A multicomponent RNA-based control system regulates subgenomic mRNA transcription in a tombusvirus

Metagenomic identification of novel viruses of maize and teosinte in North America

Background

Maize-infecting viruses are known to inflict significant agronomic yield loss throughout the world annually. Identification of known or novel causal agents of disease prior to outbreak is imperative to preserve food security via future crop protection efforts. Toward this goal, a large-scale metagenomic approach utilizing high throughput sequencing (HTS) was employed to identify novel viruses with the potential to contribute to yield loss of graminaceous species, particularly maize, in North America.

Results

Here we present four novel viruses discovered by HTS and individually validated by Sanger sequencing. Three of these viruses are RNA viruses belonging to either the Betaflexiviridae or Tombusviridae families. Additionally, a novel DNA virus belonging to the Geminiviridae family was discovered, the first Mastrevirus identified in North American maize.

Conclusions

Metagenomic studies of crop and crop-related species such as this may be useful for the identification and surveillance of known and novel viral pathogens of crops. Monitoring related species may prove useful in identifying viruses capable of infecting crops due to overlapping insect vectors and viral host-range to protect food security.

Trans-Activator Binding Site Context in RCNMV Modulates Subgenomic mRNA Transcription

Many positive-sense RNA viruses transcribe subgenomic (sg) mRNAs during infections that template the translation of a subset of viral proteins. Red clover necrotic mosaic virus (RCNMV) expresses its capsid protein through the transcription of a sg mRNA from RNA1 genome segment. This transcription event is activated by an RNA structure formed by base pairing between a trans-activator (TA) in RNA2 and a trans-activator binding site (TABS) in RNA1. In this study, the impact of the structural context of the TABS in RNA1 on the TA–TABS interaction and sg mRNA transcription was investigated using in vitro and in vivo approaches. The results (i) generated RNA secondary structure models for the TA and TABS, (ii) revealed that the TABS is partially base paired with proximal upstream sequences, which limits TA access, (iii) demonstrated that the aforementioned intra-RNA1 base pairing involving the TABS modulates the TA–TABS interaction in vitro and sg mRNA levels during infections, and (iv) revealed that the TABS in RNA1 can be modified to mediate sg mRNA transcription in a TA-independent manner. These findings advance our understanding of transcriptional regulation in RCNMV and provide novel insights into the origin of the TA–TABS interaction.

Intragenomic Long-Distance RNA-RNA Interactions in Plus-Strand RNA Plant Viruses

Plant viruses that contain positive-strand RNA genomes represent an important class of pathogen. The genomes of these viruses harbor RNA sequences and higher-order RNA structures that are essential for the regulation of viral processes during infections. In recent years, it has become increasingly evident that, in addition to locally positioned RNA structures, long-distance intragenomic interactions, involving nucleotide base pairing over large distances, also contribute significantly to the control of various viral events. Viral processes that are modulated by such interactions include genome replication, translation initiation, translational recoding, and subgenomic mRNA transcription. Here, we review the structure and function of different types of long-distance RNA–RNA interactions, herein termed LDRIs, present in members of the family Tombusviridae and other plus-strand RNA plant viruses.

Tombusvirus polymerase: Structure and function

Tombusviruses are small icosahedral viruses that possess plus-sense RNA genomes ∼4.8kb in length. The type member of the genus, tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV), encodes a 92kDa (p92) RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp) that is responsible for viral genome replication and subgenomic (sg) mRNA transcription. Several functionally relevant regions in p92 have been identified and characterized, including transmembrane domains, RNA-binding segments, membrane targeting signals, and oligomerization domains. Moreover, conserved tombusvirus-specific motifs in the C-proximal region of the RdRp have been shown to modulate viral genome replication, sg mRNA transcription, and trans-replication of subviral replicons. Interestingly, p92 is initially non-functional, and requires an accessory viral protein, p33, as well as viral RNA, host proteins, and intracellular membranes to become active. These and other host factors, through a well-orchestrated process guided by the viral replication proteins, mediate the assembly of membrane-associated virus replicase complexes (VRCs). Here, we describe what is currently known about the structure and function of the tombusvirus RdRp and how it utilizes host components to build VRCs that synthesize viral RNAs.

