Human lumbar apophyseal joint damage and intervertebral disc degeneration

Chronology of disc degeneration and facet joint arthritis in lumbar spine is variable - A CT based cross-sectional study

BACKGROUND

The notion that disc degeneration (DD) always precedes facet joint arthritis (FJA) has held sway for many decades. However, it is not always the case. We hypothesized that DD is not always the first offender studied the prevalence of isolated DD and isolated FJA in the lumbar spine.

METHODS

Inter-vertebral discs and bilateral facet joints of lumbar spines of 135 participants were graded. The participants were divided into one of the four categories. 'No degeneration,' 'Isolated disc degeneration without facet joint arthritis,' 'Combined disc degeneration and facet joint arthritis,' and 'Isolated facet joint arthritis without disc degeneration.' Multivariate logistic regression analysis was done to evaluate the predictive factors for spinal degeneration using FJA as a dependent variable while age, sex, BMI, smoking history, and DD as predictor variables.

RESULTS

The majority of participants had isolated FJA 64 (47.4%). Combined DD and FJA were noted in 32 (23.7%), isolated DD in 8 (5.9%), while 31(23%) had no degeneration. Only age was found to be significantly contributing to the prediction model in multivariate analysis.

CONCLUSION

Our study shows that spinal degeneration may begin either in the disc or in the facet joints depending upon the aetiological factors. It is a vicious circle that may be entered at any point, FJA or DD.

The Diagnostic Value of an X-ray-based Scoring System for Degeneration of the Cervical Spine: A Reproducibility and Validation Study

Background

In interventional pain medicine, cervical facet joint (CFJ) pain is commonly treated with CFJ denervation techniques, almost automatically assuming degeneration of the CFJs as an important cause of CFJ pain. A standard cervical X‐ray is still commonly used in the clinical evaluation of patients suspected for CFJ degeneration. Although degenerative features can be visualized by different radiological imaging techniques, the relation between radiological degenerative features of the cervical spine and pain remains controversial. Paramount in order to estimate the clinical usefulness of a radiological imaging is to establish the reproducibility of the radiological scoring system. A reproducible and clinically feasible diagnostic scoring system was developed to estimate cervical degeneration on standard cervical X‐rays.

Materials and Methods

A reproducibility study for the interpretation of degenerative abnormalities on standard cervical X‐rays was performed, using a dichotomous outcome (degenerative abnormalities present Yes/No). The estimation of intervertebral disc height loss on standard cervical X‐rays was validated with computed tomography (CT) scan measurements.

Results

Five radiological degenerative features on standard cervical X‐rays (disc height loss, anterior vertebral osteophytes, posterior vertebral osteophytes, vertebral end plate sclerosis, and uncovertebral osteoarthritis) showed a substantial to excellent reproducibility (kappa value ≥ 0.60). The qualitative definition of disc height loss used in the reproducibility study showed a substantial agreement with the actual measurements of disc height loss on CT scan (kappa value = 0.69).

Conclusion

Subjective judgment of a cervical standard X‐ray is a reproducible method to demonstrate degenerative abnormalities of the cervical spine.

[Lumbar facet joint degeneration contributes to degenerative lumbar scoliosis induced by asymmetric stress in rabbits]

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the role of lumbar facet joint degeneration in the development of degenerative lumbar scoliosis caused by asymmetric stress.

METHODS

Thirty-six New Zealand white rabbits were randomly divided into 3 groups (n=12): Group A with aspiration of the nucleus pulposus to induce disc degeneration; Group B with removal of the left capsule from the facet joints at L3/4 to L5/6 to induce degeneration; and Group C with both treatments. Springs were deployed on the left adjacent facets at L3/4, L5/6 and L5/6 to stress the facet joints. Serial radiographs were taken at 3 and 6 months, and the facet joint tissues were sampled at 6 months for Safranin O-fast green staining to assess the severity of cartilage degeneration based on the Mankin score.

RESULTS

The Cobb angle differed significantly among the 3 groups (F=24.865, P=0.000). In all the groups, the Cobb angles at 6 months increased significantly as compared with that at 3 months (P <0.05). The Cobb angles were significantly greater in group C than in the other 2 groups at both 3 and 6 months (P <0.05) but showed no significant difference between Groups A and B (P>0.05). The severity of facet joint degeneration also differed significantly among the 3 groups (F= 22.009, P=0.000), and was the most severe in group C (P <0.05); facet joint degeneration was more severe in group B than in group A (P <0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Facet joint degeneration is an important factor that contributes to the development of degenerative lumbar scoliosis. Disc degeneration and facet joints degeneration can lead to lumbar scoliosis, which in turn aggravates disc degeneration, facet joints degeneration and asymmetric stress, thus forming a vicious circle to further exacerbate lumbar scoliosis.

Segmental variations in facet joint translations during in vivo lumbar extension

The lumbar facet joint (FJ) is often associated with pathogenesis in the spine, but quantification of normal FJ motion remains limited to in vitro studies or static imaging of non-functional poses. The purpose of this study was to quantify lumbar FJ kinematics in healthy individuals during functional activity with dynamic stereo radiography (DSX) imaging. Ten asymptomatic participants lifted three known weights starting from a trunk-flexed (∼75°) position to an upright position while being imaged within the DSX system. High resolution computed tomography (CT) scan-derived 3D models of their lumbar vertebrae (L2-S1) were registered to the biplane 2D radiographs using a markerless model-based tracking technique providing instantaneous 3D vertebral kinematics throughout the lifting tasks. Effects of segment level and weight lifted were assessed using mixed-effect repeated measures ANOVA. Superior-inferior (SI) translation dominated FJ translation, with L5S1 showing significantly less translation magnitudes (Median (Md) = 3.5 mm, p < 0.0001) than L2L3, L3L4, and L4L5 segments (Md = 5.9 mm, 6.3 mm and 6.6 mm respectively). Linear regression-based slopes of continuous facet translations revealed strong linearity for SI translation (r² > 0.94), reasonably high linearity for sideways sliding (Z-) (r² > 0.8), but much less linearity for facet gap change (X-) (r² ∼ 0.5). Caudal segments (L4-S1), particularly L5S1, displayed greater coupling compared to cranial (L2-L4) segments, revealing distinct differences overall in FJ translation trends at L5S1. No significant effect of weight lifted on FJ translations was detected. The study presents a hitherto unavailable and highly precise baseline dataset of facet translations measured during a functional, dynamic lifting task.

