Clinical comparison of a new automated infrared blood culture system with the BACTEC 460 system

Controlled clinical comparison of bioMérieux VITAL and BACTEC NR-660 blood culture systems for detection of bacteremia and fungemia in adults

A total of 9,446 blood cultures were collected from adult patients at three university-affiliated hospitals. Of these, 8,943 cultures were received with both aerobic bottles filled adequately; 885 yielded 1,016 microorganisms, including 622 isolates (61%) that were the cause of sepsis, 337 isolates (33%) that were contaminants, and 57 isolates (6%) that were indeterminate as the cause of sepsis. With the exception of Staphylococcus aureus, which was recovered more often from VITAL aerobic bottles, more pathogenic microorganisms were recovered from BACTEC NR6 (aerobic) bottles than from VITAL aerobic bottles. Growth of pathogenic microorganisms was detected earlier in VITAL aerobic bottles. A total of 8,647 blood cultures were received with both anaerobic bottles filled adequately; 655 yielded 740 microorganisms, including 486 isolates (66%) that were the cause of sepsis, 215 isolates (29%) that were contaminants, and 39 isolates (6%) that were indeterminate as the cause of sepsis. More pathogenic microorganisms were recovered from VITAL anaerobic bottles than from BACTEC NR7 (anaerobic) bottles. Growth of pathogenic microorganisms was detected earlier in VITAL anaerobic bottles. In 8,500 sets all four bottles were received adequately filled. When paired aerobic and anaerobic bottle sets (systems) were compared, more pathogenic microorganisms (again with the exception of S. aureus) were recovered from the BACTEC system. For the 304 septic episodes (253 unimicrobial and 51 polymicrobial), significantly more were detected by the BACTEC system. We conclude that VITAL requires modification to improve recovery of pathogenic microorganisms to make it competitive with other commercially available blood culture systems.

Gram-negative bacteremia in non-neutropenic patients: a 3-year review

The causative organisms, clinical manifestations, factors influencing prognosis, and other epidemiological characteristics of 81 episodes of bacteremia due to gram-negative organisms, in non-neutropenic patients, were studied retrospectively during a 3-year period (1992-1994) at the Department of Internal Medicine of the University Hospital of Heraklion, Crete, Greece. The gram-negative bacteremia incidence was 2% and the overall mortality 12%. All 81 patients had fever; Escherichia coli was the most frequent organism isolated (from 47 patients--58%) and was associated with shock (9/47), disseminated intravascular coagulation (DIC) (8/47), anuria (5/47), adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) (3/47), and pneumonia (1/47). Other less frequent gram-negative microorganisms were Klebsiella spp. (ten patients; 12%), Pseudomonas spp. (7; 7%), Salmonella spp. (5; 6%), Enterobacter spp. (5; 6%), Proteus spp. (3; 3.4%), Stenotrophomonas spp. (3; 3.4%), and Acinetobacter spp. (1; 1.2%). ARDS. shock, DIC, anuria, presence of central venous catheter, urinary catheter, unknown origin of infection and inappropriate treatment were significantly associated with a higher death rate. Early initiation of appropriate therapy was the most important intervention that favorably affected the outcome of gram-negative bacteremias in this patient population.

Update on detection of bacteremia and fungemia

The presence of microorganisms in a patient's blood is a critical determinant of the severity of the patient's illness. Equally important, the laboratory isolation and identification of a microorganism present in blood determine the etiologic agent of infection, especially when the site of infection is localized and difficult to access. This review addresses the pathophysiology and clinical characteristics of bacteremia, fungemia, and sepsis; diagnostic strategies and critical factors in the detection of positive blood cultures; characteristics of manual and instrument approaches to bacteremia detection; approaches for isolating specific microorganisms associated with positive blood cultures; and rapid methods for the identification of microorganisms in blood cultures.