Global organization of a positive-strand RNA virus genome

The genomes of plus-strand RNA viruses contain many regulatory sequences and structures that direct different viral processes. The traditional view of these RNA elements are as local structures present in non-coding regions. However, this view is changing due to the discovery of regulatory elements in coding regions and functional long-range intra-genomic base pairing interactions. The ∼4.8 kb long RNA genome of the tombusvirus tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) contains these types of structural features, including six different functional long-distance interactions. We hypothesized that to achieve these multiple interactions this viral genome must utilize a large-scale organizational strategy and, accordingly, we sought to assess the global conformation of the entire TBSV genome. Atomic force micrographs of the genome indicated a mostly condensed structure composed of interconnected protrusions extending from a central hub. This configuration was consistent with the genomic secondary structure model generated using high-throughput selective 2′-hydroxyl acylation analysed by primer extension (i.e. SHAPE), which predicted different sized RNA domains originating from a central region. Known RNA elements were identified in both domain and inter-domain regions, and novel structural features were predicted and functionally confirmed. Interestingly, only two of the six long-range interactions known to form were present in the structural model. However, for those interactions that did not form, complementary partner sequences were positioned relatively close to each other in the structure, suggesting that the secondary structure level of viral genome structure could provide a basic scaffold for the formation of different long-range interactions. The higher-order structural model for the TBSV RNA genome provides a snapshot of the complex framework that allows multiple functional components to operate in concert within a confined context.

The genomes of many important pathogenic viruses are made of RNA. These genomes encode viral proteins and contain regulatory sequences and structures. In some viruses, distant regions of the RNA genome can interact with each other via base pairing, which suggests that certain genomes may take on well-defined conformations. This concept was investigated using a tombusvirus RNA genome that contains several long-range RNA interactions. The results of microscopic and biochemical analyses indicated a compact genome conformation with structured regions radiating from a central core. The structural model was compatible with some, but not all, long-range interactions, suggesting that the genome is a dynamic molecule that assumes different conformations. The analysis also revealed new structural features of the genome, some of which were shown to be functionally relevant. This study advances our understanding of the role played by global structure in virus genome function and provides a model to further investigate its in role virus reproduction. We anticipate that organizational principles revealed by this investigation will be applicable to other viruses.

Subgenomic mRNA transcription in tobacco necrosis virus

Tobacco necrosis virus-D (TNV-D), a positive-strand RNA Necrovirus in the family Tombusviridae, transcribes two subgenomic (sg) mRNAs during infections. We have investigated the strategy used by TNV-D in this process and uncovered evidence that it employs a premature termination (PT) mechanism for the transcription of its sg mRNAs. Structural and mutational analysis of the TNV-D genome identified local RNA structures upstream from transcriptional initiation sites that functioned in the plus-strand as attenuation structures and mediated the production of sg mRNA-sized minus-strands. Other evidence in support of a PT mechanism included the ability to uncouple minus-strand sg RNA production from plus-strand sg mRNA synthesis and the sequence similarities observed between the sg mRNA promoter and that for the viral genome. Accordingly, our results indicate that the necrovirus TNV-D, like several other genera in the family Tombusviridae, uses a PT mechanism for transcription of its sg mRNAs.

