Selective MR imaging of silicone with the three-point Dixon technique

Progressive silicone lymphadenopathy post mastectomy and implant reconstruction for breast cancer

A 56-year-old woman with a 12-year history of recurrent triple-negative invasive carcinoma of the breast presented with progressive enlargement of lymph nodes in the setting of established rupture of the ipsilateral silicone breast implant. Although this was proven to be benign on cytology, its progressive nature led to repeated core biopsies for histology, which were necessary given the high-risk nature of triple-negative breast cancer and the multiple proven previous recurrences. The histology demonstrated features of silicone deposits without evidence of malignancy. This case demonstrates the dilemma in surveillance of high-risk patients with breast cancer who have had previous silicone lymphadenopathy.

Water-fat Dixon sequences in the evaluation of breast implants: proposal of a time effective rapid approach in the clinical practice

AIM

To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy achieved from a fat-water Dixon sequence alone compared to a combination of a silicone-specific magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) sequence and a water-specific MRI sequence in the assessment of breast implants.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this institutional review board (IRB)-approved study the integrity of breast implants was assessed retrospectively in 27 patients undergoing breast MRI at 3 T. A qualitative evaluation of (set 1) a silicon-selective water-saturated short tau inversion recovery (STIR) sequence in combination with a water-only Dixon dataset (total acquisition time 7 minutes 17 seconds), and of (set 2) fat-only and water-only Dixon datasets (4 minutes 8 seconds) was performed by two readers independently evaluating the following features: margin definition of the implant, water suppression homogeneity, image quality, presence of artefacts and their effects on the imaging interpretation, and diagnostic confidence. Diagnostic accuracy in implant rupture detection was determined and either surgical confirmation or diagnosis from the radiological report was used as a standard of reference.

RESULTS

In both sequences, margin definition of the implant wall, water suppression homogeneity, and overall image quality were rated good-excellent in most of cases. Water suppression homogeneity was moderate-poor in a greater number of cases in set 1. Movement artefacts were more frequent in set 1 whereas five cases (18.5%) exhibited swap artefacts between silicone and water in set 2. Diagnostic confidence was rated high-very high with both sequences in most of cases. Diagnostic accuracy was 100% for both readers using set 1 and 96.2% and 100% using set 2.

CONCLUSION

A single Dixon sequence allows an accurate diagnostic evaluation of breast implants and concomitant shortening of the overall acquisition time.

Requirements for static and dynamic higher order B0 shimming of the human breast at 7 T

The increased magnetic susceptibility effects at higher magnetic fields increase the demands for shimming of the B0 field for in vivo MRI and MRS. Both static and dynamic techniques have been developed to compensate for susceptibility-induced field inhomogeneities. In this study, we investigate the impact of and need for both static and dynamic higher order B0 shimming of magnetic field homogeneities in clinical breast MRI at 7 T. Both global and local field variations at lipid-tissue interfaces were observed in the magnetic field using TE-optimized B0 mapping at 7 T. With static B0 shimming, a field homogeneity of 39 ± 11 Hz (n = 48) was reached in a single breast using second-order shimming. Further compensation of the residual local field inhomogeneities caused by lipid-tissue interfaces does not seem to be feasible with shallow spherical harmonic fields. For bilateral shimming, the shimming quality was significantly less at 62 ± 15 Hz (n = 22) over both breasts, even after (simulated) fourth-order shimming. In addition, a substantial time-dependent field instability of 30 Hz peak to peak, with significant higher order field contributions, was observed during regular breathing. In conclusion, TE-optimized B0 field mapping reveals substantial field variations in the lipid-rich environment of the human breast, in both space and time. The static field variations could be partially minimized by third-order B0 shimming, providing sufficient lipid suppression. However, in order to fully benefit from the increased spectral dispersion at high fields, the significant magnetic field variations during breathing need to be considered.

