Relapsing CD8+ encephalitis-looking for a solution

Learning from cerebrospinal fluid drug-resistant HIV escape-associated encephalitis: a case report

BACKGROUND

In the era of antiretroviral therapy (ART), central nervous system (CNS) complications in patients with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection are sometimes associated with cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) viral escape. Here, we reported a case of persistent CNS viral escape with recurrent symptomatic encephalitis, which had ultimate stabilization achieved by a combination of ART adjustment and corticosteroids.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 27-year-old man with HIV infection complained of recurrent headaches during the last year. His magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) presented diffused bilateral white matter lesions, and laboratory tests confirmed elevated CSF protein level, lymphocytic pleocytosis, and detectable CSF HIV RNA (774 copies/mL). Plasma HIV RNA was well suppressed with tenofovir, lamivudine, and lopinavir/ritonavir. Prednisone 60 mg once daily was initiated to reduce intracranial inflammation, followed by a good clinical response, with CSF HIV RNA still detectable (31.1 copies/mL). During the gradual tapering of prednisone, his headache relapsed, and booming viral loads were detected in both CSF (4580 copies/mL) and plasma (340 copies/mL) with consistent drug-resistant mutations. Thereupon, prednisone was resumed and the ART regimen was switched to zidovudine, lamivudine, and dolutegravir according to drug resistance tests. Persistent clinical recovery of symptoms, neuroimaging, and laboratory abnormalities were observed in the follow-up visits.

CONCLUSION

CSF and plasma HIV RNA and further drug resistance tests should be monitored in HIV-infected patients with neurologic symptoms, as opportunistic infections or tumors can be ruled out. ART optimization using a sensitive regimen may be crucial for addressing CSF viral escape and the related encephalitis.

CD8 Encephalitis in HIV: A Review of This Emerging Entity

INTRODUCTION

Encephalitis is a life-threatening neurological condition with multiple causes in the setting of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV). CD8 Encephalitis (CD8E) is a newly recognised condition which can present in an acute manner, with pertinent features including classical radiological findings with an intense brain parenchymal infiltration of CD8+ T cells. This review attempted to clarify the symptomatology, distribution and determinants of this condition, as well as to examine its vast unknowns.

METHODS

A literature review was undertaken in July 2022, utilising the PubMed and Google Scholar databases. Papers published between 2006-2022 were reviewed. Eighteen papers, totalling 57 patients, were found and analysed. Statistical analysis was undertaken using Chi-squared and Wilcoxon rank-sum tests as appropriate, with p < 0.05 deemed significant.

RESULTS

In this review, 57 patients were identified, with a female (61%, 34/56) and Black African (70%, 40/57) preponderance. Females were more likely to present with headache (p = 0.006), and headache was more likely to be present in those who died (p = 0.02). There was no statistically significant association between baseline CD4 count (p = 0.079) and viral load (p = 0.72) with disease outcome. Overall, 77% (41/53) of patients had classical imaging findings, including bilateral gadolinium-enhancing punctate and perivascular white matter lesions. However, many patients (23/57) required a brain biopsy as part of their diagnostic workup. Corticosteroid treatment was commonly prescribed in patients (64%, 35/55) and had a mortality benefit, with an overall survival in this group of 71% (p = 0.0008). In those who died, median survival was 5.5 months. In rare instances, recurrence of the disease was noted, which responded poorly to treatment.

DISCUSSION

CD8E represents a new and complex condition with few risk factors identified for its occurrence. The presenting symptoms are broad, but headache appears to be more common in females and more significantly associated with death. Though rare, CD8E is likely under-diagnosed, possibly due to overlapping features with other illnesses and lack of physician experience in its recognition and management. Corticosteroids demonstrate a clear mortality benefit, but more studies are required to determine their optimal dosing and duration, as well as the use of steroid-sparing agents. Further reviews should help to better determine the risk factors for the condition, as well as non-invasive biomarkers, to aid in diagnosis and help to predict poor prognosis and disease recurrence.

CD8 Encephalitis: A Diagnostic Dilemma

CD8+ encephalitis is a subacute encephalopathy associated with HIV infection. Pathophysiology is thought to be auto-reactive CD8+ cells attacking on HIV infected CD4+ cells and ‘viral escape’ phenomena (replication of CD8+ cells in CSF). We present a case of a 45-year-old man with well controlled HIV who developed CD8 encephalitis following Herpes simplex encephalitis. He had persistent encephalopathy for several weeks with status epilepticus and agitated delirium, and diagnosis remained elusive until a brain biopsy confirmed the diagnosis.

CD8 encephalitis with CSF EBV viraemia and HIV drug resistance, a case series

Introduction

CD8 encephalitis is a relatively recently described condition in the setting of HIV infection. It is becoming increasingly recognised in recent years though is still likely underdiagnosed.

