement is found. Transcription is affected via the modulation of the concentrations of the different types of holoenzymes, so saturated promoters are only weakly affected by sigma factor competition. However, in case of overlapping promoters or promoters recognized by two types of sigma factors, we find that even saturated promoters are strongly affected. Active transcription effectively lowers the affinity between the sigma factor driving it and the core RNAP, resulting in complex cross-talk effects. Sigma factor competition is not strongly affected by non-specific binding of core RNAPs, sigma factors and holoenzymes to DNA. Finally, we analyze the role of increased core RNAP availability upon the shut-down of ribosomal RNA transcription during the stringent response. We find that passive up-regulation of alternative sigma-dependent transcription is not only possible, but also displays hypersensitivity based on the sigma factor competition. Our theoretical analysis thus provides support for a significant role of passive control during that global switch of the gene expression program.

Bacteria respond to changing environmental conditions by switching the global pattern of expressed genes. A key mechanism for global switches of the transcriptional program depends on alternative sigma factors that bind the RNA polymerase core enzyme and direct it towards the appropriate stress response genes. Competition of different sigma factors for a limited amount of RNA polymerase is believed to play a central role in this global switch. Here, a theoretical approach is used towards a quantitative understanding of sigma factor competition and its effects on gene expression. The model is used to quantitatively describe in vitro competition assays and to address the question of indirect or passive control in the stringent response upon amino acids starvation. We show that sigma factor competition provides a mechanism for a passive up-regulation of the stress specific sigma-driven genes due to the increased availability of RNA polymerase in the stringent response. Moreover, we find that active separation of sigma factor from the RNA polymerase during early transcript elongation weakens the sigma factor-RNA polymerase equilibrium constant, raising the question of how their in vitro measure is relevant in the cell.

Transcriptional switching in Escherichia coli during stress and starvation by modulation of sigma activity

During active growth of Escherichia coli, majority of the transcriptional activity is carried out by the housekeeping sigma factor (sigma(70)), whose association with core RNAP is generally favoured because of its higher intracellular level and higher affinity to core RNAP. In order to facilitate transcription by alternative sigma factors during nutrient starvation, the bacterial cell uses multiple strategies by which the transcriptional ability of sigma(70) is diminished in a reversible manner. The facilitators of shifting the balance in favour of alternative sigma factors happen to be as diverse as a small molecule (p)ppGpp (represents ppGpp or pppGpp), proteins (DksA, Rsd) and a species of RNA (6S RNA). Although 6S RNA and (p)ppGpp were known in literature for a long time, their role in transcriptional switching has been understood only in recent years. With the elucidation of function of DksA, a new dimension has been added to the phenomenon of stringent response. As the final outcome of actions of (p)ppGpp, DksA, 6S RNA and Rsd is similar, there is a need to analyse these mechanisms in a collective manner. We review the recent trends in understanding the regulation of sigma(70) by (p)ppGpp, DksA, Rsd and 6S RNA and present a case for evolving a unified model of RNAP redistribution during starvation by modulation of sigma(70) activity in E. coli.

The spread of a beneficial mutation in experimental bacterial populations: the influence of the environment and genotype on the fixation of rpoS mutations

The spread of beneficial mutations through populations is at the core of evolutionary change. A long-standing hindrance to understanding mutational sweeps was that beneficial mutations have been slow to be identified, even in commonly studied experimental populations. The lack of information on what constitutes a beneficial mutation has led to many uncertainties about the frequency, fitness benefit and fixation of beneficial mutations. A more complete picture is currently emerging for a limited set of identified mutations in bacterial populations. In turn, this will allow quantitation of several features of mutational sweeps. Most importantly, the 'benefit' of beneficial mutations can now be explained in terms of physiological function and how variations in the environment change the selectability of mutations. Here, the sweep of rpoS mutations in Escherichia coli, in both experimental and natural populations, is described in detail. These studies reveal the subtleties of physiology and regulation that strongly influence the benefit of a mutation and explain differences in sweeps between strains and between various environments.

