Developmental regulation of the human embryonic beta-like globin gene is mediated by synergistic interactions among multiple tissue- and stage-specific elements

The modern primitives: applying new technological approaches to explore the biology of the earliest red blood cells

One of the most critical stages in mammalian embryogenesis is the independent production of the embryo's own circulating, functional red blood cells. Correspondingly, erythrocytes are the first cell type to become functionally mature during embryogenesis. Failure to achieve this invariably leads to in utero lethality. The recent application of technologies such as transcriptome analysis, flow cytometry, mutant embryo analysis, and transgenic fluorescent gene expression reporter systems has shed new light on the distinct erythroid lineages that arise early in development. Here, I will describe the similarities and differences between the distinct erythroid populations that must form for the embryo to survive. While much of the focus of this review will be the poorly understood primitive erythroid lineage, a discussion of other erythroid and hematopoietic lineages, as well as the cell types making up the different niches that give rise to these lineages, is essential for presenting an appropriate developmental context of these cells.

Analysis of primitive erythroid cell proliferation and enucleation using a cyan fluorescent reporter in transgenic mice

Primitive erythropoiesis is a vital process for mammalian embryonic development. Here we report the generation and characterization of a new transgenic mouse line that expresses a histone H2B-CFP fusion protein in the nuclei of primitive erythroid cells. We demonstrate the potential of this ε-globin-histone H2B-CFP line for multicolor imaging and flow cytometry analysis. The ε-globin-H2B-CFP line was used to analyze the cell cycle distribution and proliferation of CFP-expressing primitive erythroblasts from E8.5-E13.5. We also evaluated phagocytosis of extruded CFP-positive nuclei by macrophages in fetal liver and placenta. The ε-globin-H2B-CFP transgenic mouse line adds to the available tools for studying the development of the primitive erythroid lineage.

Maturation and enucleation of primitive erythroblasts during mouse embryogenesis is accompanied by changes in cell-surface antigen expression

Primitive erythroblasts (EryPs) are the first hematopoietic cell type to form during mammalian embryogenesis and emerge within the blood islands of the yolk sac. Large, nucleated EryPs begin to circulate around midgestation, when connections between yolk sac and embryonic vasculature mature. Two to 3 days later, small cells of the definitive erythroid lineage (EryD) begin to differentiate within the fetal liver and rapidly outnumber EryPs in the circulation. The development and maturation of EryPs remain poorly defined. Our analysis of embryonic blood at different stages reveals a stepwise developmental progression within the EryP lineage from E9.5 to E12.5. Thereafter, EryDs are also present in the bloodstream, and the 2 lineages are not easily distinguished. We have generated a transgenic mouse line in which the human epsilon-globin gene promoter drives expression of green fluorescent protein exclusively within the EryP lineage. Here, we have used this line to characterize changes in cell morphology and surface-marker expression as EryPs mature and to track EryP numbers and enucleation throughout gestation. This study identifies previously unrecognized synchronous developmental stages leading to the maturation of EryPs in the mouse embryo. Unexpectedly, we find that EryPs are a stable cell population that persists through the end of gestation.

Investigations of a human embryonic globin gene silencing element using YAC transgenic mice

A silencing element has been previously located upstream of the human epsilon-globin gene promoter using transient assays and transgenic mice carrying plasmid constructs in which the element has been deleted or its transcriptional motifs have been mutated. To investigate whether this element functions in the context of the whole beta-globin locus, we analyzed epsilon-globin gene expression in transgenic mice carrying a deletion of the silencing element in the context of a 213-kilobase human beta-globin yeast artificial chromosome (beta-YAC). epsilon-Globin gene expression was measured during embryonic and fetal development and in adult mice. epsilon-mRNA levels in embryonic cells in Day 12 blood were as high as those measured in wild-type beta-YAC controls, indicating that the deletion does not affect epsilon gene promoter function. epsilon-Globin gene expression was confined to the embryonic cells, indicating that deletion of this silencing element did not affect epsilon-globin developmental expression in the context of the beta-YAC. These results suggest that in the context of the whole beta-globin locus, other proximal and upstream epsilon gene promoter elements as well as competition by the downstream globin genes contribute to the silencing of the epsilon-globin gene in the cells of definitive erythropoiesis.

