Prenatal detection of fetal aneuploidies using transcervical cell samples

A Novel Paradigm for Non-Invasive Prenatal Genetic Screening: Trophoblast Retrieval and Isolation from the Cervix (TRIC)

As the prevalence of pregnancies with advanced maternal age increases, the risk of fetal chromosomal abnormalities is on the rise. Therefore, prenatal genetic screening and diagnosis have become essential elements in contemporary obstetrical care. Trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC) is a non-invasive procedure that can be utilized for prenatal genetic diagnosis. The method involves the isolation of fetal cells (extravillous trophoblasts) by transcervical sampling; along with its non-invasiveness, TRIC exhibits many other advantages such as its usefulness in early pregnancy at 5 weeks of gestation, and no interference by various fetal and maternal factors. Moreover, the trophoblast yields from TRIC can provide valuable information about obstetrical complications related to abnormal placentation even before clinical symptoms arise. The standardization of this clinical tool is still under investigation, and the upcoming advancements in TRIC are expected to meet the increasing need for a safe and accurate option for prenatal diagnosis.

Trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix: origins of cervical trophoblasts and their potential value for risk assessment of ongoing pregnancies

BACKGROUND

Early during human development, the trophoblast lineage differentiates to commence placentation. Where the placenta contacts the uterine decidua, extravillous trophoblast (EVT) cells differentiate and invade maternal tissues. EVT cells, identified by expression of HLA-G, invade into uterine blood vessels (endovascular EVT), as well as glands (endoglandular EVT), and open such luminal structures towards the intervillous space of the placenta. Endoglandular invasion diverts the contents of uterine glands to the intervillous space, while glands near the margin of the placenta that also contain endoglandular EVT cells open into the reproductive tract. Cells of the trophoblast lineage have thus been recovered from the uterine cavity and endocervical canal. An emerging non-invasive technology [trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC)] isolates and examines EVT cells residing in the cervix to explore their origin, biology and relationship to pregnancy and fetal status.

OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE

This review explores the origins and possible uses of trophoblast cells obtained during ongoing pregnancies (weeks 5-20) by TRIC. We hypothesize that endoglandular EVT cells at the margins of the expanding placenta enter the uterine cavity and are carried together with uterine secretion products to the cervix where they can be retrieved from a Papanicolaou (Pap) smear. The advantages of TRIC for investigation of human placentation and prenatal testing will be considered. Evidence from the literature, and from archived in utero placental histological sections, is presented to support these hypotheses.

SEARCH METHODS

We used 52 out of 80 publications that appeared between 1966 and 2017 and were found by searching the PubMed and Google Scholar databases. The studies described trophoblast invasion of uterine vessels and glands, as well as trophoblast cells residing in the reproductive tract. This was supplemented with literature on human placental health and disease.

OUTCOMES

The literature describes a variety of invasive routes taken by EVT cells at the fetal-maternal interface that could displace them into the reproductive tract. Since the 1970s, investigators have attempted to recover trophoblast cells from the uterus or cervix for prenatal diagnostics. Trophoblast cells from Pap smears obtained at 5-20 weeks of gestation have been purified (>95% β-hCG positive) by immunomagnetic isolation with nanoparticles linked to anti-HLA-G (TRIC). The isolated cells contain the fetal genome, and have an EVT-like expression profile. Similar EVT-like cells appear in the lumen of uterine glands and can be observed entering the uterine cavity along the margins of the placenta, suggesting that they are the primary source of cervical trophoblast cells. Cells isolated by TRIC can be used to accurately genotype the embryo/fetus by targeted next-generation sequencing. Biomarker protein expression quantified in cervical trophoblast cells after TRIC correlates with subsequent pregnancy loss, pre-eclampsia and fetal growth restriction. A key remaining question is the degree to which EVT cells in the cervix might differ from those in the basal plate and placental bed.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS

TRIC could one day provide a method of risk assessment for maternal and fetal disease, and reveal molecular pathways disrupted during the first trimester in EVT cells associated with placental maldevelopment. As perinatal interventions emerge for pregnancy disorders and inherited congenital disorders, TRIC could provide a key diagnostic tool for personalized precision medicine in obstetrics.

Trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC) is unaffected by early gestational age or maternal obesity

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study is to evaluate whether trophoblast yield obtained by trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC) is affected by pregnancy outcome, gestational age (GA) at retrieval, maternal body mass index (BMI), parity, or maternal age.

