Limitations of faecal chymotrypsin as a screening test for chronic pancreatitis

An overview of the diagnosis and management of nutrition in chronic pancreatitis

Chronic pancreatitis is characterized by long-standing inflammation of the pancreas, which results in fibrosis and the gradual loss of pancreatic function. The loss of islets and acinar cells results in diabetes and exocrine insufficiency, respectively. Exocrine insufficiency can result in maldigestion of fat, protein, and carbohydrate as well as vitamins and minerals. Patients may present with variable severity of disease, from mild to severe. The diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis can be challenging, especially in patients with early or mild disease who have few to no morphologic abnormalities on standard abdominal imaging studies. A number of imaging modalities and tests have evolved to aid in the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis based on changes in structure or function. Clinicians typically focus on treating pain in chronic pancreatitis as opposed to exocrine insufficiency, despite the fact that maldigestion and malabsorption can result in nutrition deficiencies. The aims of this review are to describe the various modalities used to diagnose chronic pancreatitis, to illustrate the nutrition deficiencies associated with exocrine insufficiency, and to provide an overview of nutrition assessment and treatment in these patients.

Impaired fecal elastase excretion in uremic pancreopathy

To evaluate pancreatic exocrine function in uremia, 25 patients undergoing regular hemodialysis without clinical evidence of pancreatic disease and 25 healthy control subjects were studied by fecal elastase 1 and chymotrypsin. Abdominal ultrasonography and measurement of serum lipase, calcium, phosphate, and parathormone were also carried out. Fecal elastase was significantly lower (P < 0.001) in patients than in controls. Abnormally low values were found in 12/25 patients of whom six had values <100 microg/g. Fecal chymotrypsin was significantly lower (P < 0.05) in patients than in controls, with lower than normal values found in 10/25 patients. Fecal elastase was not related to the serum calcium, phosphate, or parathormone levels or to the period of dialysis. In patients serum lipase was normal or slightly elevated (<300 units/liter), and there was no evidence of pancreatic disease at ultrasound examination. The results lend further support to the existence of pancreatic function impairment in a significant number of patients with renal failure despite the absence of clinical and morphological evidence of pancreatic disease.

Prospective evaluation of endoscopic ultrasonography, endoscopic retrograde pancreatography, and secretin test in the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis

BACKGROUND

Chronic pancreatitis in its early stages may defy diagnosis despite existing diagnostic modalities. Endoscopic retrograde pancreatography (ERCP), secretin test, and conventional ultrasound are insensitive in detecting the early stages of chronic pancreatitis. The aim of this study was to determine whether endoscopic ultrasonography (EUS) high-resolution imaging allows for the detection of chronic pancreatitis as compared with clinical history, ERCP, and secretin test.

METHODS

Eighty consecutive patients with recurrent pancreatitis underwent ERCP, EUS, and secretin test. EUS evaluated parenchymal changes: echogenic foci (calcification), prominent interlobular septae (fibrosis), small cystic cavities (edema), lobulated outer gland margin (fibrosis/atrophy), and heterogeneous parenchyma; and ductal changes: dilation, irregularity, echogenic wall (fibrosis), side-branch ectasia, and echogenic foci (stones). EUS criteria for chronic pancreatitis included mild (1 to 2 features), moderate (3 to 5 features), and severe (more than 5 features).

RESULTS

Abnormal studies were EUS = 63, ERCP = 36, and secretin test = 25. Secretin test had 100% agreement with normal and severe chronic pancreatitis by EUS criteria, but agreement was poor for mild (13%) and moderate (50%) disease. Alternatively, the agreement between ERCP- and EUS-specific criteria was excellent for normal (100%), moderate (92%), and severe (100%) chronic pancreatitis and poor for mild (17%) disease. When the 2-test modality (ERCP and secretin test) was compared with EUS alone, no enhancement in agreement was seen.

CONCLUSION

Using the above criteria EUS may assist in the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis not established by ERCP or secretin test. Excellent agreement can be expected between EUS and ERCP in the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis with the exception of mild changes noted on EUS (kappa statistics = 0.82: 95% CI [0.70, 0.95]). Long-term follow-up of the patients with mild EUS changes will determine the validity of EUS in diagnosing the early stages of chronic pancreatitis.

Alterations of exocrine pancreas in end-stage renal disease. Do they reflect a clinically relevant uremic pancreopathy?