Gene N proximal and distal RNA motifs regulate coronavirus nucleocapsid mRNA transcription

Coronavirus subgenomic mRNA (sgmRNA) transcription requires a discontinuous RNA synthesis mechanism driven by the transcription-regulating sequences (TRSs), located at the 3' end of the genomic leader (TRS-L) and also preceding each gene (TRS-B). In transmissible gastroenteritis virus (TGEV), the free energy of TRS-L and cTRS-B (complement of TRS-B) duplex formation is one of the factors regulating the transcription of sgmRNAs. In addition, N gene sgmRNA transcription is controlled by a transcription-regulating motif, including a long-distance RNA-RNA interaction between complementary proximal and distal elements. The extension of complementarity between these two sequences increased N gene transcription. An active domain, a novel essential component of the transcription-regulating motif, has been identified. The active domain primary sequence was necessary for its activity. Relocation of the active domain upstream of the N gene TRS core sequence in the absence of the proximal and distal elements also enhanced sgmRNA N transcription. According to the proposed working model for N gene transcriptional activation, the long-distance RNA-RNA interaction relocates the distant active domain in close proximity with the N gene TRS, which probably increases the frequency of template switching during the synthesis of negative RNA. The transcription-regulating motif has been optimized to a minimal sequence showing a 4-fold activity increase in relation to the native RNA motif. Full-length TGEV infectious viruses were generated with the optimized transcription-regulating motif, which enhanced by 5-fold the transcription of the 3a gene and can be used in expression vectors based in coronavirus genomes.

Subgenomic messenger RNAs: mastering regulation of (+)-strand RNA virus life cycle

Many (+)-strand RNA viruses use subgenomic (SG) RNAs as messengers for protein expression, or to regulate their viral life cycle. Three different mechanisms have been described for the synthesis of SG RNAs. The first mechanism involves internal initiation on a (−)-strand RNA template and requires an internal SGP promoter. The second mechanism makes a prematurely terminated (−)-strand RNA which is used as template to make the SG RNA. The third mechanism uses discontinuous RNA synthesis while making the (−)-strand RNA templates. Most SG RNAs are translated into structural proteins or proteins related to pathogenesis: however other SG RNAs regulate the transition between translation and replication, function as riboregulators of replication or translation, or support RNA–RNA recombination. In this review we discuss these functions of SG RNAs and how they influence viral replication, translation and recombination.

Mapping the subgenomic RNA promoter of the Citrus leaf blotch virus coat protein gene by Agrobacterium-mediated inoculation

Citrus leaf blotch virus has a single-stranded positive-sense genomic RNA (gRNA) of 8747 nt organized in three open reading frames (ORFs). The ORF1, encoding a polyprotein involved in replication, is translated directly from the gRNA, whereas ORFs encoding the movement (MP) and coat (CP) proteins are expressed via 3' coterminal subgenomic RNAs (sgRNAs). We characterized the minimal promoter region critical for the CP-sgRNA expression in infected cells by deletion analyses using Agrobacterium-mediated infection of Nicotiana benthamiana plants. The minimal CP-sgRNA promoter was mapped between nucleotides -67 and +50 nt around the transcription start site. Surprisingly, larger deletions in the region between the CP-sgRNA transcription start site and the CP translation initiation codon resulted in increased CP-sgRNA accumulation, suggesting that this sequence could modulate the CP-sgRNA transcription. Site-specific mutational analysis of the transcription start site revealed that the +1 guanylate and the +2 adenylate are important for CP-sgRNA synthesis.

Replication of Tomato bushy stunt virus RNA in a plant in vitro system

An ideal system to investigate individual determinants of the replication process of (+)-strand RNA viruses is a cell-free extract that supports viral protein and RNA synthesis in a synchronized manner. Here, we applied a translation/replication system based on cytoplasmic extracts of Nicotiana tabacum cells to Tomato bushy stunt virus (TBSV) RNA. In vitro translated TBSV proteins p33 and p92 form viral replicase, which, in the same reaction, accomplishes the entire replication cycle on exogenous TBSV DI or full-length RNA. Tests of mutant TBSV RNAs confirmed the template specificity of the in vitro replication reaction. Complementation experiments ascertained the significance of an earlier identified TBSV host factor. Interestingly, formation of the viral replicase occurs also in the absence of concurrent protein synthesis demonstrating that translation and RNA replication are not functionally linked in this system. Our studies with cell-free extracts of a plant host thus confirmed earlier findings and enabled novel insights into the TBSV RNA replication process.