Optimizing detection of microbial sepsis: a comparison of culture systems using packaged sets with directions for blood collection

Detection of microbial sepsis is an important aspect of medical practice. To facilitate the recovery of bacteria and fungi we evaluated 10,933 complete blood culture sets integrating the automated ESP system (Difco) with a manual system using the Isolator (Wampole) and Thiol broth bottle (Difco). To improve compliance with the recommended procedure for submitting specimens, we packaged the three components as a unit that included brief instructional material. A three-component (one ESP bottle, one Thiol bottle, and one Isolator tube) package containing specific instructions was used. The aerobic ESP performance was compared with the Isolator, and the anaerobic ESP with the Thiol bottle. A hypothetical assessment involving all three components was also made. The cultures were processed under routine laboratory conditions. Charts were reviewed from specimens with discrepant results to ascertain true positives versus contaminant cultures in the discordant culture sets. There were 896 organisms recovered from 393 patients. Of these, 421 were in the aerobic compared with 475 in the anaerobic portion of the study. ESP enhanced the recovery of Streptococcus pneumoniae (P < .05). The Isolator was superior for the recovery of yeasts (.05 < P < .1). Using the packaged system, the compliance rate for complete three-component culture sets was 95.2%, with a 34.4% resultant increase in positive blood cultures from only a 5.7% increase in sets. Packaged culture media including instructions enhance appropriate collection of complete sets, increase the number of recovered organisms, and improve medical practice.

Detection of bacteremia by Difco ESP blood culture system

In a multicenter study, the Difco ESP blood culture system (Difco Laboratories, Detroit, Mich.) was compared with the BACTEC NR660 system (Becton Dickinson Diagnostic Instrument Systems, Sparks, Md.). The ESP system monitors each blood culture bottle every 12 to 24 min to detect changes in oxygen consumption and gas production by microbes. Equal volumes of blood were inoculated into aerobic ESP-80A and BACTEC 6A, 16A, or PEDS Plus broths and anaerobic ESP-80N and BACTEC 7A or 17A broths and were incubated for up to 7 days. ESP bottles contain supplemented tryptic soy broth without antimicrobial agent-adsorbing resins. From 7,532 aerobic compliant sets, the ESP system detected 356 clinically significant positive cultures and the BACTEC NR660 system detected 329. From 6,007 anaerobic cultures, the ESP system detected 234 clinically significant positive cultures and the BACTEC NR660 system detected 198. In aerobic broths, 292 organisms were isolated from both systems and 78 organisms were isolated from the ESP system alone, whereas 54 organisms were isolated from the BACTEC NR660 system alone (P < 0.05). Among individual organisms, pneumococci were isolated significantly more often in ESP aerobic broths. In anaerobic broths, 180 organisms were isolated from both systems and 68 organisms were isolated from the ESP system alone, whereas 35 organisms were isolated from the BACTEC NR660 system alone (P < 0.05). Aerobic gram-positive organisms as a group and Candida spp. were isolated significantly more often in ESP anaerobic broths. Both systems detected 207 clinically significant bacteremic episodes and the ESP system alone detected 63, whereas the BACTEC NR660 system alone detected 32 (P < 0.05). Significantly more episodes of bacteremia caused by Staphylococcus epidermidis and anaerobes were detected by the ESP system. The differences in the numbers of organisms detected >6h earlier in ESP broths compared with BACTNEC NR660 broths were significant, as were earlier times to detection. Although the total number of organisms detected was not significantly different, the ESP system alone detected more organisms in a shorter time than did the BACTEC NR660 system alone. The continuous monitoring capability of the ESP system makes it an attractive alternative to the BACTEC NR660 system.