Comparison of facet joint degeneration in firefighters and hospital office workers

Background

There are few published studies on the relationship between occupational lumbar load and facet joint degeneration (FJD). This cross-sectional study was conducted to evaluate the effect of physical lumbar load on FJD by comparing magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings of firefighters (FFs) and hospital office workers (HOWs).

Methods

We randomly sampled 341 male FFs and 80 male HOWs by age stratification. A questionnaire and clinical examination, including MRI of the lumbar spine (T12-S1), were conducted. FJD was diagnosed and graded by using the classification of Pathria et al., and reclassified into two groups as follows: no FJD (grade 0) and FJD (grades 1, 2, and 3). The prevalence of FJD was analyzed according to occupational group.

Results

The prevalence of FJD ranged from 31% (L1–L2) to 75% (L4–L5) in the FFs, and from 18% (L1–L2) to 69% (L4–L5) in the HOWs. After adjustment for age, body mass index, and frequency of physical exercise, the adjusted odds ratios (OR) for FJD in the FFs were significantly higher than those in the HOWs at all lumbar spinal levels, except for L3–L4 (L1–L2: OR, 2.644; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.317–5.310; L2–L3: OR, 2.285; 95% CI, 1.304–4.006; L4–L5: OR, 1.918; 95% CI, 1.037–3.544; L5–S1: OR, 1.811; 95% CI, 1.031–3.181).

Conclusion

This study shows that FFs exhibit a greater likelihood of having FJD than HOWs after controlling for other risk factors of FJD. This suggests that the physical occupational demands of FFs affect their risk of developing FJD.

Hyperlordosis is Associated With Facet Joint Pathology at the Lower Lumbar Spine

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective study.

OBJECTIVE

Our study opted to clarify the remaining issues of lumbar lordosis (LL) with regard to (1) its physiological values, (2) age, (3) sex, and (4) facet joint (FJ) arthritis and orientation using computed tomography (CT) scans.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Recent studies have questioned whether LL really decreases with age, but study sample sizes have been rather small and mostly been based on x-rays. As hyperlordosis increases the load transferred through the FJs, it seems plausible that hyperlordosis may lead to FJ arthritis at the lower lumbar spine.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the CT scans of 620 individuals, with a mean age of 42.5 (range, 14-94) years, who presented to our traumatology department and underwent a whole-body CT scan, between 2008 and 2010. LL was evaluated between the superior endplates of L1 and S1. FJs of the lumbar spine were evaluated for arthritis and orientation between L2 and S1.

RESULTS

(1) The mean LL was 49.0 degrees (SD 11.1 degrees; range, 11.4-80.1 degrees). (2) LL increased with age and there was a significant difference in LL in our age groups (30 y and below, 31-50, 51-70, and ≥71 y and above) (P=0.02). (3) There was no significant difference in LL between females and males (50 and 49 degrees) (P=0.17). (4) LL showed a significant linear association with FJ arthritis [P=0.0026, OR=1.022 (1.008-1.036)] and sagittal FJ orientation at L5/S1 (P=0.001). In a logistic regression analysis, the cutoff point for LL was 49.4 degrees.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the largest CT-based study on LL and FJs. LL significantly increases with age. As a novelty finding, hyperlordosis is significantly associated with FJ arthritis and sagittal FJ orientation at the lower lumbar spine. Thus, hyperlordosis may present with back pain and patients may benefit from surgical correction, for example, in the setting of trauma.

CLINICAL-RADIOGRAPHIC CORRELATION OF DEGENERATIVE CHANGES OF THE SPINE - SYSTEMATIC REVIEW

ABSTRACT Systematic review of the literature on the evaluation of images of degenerative changes of the spine and its clinical correlation. A systematic literature review was conducted, and the results evaluated for the presence of clinical correlation, as well as the type of imaging method used. The search terms were "Intervertebral Disc Degeneration", "Intervertebral disc", "Classification", "Anulus fibrosus", "Nucleus pulposus", "Lumbar spine", "Degenerative disc disease", "Degeneration", "Zygapophyseal Joint". We also assessed whether there were inter- and intraobserver agreement in the selected works and possible guidelines regarding the treatment and prognosis of patients. Of the 91 reviewed abstracts, 31 articles were selected that met the inclusion criteria. Six articles were related to the cervical spine, 13 to the lumbar spine and 12 were about changes not related specifically to a single segment of the spine. Articles that determined limiting values considered normal were also included, since variations were considered signs of degeneration or pathology. It was not possible to establish the relationship between the changes identified in imaging and the clinical history of patients, either define treatment and prognosis guidelines.

