Reduced noradrenaline responsiveness of brown adipocytes isolated from estradiol-treated rats

The capacity for oestrogen to influence obesity through brown adipose tissue thermogenesis in animal models: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Pharmacological interventions to aid weight loss have historically targeted either appetite suppression or increased metabolic rate. Brown adipose tissue (BAT) possesses the capacity to expend energy in a futile cycle, thus increasing basal metabolic rate. In animal models, oestrogen has been implicated in the regulation of body weight, and it is hypothesized that oestrogen is acting by modulating BAT metabolism. A systematic search was performed, to identify research articles implementing in vivo oestrogen-related interventions and reporting outcome measures that provide direct or indirect measures of BAT metabolism. Meta-analyses were conducted where sufficient data were available. The final library of 67 articles were predominantly in rodent models and provided mostly indirect measures of BAT metabolism. Results of this review found that oestrogen's effects on body weight, in rats and possibly mice, are likely facilitated by both metabolic and appetitive mechanisms but are largely only found in ovariectomized models. There is a need for further studies to clarify the potential effects of oestrogen on BAT metabolism in gonad-intact and castrated male animal models.

A progesterone-brown fat axis is involved in regulating fetal growth

Pregnancy is associated with profound maternal metabolic changes, necessary for the growth and development of the fetus, mediated by reproductive signals acting on metabolic organs. However, the role of brown adipose tissue (BAT) in regulating gestational metabolism is unknown. We show that BAT phenotype is lost in murine pregnancy, while there is a gain of white adipose tissue (WAT)-like features. This is characterised by reduced thermogenic capacity and mitochondrial content, accompanied by increased levels of markers of WAT and lipid accumulation. Surgical ablation of BAT prior to conception caused maternal and fetal hyperlipidemia, and consequently larger fetuses. We show that BAT phenotype is altered from day 5 of gestation, implicating early pregnancy factors, which was confirmed by reduced expression of BAT markers in progesterone challenged oophorectomised mice. Moreover, in vitro data using primary BAT cultures show a direct impact of progesterone on expression of Ucp1. These data demonstrate that progesterone mediates a phenotypic change in BAT, which contributes to the gestational metabolic environment, and thus overall fetal size.

Oleoyl-oestrone inhibits lipogenic, but maintains thermogenic, gene expression of brown adipose tissue in overweight rats

In the present study we intended to determine how BAT (brown adipose tissue) maintained thermogenesis under treatment with OE (oleoyl-oestrone), a powerful slimming hormone that sheds off body lipid but maintains the metabolic rate. Overweight male rats were subjected to daily gavages of 10 nmol/g of OE or vehicle (control) for 10 days. A PF (pair-fed) vehicle-receiving group was used to discount the effects attributable to energy availability limitation. Interscapular BAT mass, lipid, DNA, mRNA and the RT-PCR (real-time PCR) expression of lipid and energy metabolism genes for enzymes and regulatory proteins were measured. BAT mass and lipid were decreased in OE and PF, with the latter showing a marked reduction in tissue mRNA. Maintenance of perilipin gene expression in PF and OE rats despite the loss of lipid suggests the preservation of the vacuolar interactive surface, a critical factor for thermogenic responsiveness. OE and, to a lesser extent, PF maintained the expression of genes controlling lipolysis and fatty acid oxidation, but markedly decreased the expression of those genes involved in lipogenic and acyl-glycerol synthesis. OE did not affect UCP1 (uncoupling protein 1) (decreased in PF), β3 adrenergic receptors or hormone-sensitive lipase gene mRNAs, which may translate in maintaining a full thermogenic system potential. OE rats were able to maintain a less energetically stressed BAT (probably through glucose utilization) than PF rats. These changes were not paralleled in PF rats, in which lower thermogenesis and glucose preservation resulted in a heavier toll on internal fat stores. Thus the mechanism of action of OE is more complex and tissue-specific than previously assumed.

Sex steroid receptor expression profile in brown adipose tissue. Effects of hormonal status

Recent investigations suggest that sex hormones play an important role in the brown adipose tissue (BAT) thermogenic program by acting on several steps of the lipolytic signal cascade and on the UCP1 transcription control. However, the number of studies focusing on steroid receptor status in brown adipose tissue is negligible. In the present study, we analyze steroid receptor mRNA levels in brown adipose tissue in male and female rats and in pregnant and lactating females, all of them models with a different hormonal background. The direct effect of sex hormones on the expression of their receptors was studied in vitro in primary culture of brown adipocytes. Oestrogen receptor (ERalpha) and androgen receptor (AR) densities were higher in male than in female BAT. PR A+B mRNA expression was downregulated in lactation, suggesting a role of progesterone signalling in thermogenesis impairment at this stage. In vitro studies showed that progesterone decreased PR A+B mRNA and that testosterone downregulated ERalpha mRNA. The results highlighted in this study demonstrate the presence of steroid receptor mRNA in BAT and in brown cell cultured adipocytes, supporting the idea that changes in steroid receptor expression would be important for the understanding of sex hormone effects on BAT physiology.