Evaluation of regulatory potential and conservation scores for detecting cis-regulatory modules in aligned mammalian genome sequences

Techniques of comparative genomics are being used to identify candidate functional DNA sequences, and objective evaluations are needed to assess their effectiveness. Different analytical methods score distinctive features of whole-genome alignments among human, mouse, and rat to predict functional regions. We evaluated three of these methods for their ability to identify the positions of known regulatory regions in the well-studied HBB gene complex. Two methods, multispecies conserved sequences and phastCons, quantify levels of conservation to estimate a likelihood that aligned DNA sequences are under purifying selection. A third function, regulatory potential (RP), measures the similarity of patterns in the alignments to those in known regulatory regions. The methods can correctly identify 50%-60% of noncoding positions in the HBB gene complex as regulatory or nonregulatory, with RP performing better than do other methods. When evaluated by the ability to discriminate genomic intervals, RP reaches a sensitivity of 0.78 and a true discovery rate of approximately 0.6. The performance is better on other reference sets; both phastCons and RP scores can capture almost all regulatory elements in those sets along with approximately 7% of the human genome.

A human embryonic hemoglobin inhibits Hb S polymerization in vitro and restores a normal phenotype to mouse models of sickle cell disease

The principle that developmentally silenced globin genes can be reactivated in adults with defects in beta-globin gene expression has been well established both in vitro and in vivo. In practice, levels of developmental stage-discordant fetal gamma globin that can be achieved by using currently approved therapies are generally insufficient to fully resolve typical clincopathological features of sickle cell disease. The therapeutic potential of another developmentally silenced globin--embryonic epsilon globin--has been difficult to evaluate in the absence of a convenient expression system or an appropriate experimental model. The current work analyzes the antisickling properties of an epsilon -globin-containing heterotetramer (Hb Gower-2) both in vitro as well as in vivo in a well-established mouse model of sickle cell anemia. These animals, expressing 100% human Hb S, display a chronic hemolytic anemia with compensatory marrow and extramedullary erythropoiesis, abundant circulating sickled erythrocytes, and chronic tissue damage evidenced by parallel histopathological and functional deficits. By comparison, related mice that coexpress Hb S as well as Hb Gower-2 exhibit normal physiological, morphological, histological, and functional attributes. Subsequent in vitro analyses substantiate results from whole-animal studies, indicating that the polymerization of deoxygenated Hb S can be significantly slowed by relatively small quantities of Hb Gower-2. Together, the in vivo and in vitro analyses suggest that reactivation of epsilon-globin gene expression would be therapeutically beneficial to adults with sickle phenotypes, and provide a rationale for detailed investigations into the molecular basis for its developmental silencing.

Histone- and protamine-DNA association: conservation of different patterns within the beta-globin domain in human sperm

Most DNA in human sperm is bound to highly basic proteins called protamines, but a small proportion is complexed with histones similar to those found in active chromatin. This raises the intriguing possibility that histones in sperm are marking sets of genes that will be preferentially activated during early development. We have examined the chromatin structure of members of the beta-globin gene family, which are expressed at different times in development, and the protamine 2 gene, which is expressed in spermatids prior to the widespread displacement of histones by transition proteins. The genes coding for epsilon and gamma globin, which are active in the embryonic yolk sac, contain regions which are histone associated in the sperm. No histone-associated regions are present at the sites tested within the beta- and delta-globin genes which are silent in the embryonic yolk sac. The trends of histone or protamine association are consistent for samples from the same person, and no significant between-subject variations in these trends are found for 13 of the 15 fragments analyzed in the two donors. The results suggest that sperm chromatin structures are generally similar in different men but that the length of the histone-associated regions can vary. The association of sperm DNA with histones or protamines sometimes changes within as little as 400 bp of DNA, suggesting that there is fine control over the retention of histones.