Value of extended agitation and subculture of BACTEC NR 660 aerobic resin blood culture bottles for clinical yeast isolates

From 10,351 blood cultures, we prospectively studied 1,000 BACTEC NR 660 aerobic resin blood culture bottles (26+ and Peds Plus) for patients suspected of having yeast septicemia to determine whether extended agitation and subculturing would increase the recovery of yeasts. Aerobic bottles were agitated continuously for 144 h. On day 7, 1,000 culture-negative aerobic bottles which had fungal blood culture requests were agitated for an additional 14 days. During this time they were subcultured twice and read twice by BACTEC NR 660. ON days 1 to 7, 81 bottles were cultured positive for yeasts from 36 patients, which included 44 isolates of Candida albicans, averaging 1.4 days to detection, and 12 isolates of Cryptococcus neoformans, averaging 3.8 days to detection. The average detection time for all yeasts was 2.2 days. On days 7 to 21, no yeasts were detected by BACTEC or recovered from the subcultures. We conclude that when continuously agitated for at least 5 full days (120 h), the BACTEC NR 660 aerobic resin bottles reliably isolate yeasts, and it is unnecessary to subculture or hold these bottles beyond 5 days. It also eliminates the need for an additional blood culture system for yeast detection, thus saving (i) confusion in the collection process, (ii) patients' blood and money, and (iii) laboratory technologists' time.

Comparison of Sentinel and Bactec blood culture systems

AIMS

To evaluate the Sentinel automated blood culture system and to compare its performance with that of Bactec.

METHODS

The Sentinel blood culture system was evaluated in three centres. The performance of the system was assessed in comparison with the routine blood culture method used in these centres, the Bactec system.

RESULTS

Blood culture sets (n = 2180) consisting of Sentinel aerobic and anaerobic, and Bactec aerobic and anaerobic bottles yielded 218 (10%) clinically important isolates. One hundred and fifty five (71%) of the isolates were detected by both systems; 35 (16%) were detected by Sentinel only; and 28 (13%) by Bactec only. For the duration of the evaluation, the Sentinel system was deliberately configured so that it was impossible to detect positive results during the first 12 hours. The times to positivity after the first 12 hours were similar. Data gathered during and subsequent to the evaluation have been used by the manufacturer to refine the algorithm so that positive results can be detected at a minimum of 2.25 hours.

CONCLUSIONS

After a period of familiarization the Sentinel system was considered easy to use. Sentinel is a useful addition to the methods available for the detection of bacteria in blood cultures.

Occurrence of bacteremia in hematologic patients

In the present study we reviewed eighty-six episodes of bacteremia occurred in 60 neutropenic patients and thirty-one episodes occurred in 30 non-neutropenic patients. Twenty-four out of 60 neutropenic patients suffered from multiple episodes of bacteremia, while only one out of 30 non-neutropenic patients presented multiple episodes. In neutropenic patients, 29 episodes of bacteremia were polymicrobial, whereas only one non-neutropenic patient had polymicrobial bacteremia. Intravascular catheters were the most common source of bacteremia (23.2%) in neutropenic patients, as compared with infections of the genito-urinary tract (45.1%) among non-neutropenic patients. In both groups, aerobic gram-positive cocci were the microorganisms most frequently isolated (71.6%). Anaerobic microorganisms showed an higher incidence in polymicrobial episodes than in monomicrobial episodes x 2 = 5.39 p = 0.02 OR = 2.97 95% CI (1.2-7.7).

Detection of bacterial growth by gas absorption

When 24 different aerobic organisms were grown in a shaken culture, all were found to first absorb gas from the headspace. In a rudimentary medium, such as tryptic soy broth, 16 of the 24 organisms did not produce gas following the initial gas absorption. We have developed a simple, noninvasive method for detecting both gas absorption and production in multiple culture vials. The time to positivity was compared with that obtained by the BACTEC 460 blood culture system. For nearly all of these organisms, there was no difference. For some of those organisms that did not produce gas, e.g. Staphylococcus epidermidis, Moraxella osloensis, and Neisseria meningitidis, detection by gas absorption was a few hours faster. Gas absorption appears to be a promising technique for a new automated blood culture system because of its simplicity and because medium without special additives can be used to detect organisms that do not produce gas.