Sigma factors in Pseudomonas aeruginosa

In Pseudomonas aeruginosa, as in most bacterial species, the expression of genes is tightly controlled by a repertoire of transcriptional regulators, particularly the so-called sigma (sigma) factors. The basic understanding of these proteins in bacteria has initially been described in Escherichia coli where seven sigma factors are involved in core RNA polymerase interactions and promoter recognition. Now, 7 years have passed since the completion of the first genome sequence of the opportunistic pathogen P. aeruginosa. Information from the genome of P. aeruginosa PAO1 identified 550 transcriptional regulators and 24 putative sigma factors. Of the 24 sigma, 19 were of extracytoplasmic function (ECF). Here, basic knowledge of sigma and ECF proteins was reviewed with particular emphasis on their role in P. aeruginosa global gene regulation. Summarized data are obtained from in silico analysis of P. aeruginosasigma and ECF including rpoD (sigma(70)), RpoH (sigma(32)), RpoF (FliA or sigma(28)), RpoS (sigma(S) or sigma(38)), RpoN (NtrA, sigma(54) or sigma(N)), ECF including AlgU (RpoE or sigma(22)), PvdS, SigX and a collection of uncharacterized sigma ECF, some of which are implicated in iron transport. Coupled to systems biology, identification and functional genomics analysis of P. aeruginosasigma and ECF are expected to provide new means to prevent infection, new targets for antimicrobial therapy, as well as new insights into the infection process.

Insights into transcriptional regulation and sigma competition from an equilibrium model of RNA polymerase binding to DNA

To explore scenarios that permit transcription regulation by activator recruitment of RNA polymerase and sigma competition in vivo, we used an equilibrium model of RNA polymerase binding to DNA constrained by the values of total RNA polymerase (E) and sigma(70) per cell measured in this work. Our numbers of E and sigma(70) per cell, which are consistent with most of the primary data in the literature, suggest that in vivo (i) only a minor fraction of RNA polymerase (<20%) is involved in elongation and (ii) sigma(70) is in excess of total E. Modeling the partitioning of RNA polymerase between promoters, nonspecific DNA binding sites, and the cytoplasm suggested that even weak promoters will be saturated with Esigma(70) in vivo unless nonspecific DNA binding by Esigma(70) is rather significant. In addition, the model predicted that sigmas compete for binding to E only when their total number exceeds the total amount of RNA polymerase (excluding that involved in elongation) and that weak promoters will be preferentially subjected to sigma competition.

Genotype-by-environment interactions influencing the emergence of rpoS mutations in Escherichia coli populations

Polymorphisms in rpoS are common in Escherichia coli. rpoS status influences a trade-off between nutrition and stress resistance and hence fitness across different environments. To analyze the selective pressures acting on rpoS, measurement of glucose transport rates in rpoS+ and rpoS bacteria was used to estimate the role of F(nc), the fitness gain due to improved nutrient uptake, in the emergence of rpoS mutations in nutrient-limited chemostat cultures. Chemostats with set atmospheres, temperatures, pH's, antibiotics, and levels of osmotic stress were followed. F(nc) was reduced under anaerobiosis, high osmolarity, and with chloramphenicol, consistent with a reduced rate of rpoS enrichment in these conditions. F(nc) remained high, however, with alkaline pH and low temperature but rpoS sweeps were diminished. Under these conditions, F(sp), the fitness reduction due to lowered stress protection, became significant. We also estimated whether the fitness need for the gene was related to its regulation. No consistent pattern emerged between the level of RpoS and the loss of rpoS function in particular environments. This dissection allows an unprecedented view of the genotype-by-environment interactions controlling a mutational sweep and shows that both F(nc) and F(sp) are influenced by individual stresses and that additional factors contribute to selection pressure in some environments.

Cells lacking ClpB display a prolonged shutoff phase of the heat shock response in Caulobacter crescentus

The heat shock response in Caulobacter crescentus was previously shown to be positively regulated by the alternative sigma factor of RNA polymerase (RNAP) sigma(32), and negatively modulated by DnaK during the induction phase of the heat shock response but not during the recovery phase. In the present work we have investigated the involvement of the chaperone ClpB in the control of the heat shock response in C. crescentus. Data obtained indicated a role of ClpB in downregulation of heat shock protein (HSP) synthesis, as cells lacking this chaperone showed a prolonged shutoff phase of the heat shock response. In Escherichia coli, it has been proposed that the DnaK chaperone system switches transcription back to constitutively expressed genes through simultaneous reactivation of heat-aggregated sigma(70), as well as sequestration of sigma(32) away from RNAP. In C. crescentus, results obtained with a clpB null mutant indicate that ClpB could be involved in the reactivation of the major sigma factor sigma(73). In support of this hypothesis, we showed that transcription directed from sigma(73)-dependent promoters is not switched back in the clpB null mutant during the recovery phase. Furthermore, we observed that resolubilization of heat-aggregated sigma(73) is dependent on the presence of ClpB. Our findings also indicated that the absence of ClpB made cells more sensitive to heat shock and ethanol but not to other stresses, and unable to acquire thermotolerance.

