Chromatin structure and transcriptional activity around the replication forks arrested at the 3' end of the yeast rRNA genes

Regulatory processes that maintain or alter ribosomal DNA stability during the repair of programmed DNA double-strand breaks

Organisms have evolved elaborate mechanisms that maintain genome stability. Deficiencies in these mechanisms result in changes to the nucleotide sequence as well as copy number and structural variations in the genome. Genome instability has been implicated in numerous human diseases. However, genomic alterations can also be beneficial as they are an essential part of the evolutionary process. Organisms sometimes program genomic changes that drive genetic and phenotypic diversity. Therefore, genome alterations can have both positive and negative impacts on cellular growth and functions, which underscores the need to control the processes that restrict or induce such changes to the genome. The ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA) is highly abundant in eukaryotic genomes, forming a cluster where numerous rDNA copies are tandemly arrayed. Budding yeast can alter the stability of its rDNA cluster by changing the rDNA copy number within the cluster or by producing extrachromosomal rDNA circles. Here, we review the mechanisms that regulate the stability of the budding yeast rDNA cluster during repair of DNA double-strand breaks that are formed in response to programmed DNA replication fork arrest.

Repair of UV induced DNA lesions in ribosomal gene chromatin and the role of "Odd" RNA polymerases (I and III)

In fast growing eukaryotic cells, a subset of rRNA genes are transcribed at very high rates by RNA polymerase I (RNAPI). Nuclease digestion-assays and psoralen crosslinking have shown that they are open; that is, largely devoid of nucleosomes. In the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisae, nucleotide excision repair (NER) and photolyase remove UV photoproducts faster from open rRNA genes than from closed and nucleosome-loaded inactive rRNA genes. After UV irradiation, rRNA transcription declines because RNAPI halt at UV photoproducts and are then displaced from the transcribed strand. When the DNA lesion is quickly recognized by NER, it is the sub-pathway transcription-coupled TC-NER that removes the UV photoproduct. If dislodged RNAPI are replaced by nucleosomes before NER recognizes the lesion, then it is the sub-pathway global genome GG-NER that removes the UV photoproducts from the transcribed strand. Also, GG-NER maneuvers in the non-transcribed strand of open genes and in both strands of closed rRNA genes. After repair, transcription resumes and elongating RNAPI reopen the rRNA gene. In higher eukaryotes, NER in rRNA genes is inefficient and there is no evidence for TC-NER. Moreover, TC-NER does not occur in RNA polymerase III transcribed genes of both, yeast and human fibroblast.

The role of the Fanconi anemia network in the response to DNA replication stress

Fanconi anemia is a genetically heterogeneous disorder associated with chromosome instability and a highly elevated risk for developing cancer. The mutated genes encode proteins involved in the cellular response to DNA replication stress. Fanconi anemia proteins are extensively connected with DNA caretaker proteins, and appear to function as a hub for the coordination of DNA repair with DNA replication and cell cycle progression. At a molecular level, however, the raison d'être of Fanconi anemia proteins still remains largely elusive. The thirteen Fanconi anemia proteins identified to date have not been embraced into a single and defined biological process. To help put the Fanconi anemia puzzle into perspective, we begin this review with a summary of the strategies employed by prokaryotes and eukaryotes to tolerate obstacles to the progression of replication forks. We then summarize what we know about Fanconi anemia with an emphasis on biochemical aspects, and discuss how the Fanconi anemia network, a late acquisition in evolution, may function to permit the faithful and complete duplication of our very large vertebrate chromosomes.

Replication fork barriers: pausing for a break or stalling for time?

Defects in chromosome replication can lead to translocations that are thought to result from recombination events at stalled DNA replication forks. The progression of forks is controlled by an essential DNA helicase, which unwinds the parental duplex and can stall on encountering tight protein-DNA complexes. Such pause sites are hotspots for recombination and it has been proposed that stalled replisomes disassemble, leading to fork collapse. However, in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes it now seems that paused forks are surprisingly stable, so that DNA synthesis can resume without recombination if the barrier protein is removed. Recombination at stalled forks might require other events that occur after pausing, or might be dependent on features of the surrounding DNA sequence. These findings have important implications for our understanding of the regulation of genome stability in eukaryotic cells, in which pausing of forks is mediated by specific proteins that are associated with the replicative helicase.

