Regulation of Brome Mosaic Virus Gene Expression by Restriction of Initiation of Protein Synthesis

How strong is the case for regulation of the initiation step of translation by elements at the 3' end of eukaryotic mRNAs?

The belief that initiation of translation requires communication between the 5' and 3' ends of the mRNA guides--or misguides--the interpretation of many experiments. The closed-loop model for initiation creates the expectation that sequences at the 3' end of eukaryotic mRNAs should regulate translation. This review looks closely at the evidence in three prominent cases where such regulation is claimed. The mRNAs in question encode 15-lipoxygenase, ceruloplasmin, and histones. Vertebrate histone mRNAs lack a poly(A) tail, instead of which a 3' stem-loop structure is said to promote translation by binding a protein which purportedly binds initiation factors. The proffered evidence for this hypothesis has many flaws. Temporal control of 15-lipoxygenase production in reticulocytes is often cited as another well-documented example of translational regulation via the 3' untranslated region, but inspection of the evidence reveals significant gaps and contradictions. Solid evidence is lacking also for the idea that a ribosomal protein binds to and shuts off translation of ceruloplasmin mRNA. Some viral RNAs that lack a poly(A) tail have alternative 3' structures which are said to promote translation via circularization of the mRNA, but in no case has this been shown convincingly. Interpretation of many experiments is compromised by possible effects of the 3' structures on mRNA stability rather than translation. The functional-half-life assay, which is often employed to rule out effects on mRNA stability, might not be adequate to settle the question. Other issues, such as the possibility of artifacts caused by overexpression of RNA-binding proteins, can complicate studies of translational regulation. There is no doubt that elements at the 3' end of eukaryotic mRNAs can regulate gene expression in a variety of ways. It has not been shown unequivocally that one of these ways involves direct participation of the 3' untranslated region in the initiation step of translation.

Interaction of spermidine with viral RNA and its influence on protein synthesis

Addition of spermidine to a cell-free protein synthesizing system from wheat germ programmed with total brome mosaic virus (BMV) RNA resulted in a several-fold stimulation of amino acid incorporation. Increasing the spermidine concentration in the system led to inhibition of the overall protein synthesis, but the production of longer polypeptides was inhibited much more than that of the coat protein (shorter product). Analysis of the products synthesized under direction of BMV RNA 3 (longer product) and RNA 4 (coat protein) revealed that optimal translation of RNA 3 occurred at a much lower concentration of spermidine than that of RNA 4. Binding experiments with radioactive spermidine and BMV RNAs showed that the saturation of spermidine binding is achieved at a lower concentration of spermidine for RNA 3 than for RNA 4, which may suggest that the structure of RNA 4 is more compact than that of RNA 3. Taking into account the binding obtained at a spermidine concentration corresponding to optimal conditions of protein synthesis, it may be concluded that the optimum translation of these two mRNAs occurs when there is a similar level of RNA charge neutralisation, which implies a similar level of RNA structure stabilisation.

Shutoff of neuroblastoma cell protein synthesis by Semliki Forest virus: loss of ability of crude initiation factors to recognize early Semliki Forest virus and host mRNA's

A crude ribosomal wash containing the initiation factors of protein synthesis was isolated from mouse neuroblastoma cells 8 h after infection with Semliki Forest virus (SFV). The activity of this wash was compared with that of a wash from control cells in a cell-free protein-synthesizing "pH5" system, with early SFV mRNA (42S), late SFV mRNA (26S), encephalomyocarditis virus (EMC) mRNA, or neuroblastoma polyadenylated mRNA templates. A pronounced loss of activity (+/-80%) of the crude ribosomal wash from infected cells was observed with host mRNA (neuroblastoma polyadenylated mRNA) and early SFV mRNA, messengers which contain a cap structure at the 5' terminus. However, these washes were only slightly less active in systems programmed with (noncapped) EMC mRNA and late SFV mRNA. Although late SFV mRNA (26S) is capped, the synthesis of late (= structural) proteins in infected lysates was insensitive to inhibition by cap analogs. Purified initiation factors eIF-4B (M(r), 80,000) and cap-binding protein (M(r), 24,000) from reticulocytes (but none of the others) were able to restore the activity of infected factors to about 90% of control levels in systems programmed with early SFV mRNA and host mRNA. These observations indicate that infection-exposed crude initiation factors have a decreased level of eIF-4B and cap-binding protein activity. However, after partial purification of these and other initiation factors from infected and control cells, we found no significant difference in activity when model assay systems were used. Furthermore, both eIF-4B and cap-binding protein from infected cells were able to restore the activity of these infection-exposed factors to the same level obtained when these factors isolated from control cells or reticulocytes were added. A possible mechanism for the shutoff of host cell protein synthesis is discussed.