Variant type and position predict two distinct limb phenotypes in patients with GLI3-mediated polydactyly syndromes

Pallister-Hall syndrome, GLI3, and kidney malformation

Pallister-Hall syndrome (PHS) is a rare autosomal dominant disease diagnosed by the presence of hypothalamic hamartoma, mesoaxial polydactyly and a truncating variant in the middle third of the GLI-Kruppel family member 3 (GLI3) gene. PHS may also include a wide range of clinical phenotypes affecting multiple organ systems including congenital anomalies of the kidney and urinary tract (CAKUT). The observed clinical phenotypes are consistent with the essential role of GLI3, a transcriptional effector in the hedgehog (Hh) signaling pathway, in organogenesis. However, the mechanisms by which truncation of GLI3 in PHS results in such a variety of clinical phenotypes with variable severity, even within the same organ, remain unclear. In this study we focus on presentation of CAKUT in PHS. A systematic analysis of reported PHS patients (n = 78) revealed a prevalence of 26.9% (21/78) of CAKUT. Hypoplasia (± dysplasia) and agenesis were the two main types of CAKUT; bilateral and unilateral CAKUT were reported with equal frequency. Examination of clinical phenotypes with CAKUT revealed a significant association between CAKUT and craniofacial defects, bifid epiglottis and a Disorder of Sex Development, specifically affecting external genitalia. Lastly, we determined that PHS patients with CAKUT predominately had substitution type variants (as opposed to deletion type variants in non-CAKUT PHS patients) in the middle third of the GLI3 gene. These results provide a foundation for future work aimed at uncovering the molecular mechanisms by which variant GLI3 result in the wide range and severity of clinical features observed in PHS.

GLIS Family Zinc Finger 1 was First Linked With Preaxial Polydactyly I in Humans by Stepwise Genetic Analysis

Background: Preaxial polydactyly (PPD) is one of the most common developmental malformations, with a prevalence of 0.8–1.4% in Asians. PPD is divided into four types, PPD I–IV, and PPD I is the most frequent type. Only six loci (GLI1, GLI3, STKLD1, ZRS, pre-ZRS, and a deletion located 240 kb from SHH) have been identified in non-syndromic PPD cases. However, pathogenesis of most PPD patients has never been investigated. This study aimed to understand the genetic mechanisms involved in the etiology of PPD I in a family with multiple affected members.

Methods: We recruited a PPD I family (PPD001) and used stepwise genetic analysis to determine the genetic etiology. In addition, for functional validation of the identified GLIS1 variant, in vitro studies were conducted. GLIS1 variants were further screened in additional 155 PPD cases.

Results: We identified a GLIS1 variant (NM_147193: c.1061G > A, p.R354H) in the PPD001 family. In vitro studies showed that this variant decreased the nuclear translocation of GLIS1 and resulted in increased cell viability and migration. RNA sequencing revealed abnormal TBX4 and SFRP2 expression in 293T cells transfected with mutant GLIS1. Additionally, we identified a GLIS1 variant (c.664G > A, p.D222N) in another PPD case.

Conclusion: We identified two GLIS1 variants in PPD I patients and first linked GLIS1 with PPD I. Our findings contributed to future molecular and clinical diagnosis of PPD and deepened our knowledge of this disease.

GLI3 variants causing isolated polysyndactyly are not restricted to the protein's C-terminal third

Loss of function variants of GLI3 are associated with a variety of forms of polysyndactyly: Pallister-Hall syndrome (PHS), Greig-Cephalopolysyndactyly syndrome (GCPS), and isolated polysyndactyly (IPD). Variants affecting the N-terminal and C-terminal thirds of the GLI3 protein have been associated with GCPS, those within the central third with PHS. Cases of IPD have been attributed to variants affecting the C-terminal third of the GLI3 protein. In this study, we further investigate these genotype-phenotype correlations. Sequencing of GLI3 was performed in patients with clinical findings suggestive of a GLI3-associated syndrome. Additionally, we searched the literature for reported cases of either manifestation with mutations in the GLI3 gene. Here, we report 48 novel cases from 16 families with polysyndactyly in whom we found causative variants in GLI3 and a review on 314 previously reported GLI3 variants. No differences in location of variants causing either GCPS or IPD were found. Review of published data confirmed the association of PHS and variants affecting the GLI3 protein's central third. We conclude that the observed manifestations of GLI3 variants as GCPS or IPD display different phenotypic severities of the same disorder and propose a binary division of GLI3-associated disorders in either PHS or GCPS/polysyndactyly.