Practical evaluation of the fertilising capacity of frozen-thawed horse semen

Fertility of frozen-thawed stallion semen cannot be predicted by the currently used laboratory methods

The aim of the project was to use current simple and practical laboratory tests and compare results with the foaling rates of mares inseminated with commercially produced frozen semen. In Exp. 1, semen was tested from 27 and in Exp. 2 from 23 stallions; 19 stallions participated in both experiments. The mean number of mares per stallion in both experiments was 37 (min. 7, max. 121). Sperm morphology was assessed and bacterial culture performed once per stallion. In Exp. 1, progressive motility after 0, 1, 2, 3, and 4 h of incubation using light microscopy, motility characteristics measured with an automatic sperm analyzer, plasma membrane integrity using carboxyfluorescein diacetate/propidium iodide (CFDA/PI) staining and light microscopy, plasma membrane integrity using PI staining and a fluorometer, plasma membrane integrity using a resazurin reduction test, and sperm concentration were evaluated. In Exp. 2, the same tests as in Exp. 1 and a hypo-osmotic swelling test (HOST) using both light microscopy and a fluorometer were performed immediately after thawing and after a 3-h incubation. Statistical analysis was done separately to all stallions and to those having ≥ 20 mares; in addition, stallions with foaling rates < 60 or ≥ 60% were compared. In Exp. 1, progressive motility for all stallions after a 2 – 4-h incubation correlated with the foaling rate (correlation coefficients 0.39 – 0.51), (p < 0.05). In stallions with > 20 mares, the artificial insemination dose showed a correlation coefficient of -0.58 (p < 0.05). In Exp. 2, the HOST immediately after thawing showed a negative correlation with foaling rate (p < 0.05). No single test was consistently reliable for predicting the fertilizing capacity of semen, since the 2 experiments yielded conflicting results, although the same stallions sometimes participated in both. This shows the difficulty of frozen semen quality control in commercially produced stallion semen, and on the other hand, the difficulty of conducting fertility trials in horses.

The effects of different insemination regimes on fertility in mares

This study investigated the effects of different artificial insemination (AI) regimes on the pregnancy rate in mares inseminated with either cooled or frozen-thawed semen. In essence, the influence of three different factors on fertility was examined; namely the number of inseminations per oestrus, the time interval between inseminations within an oestrus, and the proximity of insemination to ovulation. In the first experiment, 401 warmblood mares were inseminated one to three times in an oestrus with either cooled (500 x 10(6) progressively motile spermatozoa, stored at +5 degrees C for 2-4 h) or frozen-thawed (800 x 10(6) spermatozoa, of which > or =35% were progressively motile post-thaw) semen from fertile Hanoverian stallions, beginning -24, -12, 0, 12, 24 or 36 h after human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) administration. Mares were injected intravenously with 1500 IU hCG when they were in oestrus and had a pre-ovulatory follicle > or =40mm in diameter. Experiment 2 was a retrospective analysis of the breeding records of 2,637 mares inseminated in a total of 5,305 oestrous cycles during the 1999 breeding season. In Experiment 1, follicle development was monitored by transrectal ultrasonographic examination of the ovaries every 12 h until ovulation, and pregnancy detection was performed sonographically 16-18 days after ovulation. In Experiment 2, insemination data were analysed with respect to the number of live foals registered the following year. In Experiment 1, ovulation occurred within 48 h of hCG administration in 97.5% (391/401) of mares and the interval between hCG treatment and ovulation was significantly shorter in the second half of the breeding season (May-July) than in the first (March-April, P< or =0.05). Mares inseminated with cooled stallion semen once during an oestrus had pregnancy rates comparable to those attained in mares inseminated on two (48/85, 56.5%) or three (20/28, 71.4%) occasions at 24 h intervals, as long as insemination was performed between 24 h before and 12 h after ovulation (78/140, 55.7%). Similarly, a single frozen-thawed semen insemination between 12 h before (31/75, 41.3%) and 12 h after (24/48, 50%) ovulation produced similar pregnancy rates to those attained when mares were inseminated either two (31/62, 50%) or three (3/9, 33.3%) times at 24 h intervals. In the retrospective study (Experiment 2), mares inseminated with cooled semen only once per cycle had significantly lower per cycle foaling rates (507/1622, 31.2%) than mares inseminated two (791/1905, 41.5%), three (464/1064, 43.6%) or > or =4 times (314/714, 43.9%) in an oestrus (P< or =0.001). In addition, there was a tendency for per cycle foaling rates to increase when mares were inseminated daily (619/1374, 45.5%) rather than every other day (836/2004, 42.1%, P = 0.054) until ovulation. It is concluded that under conditions of frequent veterinary examination, a single insemination per cycle produces pregnancy rates as good as multiple insemination, as long as it is performed between 24 h before and 12 h after AI for cooled semen, or 12 h before and 12 h after AI for frozen-thawed semen. If frequent scanning is not possible, fertility appears to be optimised by repeating AI on a daily basis.

Effect of insemination time of frozen semen on incidence of uterine fluid in mares

Ninety five mares were inseminated with frozen semen either within 12 h before ovulation or within 8 h after ovulation. The effect of preovulatory versus postovulatory insemination (AI) on the subsequent detection of uterine fluid was studied. The overall pregnancy rate was 43% and this was not significantly influenced by preovulatory or postovulatory insemination. When mares were first examined 12 h after AI, 18 of 52 mares (35%) had accumulated uterine fluid. However, when mares were first examined 18 to 24 h after AI, only 6 of 43 mares (14%) had uterine fluid. Presence of intrauterine fluid significantly lowered pregnancy rates. Timing of insemination did not affect incidence of uterine fluid. Serum concentrations of estrogen and progesterone at time of insemination did not influence uterine clearance or pregnancy rates, but both hormones were higher at preovulatory than at postovulatory inseminations. We concluded that there was no evidence that postovulatory inseminations would predispose mares to persistence of uterine fluid after AI.