The yeast rDNA locus: a model system to study DNA repair in chromatin

Most of the studies on the effect of chromatin structure and chromatin remodeling on DNA repair are based on in vitro reconstituted assays. In such experiments individual nucleosomes are either released by nuclease digestion of native chromatin fibers or are assembled from purified histones. Though reconstituted assays are valid approaches to follow NER in chromatin they are of somehow limited physiological relevance since single core particles do not exist in vivo [K. van Holde, J. Zlatanova, The nucleosome core particle: does it have structural and physiological relevance? Bioessays 21 (1999) 776-778]. This is particularly true for studies involving core histones tails, as in their natural chromatin context histones tails participate in interactions that are not necessarily present in vitro [J.C. Hansen, C. Tse, A.P. Wolffe, Structure and function of the core histone N-termini: more than meets the eye, Biochemistry 37 (1998) 17637-17641; J.J. Hayes, J.C. Hansen, Nucleosomes and chromatin fiber, Curr. Opin. Genet. Dev. 11 (2001) 124-129]. Indeed it was found that human DNA ligase I has the capability to ligate a nick on the surface of a 215bp nucleosome but not a nick in a nucleosome lacking linker DNA, possibly because of forced interactions between histone tails and core DNA present in the latter complex [D.R. Chafin, J.M. Vitolo, L.A. Henricksen, B.A. Bambara, J.J. Hayes, Human DNA ligase I efficiently seals nicks in nucleosomes, EMBO J. 19 (2000) 5492-5501]. In addition, chromatin remodeling could also occur in the higher ordered folding of chromatin and involve multiple arrays of nucleosomes [P.J. Horn, C.L. Peterson, Chromatin higher order folding: wrapping up transcription, Science 297 (2002) 1824-1827]. By studying the chromatin structure of ribosomal genes in yeast, our knowledge of the fate of nucleosomes during transcription and DNA replication has improved considerably [R. Lucchini, J.M. Sogo, The dynamic structure of ribosomal RNA gene chromatin, in: M.R. Paule (Ed.), Transcription of Ribosomal RNA Genes by Eukaryotic RNA Polymerase I, Springer-Verlag/R.G. Landes Company, 1998, pp. 254-276]. How nuclear processes such as DNA repair take place in chromatin is still largely unknown, and in this review I discuss how the yeast rDNA locus may be exploited to investigate DNA repair and chromatin modification in vivo.

Psoralen photocrosslinking, a tool to study the chromatin structure of RNA polymerase I--transcribed ribosomal genes

The chromatin structure of RNA polymerase I--transcribed ribosomal DNA (rDNA) is well characterized. In most organisms, i.e., lower eukaryotes, plants, and animals, only a fraction of ribosomal genes are transcriptionally active. At the chromatin level inactive rDNA is assembled into arrays of nucleosomes, whereas transcriptionally active rDNA does not contain canonical nucleosomes. To separate inactive (nucleosomal) and active (non-nucleosomal) rDNA, the technique of psoralen photocrosslinking has been used successfully both in vitro and in vivo. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the structure of rDNA chromatin has been particularly well studied during transcription and during DNA replication. Thus, the yeast rDNA locus has become a good model system to study the interplay of all nuclear DNA processes and chromatin. In this review we focused on the studies of chromatin in ribosomal genes and how these results have helped to address the fundamental question: What is the structure of chromatin in the coding regions of genes?

Exo1 Processes Stalled Replication Forks and Counteracts Fork Reversal in Checkpoint-Defective Cells

The replication checkpoint coordinates the cell cycle with DNA replication and recombination, preventing genome instability and cancer. The budding yeast Rad53 checkpoint kinase stabilizes stalled forks and replisome-fork complexes, thus preventing the accumulation of ss-DNA regions and reversed forks at collapsed forks. We searched for factors involved in the processing of stalled forks in HU-treated rad53 cells. Using the neutral-neutral two-dimensional electrophoresis technique (2D gel) and psoralen crosslinking combined with electron microscopy (EM), we found that the Exo1 exonuclease is recruited to stalled forks and, in rad53 mutants, counteracts reversed fork accumulation by generating ss-DNA intermediates. Hence, Exo1-mediated fork processing resembles the action of E. coli RecJ nuclease at damaged forks. Fork stability and replication restart are influenced by both DNA polymerase-fork association and Exo1-mediated processing. We suggest that Exo1 counteracts fork reversal by resecting newly synthesized chains and resolving the sister chromatid junctions that cause regression of collapsed forks.