Serum pancreatic enzyme behavior, exocrine function, and morphology of the pancreas were studied in 28 patients with end-stage renal disease undergoing regular hemodialysis, in order to better delineate and assess the clinical relevance of the pancreatic alterations that occur in these patients. Twenty-eight healthy subjects served as controls. Initial studies included serum amylase, isoamylase, and lipase assays; fecal chymotrypsin measurement; and abdominal ultrasonography. The amylase, lipase, and chymotrypsin determinations, as well as ultrasound examination, were repeated four years later. None of the patients had clinical evidence of pancreatic disease at entry into the study, but one had had previous attacks of pancreatitis and another developed mild acute pancreatitis one month after entry. Initial mean serum enzyme levels were significantly higher in patients than in controls (amylase, pancreatic isoamylase, and lipase, P < 0.001; salivary isoamylase P < 0.05). Serum amylase was raised in 16/28 patients; pancreatic isoamylase in 15/28, and lipase in 7/28; these elevations were generally mild. Mean fecal chymotrypsin was significantly lower (P < 0.001) in patients than in controls: abnormally low values were found in 9/28 patients. Amylase, lipase and chymotrypsin measurements repeated after four years showed no significant difference with respect to the first study. Ultrasonographic changes were rare and mild: one patient had a small cyst in the pancreas head, another, an increase in echogenicity of the gland not related to age; these findings were unchanged at repeat examination. The results demonstrate that the frequent elevations of serum pancreatic enzymes and the rare sonographic changes found in patients undergoing hemodialysis do not generally reflect a relevant pancreopathy. However, the finding of significantly decreased fecal chymotrypsin may indicate the presence of pancreatic dysfunction in end-stage renal disease.

A preliminary report on urinary BT-PABA/PAS excretion index, serum pancreatic isoamylase and faecal chymotrypsin tests of pancreatic dysfunction in Sowetan Africans

The steady increase in chronic pancreatitis among black Africans at Soweto, RSA, in the past 40 years necessitates an objective and non-invasive test to detect the disease at an early stage. Given the biphasic nature of the disease--secretory hyperfunction with periodic active inflammatory episodes followed by steady exocrine impairment--we assessed three potential aids. Urinary BT-PABA/PAS excretion index (PEI), serum pancreatic isoamylase (PIA) and faecal chymotrypsin activity (FCA) were measured in the following groups: 16 outwardly healthy hospital workers, 16 consecutive patients with calcifying chronic pancreatitis and 19 with abdominal pain ascribed to other conditions (disease controls). (1) Healthy controls had lower PEI than those at Manchester, UK, or Madras, India, from subclinical acinar loss--as shown by lower PABA recovery whereas intestinal absorptive capacity was maintained, as shown by recovery of PAS. (2) Using the popular cut-off for PEI (0.75) only 9 of 14 patients with chronic pancreatitis were identified (sensitivity 64%, 2 tests unsatisfactory), while a value of less than 0.54, the mean -2 S.D. in local controls, yielded sensitivity of 50%. (3) If PEI of less than 0.75 or PIA outside the reference range was taken to indicate the disease, 5 of 9 disease controls would have been classed as chronic pancreatitis (among those with both tests satisfactory): retrospective ultrasound scans did not identify these. (4) Although FCA was less than the preselected cut-off, 5 units/g, in every patient with chronic pancreatitis (100% sensitivity) its poor predictive value was indicated by low specificity: subnormal levels in 4 of 14 and 6 of 16 healthy controls or disease controls, respectively, most of whom had near-normal values of PEI, PIA or both. (5) Collectively, these results suggest a high frequency of subclinical chronic pancreatitis at Soweto, but also that the combination of tests required to identify it may prove impractical--whether in field surveys or hospital practice.

Determination of faecal chymotrypsin concentration and 72-hour faecal chymotrypsin output in the detection of pancreatic steatorrhoea

In 96 consecutive patients who underwent a 72-h faecal fat determination because of suspected nutrient malassimilation (maldigestion and/or malabsorption) faecal chymotrypsin (F-Chym) was estimated with a commercial photometric test (Monotest Chymotrypsin), comparing F-Chym concentrations in the first 24-h stool with the total 72-h F-Chym output. In the first 24-h faeces, the F-Chym concentration, calculated as a mean of three random samples, did not significantly differ from a single value obtained after homogenization. In known pancreatic disease, a F-Chym concentration less than 3.0 U/g wet faeces distinguished well between steatorrhoic patients (n = 12) and nonsteatorrhoic (n = 13) (positive predictive value (PV), 91%; negative PV, 86%) but was less suitable as a screening test for pancreatic steatorrhoea in the unselected patient group (positive PV, 61%; negative PV, 98%). Although the estimation of 72-h F-Chym output could differentiate between various subgroups of patients to a certain extent, the positive PV for discovery of pancreatic steatorrhoea in a single patient was low. Four patients had excessively high F-Chym output and increased bile acid excretion after ileal resection (n = 3) and radiation ileitis (n = 1), respectively, possibly indicating the removal of an inhibitory mechanism of pancreatic and biliary secretion in these conditions.