Long-term recovery of the human corneal endothelium after toxic injury by benzalkonium chloride

A Novel Riboflavin Formulation for Corneal Delivery Without Damaging Epithelial Cells

Purpose

This study aimed to evaluate the trans-epithelial permeability enhancement and cell damage caused by a novel riboflavin composition for corneal delivery.

Methods

We developed a trans-epithelial formulation of riboflavin for corneal delivery using 1,2-dioleoyl-3-dimethylammonium-propane (DODAP) and isostearic acid (ISA). The permeation enhancement was evaluated using an in vitro corneal epithelial cell culture system by measuring the amount of transferred riboflavin with high-performance liquid chromatography. Riboflavin permeation of MedioCROSS TE, a commercially available riboflavin formulation containing benzalkonium chloride, was also evaluated and compared to that of the DODAP/ISA formulation by changing the riboflavin concentration. The trans-epithelial electrical resistance (TEER) was measured after exposure to the samples in an in vitro corneal epithelial cell culture system to assess cytotoxicity.

Results

The DODAP/ISA formulation demonstrated greater permeation when used together than when each component was used individually. The permeation enhancement effect of the DODAP/ISA formulation was almost the same as that of MedioCROSS TE. However, when a 10-fold higher riboflavin concentration was used in the DODAP/ISA formulation, the permeation enhancement effect surpassed that of MedioCROSS TE. After 24 hours of exposure, the TEER of the DODAP/ISA formulation was higher than that of MedioCROSS TE, indicating that the DODAP/ISA formulation was less cytotoxic than MedioCROSS TE.

Conclusions

This study indicated that the DODAP/ISA formulation could serve as a less cytotoxic alternative to MedioCROSS TE. Further studies are required to determine the clinical efficacy and safety of the DODAP/ISA formulation in vivo.

Translational Relevance

This study may provide alternative procedures for corneal collagen crosslinking with less of a cytotoxic effect on corneal epithelial cells.

A Review of Corneal Endotheliitis and Endotheliopathy: Differential Diagnosis, Evaluation, and Treatment

The corneal endothelium plays an integral role in regulating corneal hydration and clarity. Endotheliitis, defined as inflammation of the corneal endothelium, may disrupt endothelial function and cause subsequent visual changes. Corneal endotheliitis is characterized by corneal edema, the presence of keratic precipitates, anterior chamber inflammation, and occasionally limbal injection, neovascularization, and co-existing or superimposed uveitis. The disorder is classified into four subgroups: linear, sectoral, disciform, and diffuse. Its etiology is extensive and, although commonly viral, may be medication-related, procedural, fungal, zoological, environmental, or systemic. Not all cases of endothelial dysfunction leading to corneal edema are inflammatory in nature. Therefore, it is imperative that practitioners consider a broad differential for patients presenting with possible endotheliitis, as well as familiarize themselves with appropriate diagnostic and therapeutic modalities.

A dose-escalation ex vivo study on the effects of intracameral benzalkonium chloride in rabbits

Background

Rabbits are currently not a good model for studying diseases of the corneal endothelium because their corneal endothelial cells (CECs) maintain a high proliferative capacity throughout almost all their life. Addressing this particular feature might allow the use of this species for such a purpose. The aim of this study was to evaluate the corneal endothelial injury after intracameral benzalkonium chloride (BAC) injection into rabbit eyes ex vivo, and to establish the most suitable starting dose for an in vivo study aimed at developing an animal model of corneal endothelial disease.

Results

Forty rabbit eyes obtained postmortem by transconjunctival enucleation were divided into 8 groups according to the injected compound: Control (no injection), BSS, and increasing BAC concentrations (0.005%, 0.01%, 0.025%, 0.05%, 0.1% and 0.2%). At 0, 6, 24 and 48 h, ophthalmologic examination of the anterior segment, pachymetry and specular microscopy were performed, and corneas were finally vital-stained and observed under the light microscope to assess the CECs morphology and mortality rate. When compared to BSS, CECs density started to decrease significantly at 0.025% BAC concentration, while mean cell area, corneal edema and corneal thickness began to increase significantly at 0.05%, 0.005% and 0.1% BAC concentrations, respectively. Concentrations of 0.05% BAC and above caused significant increases in CECs pleomorphism (decreased hexagonality) and mortality, compared to control and BSS.

Conclusions

Ex vivo intracameral BAC injection induces corneal endothelial toxicity in rabbits. However, confirmatory in vivo studies are required to develop the desired model, with 0.05% BAC being a suggested starting point.