Direct effects of testosterone, 17 beta-estradiol, and progesterone on adrenergic regulation in cultured brown adipocytes: potential mechanism for gender-dependent thermogenesis

Previous studies suggest that sex hormones could be responsible, at least in part, for the gender-dependent thermogenesis found in the adrenergic control of brown adipose tissue (BAT) under control conditions and in response to diet and cold. Catecholamines, as well as several hormones, including sex hormones, may alter the function or expression of different adrenoceptor subtypes in brown adipocytes in vivo, and a confirmation could be provided by in vitro experiments. Therefore, the effect of testosterone, 17 beta-estradiol, progesterone, and norepinephrine (NE) on adrenergic receptor (AR) gene expression (alpha 2A-, beta 1-, -, and beta 3-AR) and lipolytic activity was investigated in differentiated brown adipocytes in culture. We report that the expression of each AR subtype gene was distinctively regulated by NE and sex hormones in brown adipocytes. Testosterone-treated cells had lower lipolytic activity and increased expression of antilipolytic receptors alpha 2A-AR. Both 17 beta-estradiol and progesterone decreased alpha 2A-AR expression and alpha 2A/beta 3-AR protein ratio, but progesterone had higher potency than 17 beta-estradiol, increasing beta-AR levels, mainly beta 3-AR expression, and enhancing lipolysis stimulated by NE. In conclusion, our results support the idea that male and female sex hormones, as a part of the hormonal environment of BAT, have direct and opposite effects on the AR balance and lipolytic activity, and they might play a role in the gender dimorphism for the recruitment process in BAT.

Sex-dependent thermogenesis, differences in mitochondrial morphology and function, and adrenergic response in brown adipose tissue

Gender-related differences in brown adipose tissue (BAT) thermogenesis of 110-day-old rats were studied by determining the morphological and functional features of BAT. The adrenergic control was assessed by studying the levels of beta(3)- and alpha(2A)-adrenergic receptors (AR) and by determining the lipolytic response to norepinephrine (beta(1)-, beta(2)-, beta(3)-, and alpha(2)-AR agonist), isoprenaline (beta(1)-, beta(2)-, and beta(3)-AR agonist), and CGP12177A (selective partial beta(3)-AR agonist but beta(1)- and beta(2)-AR antagonist) together with post-receptor agents, forskolin and dibutyryl cyclic AMP. The female rats that had greater oxygen consumption showed higher UCP1 content, a higher multilocular arrangement, and both longer cristae and higher cristae dense mitochondria in BAT indicating heightened thermogenic capacity and activity; this picture is accompanied by a more sensitive beta(3)-AR to norepinephrine signal (EC(50) 10-fold lower for CGP12177A) and a lower expression of alpha(2A)-AR than male rats. Taken together, our results support the idea that the BAT hormonal environment could be involved in the control of different elements of lipolytic and thermogenic adrenergic pathways. Gender dimorphism is both at receptor (changing alpha(2A)-AR density and beta(3)-AR affinity) and post-receptor (modulating the links involved in the adrenergic signal transduction) levels. These changes in adrenergic control could be responsible, at least in part, both for the important mitochondrial recruitment differences and functional and morphological features of BAT in female rats under usual rodent housing temperatures.

Oxygen consumption of oestradiol-treated rats

Rectal temperature and oxygen consumption (Vo2) were monitored in female rats acclimated either to cold or to thermoneutrality and with and without chronic administration of oestradiol. The hormone is known to inactivate brown adipose tissue (BAT) and to reduce its response to noradrenaline (NA). The role of sympathetic control was studied by administering NA or the adrenergic blocker propranolol. Oestradiol treatment did not affect rectal temperature in the states of acclimation to thermoneutrality and to cold, nor did it change the hypothermic response of cold-exposed rats to temporary food deprivation. In the cold-acclimated rats, both controls and oestradiol-treated animals exhibited similar degrees of metabolic reduction after propranolol administration in the cold and similar degrees of metabolic activation by NA at thermoneutrality. Rats acclimated to thermoneutrality showed a larger metabolic response to NA when treated with oestradiol. The results suggest that oestradiol, while inactivating the BAT response to NA, activates the NA responsiveness of other metabolically active tissues in cold-induced thermogenesis. The observation of a greater oxidative capacity in the kidney and the rectus abdominis muscle of oestradiol-treated, cold-acclimated rats would be in line with this proposal.

Dissociation between brown adipose tissue thermogenesis and sympathetic activity in rats with high plasma levels of oestradiol

It has been shown previously that high plasma levels of oestradiol inhibit brown adipose tissue thermogenesis. Since rats and mice show a close association between thermogenic activity in and sympathetic discharge to brown fat, we measured the noradrenaline turnover in rats with high plasma levels of oestradiol to establish whether the observed inhibition of thermogenic activity is brought about by a reduction in the sympathetic drive to brown adipocytes. Oestradiol-filled Silastic capsules were implanted subcutaneously in female rats previously acclimated either to thermoneutrality or to cold. Control rats received empty implants. After 15 days treatment, noradrenaline turnover was measured by blocking its synthesis with alpha-methyl-p-tyrosine. As expected, noradrenaline turnover was higher in cold-acclimated rats than in rats kept at thermoneutrality. The presence of high plasma oestradiol levels did not alter sympathetic activity in any of the treated groups despite reducing thermogenic activity. This result reveals that oestradiol dissociates the thermogenic activity of brown adipose tissue from its sympathetic activation. Such dissociation has never been previously reported in rats, although it seems to be common in Syrian hamsters. However the causative factor in this species is unknown.