Tethering sigma70 to RNA polymerase reveals high in vivo activity of sigma factors and sigma70-dependent pausing at promoter-distal locations

Bacterial sigma factors compete for binding to RNA polymerase (RNAP) to control promoter selection, and in some cases interact with RNAP to regulate at least the early stages of transcript elongation. However, the effective concentration of sigmas in vivo, and the extent to which sigma can regulate transcript elongation generally, are unknown. We report that tethering sigma70 to all RNAP molecules via genetic fusion of rpoD to rpoC (encoding sigma70 and RNAP's beta' subunit, respectively) yields viable Escherichia coli strains in which alternative sigma-factor function is not impaired. beta'::sigma70 RNAP transcribed DNA normally in vitro, but allowed sigma70-dependent pausing at extended -10-like sequences anywhere in a transcriptional unit. Based on measurement of the effective concentration of tethered sigma70, we conclude that the effective concentration of sigma70 in E. coli (i.e., its thermodynamic activity) is close to its bulk concentration. At this level, sigma70 would be a bona fide elongation factor able to direct transcriptional pausing even after its release from RNAP during promoter escape.

Downregulation of the heat shock response is independent of DnaK and sigma32 levels in Caulobacter crescentus

Expression of heat shock genes in Gram-negative proteobacteria is positively modulated by the transcriptional regulator RpoH, the sigma(32) subunit of RNA polymerase (RNAP). In this study we investigated the chaperones DnaK/DnaJ and GroES/GroEL as possible modulators of the heat response in Caulobacter crescentus. We have shown that cells overexpressing DnaK show poor induction of heat shock protein (HSP) synthesis, even though sigma(32) levels present a normal transient increase upon heat stress. On the other hand, depletion of DnaK led to higher levels of sigma(32) and increased transcription of HSP genes, at normal growth temperature. In contrast, changes in the amount of GroES/EL had little effect on sigma(32) levels and HSP gene transcription. Despite the strong effect of DnaK levels on the induction phase of the heat shock response, downregulation of HSP synthesis was not affected by changes in the amount this chaperone. Thus, we propose that competition between sigma(32) and sigma(73), the major sigma factor, for the core RNAP could be the most important factor controlling the shut-off of HSP synthesis during recovery phase. In agreement with this hypothesis, we have shown that expression of sigma(73) gene is heat shock inducible.

Affinity purification of DNA-binding proteins

The focus of this review is on DNA affinity chromatography, which is the most powerful tool for purification of DNA binding proteins. The use of nonspecific-, sequence specific- and single stranded-DNA affinity columns in purification of various DNA binding proteins is discussed. The purification strategies for transcription factors, restriction enzymes, telomerases, DNA and RNA polymerase and DNA binding antibodies are described. Different applications of DNA affinity chromatography are presented.

Competition among seven Escherichia coli sigma subunits: relative binding affinities to the core RNA polymerase

Seven different species of the RNA polymerase sigma subunit exist in Escherichia coli, each binding to a single species of the core enzyme and thereby directing transcription of a specific set of genes. To test the sigma competition model in the global regulation of gene transcription, all seven E.coli sigma subunits have been purified and compared for their binding affinities to the same core RNA polymerase (E). In the presence of a fixed amount of sigma(70), the principal sigma for growth-related genes, the level of Esigma(70) holoenzyme formation increased linearly with the increase in core enzyme level, giving an apparent K:(d) for the core enzyme of 0.26 nM. Mixed reconstitution experiments in the presence of a fixed amount of core enzyme and increasing amounts of an equimolar mixture of all seven sigma subunits indicated that sigma(70) is strongest in terms of core enzyme binding, followed by sigma(N), sigma(F), sigma(E)/sigma(FecI), sigma(H) and sigma(S) in decreasing order. The orders of core binding affinity between sigma(70) and sigma(N) and between sigma(70) and sigma(H) were confirmed by measuring the replacement of one core-associated sigma by another sigma subunit. Taken together with the intracellular sigma levels, we tried to estimate the number of each holoenzyme form in growing E. coli cells.