Image quality and diagnostic performance of silicone-specific breast MRI

PURPOSE

To compare the image quality of three techniques and diagnostic performance in detecting implant rupture.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The study included 161 implants for the evaluation of image quality, composed of water-saturated short TI inversion recovery (herein called "water-sat STIR"), three-point Dixon techniques (herein called "Dixon"), and short TI inversion recovery fast spin-echo with iterative decomposition of silicone and water using least-squares approximation (herein called "STIR IDEAL") and included 41 implants for the evaluation of diagnostic performance in detecting rupture, composed of water-sat STIR and STIR IDEAL. Six image quality categories were evaluated and three classifications were used: normal implant, possible rupture, and definite rupture.

RESULTS

Statistically significant differences were noted for the image quality categories (p<0.001). STIR IDEAL was superior or equal to water-sat STIR in all image quality categories except artifact effects and superior to Dixon in all categories. Water-sat STIR performed the poorest for water suppression uniformity. The sensitivity and specificity in detecting implant rupture of STIR-IDEAL were 81.8 % and 77.8 % and the difference between two techniques was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSION

STIR-IDEAL is a useful silicone-specific imaging technique demonstrating more robust water suppression and equivalent diagnostic accuracy for detecting implant rupture, than water-sat STIR, at the cost of longer scan time and an increase in minor motion artifacts.

Frequency response of multipoint chemical shift-based spectral decomposition

PURPOSE

To provide a framework for characterizing the frequency response of multipoint chemical shift based species separation techniques.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Multipoint chemical shift based species separation techniques acquire complex images at multiple echo times and perform maximum likelihood estimation to decompose signal from different species into separate images. In general, after a nonlinear process of estimating and demodulating the field map, these decomposition methods are linear transforms from the echo-time domain to the chemical-shift-frequency domain, analogous to the discrete Fourier transform (DFT). In this work we describe a technique for finding the magnitude and phase of chemical shift decomposition for input signals over a range of frequencies using numerical and experimental modeling and examine several important cases of species separation.

RESULTS

Simple expressions can be derived to describe the response to a wide variety of input signals. Agreement between numerical modeling and experimental results is very good.

CONCLUSION

Chemical shift-based species separation is linear, and therefore can be fully described by the magnitude and phase curves of the frequency response. The periodic nature of the frequency response has important implications for the robustness of various techniques for resolving ambiguities in field inhomogeneity.

Dixon techniques for water and fat imaging

In 1984, Dixon published a first paper on a simple spectroscopic imaging technique for water and fat separation. The technique acquires two separate images with a modified spin echo pulse sequence. One is a conventional spin echo image with water and fat signals in-phase and the other is acquired with the readout gradient slightly shifted so that the water and fat signals are 180 degrees out-of-phase. Dixon showed that from these two images, a water-only image and a fat-only image can be generated. The water-only image by the Dixon's technique can serve the purpose of fat suppression, an important and widely used imaging option for clinical MRI. Additionally, the availability of both the water-only and fat-only images allows direct image-based water and fat quantitation. These applications, as well as the potential that the technique can be made highly insensitive to magnetic field inhomogeneity, have generated substantial research interests and efforts from many investigators. As a result, significant improvement to the original technique has been made in the last 2 decades. The following article reviews the underlying physical principles and describes some major technical aspects in the development of these Dixon techniques.

Multiresolution field map estimation using golden section search for water-fat separation

Many diagnostic MRI sequences demand reliable and uniform fat suppression. Multipoint water-fat separation methods, which are based on chemical-shift induced phase differences, have shown great success in the presence of field inhomogeneities. This work presents a computationally efficient and robust field map estimation method. The method begins with subsampling image data into a multiresolution image pyramidal structure, and then utilizes a golden section search to directly locate possible field map values at the coarsest level of the pyramidal structure. The field map estimate is refined and propagated to increasingly finer resolutions in an efficient manner until the full-resolution field map is obtained for final water-fat separation. The proposed method is validated with multiecho sequences where long echo-spacings normally impose great challenges on reliable field map estimation.

