Detection of CT-proved pulmonary nodules: comparison of selenium-based digital and conventional screen-film chest radiographs

Visual assessment of calcification in solitary pulmonary nodules on chest radiography: correlation with volumetric quantification of calcification

PURPOSE

To assess the ability of digital chest radiography (CXR) to reveal calcification in solitary pulmonary nodules (SPNs), and to examine the correlation between a visual assessment and volumetric quantification of the calcification.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This study was a retrospective review of 220 SPNs identified by both CXR and chest CT. Eleven observers did blind review of the CXR images and scored nodule calcification on a confidence scale of 1 to 5. The area under the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curve (AUC) was obtained to analyze the diagnostic performance. The intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) for interrater reliability was calculated. The AUC and ICC were calculated according to the following nodule diameter groups: group 1 (< 10 mm), group 2 (≥ 10 mm and < 20 mm), and group 3 (≥ 20 mm).

RESULTS

Of the 220 SPNs, 145 SPNs (65.6%) were identified as non-calcified and 75 (34.4%) as calcified. The average percentage of calcification volume in SPN > 160 HU (Vol160HU) among the 75 calcified nodules was 47.5%. The mean Vol160HU of the 68 SPNs classified as having definite calcification was 51.1%. The overall AUC was 0.71. The AUCs for groups 1, 2, and 3 was 0.835, 0.639, and 0.620, respectively. The ICCs for groups 1, 2, 3 was 0.65, 0.48, and 0.33, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The overall diagnostic performance of digital CXR to predict calcification in SPNs was moderately accurate and the diagnostic performance for predicting calcification in SPNs was significantly higher, and interobserver reproducibility was good when SPN < 10 mm compared with ≥ 10 mm in diameter.

KEY POINTS

• The misdiagnosis of a non-calcified nodule as a calcified one by CXR could lead to poor management choices for the SPN. • The diagnostic performance of CXR in predicting calcification was best for nodules < 10 mm in diameter. SPNs with calcification of approximately 50% of their volume tend to be considered calcified. • The diagnostic performance of CXR in identifying calcification was low for nodules ≥ 10 mm in diameter; therefore, we should carefully evaluate calcification carefully for nodules ≥ 10 mm.

Tissue factor-specific ultra-bright SERRS nanostars for Raman detection of pulmonary micrometastases

Here we demonstrate a novel application of 'surface enhanced resonance Raman scattering nanoparticles' (SERRS NPs) for imaging breast cancer lung metastases with much higher precision than currently feasible. A breast cancer lung metastasis mouse model was established by intravenous injection of LM2 cells. These mice were intravenously administered SERRS NPs conjugated with ALT-836, an anti-tissue factor (TF) monoclonal antibody, and subjected to Raman imaging to visualize the expression of TF both in vivo and ex vivo. Raman imaging indicated marked uptake of αTF-SERRS-NPs by the lung metastases compared to isotype and blocking controls. Conversely, little uptake of αTF-SERRS-NPs was observed in the lungs of healthy mice. Successful detection and delineation of pulmonary micrometastatic lesions as small as 200 μm, corroborated by histology, immunohistochemistry, and bioluminescence imaging confirmed the suitability of both TF as a target and αTF-SERRS-NPs as an effective contrast agent for imaging breast cancer lung metastases. Further advancements of this technique in the form of Raman endoscopes coupled with ultrabright SERRS NPs developed in this work could lead to minimally invasive detection and resection of lung metastases.

A comparison of computed tomography, computed radiography, and film-screen radiography for the detection of canine pulmonary nodules

Computed tomography (CT) has become more widely available and computed radiography (CR) has replaced film-screen radiography for canine thoracic imaging in many veterinary practices. There are limited data comparing these modalities in a veterinary clinical setting to detect pulmonary nodules. We compared CT, CR, and film-screen radiography for detecting the presence, number, and characteristics of pulmonary nodules in dogs. Observer performance for a variety of experience levels was also evaluated. Twenty-one client-owned dogs with a primary neoplastic process underwent CT and CR; nine also received film-screen radiographs. Positive/negative classification by consensus agreed between the three modalities in 8/9 dogs and between CR and CT in the remaining 12. CT detected the greatest (P = 0.002) total number of nodules and no difference was seen between CR and films. The greatest number of nodules was seen in the right middle and both caudal regions, but only using CT (P < 0.0001). Significantly smaller nodules were detected with CT (P = 0.0007) and no difference in minimum size was detected between CR and films. Observer accuracy was high for all modalities; particularly for CT (90.5-100%) and for the senior radiologist (90.5-100%). CT was also characterized by the least interobserver variability. Although CT, CR, and film-screen performed similarly in determining the presence or absence of pulmonary nodules, a greater number of smaller nodules was detected with CT, and CT was associated with greater diagnostic confidence and observer accuracy and agreement.