Quantitative ultrasound assessment of the facet joint in the lumbar spine: a feasibility study

This study was designed to determine the feasibility and accuracy of a sonographic approach to assessment of facet joints of the lumbar spine in healthy populations. Five facet joints (L1-S1) on each side of 30 volunteers, for a total of 300 facet joints, were examined and evaluated by sonography and computed tomography. Parameters of the facet joints (height and width) were established to assess the facet joint in the parasagittal and transverse planes on all volunteers. Differences between means of continuous variables including age, height, weight, body surface area, body mass index and joint parameters were evaluated with Student's t-test. Stepwise multiple regression analysis was used to evaluate the associations between the mean values of facet joint parameters and age, height, body surface area and body mass index. In general, sonography revealed that facet joints had a clear and smooth border. There were no significant differences in width and height between the left and right facet joints at the same level by sonography. Stepwise multiple regression analysis revealed that body mass index and age (p < 0.05) were the only independent factors modulating height of the facet joint. Facet joint width was independently influenced by age (p < 0.01). There were no significant differences between ultrasound and computed tomography in mean measurements of height (1.23 ± 0.15 vs. 1.25 ± 0.07, p > 0.05) and width (0.17 ± 0.08 vs. 0.18 ± 0.07, p > 0.05) of the facet joint, respectively. In this article, we describe a feasible, accurate and simple technique for identification and depiction of facet joints of the lumbar spine in healthy populations.

Disc cell therapies: critical issues

BACKGROUND

Disc cell therapies, in which cells are injected into the degenerate disc in order to regenerate the matrix and restore function, appear to be an attractive, minimally invasive method of treatment. Interest in this area has stimulated research into disc cell biology in particular. However, other important issues, some of which are discussed here, need to be considered if cell-based therapies are to be brought to the clinic.

PURPOSE

Firstly, a question which is barely addressed in the literature, is how to identify patients with 'degenerative disc disease' who would benefit from cell therapy. Pain not disc degeneration is the symptom which drives patients to the clinic. Even though there are associations between back pain and disc degeneration, many people with even severely degenerate discs, with herniated discs or with spinal stenosis, are pain-free. It is not possible using currently available techniques to identify whether disc repair or regeneration would remove symptoms or prevent symptoms from occurring in future. Moreover, the repair process in human discs is very slow (years) because of the low cell density which can be supported nutritionally even in healthy human discs. If repair is necessary for relief of symptoms, questions regarding quality of life and rehabilitation during this long process need consideration. Also, some serious technical issues remain. Finding appropriate cell sources and scaffolds have received most attention, but these are not the only issues determining the feasibility of the procedure. There are questions regarding the safety of implanting cells by injection through the annulus whether the nutrient supply to the disc is sufficient to support implanted cells and whether, if cells are able to survive, conditions in a degenerate human disc will allow them to repair the damaged tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

If cell therapy for treatment of disc-related disorders is to enter the clinic as a routine treatment, investigations must examine the questions related to patient selection and the feasibility of achieving the desired repair in an acceptable time frame. Few diagnostic tests that examine whether cell therapies are likely to succeed are available at present, but definite exclusion criteria would be evidence of major disc fissures, or disturbance of nutrient pathways as measured by post-contrast MRI.

Increased pelvic incidence may lead to arthritis and sagittal orientation of the facet joints at the lower lumbar spine

BACKGROUND

Correct sagittal alignment with a balanced pelvis and spine is crucial in the management of spinal disorders. The pelvic incidence (PI) describes the sagittal pelvic alignment and is position-independent. It has barely been investigated on CT scans. Furthermore, no studies have focused on the association between PI and facet joint (FJ) arthritis and orientation. Therefore, our goal was to clarify the remaining issues about PI in regard to (1) physiologic values, (2) age, (3) gender, (4) lumbar lordosis (LL) and (5) FJ arthritis and orientation using CT scans.

METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed CT scans of 620 individuals, with a mean age of 43 years, who presented to our traumatology department and underwent a whole body CT scan, between 2008 and 2010. The PI was determined on sagittal CT planes of the pelvis by measuring the angle between the hip axis to an orthogonal line originating at the center of the superior end plate axis of the first sacral vertebra. We also evaluated LL, FJ arthritis and orientation of the lumbar spine.

RESULTS

596 individuals yielded results for (1) PI with a mean of 50.8°. There was no significant difference for PI and (2) age, nor (3) gender. PI was significantly and linearly correlated with (4) LL (p = < 0.0001). Interestingly, PI and (5) FJ arthritis displayed a significant and linear correlation (p = 0.0062) with a cut-off point at 50°. An increased PI was also significantly associated with more sagitally oriented FJs at L5/S1 (p = 0.01).

CONCLUSION

PI is not correlated with age nor gender. However, this is the first report showing that PI is significantly and linearly associated with LL, FJ arthritis and more sagittal FJ orientation at the lower lumbar spine. This may be caused by a higher contact force on the lower lumbar FJs by an increased PI. Once symptomatic or in the event of spinal trauma, patients with increased PI and LL could benefit from corrective surgery and spondylodesis.

Lumbar facet joint arthritis is associated with more coronal orientation of the facet joints at the upper lumbar spine

We retrospectively analyzed CT scans of 620 individuals, who presented to our traumatology department between 2008 and 2010. Facet joint (FJ) arthritis was present in 308 (49.7%) individuals with a mean grade of 1. It was seen in 27% of individuals ≤40 years and in 75% of individuals ≥41 years (P < 0.0001) as well as in 52% of females and 49% of males (P = 0.61). Mean FJ orientation was 30.4° at L2/3, 38.7° at L3/4, 47° at L4/5, and 47.3° at L5/S1. FJ arthritis was significantly associated with more coronal (increased degree) FJ orientation at L2/3 (P = 0.03) with a cutoff point at ≥32°. FJs were more coronally oriented (48.8°) in individuals ≤40 years and more sagittally oriented (45.6°) in individuals ≥41 years at L5/S1 (P = 0.01). Mean FJ asymmetry was 4.89° at L2/3, 6.01° at L3/4, 6.67° at L4/5, and 7.27° at L5/S1, without a significant difference for FJ arthritis. FJ arthritis is common, increases with age, and affects both genders equally. More coronally oriented FJs (≥32°) in the upper lumbar spine may be an individual risk factor for development of FJ arthritis.