Water-selective spectral–spatial contrast-enhanced breast MRI for cancer detection in patients with extracapsular and injected free silicone

OBJECTIVE

This study investigates the use of contrast-enhanced, T1-weighted, water-selective spectral-spatial 3D gradient echo magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) with magnetization transfer (3DSSMT) for detecting breast cancer in patients with intraparenchymal silicone.

CONCLUSION

Water-selective 3DSSMT provides superior fat and silicone suppression in patients with free silicone as compared with conventional fat saturation. It enables direct, high-quality, high-spatial-resolution, T1-weighted breast MRI of contrast enhancement without the need for subtraction processing and aids diagnosis of cancer in the breast with free silicone.

Silicone-specific imaging using an inversion-recovery-prepared fast three-point Dixon technique

PURPOSE

To demonstrate a new hybrid magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) technique capable of simultaneously generating water-specific and silicone-specific images in a single acquisition.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This technique combines short TI inversion-recovery (STIR) technique for robust fat suppression with an efficient fast spin-echo-based three-point Dixon technique for robust separation of remaining water and silicone in the presence of field inhomogeneities. Images demonstrating the feasibility of the technique were acquired with a 1.5-Tesla scanner in a phantom and in a volunteer with both saline and silicone implants in vivo.

RESULTS

The new technique provided water-specific and silicone-specific images of diagnostic quality. Separation of the water and silicone chemical species was complete and satisfactory. Compared with a chemical shift-selective technique, the new technique does not rely heavily on field homogeneity and requires the same or even less scan time to acquire images with similar scan parameters, resolution, and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR).

CONCLUSION

The feasibility and potential application of the new technique were demonstrated via imaging a phantom and a silicone breast prosthesis in vivo, and it may be used for more consistent imaging of the silicone implants without compromising the image quality or overall scan time.

Multicoil Dixon chemical species separation with an iterative least-squares estimation method

This work describes a new approach to multipoint Dixon fat-water separation that is amenable to pulse sequences that require short echo time (TE) increments, such as steady-state free precession (SSFP) and fast spin-echo (FSE) imaging. Using an iterative linear least-squares method that decomposes water and fat images from source images acquired at short TE increments, images with a high signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and uniform separation of water and fat are obtained. This algorithm extends to multicoil reconstruction with minimal additional complexity. Examples of single- and multicoil fat-water decompositions are shown from source images acquired at both 1.5T and 3.0T. Examples in the knee, ankle, pelvis, abdomen, and heart are shown, using FSE, SSFP, and spoiled gradient-echo (SPGR) pulse sequences. The algorithm was applied to systems with multiple chemical species, and an example of water-fat-silicone separation is shown. An analysis of the noise performance of this method is described, and methods to improve noise performance through multicoil acquisition and field map smoothing are discussed.

Correlation of single-lumen silicone implant integrity with chemical shift artifact on T2-weighted magnetic resonance images

PURPOSE

To correlate the integrity of single-lumen silicone gel implants with chemical shift artifact (CSA) associated with infolding of the elastomer shell.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The T2-weighted images of presurgical MRI examinations of 54 implants were retrospectively reviewed by two breast radiologists blinded to the operative and pathologic findings. CSA associated with intraluminal membranes was quantified by determining the fraction of membranes with it and categorized as minimal (0-1/3 of membranes involved), moderate (>1/3- <2/3), and marked (2/3 to all). CSA was qualified by noting whether CSA intensity of the membranes was less than or similar to that of blood vessels. The CSA was correlated with the surgical or pathology findings to judge integrity of the implant.