The interface of sigma with core RNA polymerase is extensive, conserved, and functionally specialized

The sigma subunit of eubacterial RNA polymerase is required throughout initiation, but how it communicates with core polymerase (alpha(2)betabeta') is poorly understood. The present work addresses the location and function of the interface of sigma with core. Our studies suggest that this interface is extensive as mutations in six conserved regions of sigma(70) hinder the ability of sigma to bind core. Direct binding of one of these regions to core can be demonstrated using a peptide-based approach. The same regions, and even equivalent residues, in sigma(32) and sigma(70) alter core interaction, suggesting that sigma(70) family members use homologous residues, at least in part, to interact with core. Finally, the regions of sigma that we identify perform specialized functions, suggesting that different portions of the interface perform discrete roles during transcription initiation.

Localization of a sigma70 binding site on the N terminus of the Escherichia coli RNA polymerase beta' subunit

The Escherichia coli genome encodes genes for seven different sigma subunit species while only having single genes for the alpha, beta, and beta' subunits that make up the RNA polymerase core enzyme. The various sigma factors compete for binding to the core enzyme, upon which they confer promoter DNA-specific transcription initiation to the polymerase. We have mapped a major interaction site between one of the sigma species, sigma70, and beta'. Using far-Western blotting analysis of chemically cleaved and genetically engineered protein fragments, we have identified a N-terminal fragment of beta' (residues 60-309) that could bind sigma70. We were able to more precisely map the interaction domain to amino acid residues 260-309 of beta' using nickel nitrilotriacetic acid co-immobilization assays.

RNA polymerase beta mutations have reduced sigma70 synthesis leading to a hyper-temperature-sensitive phenotype of a sigma70 mutant

This work describes a mutational analysis of the interaction between the beta and sigma subunits of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase. The rpoD800 mutant has a temperature-sensitive growth phenotype because the mutant sigma70 polypeptide is not stable at a high temperature. Some rpoB mutations, including rpoB114, enhanced the temperature sensitivity of the rpoD800 mutant. We determined the mechanism by which the rpoB114 rpoD800 double mutant becomes hyper-temperature sensitive for growth. We found that the levels of the mutant sigma70 in the rpoB114 rpoD800 mutant were dramatically reduced compared to that in the rpoD800 mutant after temperature shift-up. The rate of synthesis of the sigma70 polypeptide was reduced in the rpoB114 rpoD800 double mutant compared to the rpoD800 mutant, whereas the half-life of the mutant sigma70 polypeptide after temperature shift-up was the same in both strains. We conclude that because of the reduction of expression of rpoD800 by rpoB114, in concert with the intrinsic instability of the mutant sigma70 polypeptide, the amount of holoenzyme containing sigma70 becomes limiting upon temperature shift-up. This results in the hyper-temperature sensitivity of the rpoB114 rpoD800 double mutant. Furthermore, the effect of rpoB114 on the expression of sigma70 is independent of the rpoD800 allele and is at the transcriptional level. In vitro transcription assays showed that the mutant RNA polymerase RpoB114 was defective in transcribing the two major promoters of the rpoD operon specifically. The effects of these rpoB mutations on gene expression are discussed.

Sigma domain structure: one down, one to go

The recent publication of the 2.6 A crystal structure of a portion of sigma70 provides insight into the role of sigma during transcription initiation. This high resolution picture unveils novel questions.

The response of a Bacillus subtilis temperature-sensitive sigA mutant to heat stress

The mutant sigA allele of Bacillus subtilis DB1005 was confirmed to be temperature sensitive (ts) and transferable among strains of B. subtilis by chromosomal transformation and gene conversion. This ts sigA allele had a pleiotropic effect on gene expression of DB1005. The induction of certain heat shock proteins in DB1005 was markedly less significant than that observed in the wild-type strain (DB2) under heat stress. In contrast, some proteins required for coping with oxidative stress and glucose starvation were induced abruptly in DB1005 but not in DB2. Heat induction of the groEL gene in vivo at both transcription and translation levels was much lower in DB1005 than in DB2. Besides, the putative sigma A-type promoter from the groESL operon of B. subtilis was able to be transcribed by the reconstituted sigma A RNA polymerase in vitro at both 37 and 49 degrees C. These results strongly suggest that the expression of the groEL gene of B. subtilis under heat stress is regulated at least in part by sigma A at the level of transcription. Our results also showed that DB1005 did not respond too differently from the wild type to ethanol stress, except after a relatively long exposure.