The HMG domain protein SSRP1/PREIIBF is involved in activation of the human embryonic beta-like globin gene

The human embryonic beta-like globin (epsilon-globin) gene is expressed in primitive erythroid cells of the yolk sac during the first few weeks of development. We have previously shown that developmental stage-specific expression of the epsilon-globin gene is mediated by multiple positive and negative regulatory elements upstream of the start of transcription. Of particular interest is one positive regulatory element, PRE II, that works together with other elements (PRE I and PRE V) to confer developmental stage- and/or tissue-specific expression on a minimal promoter. An approximately 85- to 90-kDa PRE II binding factor (PREIIBF) was identified in the nuclei of erythroid cells and shown to bind specifically to a novel 19-bp region within PRE II; binding of this protein to PRE II resulted in bending of the target DNA and was required for promoter activation. In this report, we present the cDNA expression cloning of PREIIBF. The cDNA encodes a previously identified member of the HMG domain family of DNA binding proteins termed SSRP1. By a number of biochemical and immunological criteria, recombinant SSRP1 appears to be identical to the PREII binding factor from erythroid nuclei. A hallmark of HMG domain proteins is their ability to bend their target DNAs; therefore, as we speculated previously, DNA bending by SSRP1/PREIIBF may contribute to the mechanism by which PRE II synergizes with other regulatory elements located upstream and downstream. In contrast with reports from other investigators, we demonstrate that SSRP1 binds DNA with clear sequence specificity. Moreover, we show that SSRP1/PREIIBF lacks a classical activation domain but that binding by this protein to PRE II is required for activation of a minimal promoter in stable erythroid cell lines. These studies provide the first evidence that SSRP1 plays a role in transcriptional regulation. SSRP1/PREIIBF may serve an architectural function by helping to coordinate the assembly of a multiprotein complex required for stage-specific regulation of the human epsilon-globin gene.

Mutation of gene-proximal regulatory elements disrupts human epsilon-, gamma-, and beta-globin expression in yeast artificial chromosome transgenic mice

Previous studies have defined transcriptional control elements, in addition to the promoters, that both lie near individual human beta-globin locus genes and have been implicated in their differential stage-specific regulation during development (i.e., are believed to directly participate in hemoglobin switching). We have reinvestigated the activities during erythropoiesis that might be conferred by two of the more intensively analyzed of these elements, the epsilon-globin gene 5' silencer and the beta-globin gene 3' enhancer, by deleting them from a yeast artificial chromosome that spans the human beta-globin locus, and then analyzing transgenic mice for expression of all of the human genes. These studies show that sequences within the epsilon-globin "silencer" are not only required for silencing but are also required for activation of epsilon-globin transcription; furthermore, deletion of the silencer simultaneously reduced gamma-globin transcription during the yolk sac stage of erythroid development. Analysis of the adult beta-globin gene 3' enhancer deletion showed that its deletion affects only that gene.

Essential role of NF-E2 in remodeling of chromatin structure and transcriptional activation of the epsilon-globin gene in vivo by 5' hypersensitive site 2 of the beta-globin locus control region

Much of our understanding of the process by which enhancers activate transcription has been gained from transient-transfection studies in which the DNA is not assembled with histones and other chromatin proteins as it is in the cell nucleus. To study the activation of a mammalian gene in a natural chromatin context in vivo, we constructed a minichromosome containing the human epsilon-globin gene and portions of the beta-globin locus control region (LCR). The minichromosomes replicate and are maintained at stable copy number in human erythroid cells. Expression of the minichromosomal epsilon-globin gene requires the presence of beta-globin LCR elements in cis, as is the case for the chromosomal gene. We determined the chromatin structure of the epsilon-globin gene in both the active and inactive states. The transcriptionally inactive locus is covered by an array of positioned nucleosomes extending over 1,400 bp. In minichromosomes with a (mu)LCR or DNase I-hypersensitive site 2 (HS2) which actively transcribe the epsilon-globin gene, the nucleosome at the promoter is altered or disrupted while positioning of nucleosomes in the rest of the locus is retained. All or virtually all minichromosomes are simultaneously hypersensitive to DNase I both at the promoter and at HS2. Transcriptional activation and promoter remodeling, as well as formation of the HS2 structure itself, depended on the presence of the NF-E2 binding motif in HS2. The nucleosome at the promoter which is altered upon activation is positioned over the transcriptional elements of the epsilon-globin gene, i.e., the TATA, CCAAT, and CACCC elements, and the GATA-1 site at -165. The simple availability of erythroid transcription factors that recognize these motifs is insufficient to allow expression. As in the chromosomal globin locus, regulation also occurs at the level of chromatin structure. These observations are consistent with the idea that one role of the beta-globin LCR is to maintain promoters free of nucleosomes. The restricted structural change observed upon transcriptional activation may indicate that the LCR need only make a specific contact with the proximal gene promoter to activate transcription.

