CpG hypomethylation in a large domain encompassing the embryonic beta-like globin genes in primitive erythrocytes

DNA methylation patterns of β-globin cluster in β-thalassemia patients

BACKGROUND

Reactivation of fetal hemoglobin (HbF, α₂γ₂) holds a therapeutic target for β-thalassemia and sickle cell disease. Although many HbF regulators have been identified, the methylation patterns in β-globin cluster driving the fetal-to-adult hemoglobin switch remains to be determined.

RESULTS

Here, we evaluated DNA methylation patterns of the β-globin cluster from peripheral bloods of 105 β⁰/β⁰ thalassemia patients and 44 normal controls. We also recruited 15 bone marrows and 4 cord blood samples for further evaluation. We identified that the CpG sites in the locus control region (LCR) DNase I hypersensitive site 4 and 3 (HS4-3) regions, and γ- and β-globin promoters displayed hypomethylation in β⁰/β⁰-thalassemia patients, especially for the patients with high HbF level, as compared with normal controls. Furthermore, hypomethylations in most of CpG sites of the HS4-3 core regions were also observed in bone marrows (BM) of β⁰/β⁰-patients compared with normal controls; and methylation level of γ-globin promoter -50 and + 17 CpG sites showed lower methylation level in patients with high HbF level compared with those with low HbF level and a negative correlation with HbF level among β⁰-thalassemia patients. Finally, γ-globin promoter + 17 and + 50 CpG sites also displayed significant hypomethylation in cord blood (CB) tissues compared with BM tissues from normal controls.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings revealed methylation patterns in β-globin cluster associated with β⁰ thalassemia disease and γ-globin expression, contributed to understand the epigenetic modification in β⁰ thalassemia patients and provided candidate targets for the therapies of β-hemoglobinopathies.

Characterization of Hydroxymethylation Patterns in the Promoter of β-globin Clusters in Murine Fetal Livers

DNA methylation of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) is a key epigenetic regulator in mammals; the dynamic balance between methylation and demethylation affects the transcriptional activity of β-globin. However, the dynamic cytosine methylation of β-globin in vivo during the different stages of embryogenesis and in developing liver has not been fully established. 5-Hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC) is a newly discovered epigenetic modification that is presumably generated by oxidation of 5mC by the ten-eleven translocation (TET) family and it has not been fully identified in β-globin clusters. Here, we determined the 5hmC modifications in the promoter of murine β-globin from fetal livers during normal embryonic development with the methods of bisulfite (BS) and oxidative bisulfite (oxBS)-based pyrosequencing techniques, with the combination of methylated DNA immunoprecipitation (MeDIP) and chromatin immunoprecipitation-quantitative polymerase chain reaction (ChIP-qPCR). The results characterized the 5hmC modification at the CpG sites of -426, -388, and -151 of ɛ(y) promoters and -50 and -487 CpG of β(h1) from transcriptional start sites from E15.5 and E17.5 livers, while 5hmC modification was not observed in the adult β-globin promoters. These observations were validated by the induction of TET transcription after being treated with a potent demethylating agent 5-azacytidine, and TET-mediated hydroxymethylation of ɛ(y) and β(h1) from E13.5 livers was also confirmed in our study. These results suggested the 5hmC modification in promoters of ɛ(y) and β(h1) and indicated that the 5hmC modification is essential for the β-globin switching before the embryonic globin reactivation.

