Importance of structural differences between complementary RNA molecules to control of replication of an IncB plasmid

Understanding the genetic basis of the incompatibility of IncK1 and IncK2 plasmids

Antimicrobial resistance is a persistent challenge in human and veterinary medicine, which is often encoded on plasmids which are transmissible between bacterial cells. Incompatibility is the inability of two plasmids to be stably maintained in one cell which is caused by the presence of identical or closely related shared determinants between two plasmids originating from partition or replication mechanisms. For I-complex plasmids in Enterobacteriacae, replication- based incompatibility is caused by the small antisense RNA stem-loop structure called RNAI. The I-complex plasmid group IncK consists of two compatible subgroups, IncK1 and IncK2, for which the RNAI differs only by five nucleotides. In this study we focussed on the interaction of the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI structures by constructing minireplicons containing the replication region of IncK1 or IncK2 plasmids coupled with a kanamycin resistance marker. Using minireplicons excludes involvement of incompatibility mechanisms other than RNAI. Additionally, we performed single nucleotide mutagenesis targeting the five nucleotides that differ between the IncK1 and IncK2 RNAI sequences of these minireplicons. The obtained results show that a single nucleotide change in the RNAI structure is responsible for the compatible phenotype of IncK1 with IncK2 plasmids. Only nucleotides in the RNAI top loop and interior loop have an effect on minireplicon incompatibility with wild type plasmids, while mutations in the stem of the RNAI structure had no significant effect on incompatibility. Understanding the molecular basis of incompatibility is relevant for future in silico predictions of plasmid incompatibility.

Plasmid Replication Control by Antisense RNAs

Plasmids are selfish genetic elements that normally constitute a burden for the bacterial host cell. This burden is expected to favor plasmid loss. Therefore, plasmids have evolved mechanisms to control their replication and ensure their stable maintenance. Replication control can be either mediated by iterons or by antisense RNAs. Antisense RNAs work through a negative control circuit. They are constitutively synthesized and metabolically unstable. They act both as a measuring device and a regulator, and regulation occurs by inhibition. Increased plasmid copy numbers lead to increasing antisense-RNA concentrations, which, in turn, result in the inhibition of a function essential for replication. On the other hand, decreased plasmid copy numbers entail decreasing concentrations of the inhibiting antisense RNA, thereby increasing the replication frequency. Inhibition is achieved by a variety of mechanisms, which are discussed in detail. The most trivial case is the inhibition of translation of an essential replication initiator protein (Rep) by blockage of the rep-ribosome binding site. Alternatively, ribosome binding to a leader peptide mRNA whose translation is required for efficient Rep translation can be prevented by antisense-RNA binding. In 2004, translational attenuation was discovered. Antisense-RNA-mediated transcriptional attenuation is another mechanism that has, so far, only been detected in plasmids of Gram-positive bacteria. ColE1, a plasmid that does not need a plasmid-encoded replication initiator protein, uses the inhibition of primer formation. In other cases, antisense RNAs inhibit the formation of an activator pseudoknot that is required for efficient Rep translation.

Control of replication in I-complex plasmids

The closely related plasmids that make up the I-complex group and the more distantly related IncL/M plasmids regulate the frequency of initiation of their replication by controlling the efficiency of translation of the rate limiting replication initiator protein, RepA. Translation initiation of repA is dependent on the formation of a pseudoknot immediately upstream of its Shine-Dalgarno sequence. Formation of this pseudoknot involves base pairing between two complementary sequences in the repA mRNA and requires that the secondary structure sequestering the distal sequence be disrupted by movement of the ribosome translating and terminating a leader peptide, whose coding sequence precedes and overlaps that of repA. Expression of repA is controlled by a small antisense RNA, RNAI, which on binding to its complementary target in the repA mRNA not only pre-empts formation of the pseudoknot, but also inhibits translation of the leader peptide. The requirement that translation of the leader peptide be completed for the pseudoknot to form increases the time available for the inhibitory interaction of RNAI with its target, so that at high copy number the frequency of pseudoknot formation is lowered, reducing the proportion of repA mRNA that are translated. At low copy number, when concentration of RNAI is low, repA is translated with increased frequency, leading to increased frequency of plasmid replication.

Role of RepA and DnaA proteins in the opening of the origin of DNA replication of an IncB plasmid

The replication initiator protein RepA of the IncB plasmid pMU720 was shown to induce localized unwinding of its cognate origin of replication in vitro. DnaA, the initiator protein of Escherichia coli, was unable to induce localized unwinding of this origin of replication on its own but enhanced the opening generated by RepA. The opened region lies immediately downstream of the last of the three binding sites for RepA (RepA boxes) and covers one turn of DNA helix. A 6-mer sequence, 5'-TCTTAA-3', which lies within the opened region, was essential for the localized unwinding of the origin in vitro and origin activity in vivo. In addition, efficient unwinding of the origin of replication of pMU720 in vitro required the native positioning of the binding sites for the initiator proteins. Interestingly, binding of RepA to RepA box 1, which is essential for origin activity, was not required for the localized opening of the origin in vitro.

