Evaluation of the validity and reliability of A-scan ultrasound biometry with a single use disposable cover

Retinal control of lens-induced astigmatism in chicks

PURPOSE

Astigmatism is a refractive error due to meridional differences in refractive powers of lens or cornea. The resulting failure to focus image points in a single plane causes blurred vision at all distances. In this study, using an animal model of lens-induced astigmatism, we tested the hypothesis that induced astigmatism is due to processing of astigmatic retinal image information by the brain, which causes distorted growth in the anterior segment via centrifugal neural projections.

METHODS

To induce astigmatism, +4.00DS/-8.00DC crossed-cylinder-lens goggles were affixed over the right eyes of 7-day-old chicks (P7), with the -8.00DC axis oriented vertically (at 90°) or horizontally (180°) (n = 12 each); the left eyes were without goggles (non-goggled). For all experiments, refractive errors of both eyes were measured by streak retinoscopy, before and after 1 week of lens wear. To test whether neuronal pathways between retina and brain are required, axonal conduction within the eye was blocked by intravitreal injections of tetrodotoxin (TTX; 7 μL of 10^-4M) in phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), or of PBS alone (7 μL); fellow open eyes received PBS alone. Pupillary light reflex (PLR) and optokinetic response (OKR) were measured, to assess the efficacy and duration of TTX action. To test whether retinal circuitry is required, groups of chicks (n = 12 each) were treated at P7 by intravitreal injection of 20 μL of mixed excitotoxins (2 μmol N-methyl-D-aspartate, 0.2 μmol quisqualic acid, 0.2 μmol kainic acid; in water) into goggled or non-goggled eyes, to compromise retinal circuitry needed for emmetropization.

RESULTS

Crossed-cylinder goggles reliably induced refractive astigmatism. Maximum astigmatic error was induced when the cylindrical axis was oriented at 90° (vertically). TTX effectively blocked nerve conduction within the eye for 48 h after injection. Goggled eyes developed astigmatism after treatment with TTX or PBS, but not after excitotoxins.

CONCLUSION

Our hypothesis was rejected. In this model, the compensatory astigmatism induced by crossed-cylinder lenses is intrinsic to the eye, and mediated by visual processing in the retina.

Comparison of axial length, anterior chamber depth and intraocular lens power between IOLMaster and ultrasound in normal, long and short eyes

PURPOSE

To compare the axial length (AL), anterior chamber depth (ACD) and intraocular lens power (IOLP) of IOLMaster and Ultrasound in normal, long and short eyes.

METHODS

Seventy-four normal eyes (≥ 22 mm and ≤ 25 mm), 74 long eyes (> 25 mm) and 78 short eyes (< 22 mm) underwent AL and ACD measurements with both devices in the order of IOLMaster followed by Ultrasound. The IOLP were calculated using a free online LADAS IOL formula calculator.

RESULTS

The difference in AL and IOLP between IOLMaster and Ultrasound was statistically significant when all three groups were combined. The difference in ACD between IOLMaster and Ultrasound was statistically significant in the normal group (P<0.001) and short eye group (P<0.001) but not the long eye group (P = 0.465). For the IOLP difference between IOLMaster and Ultrasound in the normal group, the percentage of IOLP differences <|0.5|D, ≥|0.5|D<|0.75|D, ≥|0.75|D<|1.0|D, and ≥|1.0|D were 90.5%, 8.1%, 1.4% and 0%, respectively. For the long eye group, they were 90.5%, 5.4%, 4.1% and 0%, respectively. For the short eye group, they were 61.5%, 23.1%, 10.3%, and 5.1%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

IOLMaster and Ultrasound have statistically significant differences in AL measurements and IOLP (using LADAS formula) for normal, long eye and short eye. The two instruments agree regarding ACD measurements for the long eye group, but differ for the normal and short eye groups. Moreover, the high percentage of IOLP differences greater than |0.5|D in the short eye group is noteworthy.

Comparison axial length measurements from three biometric instruments in high myopia

AIM

To compare the axial lengths (ALs) measured with Lenstar, IOLMaster and A-scan contact ultrasound (Ultrasound) in normal and high myopia (HM).

METHODS

Eighty-four normal eyes and 49 HM eyes were included. Three consecutive measurements were performed on each eye in the following order: Lenstar, IOLMaster, and Ultrasound. The repeatabilities of the AL measurements for each instrument were assessed by calculating the pooled coefficients of variation (CVs) of 18 eyes in each group. Comparisons between the HM and normal groups were made with independent sample t-tests. The inter-device agreements were evaluated with Bland-Altman analyses and paired two-tailed t-tests.

RESULTS

For normal group, the CVs of the AL measurements taken with the Lenstar, IOLMaster and Ultrasound were 0.001%, 0.01% and 0.14%, respectively. The corresponding CVs for the HM group were 0.005%, 0.02% and 0.15%, respectively. There was significant difference between the Lenstar and the IOLMaster in normal group (P=0.031) but not in HM group (P=0.100). In the two groups, the Lenstar and the IOLMaster produced higher values than did the Ultrasound (all P<0.001). All three instruments exhibited good agreement in terms of AL values. For the intraocular lens (IOL) power calculation using SRK II formula, the Lenstar and the IOLMaster showed 0.5 D higher than Ultrasound in both groups (all P<0.001). No significant difference existed between the Lenstar and the IOLMaster for the IOL power calculation in both normal (P=0.474) and HM group (P=0.103).

CONCLUSION

The three devices exhibited excellent intra-visit repeatabilities in the AL measurements. The AL and IOL power difference between partial coherence interferometry and ultrasound instruments should be noticed.