METHODS

TRIC was performed on 224 ongoing pregnancies between 5 and 20 weeks of GA. Trophoblast cells were isolated from cervical cells using anti-human leukocyte antigen-G antibody coupled to magnetic nanoparticles. Purity was assessed by the percentage of isolated cells that express β-hCG. Patient records were monitored until delivery, and pregnancy outcomes were determined. Trophoblast yield was compared with GA at time of collection, maternal BMI, parity, maternal age, and outcome of pregnancy, using linear regression.

RESULTS

There was no effect of GA, maternal BMI, parity, and maternal age on trophoblast yield. Trophoblast yield decreased significantly with early pregnancy loss compared with uncomplicated pregnancies that delivered at term. Trophoblast yield with preeclampsia or intrauterine growth restriction was decreased compared with healthy term outcomes; however, they did not reach statistical significance.

CONCLUSIONS

If TRIC becomes available as a method for non-invasive prenatal testing, our data demonstrate that it is unaffected by BMI and is useful as early as 5 weeks of GA.

Endoreduplication in cervical trophoblast cells from normal pregnancies

OBJECTIVE

Fetal cells represented by extravillous trophoblasts (EVT) obtained from the cervix by a minimally invasive procedure are important for prenatal diagnosis in early pregnancies. Endoreduplication is a duplication of chromosomes without mitosis, leading to polyploidy that might represent increased cellular metabolic activity. In this study, we estimated the normal prevalence of polyploid trophoblasts exfoliated to the cervix between 5 and 13 weeks of gestation.

METHODS

Cervical samples were obtained by cytobrush, between 5 and 13 weeks of gestation from 36 randomly selected, singleton pregnancies. FISH was done with X, Y and two 21 probes.

RESULTS

We diagnosed 21 pregnancies with female and 15 pregnancies with male fetal karyotypes. A mean of 15.2 (0.02%) tetraploid cells were found in pregnancies with a female fetus and a mean of 2.0 (0.003%) tetraploid cells were found in pregnancies with a male fetus. The tetraploid cells (endoreduplicated trophoblasts) were two to three times larger than the normal cells usually seen in the cervix.

CONCLUSIONS

Extravillus trophoblasts tend to form endoreduplication to the ploidy level of 4c-8c of DNA. Those cells may represent a typical phenomenon in the growing placenta. Extravillus trophoblasts from female fetuses tend to form higher rates of endoreduplication.

Prenatal diagnosis of trisomy 21 through detection of trophoblasts in cervical smears

BACKGROUND

Fetal cells exfoliate in the uterine cavity during early pregnancy and are a potential source of material for NIPD.

AIMS

This study was designed to test the hypothesis that fetal cells obtained from the uterine cervix during the first trimester of pregnancy could be utilized for prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal aneuploidy.

STUDY DESIGN

Fetal cells retrieved from the distal endocervical canal during the first trimester of pregnancy were hybridized with chromosome 21 specific FISH probes and analyzed with an automated fluorescence microscope.

SUBJECTS AND OUTCOME MEASURES

Cells with 3 copies of chromosome 21 were detected in 5 out of 5 trisomy 21 pregnancies.

RESULTS

The number of trisomic cells detected ranged from 1 to 27 with a median value of 5.

CONCLUSIONS

FISH-based scanning can identify trisomy 21 pregnancies by analysis of routine cervical brushings. The approach offers the potential for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis as early as 5 weeks gestation.

Retrieval of trophoblast cells from the cervical canal for prediction of abnormal pregnancy: a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Fetal cells are shed from the regressing chorionic villi and it is possible to retrieve extravillous cytotrophoblast cells by transcervical sampling. The abundance of trophoblast cells in transcervical samples suggests that this non-invasive approach could distinguish between normal and abnormal pregnancies, such as an ectopic pregnancy (EP) and blighted ovum (BO). We aim to identify and quantify fetal trophoblast cells in the cervical canal during the first trimester to assess their usefulness to predict an abnormal pregnancy.

METHODS

Patients, age 18-45, presenting with a normal intrauterine pregnancy (IUP; n = 37), diagnosis of EP (n = 10) or BO (n = 5) were enrolled for collection of transcervical specimens using a cytobrush and fixative rinse. Non-pregnant, nulliparous women (n = 7) were included as negative controls. Cells were cleared of mucus by acidification, prepared on microscope slides and labeled with a monoclonal antibody recognizing the trophoblast marker, human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-G. HLA-G positive and negative cells were counted to calculate the ratio of trophoblast cells to total cervical cells.