Evaluation of corneal endothelium in adolescents with juvenile glaucoma

Purpose. To evaluate the endothelial cell density (ECD) and central corneal thickness (CCT) in adolescents with juvenile open-angle glaucoma (JOAG) and ocular hypertension (OH) and to investigate the influence of topical antiglaucoma medications on ECD and CCT in adolescents with JOAG. Methods. ECD and CCT were investigated in 66 eyes of 33 adolescents with JOAG. Depending on the topical treatment the eyes were classified into 4 groups: (1) topical carbonic anhydrase inhibitor, (2) prostaglandin analogs, (3) beta-blocker, and (4) CAI-beta-blocker combination. ECD and CCT were also checked in 24 adolescents with OH and in control group (33 persons). Results. ECD was significantly lower in eyes with JOAG (2639.5 cells/mm²) compared with ECD in eyes with OH (2924.5 cells/mm²) and in control group (2955.5 cells/mm²). CCT was 0.554 mm in eyes with JOAG, 0.55 mm in eyes with OH, and 0.544 mm in control group. ECD in patients with JOAG was 2730 cells/mm² (1 group), 2773.5 cells/mm² (2 group), 2539.5 cells/mm² (3 group), and 2551 cells/mm² (4 group). CCT was 0.556 mm in 1 group, 0.558 mm in 2 group, 0.532 mm in 3 group, and 0.544 mm in 4 group. Conclusions. Our findings indicate that JOAG and OH did not affect CCT, but JOAG has influence on ECD in adolescents. There were no significant differences between ECD and CCT of eyes treated with different kinds of antiglaucoma medications.

Toxicity of antiglaucoma drugs with and without benzalkonium chloride to cultured human corneal endothelial cells

Purpose

The toxicity of antiglaucoma medications to ocular surface cells has been evaluated extensively; however, the toxicity to corneal endothelial cells (CECs) remains elusive. Our aim is to evaluate the toxicity of antiglaucoma medications to CECs using an in vitro toxicity assay.

Methods

Primary cultures of human (H) CECs derived from eye bank specimens were established. Following exposure of HCECs to test solutions for 10, 30, or 60 minutes, or 48 hours, we measured cell viability using a WST-1 assay. Test solutions were diluted in culture media and included 0.5% Timoptol^®, preservative-free 0.5% timolol maleate, 1% Trusopt^®, preservative-free 1% dorzolamide, Travatan^®, Travatan Z^®, Xalatan^®, and benzalkonium chloride (BAK). To assess cell viability, the value of the test culture well after treatment was expressed as a percentage of that of the control well. Toxicity of each solution was compared using the cell viability score (CVS).

Results

After exposure to 10-fold dilutions of test solutions for 48 hours, HCEC viabilities were 48.5% for 0.5% Timoptol, 80.9% for preservative-free 0.5% timolol maleate, 47.0% for 1% Trusopt, 71.7% for preservative-free 1% dorzolamide, 55.5% for Travatan, 88.5% for Travatan Z, and 52.5% for Xalatan. Exposure to test solutions diluted 100-fold or more resulted in HCEC viabilities >80%, with the exception of preservative-free 1% dorzolamide, which resulted in a viability of 72.0% at a dilution of 100-fold. Based on CVS, the order of cell viability was Travatan Z ≥ preservative-free timolol maleate = preservative-free dorzolamide > 0.5% Timoptol = 1% Trusopt > Travatan ≥ Xalatan. Assessment of the combined effect of drug and BAK revealed that latanoprost reduced the toxicity of BAK.

Conclusion

Antiglaucoma eye drops produced HCEC toxicity that appeared to depend on the presence of BAK. Because dilution of the antiglaucoma solutions resulted in markedly lower HCEC toxicity, HCEC damage due to antiglaucoma medication may occur only in rare cases. The CVS was useful for comparison of the toxicity of the drugs.

The influence of various toxic effects on the cornea and changes in corneal light transmission

PURPOSE

Normal corneal hydration is necessary for the maintenance of corneal transparency. Damage of the corneal epithelium or endothelium by various external influences disturbs the mechanism by which the cornea maintains normal hydration and transparency. The cornea swells, and the corneal thickness increases, resulting in increased scatter and the development of corneal opacity. The transmission of light across the cornea is changed. The purpose of this study is to investigate spectrophotometrically the corneal light transmission under the influence of the various factors affecting the cornea.

METHODS

We developed a spectrophotometric method to measure the light transmission across the cornea under the influence of various factors affecting the cornea, such as treatment with 0.9% NaCl, saline, or phosphate buffered saline (PBS), solutions employed as placebo eye drops (negative controls) in experimental studies, agents toxic to the cornea, such as diluted acids or alkalis. The method distinguishes between changes in corneal light transmission caused by altered corneal thickness (the level of hydration) and changes resulting from other corneal disturbances which in turn affect corneal light transmission.

RESULTS

The results obtained show that the corneal light transmission is decreased following the application of toxic substances on the corneal surface. This decrease is highly dependent on the severity of the corneal injury evoked by individual noxes, and the resulting changes in corneal hydration and transparency.

CONCLUSIONS

The influence of various influences applied to the cornea, manifested as changes in corneal light transmission, can be measured using our spectrophotometric method with a high degree of sensitivity.