rDNA enhancer affects replication initiation and mitotic recombination: Fob1 mediates nucleolytic processing independently of replication

To investigate the influence of the ribosomal DNA enhancer on initiation of replication and recombination at the ribosomal array, we used yeast S. cerevisiae strains with adjacent, tagged rRNA genes. We found that the enhancer is an absolute requirement for replication fork barrier function, while it only modulates initiation of replication. Moreover, the formation of monomeric extrachromosomal ribosomal circles depends on this element. Our data indicate that DNA double-strand breaks occur at specific sites in the parental leading arm of replication forks stalled at the replication fork barrier. Additionally, nicks upstream of the replication fork barrier were visualized by nucleotide-resolution mapping. They coincide with essential sequences of the mitotic hyperrecombination site HOT1, which previously has been determined at ectopic sites. Interestingly, these nicks are strictly dependent on the replication fork blocking-protein (Fob1), but are replication independent, suggesting that intrachromosomal ribosomal DNA recombination may occur outside of S phase.

Epigenetic silencing of RNA polymerase I transcription

The genes that encode ribosomal RNA exist in two distinct types of chromatin--an 'open' conformation that is permissive to transcription and a 'closed' conformation that is transcriptionally refractive. Recent studies have provided insights into the molecular mechanisms that silence either entire nucleolus organizer regions (NORs) in genetic hybrids or individual rRNA genes within a NOR. An emerging theme from these studies is that epigenetic mechanisms operating at the level of DNA methylation and histone modifications alter the chromatin structure and control the ratio of active and inactive rRNA genes.

Microarray deacetylation maps determine genome-wide functions for yeast histone deacetylases

Yeast contains a family of five related histone deacetylases (HDACs) whose functions are known at few genes. Therefore, we used chromatin immunoprecipitation and intergenic microarrays to generate genome-wide HDAC enzyme activity maps. Rpd3 and Hda1 deacetylate mainly distinct promoters and gene classes where they are recruited largely by novel mechanisms. Hda1 also deacetylates subtelomeric domains containing normally repressed genes that are used instead for gluconeogenesis, growth on carbon sources other than glucose, and adverse growth conditions. These domains have certain features of heterochromatin but are distinct from subtelomeric heterochromatin repressed by the deacetylase Sir2. Finally, Hos1/Hos3 and Hos2 preferentially affect ribosomal DNA and ribosomal protein genes, respectively. Thus, acetylation microarrays uncover the "division of labor" for yeast histone deacetylases.

Ku antigen supports termination of mammalian rDNA replication by transcription termination factor TTF-I

A replication fork barrier at the 3'-end of mouse ribosomal RNA genes blocks bidirectional fork progression and limits DNA replication to the same direction as transcription. This barrier is an inherent property of a defined DNA-protein complex including transcription termination factor I, and specific protein-protein interactions occur between this factor and protein(s) of the replication machinery. Here we report that a second DNA-binding protein is essential for barrier activity. We have purified and functionally characterised the protein from HeLa cells. The final preparation contained two polypeptides with molecular masses of 70 and 86 kDa, respectively. Both polypeptides interact with a GC-stretch adjacent to the binding site of transcription termination factor I. The specificity of binding to the barrier DNA was demonstrated in an electrophoretic mobility shift assay. The biochemical properties of this protein resemble that of Ku antigen, a human nuclear DNA-binding heterodimer that is the target of autoimmune-antibodies in several autoimmune diseases. Recombinant Ku protein, purified as heterodimer from co-infected insect cells, is able to partially rescue the barrier activity in Ku-depleted HeLa cell extracts. These data demonstrate that transcription termination factor I and Ku act synergistically to prevent head-on collision between the replication and the transcription machinery.