Interaction of the initiator protein of an IncB plasmid with its origin of DNA replication

The replication initiator protein RepA of the IncB plasmid pMU720 was purified and used in DNase I protection assays in vitro. RepA protected a 68-bp region of the origin of replication of pMU720. This region, which lies immediately downstream of the DnaA box, contains four copies of the sequence motif 5'AANCNGCAA3'. Mutational analyses identified this sequence as the binding site specifically recognized by RepA (the RepA box). Binding of RepA to the RepA boxes was ordered and sequential, with the box closest to the DnaA binding site (box 1) occupied first and the most distant boxes (boxes 3 and 4) occupied last. However, only boxes 1, 2, and 4 were essential for origin activity, with box 3 playing a lesser role. Changing the spacing between box 1 and the other three boxes affected binding of RepA in vitro and origin activity in vivo, indicating that the RepA molecules bound to ori(B) interact with one another.

Antisense-RNA regulation and RNA interference

For a long time, RNA has been merely regarded as a molecule that can either function as a messenger (mRNA) or as part of the translational machinery (tRNA, rRNA). Meanwhile, it became clear that RNAs are versatile molecules that do not only play key roles in many important biological processes like splicing, editing, protein export and others, but can also--like enzymes--act catalytically. Two important aspects of RNA function--antisense-RNA control and RNA interference (RNAi)--are emphasized in this review. Antisense-RNA control functions in all three kingdoms of life--although the majority of examples are known from bacteria. In contrast, RNAi, gene silencing triggered by double-stranded RNA, the oldest and most ubiquitous antiviral system, is exclusively found in eukaryotes. Our current knowledge about occurrence, biological roles and mechanisms of action of antisense RNAs as well as the recent findings about involved genes/enzymes and the putative mechanism of RNAi are summarized. An interesting intersection between both regulatory mechanisms is briefly discussed.

Effect of CIS on activity in trans of the replication initiator protein of an IncB plasmid

RepA, the replication initiator protein of the IncB plasmid pMU720, acts preferentially in cis. The cis activity of RepA is thought to be mediated by CIS, a 166-bp region of DNA separating the coding region of repA from the origin of replication (ori) of pMU720. To investigate the trans activity of RepA, the repA gene, without its cognate ori, was cloned on a multicopy plasmid, pSU39. The ori on which RepA acts was cloned on pAM34, a plasmid whose replicon is inactive without induction by isopropyl-beta-D-thiogalactopyranoside (IPTG). Thus, in the absence of IPTG, replication of the pAM34 derivatives was dependent on activation of the cloned ori by RepA produced in trans from the pSU39 derivatives. The effect of CIS, when present either on the RepA-producing or the ori plasmid or both, on the efficiency of replication of the ori plasmid in vivo, was determined. The presence of CIS, in its native position and orientation, on the RepA-producing plasmid reduced the efficiency of replication of the ori plasmid. This inhibitory activity of CIS was sequence specific and involved interaction with the C-terminal 20 to 37 amino acids of RepA. By contrast, CIS had no effect when present on the ori plasmid. Initiation of replication from the ori in trans was independent of transcription into CIS.

Structural analysis of late intermediate complex formed between plasmid ColIb-P9 Inc RNA and its target RNA. How does a single antisense RNA repress translation of two genes at different rates?

The antisense Inc RNA encoded by the IncIalpha ColIb-P9 plasmid replicon controls the translation of repZ encoding the replication initiator and its leader peptide repY at different rates with different mechanisms. The initial loop-loop base pairing between Inc RNA and the target in the repZ mRNA leader inhibits formation of a pseudoknot required for repZ translation. A subsequent base pairing at the 5' leader of Inc RNA blocks repY translation. To delineate the molecular basis for the differential control, we analyzed the intermediate complexes formed between RepZ mRNA and Inc RNA(54), a 5'-truncated Inc RNA derivative. We found that the initial base pairing at the loops transforms into a more stable intermediate complex by its propagation in both directions. The resulting extensive base pairing indicates that the inhibition of the pseudoknot formation is established at this stage. Furthermore, the region of extensive base pairing includes bases different in related plasmids showing different incompatibility. Thus, the observed extensive base pairing is important for determining the incompatibility of the low-copy-number plasmids. We discuss the evolution of replication control systems found in IncIalpha, IncB, and IncFII group plasmids.