Methods

We present three cases of encephalitis in HIV-positive black African females initially presenting with neurological pathology. Two cases concern recent presentations of patients attending HIV services at a large tertiary referral hospital and the third case involves a retrospective analysis of an archived case.

Results and discussion

MRI brain demonstrated periventricular white matter changes in 2 cases and a cerebellar lesion in the third case. CSF examination revealed lymphocytosis and elevated protein levels. CSF HIV viral load analysis showed viral escape along with new antiretroviral drug resistance mutations. CSF flow cytometry studies demonstrated a reversed CD4:CD8 ratio with a high CD8⁺ cells percentage. All patients had EBV DNA detected in their CSF. Brain biopsy in two patients confirmed CD8 encephalitis and also revealed isolated cells demonstrating EBV positivity by in-situ hybridization using EBER (Epstein–Barr virus-encoded small RNAs). Treatment with steroids and ART optimisation led to significant clinical and radiological improvements in all cases.

Discussion

CD8 encephalitis should be considered as a cause of neurological symptoms and confusion in the HIV-positive patient, particularly if poor ART adherence or viral resistance are suspected. Brain biopsy should be considered in HIV-positive patients with encephalopathy of uncertain cause. Early treatment with high-dose corticosteroids when suspecting this diagnosis is essential for a favourable outcome. The prognosis is variable but can be favourable even following severe encephalopathy. The presence of new INSTI mutations in the CSF but absent peripherally in two INSTI-era patients is a novel finding for this case series in the context of CD8 encephalitis. The role played by EBV in this disease remains unclear and warrants further investigation.

Relapse of Symptomatic Cerebrospinal Fluid HIV Escape

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Symptomatic cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) HIV escape defines the presence of neurological disease in combination antiretroviral therapy (cART)-treated persons due to HIV replication in CSF despite systemic suppression or to higher viral replication in CSF than in plasma. The aim was to search for cases of recurrent symptomatic CSF escape and to define their characteristics.

RECENT FINDINGS

By review of the literature, we identified symptomatic CSF escape relapses in three patients who had shown clinical remission of a first escape episode following cART optimization. By examination of our cohort of 21 patients with symptomatic CSF escape, we identified five additional patients. In the latter, viral escape relapsed over a median follow-up of 108 months because of low adherence or upon treatment simplification of a previously optimized regimen. cART reoptimization based on resistance profile and potential drug neuropenetration and efficacy led to relapse resolution with no further episodes after a median follow-up of 50 months from relapse. The observation that CSF escape may relapse highlights the importance of long-term neuro-suppressive regimens after a first episode and supports the role of the brain as a reservoir for HIV.

Severe Exacerbation of Multiple Sclerosis Following Withdrawal of Fingolimod

BACKGROUND

Fingolimod is an effective therapy for multiple sclerosis (MS). Isolated reports of very aggressive MS rebound after discontinuation of fingolimod are drawing neurologists' attention to this potentially severe complication of the drug.

OBJECTIVE

Our objective was to collect literature data on cases of MS rebound following fingolimod withdrawal. In addition, we report six new cases of this adverse event in Brazil.

METHODS

We carried out a systematic review of published data on cases of MS rebound after fingolimod was discontinued. In addition, the study reports a retrospective data series of Brazilian patients presenting this rebound reaction.

RESULTS

Twenty papers have been published reporting on 52 patients with severe MS rebound after fingolimod withdrawal. Six new patients are included in the present paper, all of them with aggressive rebound and accumulated disability sequelae.

CONCLUSION

We recommend gradual discontinuation of fingolimod with replacement by other treatment. The washout period should not exceed 4 weeks.

Symptomatic cerebrospinal fluid escape

: Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) viral escape is defined by detectable HIV-RNA in CSF despite undetectable or lower-than-CSF level in plasma of patients receiving combination antiretroviral therapy (cART). This condition may occasionally be associated with neurological problems, consisting of new and progressive cognitive decline and/or focal symptoms and signs, defining the 'symptomatic CSF escape'. Brain MRI usually shows diffuse white matter hyperintensities that recall the presentation of HIV encephalopathy in the precART era. However, patients develop symptomatic CSF escape with relatively high CD4 cell counts and suppressed or low systemic virus replication. In addition, the frequent CSF pleocytosis and the pathological demonstration of CD8 T-cell brain infiltrates in some cases of symptomatic escape indicate that inflammation is an important component in the pathogenesis of this condition. Low nadir CD4 cells are common, likely reflecting the establishment of a HIV reservoir in the central nervous system (CNS). CSF escape seems to result from reactivation of CNS infection when cART potency is lowered, because of low patient's adherence, drug resistance, or use of drug combinations that are poorly effective in the CNS and cART optimization is key to revert escape and neurological disease in the great majority of cases.