Lições sobre a substituição total de disco cervical após sete anos de acompanhamento

OBJETIVOS: Apresentar a experiência clínica e radiológica da artroplastia cervical no tratamento da degeneração do disco intervertebral, mantendo o movimento e reduzindo o estresse e a degeneração dos segmentos adjacentes. MÉTODOS: Foram estudadas as radiografias de 280 níveis em 161 pacientes (média de idade de 45,4 anos) tratados entre os níveis cervicais C3-4 e C7-T1. Setenta e um pacientes foram operados em um único nível, 67 pacientes em dois, 17 em três, e seis em quatro níveis. Os resultados radiológicos e clínicos foram coletados no pré-operatório, 1 semana, 1, 3 e 6 meses e anualmente. Questionários NDI/VAS foram utilizados para avaliar a dor e os resultados funcionais. Para a análise da degeneração facetária, foi utilizada uma escala de quatro graus com base em tomografias computadorizadas. RESULTADOS: Os resultados clínicos melhoraram significativamente em todas as visitas pós-operatórias. A maioria dos pacientes evoluiu com grau I e II de degeneração facetária, e para esses casos não houve piora clínica, diferentemente de casos com grau III e IV. Entre os níveis estudados, 25 (8,93%) revelaram algum grau de HO: 14 apresentaram grau I (56%), 7 de grau II (28%), 3 com grau III (12%) e apenas um com grau IV (4%). Em 92% dos pacientes que desenvolveram HO havia presença de osteófitos incipientes. Ocorreu doença em nível adjacente em 5,7% dos pacientes. CONCLUSÃO: Os bons resultados clínicos também corroboram a superioridade do CTDR em comparação com a ACDF, já descritos na literatura.

In vivo topographic analysis of lumbar facet joint space width distribution in healthy and symptomatic subjects

STUDY DESIGN

In vivo 3-dimensional facet joint space width measurement.

OBJECTIVE

To determine lumbar facet joint space width within clinically relevant topographical zones in vivo and its correlations with age, level, and presence of lower back pain symptoms.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

Facet joint gap narrowing, articular cartilage thinning, and subarticular cortical bone hypertrophy are frequently observed age-related changes. Facet joint space width is a well-defined parameter to evaluate osteoarthritis. To the best of our knowledge, there is no other study that quantifies 3-dimensional facet joint space width distribution in vivo.

METHODS

Three-dimensional measurement to quantify facet joint space width distribution based on 5 clinically relevant topographic zones in a cohort of healthy and symptomatic volunteers with low back pain, using subject-based 3-dimensional computed tomographic models with respect to spinal level, subject age, sex, and presence/absence of lower back pain.

RESULTS

Facet joint space width (mean ± SD) was 1.93 ± 0.51 mm for the central zone, 1.75 ± 0.48 mm for the superior zone, 1.63 ± 0.49 mm for the inferior zone, 1.48 ± 0.44 mm for the medial zone, and 1.65 ± 0.48 mm for the lateral zone, respectively. There were no significant differences between right and left facet joints. Male patients showed larger space width than female patients. Overall, space width of symptomatic subjects was significantly narrower than that of the asymptomatic group. Facet joints in the peripheral zones were narrower than in the central zone. Age-group comparisons showed that local narrowing occurring as early as in the third decade at the inferior zone of L5-S1, with all the remaining zones implicated after the fourth decade.

CONCLUSION

This in vivo study shows variations in facet joint space width narrowing with spinal level and region within the facet joint and in vivo evidence of localized, age-influenced facet cartilage thinning. Techniques developed in this study may be applied in the detection of early osteoarthritis-related changes in the facet joints.

Does lumbar spinal degeneration begin with the anterior structures? A study of the observed epidemiology in a community-based population

BACKGROUND

Prior studies that have concluded that disk degeneration uniformly precedes facet degeneration have been based on convenience samples of individuals with low back pain. We conducted a study to examine whether the view that spinal degeneration begins with the anterior spinal structures is supported by epidemiologic observations of degeneration in a community-based population.

METHODS

361 participants from the Framingham Heart Study were included in this study. The prevalences of anterior vertebral structure degeneration (disk height loss) and posterior vertebral structure degeneration (facet joint osteoarthritis) were characterized by CT imaging. The cohort was divided into the structural subgroups of participants with 1) no degeneration, 2) isolated anterior degeneration (without posterior degeneration), 3) combined anterior and posterior degeneration, and 4) isolated posterior degeneration (without anterior structure degeneration). We determined the prevalence of each degeneration pattern by age group < 45, 45-54, 55-64, ≥65. In multivariate analyses we examined the association between disk height loss and the response variable of facet joint osteoarthritis, while adjusting for age, sex, BMI, and smoking.

RESULTS

As the prevalence of the no degeneration and isolated anterior degeneration patterns decreased with increasing age group, the prevalence of the combined anterior/posterior degeneration pattern increased. 22% of individuals demonstrated isolated posterior degeneration, without an increase in prevalence by age group. Isolated posterior degeneration was most common at the L5-S1 and L4-L5 spinal levels. In multivariate analyses, disk height loss was independently associated with facet joint osteoarthritis, as were increased age (years), female sex, and increased BMI (kg/m(2)), but not smoking.