RESULTS

Trophoblast cells were observed in 35/37 normal IUP, 6/10 EP and 4/5 BO specimens. The average frequency of HLA-G positive cells in the normal IUP cervical samples was approximately 1 in 2000, which was 4-fold higher than samples from patients with EP or BO (P < 0.001). Receiver operating characteristic analysis showed that EP and BO pregnancies were distinguishable from normal pregnancies with 93% sensitivity, 95% specificity, 97% positive predictive value and 87% negative predictive value.

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study presents evidence that trophoblast cells can be reliably obtained and identified among cervical cells in the first trimester by immunohistochemical staining for HLA-G, and suggests for the first time that abnormal pregnancies may be predictable based on the abundance of trophoblast cells in the cervical canal.

Prenatal diagnosis of common aneuploidies in transcervical samples using quantitative fluorescent-PCR analysis

AIM

The aim of this study was to test the feasibility of diagnosing common fetal chromosomal aneuploidies using quantitative fluorescent (QF)-PCR on transcervical cell (TCC) samples collected in the first trimester of pregnancy by means of intrauterine lavage (IUL).

METHODS

A total of 181 TCC samples were retrieved from pregnant women between 5 and 12 weeks of gestation, immediately before elective termination of pregnancy, at which time corresponding placental tissue and maternal blood specimens were also obtained. Isolation of trophoblastic cells by micromanipulation was attempted in all TCC samples. Micromanipulated specimens were analyzed by multiplex QF-PCR, including short tandem repeats for the chromosomes X, Y, 21, 18, and 13.

RESULTS

The micromanipulation was successful in 152 of 181 cases (84.8%) where chorionic villous filaments and/or cell clumps of seeming trophoblastic origin could be isolated. All 152 samples were tested by QF-PCR analysis and peaks of paternal origin could be documented in all cases. Two cases of trisomy 21 and two cases of monosomy X0 were detected by means of QF-PCR assay, in accordance with the results obtained in corresponding placental samples.

CONCLUSION

This study provides evidence that the use of multiplex QF-PCR amplification of selected microsatellites could be applied to micromanipulated TCC samples and in particular to IUL samples, which often contain trophoblastic cells, for the detection of chromosomal aneuploidies. The approach described in this study appears, therefore, a very promising tool toward non-invasive prenatal genetic diagnosis in the early stage of gestation.

Preliminary report: Correct diagnosis of sex in fetal cells isolated from cervical mucus during early pregnancy

The aim of this study was to determine the accuracy of sexing fetal cells isolated from cervical mucus. Immunopositive cells identified using a fetal-specific antibody were isolated and subjected to genetic analysis. Fetal sex was predicted in all 22 samples, as confirmed by analysis of the corresponding placental tissue. This study validates the accuracy of our test for sex diagnosis and confirms the ability to effectively recover and analyse fetal cells from the cervical mucus during early pregnancy.

Endocervical fetal trophoblast for prenatal genetic diagnosis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

For over a decade, methods of first-trimester, noninvasive prenatal genetic diagnosis have been actively pursued by many investigators. Isolation of fetal trophoblast from endocervical specimens remains an attractive approach, given the greater numbers of fetal cells than in maternal blood and the better potential for fetal-cell identification based on markers specific for a single cell type (trophoblasts).

RECENT FINDINGS

Current studies demonstrate feasibility in identification and molecular analysis of fetal trophoblast cells for prenatal genetic testing. Sampling methods involving lavage, cytobrush, or aspiration of cervical specimens, however, have limitations in the recovery of trophoblasts.

SUMMARY

Clinical applications await further systematic studies to determine safety and accuracy in recovery.

DNA identification of fetal cells isolated from cervical mucus: potential for early non-invasive prenatal diagnosis

OBJECTIVES

To develop a reliable method to isolate fetal cells for genetic diagnosis.

DESIGN

Aspiration of cervical mucus from pregnant women in the first trimester.

SETTING

Pregnant women were recruited before an elective termination of pregnancy.

POPULATION

Sixty pregnant women (7-10 weeks of gestation).

METHODS

Fetal cells were isolated from aspirated cervical mucus of pregnant women using a combination of enzymatic digestion, fluorescent immunohistochemistry, micromanipulation and single-cell DNA allelic profiling.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The isolation and identification of fetal cells.