RESULTS

Nineteen implants were intact, 35 were dysfunctional (gel leakage or rupture). Twenty-eight of 29 (97%) with a minimal fraction of membranes with CSA were dysfunctional; 17/21 (81%) with CSA associated with a marked fraction of membranes were intact (P < 0.001). All 28 implants with CSA intensity less than vessels were dysfunctional, 19/26 (73%) with CSA equal to vessels were intact (P < 0.001). All 25 implants with minimal CSA and intensity less than vessels were dysfunctional. Seventeen of 19 (89%) implants with CSA associated with a marked fraction of membranes and intensity equal to vessels were intact (P = 0.02). The magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) signs were combined with strong CSA as a predictor of integrity, and 22 of 26 (85%) implants were correctly diagnosed, 4 dysfunctional and 18 intact (P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

CSA correlates with integrity of silicone gel implants on T2-weighted images and can be used with other MRI signs to improve diagnosis.

Chemical shift imaging with spectrum modeling

A new chemical shift imaging technique was developed to efficiently obtain separate images for multiple chemical shift peaks from a set of spin-echo acquisitions. Information from localized NMR spectroscopy was used to model the chemical shift spectrum as sharp peaks with known resonance frequencies but unknown amplitudes. Based on this model, a set of spin-echo images with shifted 180 degrees RF pulses were acquired, in which the magnetization vectors of different chemical components were put into different directions. The amplitudes of the chemical shift peaks were obtained by solving nonlinear equations in a region-growing process. Experimental results on an ethanol phantom as well as a subject with silicone breast implants are presented. Magn Reson Med 46:126-130, 2001.

Accuracy of ultrasonography and magnetic resonance imaging in detecting failure of breast implants filled with silicone gel

We prospectively studied the accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ultrasonography (US) for preoperative detection of rupture in 35 single-lumen implants filled with silicone gel in 18 patients. The positive predictive value of US for rupture of an implant was 70% and the negative predictive value 64%. Sensitivity and specificity were 44% and 87%, respectively. Accuracy, defined as the total true positive and true negative values divided by the total number of implants studied was 66%. The positive predictive value of MRI was 100% and the negative predictive value 90%. The corresponding sensitivity and specificity were 88% and 100% and the accuracy 94%. MRI offers significantly better diagnostic sensitivity (p = 0.02) and accuracy (p = 0.004), and should be regarded as the "gold standard" in the evaluation of rupture of breast implants filled with silicone gel. When MRI is not readily available, US is an acceptable alternative.

Breast cancer detection using magnetic resonance imaging in breasts injected with liquid silicone

Two patients who had received silicone injections in their breasts several years ago presented with breast complaints. Excluding cancer in these patients was very difficult. Mammograms were very difficult to interpret, as were the physical findings. Carcinoma was successfully detected by magnetic resonance imaging. When women who underwent the injudicious injection of silicone reach the cancer-prone age, the examining physicians should have a greater awareness of the detection and management of carcinoma coexistent with silicone mastopathy. We think that MRI is potentially valuable in the evaluation of the breast lesions; it plays an important role in the detection of breast cancer in breasts augmented with liquid silicone.

Silicone breast implant rupture: pitfalls of magnetic resonance imaging and relative efficacies of magnetic resonance, mammography, and ultrasound

The objective of this study was to evaluate the relative efficacies of magnetic resonance (MR) imaging, ultrasonography, and mammography in implant rupture detection and to illustrate pitfalls in MR image interpretation. Thirty patients referred by plastic surgeons with suspected breast implant rupture were prospectively evaluated using MR, ultrasonography, and mammography. Imaging examinations were interpreted independently and blindly for implant rupture and correlated to operative findings. Surgical correlation in 16 patients (53 percent) with 31 implants showed 13 (42 percent) were intact, 5 (16 percent) had severe gel bleed, and 13 (42 percent) were ruptured. MR sensitivity was 100 percent and specificity was 63 percent. Accuracy for rupture was 81 percent with MR, higher than with ultrasonography and mammography (77 and 59 percent, respectively). We describe a specific pitfall in MR interpretation, the "rat-tail" sign, composed of a medial linear extension of silicone along the chest wall. Seen in eight cases (four intact, three ruptures, one gel bleed), the rat-tail sign may lead to misdiagnosis of implant rupture if seen in isolation. Magnetic resonance imaging is more accurate and sensitive than ultrasonography and mammography in detecting breast implant rupture. We describe a new sign (rat-tail sign) composed of medial compression of the implant simulating silicone extrusion as a potential false-positive MR finding for rupture. This article presents clinical experience with magnetic resonance, mammography, and ultrasound in the diagnosis of implant rupture and defines and illustrates potential pitfalls of MR interpretation, including the new rat-tail sign.