CONCLUSIONS

The observed epidemiology of lumbar spinal degeneration in the community-based population is consistent with an ordered progression beginning in the anterior structures, for the majority of individuals. However, some individuals demonstrate atypical patterns of degeneration, beginning in the posterior joints. Increased age and BMI, and female sex may be related to the occurrence of isolated posterior degeneration in these individuals.

Prevalence of facet joint degeneration in association with intervertebral joint degeneration in a sample of organ donors

Among the most common causes of low back pain are strain on the muscles and ligaments associated with the spine, degeneration of the intervertebral discs (IVDs), and osteoarthritis of the facet joints. It is not clear, however, how these latter two conditions are related to each other in terms of their development during a patient's lifetime. The facet joint is the sole synovial joint of the spine but because it is difficult to image its degenerative history as well as its relationship to other degenerative factors within the spine remain elusive. We compared the gross and histologic characteristics of the lumbar spine from a sample of organ donors to the integrity of their associated IVDs as assessed through magnetic resonance imaging. In our study sample, we found that facet joint degeneration was common, occurring as early as 15 years of age, while the IVD could still remain intact. Facet degeneration was more severe at the L4/5 level and progressed along with IVD degeneration with age. Because such early degenerative changes in the facet joint are somewhat surprising, degeneration of this joint should not be overlooked when assessing OA of the spine and causes of lower back pain.

Qualitative and quantitative assessment of degeneration of cervical intervertebral discs and facet joints

Degeneration of intervertebral discs and facet joints is one of the most frequently encountered spinal disorders. In order to describe and quantify degeneration and evaluate a possible relationship between degeneration and biomechanical parameters, e.g., the intervertebral range of motion and intradiscal pressure, a scoring system for degeneration is mandatory. However, few scoring systems for the assessment of degeneration of the cervical spine exist. Therefore, two separate objective scoring systems to qualitatively and quantitatively assess the degree of cervical intervertebral disc and facet joint degeneration were developed and validated. The scoring system for cervical disc degeneration consists of three variables which are individually scored on neutral lateral radiographs: "height loss" (0-4 points), "anterior osteophytes" (0-3 points) and "endplate sclerosis" (0-2 points). The scoring system for facet joint degeneration consists of four variables which are individually scored on neutral computed tomography scans: "hypertrophy" (0-2 points), "osteophytes" (0-1 point), "irregularity" on the articular surface (0-1 point) and "joint space narrowing" (0-1 point). Each variable contributes with varying importance to the overall degeneration score (max 9 points for the scoring system of cervical disc degeneration and max 5 points for facet joint degeneration). Degeneration of 20 discs and facet joints of 20 patients was blindly assessed by four raters: two neurosurgeons (one senior and one junior) and two radiologists (one senior and one junior), firstly based on first subjective impression and secondly using the scoring systems. Measurement errors and inter- and intra-rater agreement were determined. The measurement error of the scoring system for cervical disc degeneration was 11.1 versus 17.9% of the subjective impression results. This scoring system showed excellent intra-rater agreement (ICC = 0.86, 0.75-0.93) and excellent inter-rater agreement (ICC = 0.78, 0.64-0.88). Surgeons as well as radiologists and seniors as well as juniors obtained excellent inter- and intra-rater agreement. The measurement error of the scoring system for cervical facet joint degeneration was 20.1 versus 24.2% of the subjective impression results. This scoring system showed good intra-rater agreement (ICC = 0.71, 0.42-0.89) and fair inter-rater agreement (ICC = 0.49, 0.26-0.74). Both scoring systems fulfilled the criteria for recommendation proposed by Kettler and Wilke. Our scoring systems can be reliable and objective tools for assessing cervical disc and facet joint degeneration. Moreover, the scoring system of cervical disc degeneration was shown to be experience- and discipline-independent.

Biomechanical implications of degenerative joint disease in the apophyseal joints of human thoracic and lumbar vertebrae

An experimental technique for quantifying load-sharing in cadaveric spines is used to test the hypothesis that degenerative changes in human apophyseal joints are directly related to high levels of compressive load-bearing by these joints. About 36 cadaveric thoraco-lumbar motion segments aged 64-92 years were subjected to a compressive load of 1.5 kN. The distribution of compressive stress was measured in the intervertebral discs using a miniature pressure transducer, and stress measurements were summed over area to give the compressive force resisted by the disc. This was subtracted from the applied 1.5 kN to indicate compressive load-bearing by the apophyseal joints. The cartilage of each apophyseal joint surface was then graded for degree of degeneration. After maceration, each joint surface was scored for degenerative joint disease (DJD) affecting the bone. Results demonstrated that the apophyseal joints resisted 5-96% (mean 45%) of the applied compressive force. A significant positive correlation was demonstrated between age and cartilage degeneration, age and DJD bone score, apophyseal joint load-bearing and bone score, and cartilage score and load-bearing. The latter correlation was strongest for load-bearing above 50%. Ordinal regression showed that the variables describing bone DJD (marginal osteophytes, pitting, bony contour change, and eburnation) were significantly correlated with degree of cartilage degeneration. It is concluded that in elderly individuals apophyseal joint load-bearing above a threshold of 50% is associated with severe degenerative changes in cartilage and bone, and that markers of DJD observed palaeopathologically may be used as predictors of such loadingin life.

Kyphosed seated postures: extending concepts of postural health beyond the office

INTRODUCTION

The harmful effects of sustained sitting and the health of the spine are well documented. The focus of much of this investigation has been sedentary occupations. However, how people sit during leisure hours can impact on the health of the spine both in and out of working hours.