A DNA-bending protein interacts with an essential upstream regulatory element of the human embryonic beta-like globin gene

The mammalian beta-like globin gene family has served as an important model system for analysis of tissue- and developmental state-specific gene regulation. Although the activities of a number of regulatory proteins have been implicated in the erythroid cell-specific transcription of globin genes, the mechanisms that restrict their expression to discrete stages of development are less well understood. We have previously identified a novel regulatory element (PRE II) upstream from the human embryonic beta-like globin gene (epsilon) that synergizes with other sequences to confer tissue- and stage-specific expression on a minimal epsilon-globin gene promoter in cultured embryonic erythroid cells. Binding of an erythroid nuclear protein (PRE II-binding factor [PRE-IIBF]) to the PRE II control element is required for promoter activation. Here we report on some of the biochemical properties of PREIIBF, including the characterization of its specificity and affinity for DNA. The embryonic and adult forms of PREIIBF recognize their cognate sequences with identical specificities, supporting our earlier conclusion that they are very similar proteins. PREIIBF binds DNA as a single polypeptide with an Mr of approximately 80,000 to 85,000 and introduces a bend into the target DNA molecule. These results suggest a mechanism by which PREIIBF may contribute to the regulation of the embryonic beta-like globin gene within the context of a complex locus.

A novel developmental regulatory motif required for stage-specific activation of the epsilon-globin gene and nuclear factor binding in embryonic erythroid cells

Members of the human beta-globin gene family are expressed at discrete stages of development and therefore provide an important model system for examining mechanisms of temporal gene regulation. We have previously shown that expression of the embryonic beta-like globin gene (epsilon) is mediated by a complex array of positive and negative upstream control elements. Correct developmental stage- and tissue-specific gene expression is conferred by synergistic interactions between a positive regulatory element (termed epsilon-PRE II) which is active only in embryonic erythroid cells and at least two other regulatory domains upstream of the epsilon-globin gene promoter. A nuclear factor highly enriched in cultured embryonic erythroid cells and in mouse embryonic yolk sac binds to a novel, evolutionarily conserved sequence within epsilon-PRE II. We show here that binding of this factor to the conserved element within epsilon-PRE II is critical for transcriptional activity. Point mutations that interfere with protein binding to epsilon-PRE II abolish transcriptional activation of the constitutive epsilon-globin promoter. Adult erythroid nuclei (from cultured cells or adult mouse liver) also contain a factor that binds to this region, but the complex formed migrates more rapidly during nondenaturing electrophoresis, suggesting either that distinct proteins bind to epsilon-PRE II or that a single protein is differentially modified in these cells in a way that modulates its activity. Several lines of evidence suggest that the binding factors in embryonic and adult erythroid cells are distinguished by posttranscriptional differences.

A novel developmental regulatory motif required for stage-specific activation of the epsilon-globin gene and nuclear factor binding in embryonic erythroid cells

Members of the human beta-globin gene family are expressed at discrete stages of development and therefore provide an important model system for examining mechanisms of temporal gene regulation. We have previously shown that expression of the embryonic beta-like globin gene (epsilon) is mediated by a complex array of positive and negative upstream control elements. Correct developmental stage- and tissue-specific gene expression is conferred by synergistic interactions between a positive regulatory element (termed epsilon-PRE II) which is active only in embryonic erythroid cells and at least two other regulatory domains upstream of the epsilon-globin gene promoter. A nuclear factor highly enriched in cultured embryonic erythroid cells and in mouse embryonic yolk sac binds to a novel, evolutionarily conserved sequence within epsilon-PRE II. We show here that binding of this factor to the conserved element within epsilon-PRE II is critical for transcriptional activity. Point mutations that interfere with protein binding to epsilon-PRE II abolish transcriptional activation of the constitutive epsilon-globin promoter. Adult erythroid nuclei (from cultured cells or adult mouse liver) also contain a factor that binds to this region, but the complex formed migrates more rapidly during nondenaturing electrophoresis, suggesting either that distinct proteins bind to epsilon-PRE II or that a single protein is differentially modified in these cells in a way that modulates its activity. Several lines of evidence suggest that the binding factors in embryonic and adult erythroid cells are distinguished by posttranscriptional differences.