Determination of growth value thresholds for BACTEC PLUS aerobic blood culture vials

Growth value thresholds used to identify positive blood culture vials can be defined by users for each BACTEC NR-660 bacteremia detection instrument. Growth values were compared with the recovery of organisms from vials flagged as positive during the testing of 3.056 high-volume vials containing aerobic (BACTEC PLUS 26) medium over a 2-month period. Results showed that optimal threshold values for our use of these vials varied from those recommended by the manufacturer; if the thresholds defined from these data had been used during the study period, total vials flagged as positive from which no organisms were recovered (false alarms) would have been reduced from 181 (5.9/100 vials tested) to 71 (2.3/100 vials tested), with a minimal decrease in the identification of vials containing usual or occasional pathogens (hits). Adjustments of growth value thresholds by the individual user can make the use of BACTEC instruments more efficient by decreasing further processing of vials from which no organisms are recovered.

Multicenter comparison of the high volume (10 ml) NR BACTEC PLUS system and the standard (5 ml) NR BACTEC system

This multicenter study was designed to compare the new BACTEC PLUS system (nonradiometric), which utilizes an 8- to 10-ml blood inoculum in a resin-containing medium, to the standard BACTEC (nonradiometric) without resins and 5-ml blood inoculum. There were 12,341 compliant sets studied, yielding 1331 positives, with 1099 sets deemed clinically significant. Overall the BACTEC PLUS showed an enhanced recovery of 33% (p less than 0.001) over its standard counterpart, with significant yield increased in the staphylococci (p less than 0.001), streptococci (p less than 0.002), pseudomonads (p less than 0.002), Enterobacteriaceae (p less than 0.001), and other aerobic Gram negatives (p less than 0.02). The enhanced performance increased to 53% if the patient was receiving any antibiotics at the time the blood was cultured. In patients known to be free of antibiotics at the time of blood draw, there was still an increased yield of 18%. The new system detected positivity at least one reading sooner than twice as often as the converse, and confirmed septic episodes significantly more often (21% overall) (41% on antibiotics) (15% no antibiotics). The BACTEC PLUS has distinct advantages over its low blood volume, nonresin counterpart.

Bacteraemia in man and animals: an overview

Bacteraemia signifies invasion of the bloodstream by bacteria. In most systemic infections in man and animals, bacteria enter the blood at some stage during the infection and are rapidly distributed throughout the body. A wide variety of organisms have been associated with bacteraemia. Prompt detection of the aetiological agents of bacteraemia is of prime importance in clinical microbiology. There are no defined recommendations for blood cultures in animals but both conventional and improved methods are available for detection of bacteraemia in man. The consequences of bacteraemia are as diverse as the potential aetiological agents. Monoclonal antibodies to the core glycolipid (lipid A) seems very promising for the treatment of bacteraemia and septic shock caused by Gram-negative bacteria in man and animals.

Enhanced detection of Candida in blood cultures with the BACTEC 460 system by use of the aerobic-hypertonic (8B) medium

The blood culture records during the 6-year period 1984-9 were reviewed to compare the performance of the BACTEC aerobic (6B) and aerobic-hypertonic (8B) media for the recovery of Candida spp. and Torulopsis glabrata from blood. There were 137 positive blood culture sets that contained both a 6B and an 8B bottle. Sixty-eight different yeasts were recovered from 65 patients including 35 Candida albicans, 19 C. tropicalis, 6 C. parapsilosis, 4 C. krusei, 1 C. pseudotropicalis and 3 Torulopsis glabrata. The 8B medium detected 120 of the positive cultures (87.6%) and was the only positive medium in 35 (25.6%) sets, while the 6B medium detected 102 positive cultures (74.4%) and was the only positive medium in 17 (12.4%) sets (P less than 0.04). For those sets in which both bottles were positive, radiometric detection occurred first in the 8B bottle in 39 sets and first in the 6B bottle in 11 sets (P less than 0.001). The superior performance of the 8B bottle was not related to the administration of amphotericin B. Cultures of stock strains of C. albicans, C. tropicalis, and C. parapsilosis in 6B and 8B media with and without added blood confirmed the finding that 8B was substantially superior to 6B for the detection of candidaemia. It is concluded that an 8B bottle should be included in the blood culture set whenever candidaemia is suspected.