METHODS

A literature search was conducted using Amed, Cinahl and OVID Medline databases. Papers published between 1985 and 2007 were selected for review. These included epidemiological and experimental studies that explored the relationships between seated postures and health of the lumbar spine. Until recently there was confusion in the scientific literature as to which seated postures were least harmful: lordosed or kyphosed. This article reviews and analyses these conflicts in relation to leisure sitting.

RESULTS

Analysis of the literature demonstrates that kyphosed seated postures when sustained are more harmful to the health of the lumbar spine than lordosed seated postures. There is a misconception amongst designers and users of leisure seating that kyphosed relaxed postures are comfortable and that comfort equates with health. It is argued that sustained kyphosed postures are insidiously harmful to the spine in that they may contribute to disc degeneration in the absence of pain. Sustained kyphosed postures also adversely affect spinal ligaments, muscles and joints and lead to neuromuscular and cumulative trauma disorders and loss of spinal stability.

CONCLUSION

Recent research demonstrates that postures popularly assumed in recreational or leisure seating lead to cumulative damage to soft tissues of the spine. These effects may still be present at the commencement of the following work day. In the prevention of work disability caused by sustained sitting, health professionals must consider the impact of leisure seating design and recreational sitting behaviour.

Intra-articular injection of collagenase induced experimental osteoarthritis of the lumbar facet joint in rats

We aimed to establish an animal model to investigate primary osteoarthritis of the lumbar facet joints after collagenase injection in rats and its effects on chondrocyte apoptosis. We hypothesized that osteoarthritic-like changes would be induced by collagenase injection and that apoptosis of chondrocytes would increase. Collagenase (1, 10, or 50 U) or saline (control) was injected into the lumbar facet joints. The histology and histochemistry of cartilage, synovium, and subchondral bone were examined at 1, 3, and 6 weeks after surgery. Apoptotic cells induced by 1 U of collagenase were quantified using the terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-mediated dUTP nick end labelling (TUNEL) assay. Degeneration of the cartilage and changes to the synovium and subchondral bone were dependent on both the doses of collagenase and the time after surgery. There were significantly more apoptotic chondrocytes in collagenase-treated joints than in control (P < 0.001 at 1 and 3 weeks and P < 0.05 at 6 weeks). Thus, lumbar facet joints subjected to collagenase developed osteoarthritic-like changes that could be quantified and compared. This model provides a useful tool for further study on the effects of compounds that have the potential to inhibit enzyme-associated damage to cartilage.

Lumbar Facet Joint Osteoarthritis: A Review

OBJECTIVES

The facet joints (FJ) can be a potentially important source of symptoms because of the high level of mobility and load forces, especially in the lumbar area. We reviewed the anatomy, biomechanics, and possible sources of pain of the FJ, natural history, and risk factors of lumbar FJ osteoarthritis and briefly reviewed the relevant imaging methods.

METHODS

PubMed and MEDLINE databases (1950-2006) were searched for the key words "facet joints," "zygapophyseal joints," "osteoarthritis," "low back pain," and "spondyloarthritis." All relevant articles in English were reviewed. Pertinent secondary references were also retrieved.

RESULTS

The FJ play an important role in load transmission; they provide a posterior load-bearing helper, stabilizing the motion segment in flexion and extension and also restricting axial rotation. The capsule of the FJ, subchondral bone, and synovium are richly innervated and can be a potential source of the low back pain. Degenerative changes in the FJ comprise cartilage degradation that leads to the formation of focal and then diffuse erosions with joint space narrowing, and sclerosis of the subchondral bone. Because the most prominent changes occur in bone, the best method of evaluation of the FJ is computed tomography. Risk factors for lumbar FJ osteoarthritis include advanced age, relatively more sagittal orientation of the FJ, and a background of intervertebral disk degeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

An up-to-date knowledge of this subject can be helpful in the development of diagnostic techniques and in the prevention of lumbar FJ osteoarthritis and low back pain and can assist in the determination of future research goals.

Morphological changes of cervical facet joints in elderly individuals

To better understand the role of facet joint degeneration in chronic neck and back pain epidemiological and morphological data are needed. For the cervical spine, however, such data are rare. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the degree of cartilage degeneration of cervical facet joints with respect to spinal level and age, to investigate whether any region of the joint surface is more often affected by degeneration and to determine the localisation of osteophytes. A total of 128 left-sided facet surfaces from 15 fresh frozen cervical spine specimens (59-92 years) including in maximum C2-C7 were inspected in a way to ensure a direct comparability to data reported for the lumbar spine. First, the macroscopic degree of cartilage degeneration was determined and correlated to spinal level and age. Then, each facet surface was divided into five regions (anterior, posterior, lateral, medial and central) to check whether cartilage degeneration occurs more often in any of these regions. Finally, the localisation of osteophytes was determined. The results showed that the mean degree of cartilage degeneration was 2.8 (+/-0.6) on a scale from Grade 1 (no degeneration) to 4 (severe degeneration). None of all 128 facet surfaces was classified as Grade 1. All spinal levels had about the same degree of degeneration (in mean 2.5-3.0). The youngest age group (<70 years) had a somewhat lower degree of degeneration (2.6) than the oldest (> or = 90 years) (3.1). Cartilage defects were found all over the joint surfaces, none of the five regions was more often affected than the others. Least osteophytes were found on the medial border of the facet joints. In conclusion, the prevalence of cervical facet joint degeneration is probably very high in individuals aged 50 years and more, with a tendency to increase in severity with age. All levels of the middle and lower cervical spine were affected to almost the same degree, whereas in the lumbar spine an increase in degeneration towards the lower levels was reported. Also, in the cervical spine in most cases the cartilage was evenly degenerated all over the joint surface while in the lumbar spine certain regions were reported to be affected predominantly.