RNA-based regulation of transcription and translation of aureusvirus subgenomic mRNA1

Cucumber leaf spot virus (CLSV) is an aureusvirus (family Tombusviridae) that has a positive-sense RNA genome encoding five proteins. During infections, CLSV transcribes two subgenomic (sg) mRNAs and the larger of the two, sg mRNA1, encodes coat protein. Here, the viral RNA sequences and structures that regulate transcription and translation of CLSV sg mRNA1 were investigated. A medium-range RNA-RNA interaction in the CLSV genome, spanning 148 nucleotides, was found to be required for the efficient transcription of sg mRNA1. Further analysis indicated that the structure formed by this interaction acted as an attenuation signal required for transcription of sg mRNA1 via a premature termination mechanism. Translation of coat protein from sg mRNA1 was determined to be facilitated by a 5'-terminal stem-loop structure in the message that resembled a tRNA anticodon stem-loop. The results from mutational analysis indicated that the 5'-terminal stem-loop mediated efficient base pairing with a 3'-cap-independent translational enhancer at the 3' end of the message, leading to efficient translation of coat protein from sg mRNA1. Comparison of the regulatory RNA structures for sg mRNA1 of CLSV to those used by the closely related tombusviruses and certain cellular RNAs revealed interesting differences and similarities that provide evolutionary and mechanistic insights into RNA-based regulatory strategies.

Structural and functional analyses of the 3' untranslated region of Bamboo mosaic virus satellite RNA

The 3'-untranslated region (UTR) of RNA genomes of viruses and satellite RNAs plays essential roles in viral replication and transcription. The structural features of the 3'-UTR of the satellite RNA of Bamboo mosaic virus (satBaMV) involved in its replication were analyzed in this study. By the use of enzymatic probing, the secondary structure of satBaMV 3'-UTR was confirmed to comprise two small stem-loops (SLA and SLB), one large stem-loop (SLC), and a poly(A) tail of mainly 75-200 adenylate residues, which is similar to those on the genomic RNA of the helper virus, BaMV. Five sets of mutants of satBaMV were constructed to analyze the biological functions of the structural elements of the 3'-UTR. The data revealed that both the polyadenylation signal and poly(A) tail are required for satBaMV RNA replication. The structural conservation of SLA, SLB, and SLC is also important for efficient satBaMV accumulation, whereas the nucleotides in these regions may also possess sequence-specific functions. In contrast to the requirement for the accumulation of BaMV genomic RNA, mutations in the conserved hexanucleotide (ACCUAA) in the loop region of SLC had limited effect on the accumulation of satBaMV RNA. In addition, replacing the 5'-, 3'-UTR, or both regions of satBaMV by those of BaMV greatly decreased the accumulation of satBaMV RNA. Taken together, these data indicate that satBaMV might have adopted a 3'-UTR structure similar to that of BaMV but may have evolved distinct features for its efficient replication.

Identification of a coronavirus transcription enhancer

Coronavirus (CoV) transcription includes a discontinuous mechanism during the synthesis of sub-genome-length minus-strand RNAs leading to a collection of mRNAs in which the 5' terminal leader sequence is fused to contiguous genome sequences. It has been previously shown that transcription-regulating sequences (TRSs) preceding each gene regulate transcription. Base pairing between the leader TRS (TRS-L) and the complement of the body TRS (cTRS-B) in the nascent RNA is a determinant factor during CoV transcription. In fact, in transmissible gastroenteritis CoV, a good correlation has been observed between subgenomic mRNA (sg mRNA) levels and the free energy (DeltaG) of TRS-L and cTRS-B duplex formation. The only exception was sg mRNA N, the most abundant sg mRNA during viral infection in spite of its minimum DeltaG associated with duplex formation. We postulated that additional factors should regulate transcription of sg mRNA N. In this report, we have described a novel transcription regulation mechanism operating in CoV by which a 9-nucleotide (nt) sequence located 449 nt upstream of the N gene TRS core sequence (CS-N) interacts with a complementary sequence just upstream of CS-N, specifically increasing the accumulation of sg mRNA N. Alteration of this complementarity in mutant replicon genomes showed a correlation between the predicted stability of the base pairing between 9-nt sequences and the accumulation of sg mRNA N. This interaction is exclusively conserved in group 1a CoVs, the only CoV subgroup in which the N gene is not the most 3' gene in the viral genome. This is the first time that a long-distance RNA-RNA interaction regulating transcriptional activity specifically enhancing the transcription of one gene has been described to occur in CoVs.