RESULTS

The transformation of the tenacious cervical mucus into a single-cell suspension enabled the isolation and identification of fetal cells by fluorescent immunohistochemistry. Confirmation of fetal origin was accomplished by single-cell DNA allelic profiling alongside known maternal cells.

CONCLUSIONS

This novel non-invasive method is rapid and efficient with results attainable within 24 hours as early as seven weeks of gestation. The technique would offer earlier reassurance and the option of first trimester therapeutic abortions to both high and low risk pregnant women.

HLA-G positive trophoblastic cells in transcervical samples and their isolation and analysis by laser microdissection and QF-PCR

OBJECTIVE

To assess the frequency of cytotrophoblastic cells in endocervical samples collected by lavage at early stages of gestation using a specific anti-HLA-G McAb (G233). From a set of four selected samples, cells identified by immunostaining were collected by laser microdissection and then tested by quantitative fluorescent polymerase chain reaction (QF-PCR) for the presence of paternally derived DNA markers, in order to establish their fetal origin.

METHODS

Syncytial fragments and cytotrophoblastic cells from 23 transcervical samples were identified by immunostaining with McAb G233 reacting against HLA-G antigen and with antibodies against cytokeratin. Slides from the same samples were also tested by fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH), while selected samples were analysed by QF-PCR. Slides from four samples retrieved from mothers with male fetuses were immunolabelled and then cytotrophoblastic cells, syncytial fragments and maternal epithelial cells were collected by laser microdissection and tested by QF-PCR.

RESULTS

All endocervical samples retrieved from mothers with male fetuses were found to contain some cells with chromosome Y-specific signals when tested by FISH. Using McAb anti- HLA-G, cytotrophoblastic cellular elements were detected in about 50% of the samples. From four samples, cellular elements identified by immunostaining as cytotrophoblast or syncytial fragments were collected by laser microdissection and shown to be of fetal origin when tested by QF-PCR for the presence of fetal DNA markers.

CONCLUSIONS

These results confirm that, during an early phase of gestation, fetal cells are released in the lower uterine cavity and that they can be isolated and analysed for prenatal diagnosis of single gene defects and aneuploidies.

Fetal cells in the uterine cervix: a source for early non-invasive prenatal diagnosis

Various non-invasive techniques for prenatal diagnosis have been under investigation. We evaluated the success of fetal sexing using a non-invasive technique for obtaining fetal cells, uterine cervix brushing, in combination with FISH. Thirty pregnant women who completed between 6 and 10 weeks of gestation and who were scheduled to undergo pregnancy termination were included in the study. A Pap smear cytobrush was inserted through the external os to a maximum depth of 2 cm and removed while rotating it a full turn. The material that was caught on the brush was spread on four microscope slides. Two-color FISH was used for fetal sexing. Following pregnancy termination, a placental sample was used for full karyotyping. In 29/30 cases FISH diagnosis was confirmed by chromosomal analysis. The only male case in which a Y chromosome was not seen was from a pregnancy of 6 weeks 6 days gestational age. One case was mosaic of 46,XY/47,XXY (25%). In most cases (7/13) the Y chromosome was already identified in the first analyzed slide. With the use of a cytobrush fetal cells can be easily obtained for the purpose of prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal disorders.

A successful strategy for preimplantation genetic diagnosis of myotonic dystrophy using multiplex fluorescent PCR

The most common form of inherited muscular dystrophy in adults is myotonic dystrophy (DM), an autosomal-dominant disease caused by the expansion of an unstable CTG repeat sequence in the 3' untranslated region of the myotonin protein kinase (DMPK) gene. Expanded (mutant) CTG repeat sequences are refractory to conventional PCR, but alleles with a number of repeats within the normal range can be readily amplified and detected. Preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) of DM has been successfully applied. However, a misdiagnosis using the reported protocol was recently documented. Two new PGD protocols for DM have been developed which utilise multiplex fluorescent PCR. Ideally a linked polymorphic marker, APOC2, is amplified in addition to the normal DMPK alleles, thus providing a back-up diagnostic result. However, the two couples reported in the present study were not fully informative at the APOC2 locus and so an unlinked short tandem repeat (STR) marker, D21S1414, was substituted. The highly polymorphic nature of the D21S1414, DMPK and APOC2 loci means that a very simple genetic fingerprint can be generated by analyses of these loci. This allows most DNA contaminants to be detected. Contamination is a significant problem for PGD and is the primary reason for the inclusion of D21S1414 and APOC2 in this protocol. This paper reports the first clinical experience and pregnancies following PGD for DM using a multiplex fluorescent PCR protocol.