Replication of yeast rDNA initiates downstream of transcriptionally active genes

In the yeast S. cerevisiae, ARS (autonomously replicating sequence) elements located in the intergenic spacers of the rRNA gene locus are infrequently activated as origins of replication. We analyzed the rARS activation with a combination of neutral/neutral (N/N) two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis and either the intercalating drug psoralen, which in vivo specifically marks the transcribing gene copies, or the selective accessibility of restriction sites in transcriptionally active genes. We found that initiation of replication starts at those rARSs placed immediately downstream of transcribing rRNA genes. This correlation between transcription and replication is consistent with the presence of nucleosome-free enhancers at each transcriptionally active gene copy and suggests that the transcription factor Abf1p is involved in replication initiation at the ARS in the rDNA gene locus.

Mechanisms and consequences of replication fork arrest

Chromosome replication is not a uniform and continuous process. Replication forks can be slowed down or arrested by DNA secondary structures, specific protein-DNA complexes, specific DNA-RNA hybrids, or interactions between the replication and transcription machineries. Replication arrest has important implications for the topology of replication intermediates and can trigger homologous and illegitimate recombination. Thus, replication arrest may be a key factor in genome instability. Several examples of these phenomena are reviewed here.

Developmental regulation of replication fork pausing in Xenopus laevis ribosomal RNA genes

In early Xenopus embryos, replication forks move along the rRNA genes (rDNA) at a uniform rate and terminate at multiple, apparently random sites. In contrast, a polar replication fork barrier (RFB) is found at the 3' end of the rRNA genes in Xenopus cultured cells. We have now analysed the replication intermediates of Xenopus rDNA from a wide range of developmental stages by 2D gel electrophoresis. Surprisingly, up to 15 different replication fork pausing sites (RFPs) simultaneously appear in the rDNA at the midgastrula stage, when rRNA transcription abruptly increases. They disappear during the neurula stage, except for a polar RFP at the 3' end of Xthe transcription unit, which persists to the tadpole stage. The latter RFP is found at the same location as the RFB in cultured cells; however the arrest of replication forks at this RFP is not absolute, since termination occurs at multiple positions throughout the rDNA repeat. The efficiency of fork arrest at this RFP remains constant from midgastrula to early tadpole, and decreases around hatching. The transient appearance of multiple RFPs at midgastrula may reflect some chromatin remodeling associated with developmental activation of rRNA transcription.

Elimination of replication block protein Fob1 extends the life span of yeast mother cells

A cause of aging in yeast is the accumulation of circular species of ribosomal DNA (rDNA) arising from the 100-200 tandemly repeated copies in the genome. We show here that mutation of the FOB1 gene slows the generation of these circles and thus extends life span. Fob1p is known to create a unidirectional block to replication forks in the rDNA. We show that Fob1p is a nucleolar protein, suggesting a direct involvement in the replication fork block. We propose that this block can trigger aging by causing chromosomal breaks, the repair of which results in the generation of rDNA circles. These findings may provide a novel link between metabolic rate and aging in yeast and, perhaps, higher organisms.

Regulation of RNA polymerase I transcription in yeast and vertebrates

This article focuses on what is currently known about the regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase I (pol I) in eukaryotic organisms at opposite ends of the evolutionary spectrum--a yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and vertebrates, including mice, frogs, and man. Contemporary studies that have defined the DNA sequence elements are described, as well as the majority of the basal transcription factors essential for pol I transcription. Situations in which pol I transcription is known to be regulated are reviewed and possible regulatory mechanisms are critically discussed. Some aspects of basal pol I transcription machinery appear to have been conserved from fungi to vertebrates, but other aspects have evolved, perhaps to meet the needs of a metazoan organism. Different parts of the pol I transcription machinery are regulatory targets depending on different physiological stimuli. This suggests that multiple signaling pathways may also be involved. The involvement of ribosomal genes and their transcripts in events such as mitosis, cancer, and aging is discussed.