Role of CIS in replication of an IncB plasmid

Replication of the IncB plasmid pMU720 requires the synthesis of the cis-acting RepA protein and the presence of two DNA elements, ori and CIS. CIS is the 166-bp sequence separating the RepA coding sequence from ori. To investigate how this organization of the pMU720 replicon contributes to the mechanism of initiation of replication, mutations in the sequence and/or the length of CIS were introduced into the CIS region and their effects on the efficiency of replication of the pMU720 replicon in vivo was determined. The CIS region was found to be composed of two domains. The repA-proximal domain, which showed strong transcription termination activity, could be replaced by equivalent sequences from I-complex and IncL/M plasmids, whose replicons are organized in the same fashion as pMU720. Replacement by a trpA transcription terminator afforded only partial replication activity. The repA-distal domain was shown to be a spacer whose role was to position sequence(s) within ori on the correct face of the DNA helix vis-à-vis the repA-proximal portion of CIS. A model for the loading of RepA protein onto ori is discussed.

Analysis of elements involved in pseudoknot-dependent expression and regulation of the repA gene of an IncL/M plasmid

Replication of the IncL/M plasmid pMU604 is controlled by a small antisense RNA molecule (RNAI), which, by inhibiting the formation of an RNA pseudoknot, regulates translation of the replication initiator protein, RepA. Efficient translation of the repA mRNA was shown to require the translation and correct termination of the leader peptide, RepB, and the formation of the pseudoknot. Although the pseudoknot was essential for the expression of repA, its presence was shown to interfere with the translation of repB. The requirement for pseudoknot formation could in large part be obviated by improving the ribosome binding region of repA, either by replacing the GUG start codon by AUG or by increasing the spacing between the start codon and the Shine-Dalgarno sequence (SD). The spacing between the distal pseudoknot sequence and the repA SD was shown to be suboptimal for maximal expression of repA.

Structural basis for binding of the plasmid ColIb-P9 antisense Inc RNA to its target RNA with the 5'-rUUGGCG-3' motif in the loop sequence

The sequence 5'-rUUGGCG-3' is conserved within the loop regions of antisense RNAs or their targets involved in replication of various prokaryotic plasmids. In IncIalpha plasmid ColIb-P9, the partially base paired 21-nucleotide loop of a stem-loop called structure I within RepZ mRNA contains this hexanucleotide sequence, and comprises the target site for the antisense Inc RNA. In this report, we find that the base pairing interaction at the 5'-rGGC-3' sequence in the hexanucleotide motif is important for interaction between Inc RNA and structure I. In addition, the 21-base loop domain of structure I is folded tighter than predicted, with the hexanucleotide sequence at the top. The second U residue in the sequence is favored for Inc RNA binding in a base-specific manner. On the other hand, the upper domain of the Inc RNA stem-loop is loosely structured, and maintaining the loop sequence single-stranded is important for the intermolecular interaction. Based on these results, we propose that a structural feature in the loop I domain, conferred probably by the conserved 5'-rUUGGCG-3' sequence, favors binding to a complementary, single-stranded RNA. This model also explains how the RepZ mRNA pseudoknot, described in the accompanying paper (Asano, K., and Mizobuchi, K. (1998) J. Biol. Chem. 273, 11815-11825) is formed specifically with structure I. A possible conformation adopted by the 5'-rUUGGCG-3' loop sequence is discussed.

Programmed cell death by hok/sok of plasmid R1: processing at the hok mRNA 3'-end triggers structural rearrangements that allow translation and antisense RNA binding

The hok/sok locus of plasmid R1 mediates plasmid stabilization by killing of plasmid-free cells. The locus specifies two RNAs, hok mRNA and Sok antisense RNA. The post-segregational killing mediated by hok/sok is governed by a complicated control mechanism that involves both post-transcriptional inhibition of translation by Sok-RNA and activation of hok translation by mRNA 3' processing. Sok-RNA inhibits translation of a reading frame (mok) that overlaps with hok, and translation of hok is coupled to translation of mok. In the inactive full-length hok mRNA, the translational activator element at the mRNA 5'-end (tac) is sequestered by the fold-back-inhibitory element located at the mRNA 3'-end (fbi). The 5' to 3' pairing locks the RNA in an inert configuration in which the SDmok and Sok-RNA target regions are sequestered. Here we show that the 3' processing leads to major structural rearrangements in the mRNA 5'-end. The structure of the refolded RNA explains activation of translation and antisense RNA binding. The refolded RNA contains an antisense RNA target stem-loop that presents the target nucleotides in a single-stranded conformation. The stem of the target hairpin contains SDmok and AUGmok in a paired configuration. Using toeprinting analysis, we show that this pairing keeps SDmok in an accessible configuration. Furthermore, a mutational analysis shows that an internal loop in the target stem is prerequisite for efficient translation and antisense RNA binding.