Transcriptional environment and chromatin architecture interplay dictates globin expression patterns of heterospecific hybrids derived from undifferentiated human embryonic stem cells or from their erythroid progeny

To explore the response of β globin locus with established chromatin domains upon their exposure to new transcriptional environments, we transferred the chromatin-packaged β globin locus of undifferentiated human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) or hESC-derived erythroblasts into an adult transcriptional environment. Distinct globin expression patterns were observed. In hESC-derived erythroblasts where both ε and γ globin were active and marked by similar chromatin modifications, ε globin was immediately silenced upon transfer, whereas γ globin continued to be expressed for months, implying that different transcriptional environments were required for their continuing expression. Whereas β globin was silent both in hESCs and in hESC-derived erythroblasts, β globin was only activated upon transfer from hESCs, but not in the presence of dominant γ globin transferred from hESC-derived erythroblasts, confirming the competing nature of γ versus β globin expression. With time, however, silencing of γ globin occurred in the adult transcriptional environment with concurrent activation of β-globin, accompanied by a drastic change in the epigenetic landscape of γ and β globin gene regions without apparent changes in the transcriptional environment. This switching process could be manipulated by overexpression or downregulation of certain transcription factors. Our studies provide important insights into the interplay between the transcription environment and existing chromatin domains, and we offer an experimental system to study the time-dependent human globin switching.

The modern primitives: applying new technological approaches to explore the biology of the earliest red blood cells

One of the most critical stages in mammalian embryogenesis is the independent production of the embryo's own circulating, functional red blood cells. Correspondingly, erythrocytes are the first cell type to become functionally mature during embryogenesis. Failure to achieve this invariably leads to in utero lethality. The recent application of technologies such as transcriptome analysis, flow cytometry, mutant embryo analysis, and transgenic fluorescent gene expression reporter systems has shed new light on the distinct erythroid lineages that arise early in development. Here, I will describe the similarities and differences between the distinct erythroid populations that must form for the embryo to survive. While much of the focus of this review will be the poorly understood primitive erythroid lineage, a discussion of other erythroid and hematopoietic lineages, as well as the cell types making up the different niches that give rise to these lineages, is essential for presenting an appropriate developmental context of these cells.

Mi2β-mediated silencing of the fetal γ-globin gene in adult erythroid cells

An understanding of the human fetal to adult hemoglobin switch offers the potential to ameliorate β-type globin gene disorders such as sickle cell anemia and β-thalassemia through activation of the fetal γ-globin gene. Chromatin modifying complexes, including MBD2-NuRD and GATA-1/FOG-1/NuRD, play a role in γ-globin gene silencing, and Mi2β (CHD4) is a critical component of NuRD complexes. We observed that knockdown of Mi2β relieves γ-globin gene silencing in β-YAC transgenic murine chemical inducer of dimerization hematopoietic cells and in CD34(+) progenitor-derived human primary adult erythroid cells. We show that independent of MBD2-NuRD and GATA-1/FOG-1/NuRD, Mi2β binds directly to and positively regulates both the KLF1 and BCL11A genes, which encode transcription factors critical for γ-globin gene silencing during β-type globin gene switching. Remarkably, <50% knockdown of Mi2β is sufficient to significantly induce γ-globin gene expression without disrupting erythroid differentiation of primary human CD34(+) progenitors. These results indicate that Mi2β is a potential target for therapeutic induction of fetal hemoglobin.

Prevention of transcriptional silencing by a replicator-binding complex consisting of SWI/SNF, MeCP1, and hnRNP C1/C2

Transcriptional silencing selectively impedes gene expression. Silencing is often accompanied by replication delay and can be prevented by replicator sequences. Here we report a replicator-binding protein complex involved in the prevention of transcriptional silencing. The protein complex interacts with an essential asymmetric region within the human β-globin Rep-P replicator and includes hnRNP C1/C2, SWI/SNF complex, and MeCP1, which are members of the locus control region (LCR)-associated remodeling complex (LARC). Interaction between LARC and Rep-P prevented transcriptional silencing and replication delay. Transgenes that did not contain the asymmetric LARC-binding region of Rep-P replicated late and exhibited stable silencing that could not be affected by a DNA methylation inhibitor. In contrast, transgenes that contain a mutation of the asymmetric region of Rep-P that could not bind LARC exhibited a silent state that could transiently be reactivated by DNA demethylation. The effect of DNA demethylation was transient, and prolonged exposure to a methylation inhibitor induced distinct, stable, methylation-independent silencing. These observations suggest that the interaction of LARC complex with replicators plays a role in preventing gene silencing and provides support for a novel, epigenetic mechanism of resistance to methylation inhibitors.