Evaluation of the accuracy of 3-dimensional ultrasonography of the kidney using an in vitro renal model

OBJECTIVE

Three-dimensional ultrasonography (3DUS) has recently become a reality because of advances in ultrasound probes and machine processing ability. We have developed an anthropomorphic phantom of the human loin to assess both the accuracy of 3DUS of the kidney and its potential usefulness for training in ultrasonographically guided percutaneous renal intervention.

METHODS

The model was built with easily available and inexpensive materials such as agar and latex with known ultrasonographic properties. The accuracy of 2-dimensional ultrasonography (2DUS) and 3DUS was assessed by measuring the dimensions of the pelvicalyceal system (PCS) ultrasonographically (pelvis width and calyx diameters) and then comparing these with measurements obtained at the time of construction. Radiology interventional trainees then punctured the PCS with 2DUS and 4-dimensional ultrasonographic (real-time/time-resolved 3DUS) guidance and reported the phantom's performance.

RESULTS

The 3-dimensional nature of the model's PCS could be clearly visualized on 2DUS and 3DUS, and the scan characteristics were very similar to those in real life. Measurements using 3DUS proved to be closer to the true dimensions of the model's PCS than those using 2DUS. The mean error percentage for 2DUS measurements was -10.2%, and that for 3DUS was -2.2% (P < 0.0001). Interventional trainees were satisfied with the "tissue feel" and level of difficulty posed on puncturing the phantom.

CONCLUSIONS

Three-dimensional ultrasonography proved to be more accurate than 2DUS for intrarenal measurements using this in vitro renal model. Three-dimensional ultrasonography has the potential to ease diagnostic renal scanning with the ability to further scrutinize and postprocess the scanned volumes. The model was realistic in its anthropomorphic properties and simulated human tissue during puncture.

Percutaneous renal intervention: comparison of 2-D and time-resolved 3-D (4-D) ultrasound for minimal calyceal dilation using an ultrasound phantom and fluoroscopic control

The rapid advances made by ultrasound in recent years have increasingly taken 3-D ultrasound (3DUS) and 4-D ultrasound (4DUS) from the research setting to the patient's bedside. There are still unexplored areas like renal percutaneous intervention, where 4DUS has yet to be proven an effective tool. Ultrasound-only guidance in renal percutaneous access is used in selected well-dilated pelvi-calyceal systems (PCS), and fluoroscopy is often utilized as an adjunct. Our aim was to compare 2-D and 4-D guidance for punctures, with fluoroscopy as control, using an in vitro ultrasound phantom. Agar and latex were the tissue-mimicking materials used for the construction of the phantom. The latex targets were designed to simulate multidirection-facing minimally dilated renal calyces. Two interventional fellows punctured the "calyces" using first 2DUS and then 4DUS guidance, making use of a different set of targets each time. The time to puncture, time to introduction of wire, quality of puncture (judged on fluoroscopy) and global rating of both modalities were documented. There was no significant difference between the times to puncture using 2DUS (1.8 min) and 4DUS (2 min). Nor was there a significant difference in the quality of puncture. 4DUS had a higher median difficulty rating. The multiplanar reformatted (MPR) longitudinal and transverse images were found to be the most useful for needle guidance. Cross hairs in all MPR images were not just useful in aligning the images on target but also as surrogate targets. The phantom was found to be robust, with only one instance of air introduction after 30 punctures. We have found that 4DUS is at least as good as 2DUS in terms of quality of punctures in vitro. The technology still has some way to go as frame rates, transducer size and resolution improve.

Disposable devices for measuring intraocular pressure: a clinical study to assess their accuracy

AIMS

We conducted a study to compare the accuracy of two commercially available disposable tonometry devices (the acrylic biprism, Tonosafe and the silicone shield, Tonoshield) with the standard Goldmann applanation tonometer (GAT).

METHODS

A total of 80 eyes of 40 patients were randomly assigned to two groups. Group A (40 eyes) had the intraocular pressure IOP measured using GAT and the acrylic biprism (Tonosafe), while Group B (40 eyes) had IOP measured using GAT and the disposable silicone shield (Tonoshield). IOP was measured using the GAT both before and after the disposable device and average of the two standard Goldmann readings was compared with the IOP measured using the disposable devices.

RESULTS

The mean difference in IOP in Group A was 0.29 mmHg (SD 0.54) (P=0.0018) while in Group B the mean difference in IOP was 2.09 mmHg (SD 1.23) (P<0.0001). The Altman-Bland method was used to assess the agreement between two methods of clinical measurement. This shows a positive bias of 0.29 (95% confidence interval (CI) 0.11-0.46) when using the disposable acrylic biprism and a positive bias of 2.09 (95% CI 1.69-2.48) with the silicone shield.

CONCLUSION

The IOP recorded using the disposable acrylic biprism (Tonosafe) was in close agreement with the standard GAT. However, IOP readings obtained with the silicone shield (Tonoshield) tend to be higher than with the standard GAT. These facts should be kept in mind when recording IOP in clinical situations.

Cling film as a barrier against CJD in corneal contact A-scan ultrasonography

PURPOSE

To determine the validity of covering a corneal contact transducer probe with cling film as protection against the transmission of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD).

METHODS

The anterior chamber depth, lens thickness and vitreous chamber depth of the right eyes of 10 subjects was recorded, under cycloplegia, with and without cling film covering over the transducer probe of a Storz Omega Compu-scan Biometric Ruler. Measurements were repeated on two occasions.

RESULTS

Cling film covering did not influence bias or repeatability. Although the 95% limits of agreement between measurements made with and without cling film covering tended to exceed the intrasessional repeatability, they did not exceed the intersessional repeatability of measurements taken without cling film.

CONCLUSIONS

The results support the use of cling film as a disposable covering for corneal contact A-scan ultrasonography to avoid the risk of spreading CJD from one subject to another.