Higher-order RNA structural requirements and small-molecule induction of tombusvirus subgenomic mRNA transcription

Subgenomic (sg) mRNAs are small viral messages that are synthesized by polycistronic positive-strand RNA viruses to allow for the translation of certain viral proteins. Tombusviruses synthesize two such sg mRNAs via a premature termination mechanism. This transcriptional process involves the viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase terminating minus-strand RNA synthesis prematurely at internal RNA signals during copying of the viral genome. The 3'-truncated minus-strand RNAs generated by the termination events then serve as templates for sg mRNA transcription. A higher-order RNA structure in the viral genome, located just upstream from the termination site, is a critical component of the RNA-based polymerase attenuation signal. Here, we have analyzed the role of this RNA structure in mediating efficient sg mRNA2 transcription. Our results include the following: (i) we define the minimum overall thermodynamic stability required for an operational higher-order RNA attenuation structure; (ii) we show that the distribution of stability within an attenuation structure affects its function; (iii) we establish that an RNA quadruplex structure can act as an effective attenuation structure; (iv) we prove that the higher-order RNA structure forms and functions in the plus strand; (v) we provide evidence that a specific attenuation structure-binding protein factor is not required for transcription; (vi) we demonstrate that sg mRNA transcription can be controlled artificially through small-molecule activation using RNA aptamer technology. These findings provide important new insights into the premature termination mechanism and present a novel approach to regulate the transcriptional process.

Uncoupling RNA virus replication from transcription via the polymerase: functional and evolutionary insights

Many eukaryotic positive-strand RNA viruses transcribe subgenomic (sg) mRNAs that are virus-derived messages that template the translation of a subset of viral proteins. Currently, the premature termination (PT) mechanism of sg mRNA transcription, a process thought to operate in a variety of viruses, is best understood in tombusviruses. The viral RNA elements involved in regulating this mechanism have been well characterized in several systems; however, no corresponding protein factors have been identified yet. Here we show that tombusvirus genome replication can be effectively uncoupled from sg mRNA transcription in vivo by C-terminal modifications in its RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (RdRp). Systematic analysis of the PT transcriptional pathway using viral genomes harboring mutant RdRps revealed that the C-terminus functions primarily at an early step in this mechanism by mediating both efficient and accurate production of minus-strand templates for sg mRNA transcription. Our results also suggest a simple evolutionary scheme by which the virus could gain or enhance its transcriptional activity, and define global folding of the viral RNA genome as a previously unappreciated determinant of RdRp evolution.

Subgenomic mRNA transcription in an aureusvirus: down-regulation of transcription and evolution of regulatory RNA elements

The genus Aureusvirus is composed of a group of positive-strand RNA plant viruses that belong to the family Tombusviridae. Expression of certain aureusvirus genes requires the transcription of two subgenomic (sg) mRNAs. Interestingly, the level of sg mRNA2 accumulation in aureusvirus infections is considerably lower than that of sg mRNA1. The nature of this difference was investigated using the aureusvirus Cucumber leaf spot virus (CLSV). Analysis of sg mRNA2 transcription indicated that it is synthesized by a premature termination mechanism. The results also implicated the transcriptional promoter, the attenuation signal, and global RNA folding of the viral genome as mediators of sg mRNA2 suppression. Additionally, evaluation of the transcriptional regulatory RNA elements in aureusviruses and related tombusviruses revealed alternative strategies for building functionally-equivalent stem-loop structures and showed that sequences encoding a critical and invariant amino acid can be successfully incorporated into essential long-distance tertiary RNA-RNA interactions.