Nuclear receptors TR2 and TR4 recruit multiple epigenetic transcriptional corepressors that associate specifically with the embryonic β-type globin promoters in differentiated adult erythroid cells

Nuclear receptors TR2 and TR4 (TR2/TR4) were previously shown to bind in vitro to direct repeat elements in the mouse and human embryonic and fetal β-type globin gene promoters and to play critical roles in the silencing of these genes. By chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) we show that, in adult erythroid cells, TR2/TR4 bind to the embryonic β-type globin promoters but not to the adult β-globin promoter. We purified protein complexes containing biotin-tagged TR2/TR4 from adult erythroid cells and identified DNMT1, NuRD, and LSD1/CoREST repressor complexes, as well as HDAC3 and TIF1β, all known to confer epigenetic gene silencing, as potential corepressors of TR2/TR4. Coimmunoprecipitation assays of endogenous abundance proteins indicated that TR2/TR4 complexes consist of at least four distinct molecular species. In ChIP assays we found that, in undifferentiated murine adult erythroid cells, many of these corepressors associate with both the embryonic and the adult β-type globin promoters but, upon terminal differentiation, they specifically dissociate only from the adult β-globin promoter concomitant with its activation but remain bound to the silenced embryonic globin gene promoters. These data suggest that TR2/TR4 recruit an array of transcriptional corepressors to elicit adult stage-specific silencing of the embryonic β-type globin genes through coordinated epigenetic chromatin modifications.

MBD2 contributes to developmental silencing of the human ε-globin gene

During erythroid development, the embryonic ε-globin gene becomes silenced as erythropoiesis shifts from the yolk sac to the fetal liver where γ-globin gene expression predominates. Previous studies have shown that the ε-globin gene is autonomously silenced through promoter proximal cis-acting sequences in adult erythroid cells. We have shown a role for the methylcytosine binding domain protein 2 (MBD2) in the developmental silencing of the avian embryonic ρ-globin and human fetal γ-globin genes. To determine the roles of MBD2 and DNA methylation in human ε-globin gene silencing, transgenic mice containing all sequences extending from the 5' hypersensitive site 5 (HS5) of the β-globin locus LCR to the human γ-globin gene promoter were generated. These mice show correct developmental expression and autonomous silencing of the transgene. Either the absence of MBD2 or treatment with the DNA methyltransferase inhibitor 5-azacytidine increases ε-globin transgene expression by 15-20 fold in adult mice. Adult mice containing the entire human β-globin locus also show an increase in expression of both the ε-globin gene transgene and endogenous ε(Y) and β(H1) genes in the absence of MBD2. These results indicate that the human ε-globin gene is subject to multilayered silencing mediated in part by MBD2.

DNA methylation profiling in zebrafish

DNA methylation on cytosine in vertebrates such as zebrafish serves to silence gene expression by interfering with the binding of certain transcription factors and through the recruitment of repressive chromatin machinery. Cytosine DNA methylation is chemically stable and heritable through the germline - but also reversible through many modes, making it a useful and dynamic epigenetic modification. Virtually all of the enzymes and factors involved in the deposition, binding, and removal of cytosine methylation are conserved in zebrafish, and therefore the organism an excellent model for understanding the use of DNA methylation in the control of gene regulation and other processes. Here, we discuss the main approaches to quantifying DNA methylation levels genome-wide in zebrafish: one is an established method for revealing regional methylation (methylated DNA immunoprecipitation (MeDIP)), and the other is an emerging method that reveals DNA methylation at base-pair resolution (shotgun bisulphite sequencing). We also introduce some of the analytical methods that are useful for identifying regions of hypo- or hyper-methylation, and ways to identify differentially methylated regions.