An investigation of indirect conductimetry for detection of some food-borne bacteria

Indirect conductimetry using a rapid automated bacterial impedance technique was investigated. Strains of Staphylococcus aureus, Listeria monocytogenes, Enterococcus faecalis, Bacillus subtilis, Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Aeromonas hydrophila and Salmonella spp. grown in Whitley Impedance broth all elicited indirect conductimetric changes. These indirect conductance responses were improved by the addition of 2 g/l glucose to the medium and resulted in maximum changes of 2340-4300 microS with associated maximum rates of change of 520-1210 microS/h. Furthermore, the indirect conductimetric assay detected growth of staphylococci, listeria and salmonella in media containing high concentrations of salts used as selective agents in culture media for the isolation of these organisms.

Comparison between Bactec Nr. 660 and a conventional 12-tube blood culture system

The detection power of the automated blood culture system Bactec NR 660, based on infrared detection of carbon dioxide in an agitated aerobic medium and a non-agitated anaerobic medium, was compared with that of our conventional 12-tube blood culture system. Of 1685 paired blood cultures, 258 (15.3%) were positive in one or both systems. Clinically relevant isolates were found in 11.5%. The dominating species were Escherichia coli(41%), followed by Staphylococcus aureus(14%) and Klebsiella spp.(8%). The Bactec system detected 178 (10.6%) and the 12-tube system 157 (9.3%) clinically relevant microorganisms after seven days' incubation. Significantly more clinically relevant isolates were detected by the Bactec system alone as compared with the conventional system alone (40 versus 19, p less than 0.01). The detection time was significantly shorter in the Bactec system for all isolates and for E. coli and S. aureus separately (p less than 0.01). 1.8% of the isolates in the Bactec system and 2.1% in the 12-tube system were considered clinically non-relevant contaminants.

Comparative evaluation of nonradiometric BACTEC and improved oxoid signal blood culture systems in a clinical laboratory

The BACTEC NR660 blood culture system, which uses infrared spectroscopy to detect carbon dioxide generated by bacterial growth, was compared with the new medium formulation of the Oxoid Signal system. Two trials were conducted: a comparative study of 88 organisms in simulated blood cultures and a clinical trial of 3,321 paired patient blood culture samples. Both trials showed that overall the BACTEC system performed better in the recovery of organisms. The Oxoid system was unable to detect by signal the growth of the majority of yeasts, nonfermentative gram-negative bacilli, Neisseria meningitidis, Nocardia spp., and Corynebacterium jeikeium. There were no significant differences in the yield of Staphylococcus spp., members of the family Enterobacteriaceae, Streptococcus spp., or anaerobic organisms. BACTEC detected growth more quickly than did the Oxoid system; 61% of the isolates were detected by BACTEC at 24 h, while 49% of the isolates were detected by Oxoid. The Oxoid system had a high proportion (58.5%) of false-positives, compared with 7.7% for the BACTEC system. Despite the new medium formulation of the Oxoid system, its performance is still not equivalent to that of the BACTEC system.

Resin versus standard blood culture media used with the new BACTEC automated infrared system: an evaluation in febrile granulocytopenic patients

Resin-containing aerobic and anaerobic blood culture media (NR 16A and NR 17A) for use with the new BACTEC infrared blood cultures system were compared with standard BACTEC media (NR 6A and NR 7A) in their efficacy to detect bacteremia in febrile granulocytopenic patients receiving antimicrobial treatment. A total of 1185 sets of blood cultures obtained from 341 patients during a 12-month period were evaluated. There were 109 positive cultures (9.2%) with 128 pathogenic organisms isolated from 52 patients (15.2%). Statistically significant differences were found between aerobic media, but not between anaerobic media. Aerobic resin bottles (NR 16A) were more often positive (90 versus 78, p less than 0.05) than standard aerobic bottles (NR 6A). They yielded a higher number of microorganismS (98 versus 80, p less than 0.05) per culture and per culture-positive patient (53 versus 42, p less than 0.01). NR 16A cultures also were more often positive after 1-day incubation (44% versus 21%, p less than 0.01) than NR 6A cultures and allowed earlier subcultivation. The use of NR 16A medium instead of resin-free aerobic NR 6A medium may enhance the detection of bacteremia in selected groups of patients receiving antimicrobial treatment, and can shorten the time until detection of bacteremia.