Breast magnetic resonance imaging

Breast MRI is becoming an important tool for the improved management of breast cancer. The technical attributes of high contrast, high-resolution breast MRI acquisitions are summarized. The fundamentals of image interpretation are outlined, including lesion enhancement, morphological features, and extent categories. The indications for breast MRI include compromised mammography, staging of disease within the breast and adjacent structures, difficult histology, and other special diagnostic situations. Patients with compromised mammography include previous surgery, radiographically dense breasts, and silicone augmentation. The improved determination of disease extent aids in the management of breast conservation treatment. Certain lesions, particularly lobular carcinoma and ductal carcinoma in situ, can be better managed with the information available with breast MRI. Other potential indications are also discussed, including patients presenting with positive axillary nodes and no known primary, women with a high risk of malignancy, and recently postoperative breasts with positive margins. The need for MRI stereotaxis is reviewed, with indications and potential solutions. The potential future roles for MRI-directed interstitial hyperthermia are outlined.

Rupture of silicone-gel breast implants: causes, sequelae, and diagnosis

Silicone-gel-filled breast implants have been widely used for breast augmentation and reconstruction after mastectomy. The rate of implant rupture and its sequelae are not known. We review the frequency, causes, sequelae, and detection of implant rupture. Materials testing of removed implants provides evidence that as implants age in vivo, they weaken and may rupture. Sequelae of rupture include migration of gel accompanied by inflammation and silicone granuloma formation. The role of free silicone gel in relation to idiopathic or atypical connective tissue disease is not clear. Magnetic resonance imaging is substantially more sensitive in the detection of rupture than is mammography or ultrasonography.

MRI in breast cancer diagnosis and treatment

Breast cancer diagnosis and treatment are important health care issues in the Industrialized World. About 180,000 new breast cancers are discovered annually in the United States. Because this cancer often occurs in premenopausal women, breast cancer is a leading cause of potential life years lost. Breast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is capable of producing detailed information concerning the extent and character of breast lesions. The technique and alternatives for generating high-resolution breast MR images are reviewed. Characteristic features of a pulse sequence for breast imaging includes heavy T1 weighting and magnetization transfer weighting for more effective gadolinium contrast, fat suppression, and rapid acquisition time. MRI is best employed for breast cancer diagnosis as a supplement to conventional breast imaging. Diagnostic groups particularly well suited to breast MRI include women with radiographically dense breasts, silicone augmentation, and postoperative scar. The capacity of breast MRI to show disease extent is employed to plan and localize for breast-conservation therapy. Tumor size and multiple tumors can be characterized for more-effective surgical management. Ductal carcinoma in situ can be imaged and staged for tailored therapy. MRI-directed biopsy and localization can be used to optimize lumpectomy surgery and reduce the potential for histologically positive margins. MRI can define the effectiveness of radiation therapy and chemotherapy to provide improved information on nonsurgical treatment of breast cancer. The clinical implementation of breast MRI in the future depends on the careful coordination of quality MRI images and interpretations with skillful therapeutic management.