A spectrum of gene regulatory phenomena at mammalian beta-globin gene loci

The beta-globin gene cluster in mammals, consisting of a set of erythroid-specific, developmentally activated, and (or) silenced genes, has long presented a model system for the investigation of gene regulation. As the number and complexity of models of gene activation and repression have expanded, so too has the complexity of phenomena associated with the regulation of the beta-globin genes. Models for expression from within the locus must account for local (promoter-proximal), distal (enhancer-mediated), and domain-wide components of the regulatory pathways that proceed through mammalian development and erythroid differentiation. In this review, we provide an overview of transcriptional activation, silencing, chromatin structure, and the function of distal regulatory elements involved in the normal developmental regulation of beta-globin gene expression.

Dnmt3 and G9a cooperate for tissue-specific development in zebrafish

Although DNA methylation is critical for proper embryonic and tissue-specific development, how different DNA methyltransferases affect tissue-specific development and their targets remains unknown. We address this issue in zebrafish through antisense-based morpholino knockdown of Dnmt3 and Dnmt1. Our data reveal that Dnmt3 is required for proper neurogenesis, and its absence results in profound defects in brain and retina. Interestingly, other organs such as intestine remain unaffected suggesting tissue-specific requirements of Dnmt3. Further, comparison of Dnmt1 knockdown phenotypes with those of Dnmt3 suggested that these two families have distinct functions. Consistent with this idea, Dnmt1 failed to complement Dnmt3 deficiency, and Dnmt3 failed to complement Dnmt1 deficiency. Downstream of Dnmt3 we identify a neurogenesis regulator, lef1, as a Dnmt3-specific target gene that is demethylated and up-regulated in dnmt3 morphants. Knockdown of lef1 rescued neurogenesis defects resulting from Dnmt3 absence. Mechanistically, we show cooperation between Dnmt3 and an H3K9 methyltransferase G9a in regulating lef1. Further, like Dnmt1-Suv39h1 cooperativity, Dnmt3 and G9a seemed to function together for tissue-specific development. G9a knockdown, but not Suv39h1 loss, phenocopied dnmt3 morphants and G9a overexpression provided a striking rescue of dnmt3 morphant phenotypes, whereas Suv39h1 overexpression failed, supporting the notion of specific DNMT-histone methyltransferase networks. Consistent with this model, H3K9me3 levels on the lef1 promoter were reduced in both dnmt3 and g9a morphants, and its knockdown rescued neurogenesis defects in g9a morphants. We propose a model wherein specific DNMT-histone methyltransferase networks are utilized to silence critical regulators of cell fate in a tissue-specific manner.

Developmentally regulated extended domains of DNA hypomethylation encompass highly transcribed genes of the human beta-globin locus

OBJECTIVE

DNA methylation has long been implicated in developmental beta-globin gene regulation. However, the mechanism underlying this regulation is unclear, especially because these genes do not contain CpG islands. This has led us to propose and test the hypothesis that, just as for histone modifications, developmentally specific changes in human beta-like globin gene expression are associated with long-range changes in DNA methylation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Bisulfite sequencing was used to determine the methylation state of individual CpG dinucleotides across the beta-globin locus in uncultured primary human erythroblasts from fetal liver and bone marrow, and in primitive-like erythroid cells derived from human embryonic stem cells.

RESULTS

beta-globin locus CpGs are generally highly methylated, but domains of DNA hypomethylation spanning thousands of base pairs are established around the most highly expressed genes during each developmental stage. These large domains of DNA hypomethylation are found within domains of histone modifications associated with gene expression. We also find hypomethylation of a small proportion of gamma-globin promoters in adult erythroid cells, suggesting a mechanism by which adult erythroid cells produce fetal hemoglobin.

CONCLUSION

This is one of the first reports to show that changes in DNA methylation patterns across large domains around non-CpG island genes correspond with changes in developmentally regulated histone modifications and gene expression. These data support a new model in which extended domains of DNA hypomethylation and active histone marks are coordinately established to achieve developmentally specific gene expression of non-CpG island genes.