Impact of the BACTEC NR system in detecting Candida fungemia

As a result of the growing importance of candidemia, various techniques for the detection of Candida spp. in blood have been designed with a view to speeding up the laboratory procedure. We have performed a retrospective comparison of the efficiencies of the conventional VACUTAINER system (Becton Dickinson Vacutainer Systems) and the BACTEC NR system (Johnston Laboratories, Inc.). During a 4-year period, 88,300 blood cultures were processed, with growth of Candida species in 552. The mean times required for the detection of growth were 7.55 days with the VACUTAINER system and 4.1 days with the BACTEC NR system (P less than 0.05). During the first week of incubation, the VACUTAINER system detected 56.1% of the candidemias and the BACTEC NR detected 93.6% (P less than 0.05). Use of the BACTEC NR therefore permits reduction of the incubation period from the previously established 4 weeks to a more convenient 7 to 14 days.

A comparison of oxoid signal with nonradiometric BACTEC NR-660 for detection of bacteremia

The Oxoid Signal (Oxoid U.S.A. Inc., Columbia, Maryland) system was compared with the nonradiometric BACTEC NR-660 (Johnston Laboratories, Towson, Maryland) system for detection of bacteria in 2714 blood cultures. The volume of blood collected into 20 ml blood-collection tubes containing sodium polyanetholsulfonate (SPS) (Becton Dickinson, Vacutainer Systems, Rutherford, New Jersey) ranged from 10 to 20 ml with an average of 15 ml. Subsequently, equal volumes of blood were inoculated into each system. A total of 250 organisms was isolated (9.6%), of which 149 (5.5%) were considered significant while 111 isolates from 98 cultures (3.6%) were contaminants. Of the significant isolates 32.9% were aerobic Gram-negative rods, 53.0% aerobic Gram-positive cocci, 5.4% anaerobes, 7.4% yeasts, and two isolates of Neisseria meningitidis. Ninety-five isolates were recovered in both systems, 29 by Bactec only and 25 by Signal only. Of the isolates recovered there were no significant differences in detection between the two systems with the exception of anaerobes (p less than 0.005). The median detection times for many of the most commonly isolated organisms--Enterobacteriaceae, streptococci, and Staphylococcus aureus--were very similar in both systems, ranging from 14 to 21 hours. With the remaining organisms recovered, the median times in hours for BAC-TEC and Signal, respectively, were 31 and 47 for Staphylococcus epidermidis, 48 and 60 for Bacteroides, 39 and 168 for yeast, and 16.5 and 168 for N. meningitidis. Oxoid Signal compares favorably with the BACTEC system. Its main advantages are: (1) it requires no instrumentation; (2) it is characterized by ease of detection; and (3) it uses a single-bottle system.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Detection of bloodstream infections in children

A critical responsibility of the clinical microbiology laboratory serving clinicians who care for infected children is accurate and timely detection of bacteremia. Blood culture protocols which are suitable for processing adult specimens are not necessarily the first choice for processing pediatric specimens. In this review, the following aspects of detection of bacteremia in children are covered: obtaining blood culture specimens from children, including skin disinfection, specimen volume and timing of specimen collection; the array of blood culture methods available, focusing upon conventional, radiometric, infrared spectroscopic and manometric broth cultures, as well as biphasic agar/broth and lysis direct plating techniques: the strengths and weaknesses of the various methods; and recommendations to laboratories for selection of a blood culture method based upon the laboratory's staffing level.