Detailed pathological changes of human lumbar facet joints L1-L5 in elderly individuals

Facet joints play an important role in intervertebral load transmission and are crucial for rotational kinematics. Clinically, the role of facet joints as a possible source of low back pain is seen as controversial and at present is not sufficiently investigated. In this study, human lumbar facet (zygapopyhysial) joints from donors with advanced age were analyzed macroscopically, for degenerative changes. The aim was to determine the extent and morphology of degenerative changes in these joints. Lumbar facet joints (L1-L5) of 32 donors were studied (mean age 80.1+/-11.2 years). Joint capsules were carefully removed and joint surfaces (5 zones) examined using magnifying glasses and probes. In the result, the majority of facet joints showed cartilage defects of varying extent. Defects were located mostly at the margins of the articular surface, the central zone being relatively well preserved. Defect localization was different between superior (most cartilage defects in superior zone) and inferior (most defects inferiorly) facets. Further, defects were more severe caudal (level of L5) and in older persons. Osteophytes were present in up to 30%, located mostly at the latero-dorsal enthesis of the joint capsule on the superior facet. In conclusion, most margins of the articular facets are subject to degenerative changes in the lumbar spine of elderly persons, the topographical pattern being different in superior and inferior facets. This observation can be explained by the segmental motion patterns during extension/flexion movements of the facets. Sometimes, due to the marginal extension, it is obvious that not all changes can be assessed by CT or MRI.

Review of existing grading systems for cervical or lumbar disc and facet joint degeneration

The aim of this literature review was to present and to evaluate all grading systems for cervical and lumbar disc and facet joint degeneration, which are accessible from the MEDLINE database. A MEDLINE search was conducted to select all articles presenting own grading systems for cervical or lumbar disc or facet joint degeneration. To give an overview, these grading systems were listed systematically depending on the spinal region they refer to and the methodology used for grading. All systems were checked for reliability tests and those recommended for use having an interobserver Kappa or Intraclass Correlation Coefficient >0.60 if disc degeneration was graded and >0.40 if facet joint degeneration was graded. MEDLINE search revealed 42 different grading systems. Thirty of these were used to grade lumbar spine degeneration, ten were used to grade cervical spine degeneration and two were used to grade both. Thus, the grading systems for the lumbar spine represented the vast majority of all 42 grading systems. Interobserver reliability tests were found for 12 grading systems. Based on their Kappa or Intraclass Correlation Coefficients nine of these could be recommended for use and three could not. All other systems could neither be recommended nor not be recommended since reliability tests were missing. These systems should therefore first be tested before use. The design of the grading systems varied considerably. Five grading systems were beginning with the lowest degree of degeneration, 37, however, with the normal, not degenerated state. A 5-grade scale was used in six systems, a 4-grade scale in 24, a 3-grade scale in eight and a 2-grade scale in three systems. In 15 cases the normal, not degenerated state was assigned to "grade 0", in another 15 cases, however, this state was assigned to "grade 1". This wide variety in the design of the grading systems makes comparisons difficult and may easily lead to confusion. We would therefore recommend to define certain standards. Our suggestion would be to use a scale of three to five grades, to begin the scale with the not degenerated state and to assign this state to "grade 0".

Morphometry of the lumbar zygapophyseal facet capsule and cartilage with special reference to degenerative osteoarthritic changes: an anatomical study using fresh cadavers of elderly Japanese and Korean subjects

Morphometric data were obtained from fresh cadaver dissections, and observations of degenerative changes in the joint cartilage (DCs) were analyzed to determine whether the morphometric parameters of the lumbar zygapophyseal joint capsule varied according to the presence and severity of DCs. There have been no previous morphometric studies of the facet capsule that describe age-related DCs. Using 23 fresh osteoligamentous lumbar spines from donated cadavers, we performed morphometric investigations of the surface areas of the joints and their capsules and measured the capsular thickness. We hypothesized that the ratio of the inner capsular area to the joint surface area for each facet (the capsule/facet index) could serve as an index showing a functional aspect of a large or small capsule. Our results showed that the joint surface area increased significantly with increasing severity of DCs, according to Grogan's classification. Facets with advanced DCs tended to have a small inner capsular surface. The capsule/facet index generally correlated positively with capsular thickness, especially the dorsal portion; however, this was not true for the ventral portion. The index also correlated negatively with DC progression. Thus, lumbar facet DCs were strongly linked to reconstructive alterations in capsular size, thickness, and looseness. The occurrence and progression of DCs narrowed the joint capsule, especially the dorsal portion, and this seemed to decrease the potential looseness of the joint. Conversely, these capsular alterations seemed to accelerate DC progression. A negative adaptation cycle seemed to occur.

Which portion in a facet is specifically affected by articular cartilage degeneration with aging in the human lumbar zygapophysial joint?

Using 10 osteoligamentous vertebral columns obtained from elderly donated cadavers, we describe in detail degenerative changes of the articular cartilage in lumbar zygapophysial joints to show which portion in a facet is specifically affected. Degenerative changes, including extended cartilage defects, occurred in multiple facets of every specimen. The results demonstrated 5 basic morphologies of degeneration, i.e., 1) marginal dominace in the articular surface, 2) lower segment dominance except for the lowest (L5/S) facet, 3) advancement in the inferior articular process, 4) cranial and caudal dominance rather than the dorsal dominance in the articular surface and 5) progress in a mirror-image manner. These rules seemed to be consistent with differences in size, shape and kinesiological aspects of the facet between segments and between portions in a facet.