Short-chain fatty acid-mediated effects on erythropoiesis in primary definitive erythroid cells

Short-chain fatty acids (SCFAs; butyrate and propionate) up-regulate embryonic/fetal globin gene expression through unclear mechanisms. In a murine model of definitive erythropoiesis, SCFAs increased embryonic beta-type globin gene expression in primary erythroid fetal liver cells (eFLCs) after 72 hours in culture, from 1.7% (+/- 1.2%) of total beta-globin gene expression at day 0 to 4.9% (+/- 2.2%) in propionate and 5.4% (+/- 3.4%) in butyrate; this effect was greater in butyrate plus insulin/erythropoietin (BIE), at 19.5% (+/- 8.3%) compared with 0.1% (+/- 0.1%) in ins/EPO alone (P < .05). Fetal gamma-globin gene expression was increased in human transgene-containing eFLCs, to 35.9% (+/- 7.0%) in BIE compared with 4.4% (+/- 4.2%) in ins/EPO only (P < .05). Embryonic globin gene expression was detectable in 11 of 15 single eFLCs treated with BIE, but in0 of 15 ins/EPO-only treated cells. Butyrate-treated [65.5% (+/- 9.9%)] and 77.5% (+/- 4.0%) propionate-treated eFLCs were highly differentiated in culture, compared with 21.5% (+/- 3.5%) in ins/EPO (P < .005). Importantly, signaling intermediaries, previously implicated in induced embryonic/fetal globin gene expression (STAT5, p42/44, and p38), were not differentially activated by SCFAs in eFLCs; but increased bulk histone (H3) acetylation was seen in SCFA-treated eFLCs. SCFAs induce embryonic globin gene expression in eFLCS, which are a useful short-term and physiologic primary cell model of embryonic/fetal globin gene induction during definitive erythropoiesis.

Epigenetics of beta-globin gene regulation

It is widely recognized that the next great challenge in the post-genomic period is to understand how the genome establishes the cell and tissue specific patterns of gene expression that underlie development. The beta-globin genes are among the most extensively studied tissue specific and developmentally regulated genes. The onset of erythropoiesis in precursor cells and the progressive expression of different members of the beta-globin family during development are accompanied by dramatic epigenetic changes in the locus. In this review, we will consider the relationship between histone and DNA modifications and the transcriptional activity of the beta-globin genes, the dynamic changes in epigenetic modifications observed during erythroid development, and the potential these changes hold as new targets for therapy in human disease.

The role of the epigenetic signal, DNA methylation, in gene regulation during erythroid development

The sequence complexity of the known vertebrate genomes alone is insufficient to account for the diversity between individuals of a species. Although our knowledge of vertebrate biology has evolved substantially with the growing compilation of sequenced genomes, understanding the temporal and spatial regulation of genes remains fundamental to fully exploiting this information. The importance of epigenetic factors in gene regulation was first hypothesized decades ago when biologists posited that methylation of DNA could heritably alter gene expression [Holliday and Pugh, 1975. Science 187(4173), 226-232; Riggs, 1975. Cytogenet. and Cell Genet.14(1), 9-25; Scarano et al., 1967. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 57(5), 1394-1400)]. It was subsequently shown that vertebrate DNA methylation, almost exclusively at the 5' position of cytosine in the dinucleotide CpG, played a role in a number of processes including embryonic development, genetic imprinting, cell differentiation, and tumorigenesis. At the time of this writing, a large and growing list of genes is known to exhibit DNA methylation-dependent regulation, and we understand in some detail the mechanisms employed by cells in using methylation as a regulatory modality. In this context, we revisit one of the original systems in which the role of DNA methylation in vertebrate gene regulation during development was described and studied: erythroid cells. We briefly review the recent advances in our understanding of DNA methylation and, in particular, its regulatory role in red blood cells during differentiation and development. We also address DNA methylation as a component of erythroid chromatin architecture, and the interdependence of CpG methylation and histone modification.