Poor performance of BACTEC NR 730 blood culture system in early detection of Neisseria meningitidis

During an 8-month period at Children's Hospital, Oakland, Calif., a 9% rate for positive blood culture for children with Neisseria meningitidis meningitis was identified. The blood culture system used in each case was the BACTEC NR 730. This rate seemed significantly lower than previous rates (33 to 55%) (P.R. Dodge and M.N. Swartz, N. Engl. J. Med. 272:1003-1010, 1965; A.L. Hoyne and R.H. Brown, Ann. Intern. Med. 28:248-259, 1948; S. Levin and M.B. Painter, Ann. Intern. Med. 64:1049-1057, 1966). The low rate prompted our study. With 14 test strains, anaerobic and aerobic BACTEC bottles were evaluated for their ability to support and detect the growth of N. meningitidis. Sodium polyanetholesufonate (SPS) and inoculum size, two factors thought to affect the growth of N. meningitidis, were controlled for by use of bottles with and without SPS and by inoculum sizes simulating the magnitudes of bacteremia previously described for children infected with N. meningitidis (L.J. La Scolea, Jr., D. Dryja, T.D. Sullivan, L. Mosovich, N. Ellerstein, and E. Neter, J. Clin. Microbiol. 13:478-482, 1981). BACTEC failed to detect growth in aerobic bottles after 6 h of incubation, while 76 of 80 bottles (95%) showed growth when subcultured. At 24 h, BACTEC detected growth in only 29 of 80 bottles (36%); when subcultured, all 80 cultures grew confluently. At 48 h, BACTEC detected growth in the remaining 53 bottles. BACTEC failed to detect growth in anaerobic bottles at 6 h and at 1, 2, 4, and 5 days of incubation despite growth in subculture. Subcultures from bottles with tryptic soy broth with and without SPS showed growth in 63 to 76 bottles in 6 h and in all bottles after 24 h. The presence of SPS in BACTEC bottles had no effect on growth detection. On the basis of these studies and our clinical experience, we find the NR 730 system to be insensitive and unsuitable for detection of N.meningitidis in </= 24h. However, all test strains were detected after 48h.

Assessment of the BACTEC NR660 blood culture system for the detection of bacteremia in young children

The sensitivity of the BACTEC NR660 blood culture system was assessed by using paired bottles of anaerobic (NR7A) and resin-containing aerobic (NR16A) media and conditions and organisms which simulated those found in pediatric practice. Corresponding media (7D and 16B) of the established BACTEC 460 radiometric method served as controls. The performances of the two systems were similar with 50 isolates of 10 aerobic organisms (aerobic medium) and with 21 isolates of 15 strict anaerobes (anaerobic medium).

Comparative evaluation of the oxoid signal and Roche Septi-Chek blood culture systems

The Oxoid Signal blood culture system (Oxoid USA, Inc., Columbia, Md.) was compared with the Roche Septi-Chek system (Roche Diagnostics, Div. Hoffmann-La Roche Inc., Nutley, N.J.), with the latter consisting of a tryptic soy broth (R-TSB) bottle with an attached agar slide unit and a Columbia broth bottle. A total of 5,034 cultures with equal volumes of blood in each bottle were processed. Overall, more organisms were recovered in the R-TSB bottle than in the Signal bottle, with significantly more aerobic organisms (Pseudomonas spp., Acinetobacter spp., and yeasts) recovered in the R-TSB bottles and anaerobes and viridans group streptococci recovered in Signal bottles. Approximately equivalent numbers of organisms were recovered in the Signal and Columbia broth bottles. The times of detection were essentially identical with the three blood culture broth systems. During the study, 30.6% of the Signal bottles had a positive indicator of growth, of which 1,103 (71.7%) were false-positive cultures. Additionally, nonviable organisms resembling streptococci were observed in 13.7% of the Signal bottles that were Gram stained and in unioculated blood culture bottles. With appropriate modifications of the preparation of the media, the latter problem can be eliminated.