Fetal cells in cervical mucus and maternal blood

Research in developing effective and accurate methods for non-invasive prenatal diagnosis has focused on two main techniques: the retrieval of trophoblast cells from the cervix and the enrichment of fetal erythroblasts from the blood of pregnant women. The isolation of fetal cells by both approaches has permitted the identification of fetal aneuploidies by the use of fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH) with appropriate probes, as well as fetal single gene disorders by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). In the latter instance, it has been shown that in order to attain the high degree of specificity required for prenatal diagnosis, it is necessary to analyse single fetal cells isolated by micromanipulation. This practice has permitted the successful characterization of fetal rhesus status, haemoglobinopathies, Duchenné's muscular dystrophy and spinal muscular atrophy, amongst others.Further developments include investigations into whether the diagnostic potential of fetal cells retrieved by either method can be expanded by the possible culturing of such cells, as well as the possibility of performing successive rounds of FISH and PCR by the recycling of isolated fetal cells.A novel observation that our group has made is that the traffic of fetal cells is enhanced in pregnancies affected by the pregnancy related disorder, pre-eclampsia. Our subsequent investigations have shown that this elevation in fetal cell traffic may serve as an early marker for those pregnancies at risk for this disorder.A very recent exciting discovery has been that free extracellular fetal DNA can be detected in the plasma and serum of pregnant women, which may permit the rapid and accurate detection of uniquely fetal loci, such as the fetal rhesus D gene in rhesus D negative pregnant women.

Prenatal diagnosis of cystic fibrosis: a case of twin pregnancy diagnosis and a review of 5 years' experience

We performed prenatal diagnoses for cystic fibrosis in 32 high risk (1:4) couples (including a dizygotic pregnancy). Chorionic villi sampling did not cause abortion or fetal malformation in any case. The preliminary analysis of 9 short tandem repeats always excluded maternal contamination of the DNA extracted from chorionic villi and confirmed paternity. Twenty-two prenatal diagnoses were made by direct analysis of the mutations. In seven cases diagnosis was made by the analysis of intragenic polymorphisms; in three cases, we analyzed two extragenic polymorphisms. The prenatal diagnosis (including genetic counselling) was completed within 24 h from the sampling. Seven prenatal diagnoses revealed an affected fetus; all couples opted for therapeutic abortion. In 17 cases the fetus was heterozygote, and in seven cases it was non carrier of mutated alleles. In the twin pregnancy, mutations were DeltaF508/N1303K. Direct analysis of the DNA extracted from the two independent samples of chorionic villi revealed one fetus non carrier of mutated alleles and the other a carrier of the N1303K mutation. Analysis of the HPRT locus predicted both the fetuses as males. Furthermore, the genotype of each fetus was defined after birth. The prenatal diagnosis with chorionic villi sampling plays a key role in the prevention of cystic fibrosis. The laboratories must be equipped for both the direct analysis of mutations and for the analysis of a large number of polymorphisms. The preliminary analysis of short tandem repeats is recommended both to exclude maternal contamination and to confirm parentage.

Recent advances and future developments in PGD

PGD has now been practised for a decade. The basic techniques currently used involve embryo biopsy, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Recent advances in molecular diagnostic techniques have included the use of fluorescent PCR, multiplex PCR and whole genome amplification. For cytogenetic analysis, many centres are now using five or more chromosome probes to examine for chromosome abnormalities, sexing and aneuploidy. Future improvements in molecular diagnosis include the use of quantitative PCR, DNA fingerprinting and microarray technology. Developments in methods to analyse chromosomes from a single cell have included interphase chromosome conversion, which has already been clinically applied, and the use of comparative genomic hybridization, which is still being developed. These methods will hopefully enable more accurate and a greater number of diseases to be diagnosed at the single cell level.

Advances in fluorescent in situ hybridisation

Recent advances in fluorescent in situ hybridisation included the generation of allele-specific probes, bar-coded chromosomes, and the visualisation of chromosome territories and genes within the nucleus. One major advance has been our ability to visualise and make precise and reproducible measurements from stretched DNA molecules prepared directly from human cells.