Historical perspective milestones in the evolution of lumbar spinal postural health in seating

The best knowledge on seated posture before the Enlightenment was not scientific, but influenced by sociocultural, economic, and manufacturing factors. Although the pursuit of knowledge related to spinal postural health was advanced with the advent of empirico-analytic research, academic opinion continued to be influenced by unsubstantiated information, often resulting in incorrect advice to the public. Only in the past decade has advice on "correct" seated posture, spanning the time from the Hippocratic texts to the present, been brought into question by evidence-based research. By exploring seating from 3100 B.C to the present, this article discusses key influences that have an impact on seating functional to spinal postural health. Emphasis is placed on the role of medical opinion.

Morphometrical study of the joint surface and capsule of the lumbar zygapophysial joint with special reference to their laterality

Using 26 osteoligamentous lumbar vertebral columns (260 facets), we morphometrically investigated the cartilagenous joint surface, inner capsular surface and capsular thickness. We also examined whether the subcapsular pocket was present and, if present, how far it extended along the joint margin. The proportion of the inner capsular area in the total joint surface area in a facet (the capsular-joint surface ratio) was hypothesized to correspond to the potential looseness (or tightness) of the facet. The absolute data themselves seemed to be useful for better understanding of the joint morphology. However, further evaluations of the differences between segments, left/right differences, individual segmental fluctuation patterns and correlations between parameters provided a novel classification of specimens according to the hypothetical progress of joint degeneration. Criteria for the classification existed in 1) the laterality in parameters defined as more than 100% larger or smaller than the contralateral facet and 2) the drastic segmental difference in parameters over 50% larger or smaller than the adjacent segment. Consequently, three types were identified: 1) outside of the criteria in both area and thickness (-/- type, 9 of 26); 2) the criteria did not fit the area parameters but did fit the thickness parameters (-/+ type, 8); the criteria were filled in both categories of parameters (+/+ type, 9). Notably, in the +/+ types, the capsular thickness and capsular-joint surface ratio correlated significantly (p < 0.01), i.e., the hypothetical loose joint had a thick capsule. We speculated that early joint degeneration starts from the -/- type and advances via the -/+ type to the +/+ type. Considerating these results, we recommended using MR imaging for detailed identification of laterality in the capsular thickness for low-back pain patients to discriminate candidates for future severe degenerative changes of the articular cartilage in the lumbar spine.

Osteoarthrosis of the facet joints resulting from anular rim lesions in sheep lumbar discs

STUDY DESIGN

Facet joints from sheep lumbar spines were examined for histologic evidence of osteoarthrosis after anular incision.

OBJECTIVES

To describe the sequence of changes in facet joints in an animal model of disc degeneration.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

There are many studies with results showing a link between facet joint osteoarthrosis and disc degeneration, but the development of osteoarthrosis in facet joints has not been observed in a controlled study of disc degeneration.

METHODS

Histologic features of facet joint degeneration were compared with established descriptions of human osteoarthrosis, and the sequence of changes was documented in a controlled prospective study of disc degeneration.

RESULTS

Osteoarthrosis in sheep lumbar facet joints is similar to that described in human joints and develops in response to anular injury. Discs degenerate relatively soon after anular incision, but there is a long delay in the appearance of significant changes to the facet joints at the level of anular incision and adjacent levels.

CONCLUSIONS

The results shows that facet joints in sheep undergo osteoarthrotic changes in response to disc degeneration and confirm the sheep as a suitable model for the study of degenerative spinal disorders.

Morphometry of human lumbar apophyseal joints. A novel technique

STUDY DESIGN

The anatomy of cadaveric lumbar apophyseal joints was examined as part of a study of possible correlations between lumbar apophyseal morphology, arthrosis, and cartilage thickness and stiffness.

OBJECTIVES

To establish the morphometry of human upper lumbar apophyseal joints using an objective technique.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

The apophyseal joints of 30 unfixed lumbar motion segments, all from different cadavers (24 male, five female, and one unknown, mean age 35 years, range 16-78 years) were exposed by dissection and disarticulation. Twenty-five motion segments were L1-L2, three were L2-L3, and two were L3-L4. The extent of fibrillation and linear dimensions of 29 of these specimens were examined, whereas the vertebrae and joints of 22 of them (18 being L1-L2) were cast in araldite resin.

METHODS

The casts of the vertebrae were sectioned cephalocaudally at 1-mm intervals. Image processing of photographic slides of the sections established the orientations and dimensions of the lumbar apophyseal joints and their shapes using Fourier analysis.

RESULTS

Apophyseal joint surface area was 158 +/- 43 mm2, cephalocaudal length 15.2 +/- 2.7 mm, and straight line length between anterior and posterior borders was 13.2 +/- 1.9 mm. The joints were orientated at 62.5 +/- 11.8 degrees to the coronal plane. Average maximum depth of concavity was 1.8 +/- 0.7 mm. The posterior edges of two joint pairs twisted inward toward the midsagittal plane in a cephalocaudal direction; thus, some apophyseal joints bear part of the axial spinal load. The right inferior surfaces were more elongated cephalocaudally (but not longer) than their contralateral partners. Inferior apophyses were significantly more elongated cephalocaudally (but not longer) than their ipsilateral articulating superior surfaces.

CONCLUSIONS

In theory, Fourier analysis of joint surfaces was objective, but it dictated the criterion by which joints were grouped; care must be exercised so that measurement methods do not categorize joints artificially. "Symmetry" is too subjective to be applied to contralateral apophyseal joints; correlation coefficients should be quoted for areas and orientations. The morphology of contralateral lumbar apophyseal joint pairs was significantly correlated in all respects, as was the morphology of articulating lumbar apophyseal surfaces.