Ribosomal DNA replication in the fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe

We have employed genetic and two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoretic methods to identify replication initiation, pausing, and termination sites in the tandem ribosomal DNA (rDNA) repeats of the fission yeast, Schizosaccharomyces pombe. An autonomously replicating sequence (ARS) element, ars3001, maps to a 2.3-kb restriction fragment spanning the junction between the nontranscribed spacer (NTS) and the external transcribed spacer upstream of the ribosomal RNA genes, and 2D gel analysis shows that replication initiates in the NTS portion of the same fragment. A pause region at the 3' end of the rRNA genes inhibits forks from entering these genes counter to the direction of transcription. Thus, most forks move through the genes in the same direction as transcription. In these respects, fission yeast rDNA replication resembles that in the budding yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and in multicellular eukaryotic organisms. A feature which, so far, has been detected only in fission yeast is the pausing of replication forks in a broad region near the 5.8S rRNA gene.

Termination of mammalian rDNA replication: polar arrest of replication fork movement by transcription termination factor TTF-I

A replication fork barrier (RFB) at the 3' end of eukaryotic ribosomal RNA genes blocks bidirectional fork progression and limits DNA replication to the same direction as transcription. We have reproduced the RFB in vitro in HeLa cell extracts using 3' terminal murine rDNA fused to an SV40 origin-based vector. The RFB is polar and modularly organized, requiring both the Sal box transcription terminator and specific flanking sequences. Mutations within the terminator element, depletion of the RNA polymerase I-specific transcription termination factor TTF-I, or deletion of the termination domain of TTF-I abolishes RFB activity. Thus, the same factor that blocks elongating RNA polymerase I prevents head-on collision between the DNA replication apparatus and the transcription machinery.

The ColE1 unidirectional origin acts as a polar replication fork pausing site

Co-orientation of replication origins is the most common organization found in nature for multimeric plasmids. Streptococcus pyogenes broad-host-range plasmid pSM19035 and Escherichia coli pPI21 are among the exceptions. pPI21, which is a derivative of pSM19035 and pBR322, has two long inverted repeats, each one containing a potentially active ColE1 unidirectional origin. Analysis of pPI21 replication intermediates (RIs) by two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis and electron microscopy revealed the accumulation of a specific RI containing a single internal bubble. The data obtained demonstrated that initiation of DNA replication occurred at a single origin in pPI21. Progression of the replicating fork initiated at either of the two potential origins was transiently stalled at the other inversely oriented silent ColE1 origin of the plasmid. The accumulated RIs, containing an internal bubble, occurred as a series of stereoisomers with different numbers of knots in their replicated portion. These observations provide one of the first functional explanations for the disadvantage of head-to-head plasmid multimers with respect to head-to-tail ones.

Replication of transcriptionally active chromatin

In eukaryotic cells, active genes and their regulatory sequences are organized into open chromatin conformations in which nucleosomes can be modified, disrupted or totally absent. It has been proposed that these characteristic chromatin structures and their associated factors might be directly inherited by the newly synthesized daughter strands during chromosome duplication. Here we show that in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, replication machinery entering upstream of a transcriptionally active ribosomal RNA gene generates two newly replicated coding regions regularly packaged into nucleosomes, indicating that the active chromatin structure cannot be directly inherited at the replication fork. Whereas the establishment of an exposed chromatin conformation at some newly replicated rRNA gene promoters can occur shortly after the passage of the replication fork, regeneration of the active chromatin structure along the coding region is always a post-replicative process involving disruption of preformed nucleosomes.

Inheritance of chromatin states

The packaging of regulatory DNA within the eukaryotic chromosome has considerable potential not only for modulating the transcriptional activity of genes, but also for propagating states that are permissive or restrictive for transcription. Sequence-specific transcription factors, histones and their modifications, chromodomain proteins and enzymes that modify histones, DNA methylation and proteins that recognize methylated DNA could all play independent or interrelated roles in regulating gene activity. They all also have the potential of propagating their interactions with nascent DNA following replication. However, observations on the phenomenon of X chromosome inactivation suggest that the formation and stability of specific histone-DNA interactions through replication may be central to the inheritance of chromatin states, and that other molecular mechanisms have supporting roles. The future offers the exciting prospect of reconstructing the propagation of stable active or repressed chromatin states in vitro, and consequently understanding the events occurring at the replication fork in molecular detail.