MR imaging of silicone breast implants: evaluation of prospective and retrospective interpretations and interobserver agreement

MR imaging was used to evaluate the integrity of silicone breast implants in 54 women with 108 implants. MR images were interpreted by relatively inexperienced readers who tried to reproduce the experiences reported in the literature. The study examines the interobserver agreement using different diagnostic signs and the influence of experience on interpretation errors. Prospective and retrospective interpretations were compared with surgical findings at the time of explanation. Diagnostic indicators, including the linguine sign, the inverted tear drop sign, the C sign, water droplets mixed with silicone, and extracapsular globules of silicone, were evaluated for diagnostic efficacy and interobserver agreement. The prospective sensitivity and specificity were 87% and 78%, respectively. With the retrospective interpretations, the sensitivity and specificity increased to 93% and 92%, respectively. Most of the prospective false-positive interpretations were due to misinterpreting radial folds as signs of implant rupture. Six implants interpreted retrospectively as false positives had gross amounts of silicone around the implants at surgery but there were no obvious rents in the implant shells. There was fair to excellent interobserver agreement with the individual diagnostic signs except for extracapsular globules of silicone. All of the signs had specificities of greater than 90%. The sensitivities of the individual signs were less than the overall retrospective sensitivity. With experience, the sensitivity improved from 87% to 93% and the specificity improved from 78% to 92%. This study helps substantiate the use of diagnostic signs used by other authors to detect silicone loss from breast implants by MR imaging; however, questions remain as to the clinical role of MR imaging in evaluating implants for silicone loss.

Residual silicone detection using MRI following previous breast implant removal: case reports

The current controversy surrounding the safety of silicone gel breast implants has resulted in an increasing number being removed. Although previous reports have suggested that remnants of the implant capsule are reabsorbed after explantation surgery, the persistence of the capsule in fact may be associated with implant fragments and silicone gel leakage. In this study we have used magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to identify residual silicone gel and silicone granulomas following the removal of silicone gel breast implants. Four representative clinical case reports are presented. These patients, who had residual silicone present in their bodies, presented to us with breast pain, palpable masses, or abnormal calcific mass densities apparent on a mammogram. High-resolution MRI images were found to be helpful in identifying local and remote collections of silicone gel, silicone granulomas, and residual capsules that were incompletely removed from previous explantation surgery. MRI breast images demonstrated high resolution and provided the accurate anatomical locations of residual silicone gel and silicone granulomas in all the regions of breast parenchyma, chest wall muscles, and axillae. Patients with persistent local symptoms following explantation surgery may benefit from an evaluation of the breast using MRI.

MRI of silicone vitreous ocular implants with phantom correlation

We imaged two patients who had silicone oil injected their vitreous cavities. The images demonstrated an increased chemical shift artifact. We developed and tested an in vitro silicone oil model in an attempt to explain this. To our knowledge, this artifact has not been previously described. We constructed a phantom using medication cups containing water, lard and two types of silicone. Background control baths of water and lard were used to simulate different local environments. The phantoms were imaged with T1-and T2-weighted and T1-weighted fat suppression sequences. The artifacts were due to the pronounced chemical shift of silicone in relation to intraconal fat. Our model accurately reproduced our clinical images. Spectral analysis of the silicone model revealed different resonating frequencies for fat/silicone, thereby explaining the pronounced chemical shift artifact.

Silicone-fat differentiation in the breast: exploiting the bright-fat phenomenon in fast spin-echo MR imaging

Selective suppression of silicone or fat with chemical shift-selective (CHESS) pulses is difficult because of the small chemical shift difference between the primary lipid signal and the primary silicone signal at 1.5 T. Differentiation of these chemically distinct species is, however, an important clinical task in assessing implant rupture and silicone migration in breast tissue. A method uniquely suited for silicone-fat differentiation with fast spin-echo (FSE) sequences is reported. It is based on the dependence of fat signal on echo spacing in FSE imaging and results show that it may provide a clinically robust method for silicone-fat differentiation in magnetic resonance imaging of the breast.