Rapid detection of positive blood cultures with the BACTEC NR-660 does not require first-day subculturing

An analysis of blood culture data was performed to determine whether subculturing within the first 24 h of incubation decreased the time to detection of positive blood cultures when compared with the routine use of the BACTEC NR-660 system (Johnston Laboratories, Inc., Towson, Md.). During a 9-month period (June 1985 to February 1986), 17,913 blood cultures were received in our laboratory, of which 1,463 (8.2%) became positive. Of the positive cultures, 97% were detected with equal or greater rapidity by the NR-660 system than by visual inspection and first-day blind subculturing. There were 37 delayed positive cultures from which only one isolate (0.07%) was not eventually detected by the NR-660 system. Coagulase-negative staphylococcus was the most frequent isolate among the delayed positive cultures, but only 3 of 15 isolates were known to be clinically significant isolates. The longest delay in detection by the NR-660 system was 6 days for one isolate of Cryptococcus neoformans and one isolate of Klebsiella pneumoniae. Although subculturing may decrease the time to detection of a few cultures, the majority of positive blood cultures were detected faster or with equal speed by the NR-660 system. When the data were evaluated, routine use of the NR-660 system was sufficient for the detection of positive blood cultures and was cost-effective.

Comparison of a biphasic system and a non-radiometric system for blood culture

The performance of a biphasic system for blood culture and a non-radiometric system using infrared spectroscopy was compared using 2,000 blood samples. The biphasic system detected bacteria or fungi in 237 blood cultures in 114 patients, while the non-radiometric system detected these microorganisms in only 186 blood cultures in 91 patients (p less than or equal to 0.05). The speed with which the bacteria were detected and the rate of contamination were similar in the two systems. The capacity to detect different genera and species was similar except in the case of Brucella spp., which the biphasic system detected in 28 blood cultures but the non-radiometric system in only 12 (p less than or equal to 0.05).

Routine evaluation of BACTEC NR-16A and NR-17A media

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the BACTEC NR-16A and NR-17A media were more effective than the BACTEC NR-6A and NR-7A media in recovering organisms from the blood of patients undergoing antimicrobial therapy. A total of 986 sets of four blood culture bottles were compared, giving 141, 174, 93, and 104 isolates with BACTEC NR-6A, NR-16A, NR-7A, and NR-17A, respectively. BACTEC NR-6A and NR-7A media recovered 234 isolates, whereas BACTEC NR-16A and NR-17A media recovered 278 isolates. The recovery rate of bacteria when aerobic resin media were used was better than that with conventional aerobic media (P less than 0.001). The mean detection times were 51.5 and 69.7 h with NR-16A and NR-6A, respectively (P less than 0.01), whereas they were 68.2 and 71.3 h with NR-17A and NR-7A, respectively (P greater than 0.05). The small number of anaerobes recovered precluded a statistical comparison of relative recovery for that group of organisms.

Comparative analysis of two blood culture systems (Isolator and a 12-tube system) by cumulative differences in detection power at different times during incubation

A lysis-centrifugation blood culture system (Isolator) and a conventional system (4 tubes of nutrient broth, 4 tubes of semisolid agar, and 4 tubes of thioglycollate agar) were compared after different lengths of incubation by cumulative scoring of differences in detection power. After the first half day of incubation, the Isolator system was already significantly faster in detecting isolates of clinical significance (15 vs. 4, P = 0.02). Maximum difference in first or only detection system was seen after two days of incubation and was based on an overall superior detection of Staphylococcus aureus (11 vs. 0, P = 0.001), and an earlier detection of Enterobacteriaceae (30 vs. 13, P = 0.01) in the Isolator system. On the contrary, the detection of Streptococcus pneumoniae was significantly inferior in the Isolator system (0 vs. 10, P = 0.002). The earlier finding of clinically significant microorganisms in the Isolator system certainly contributes to good patient-care. A drawback of the Isolator system was the finding of clinically insignificant coagulase-negative staphylococci in 11%, compared with 1% in the conventional system. This led to a considerable waste of time and materials in the laboratory. The comparison of the two blood culture systems, based on statistical analysis of cumulative differences in detection power, expressed as the earliest or only findings, gives the optimal information, and is in our opinion the clinically most relevant comparison.