Improved detection of subtle lung nodules by use of chest radiographs with bone suppression imaging: receiver operating characteristic analysis with and without localization

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this article is to evaluate radiologists' ability to detect subtle nodules by use of standard chest radiographs alone compared with bone suppression imaging used together with standard radiographs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The cases used in this observer study comprised radiographs of 72 patients with a subtle nodule and 79 patients without nodules taken from the Japanese Society of Radiological Technology nodule database. A new image-processing system was applied to the 151 radiographs to create corresponding bone suppression images. Two image reading sets were used with an independent test method. The first reading included half of the patients (a randomly selected subset A) showing only the standard image and the remaining half (subset B) showing the standard image plus bone suppression images. The second reading entailed the same subsets; however, subset A was accompanied by bone suppression images, whereas subset B was shown with only the standard image. The two image sets were read by three experienced radiologists, with an interval of more than 2 weeks between the sessions. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves, with and without localization, were obtained to evaluate the observers' performance.

RESULTS

The mean value of the area under the ROC curve for the three observers was significantly improved, from 0.840 with standard radiographs alone to 0.863 with additional bone suppression images (p = 0.01). The area under the localization ROC curve was also improved with bone suppression imaging.

CONCLUSION

The use of bone suppression images improved radiologists' performance in the detection of subtle nodules on chest radiographs.

The usefulness of three-dimensional angiography with a flat panel detector of direct conversion type in a transcatheter arterial chemoembolization procedure for hepatocellular carcinoma: initial experience

The purpose of this study was to assess the usefulness of a three-dimensional (3D) angiography system using a flat panel detector of direct conversion type in treatments with subsegmental transcatheter arterial chemoembolization (TACE) for hepatocellular carcinomas (HCCs). Thirty-six consecutive patients who underwent hepatic angiography were prospectively examined. First, two radiologists evaluated the degree of visualization of the peripheral branches of the hepatic arteries on 3D digital subtraction angiography (DSA). Then the radiologists evaluated the visualization of tumor staining and feeding arteries in 25 patients (30 HCCs) who underwent subsegmental TACE. The two radiologists who performed the TACE assessed whether the additional information provided by 3D DSA was useful for treatments. In 34 (94.4%) of 36 patients, the subsegmental branches of the hepatic arteries were sufficiently visualized. The feeding arteries of HCCs were sufficiently visualized in 28 (93%) of 30 HCCs, whereas tumor stains were sufficiently visualized in 18 (60%). Maximum intensity projection images were significantly superior to volume recording images for visualization of the tumor staining and feeding arteries of HCCs. In 27 (90%) of 30 HCCs, 3D DSA provided additional useful information for subsegmental TACE. The high-quality 3D DSA with flat panel detector angiography system provided a precise vascular road map, which was useful for performing subsegmental TACE of HCCs.

Improved detection of small lung cancers with dual-energy subtraction chest radiography

OBJECTIVE

The objective of our study was to retrospectively evaluate whether the use of dual-energy subtraction chest radiographs can improve radiologists' performance for the detection of small previously missed lung cancers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Dual-energy subtraction chest radiographs of 19 patients with previously missed nodular cancers, in which the radiology report did not mention a nodule that was visible in retrospect, were selected. Dual-energy subtraction radiographs of 19 patients with cancer and 16 patients without cancer were used for an observer study. Six radiologists indicated their confidence level regarding the presence of a lung cancer and, if they thought a cancer was present, also marked the most likely position for each lung, first using standard posteroanterior and lateral chest radiographs and then using both soft-tissue and bone dual-energy subtraction images along with standard radiographs. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were used to evaluate the observers' performance. The indicated locations of cancers and false-positives were also analyzed.

RESULTS

The average area under the ROC curve (A(z)) value for the six radiologists was improved from 0.718 to 0.816, a statistically significant amount (p = 0.004), and the average sensitivity (correct localizations) for 19 previously missed cancers was also significantly improved from 40% to 59% (p = 0.008) with the aid of dual-energy subtraction images. The average number of false-positive (incorrect) localizations on 70 lungs was 10 without and nine with dual-energy subtraction images (p = 0.785).

CONCLUSION

Dual-energy subtraction chest radiography has the potential to improve radiologists' performance for the detection of small missed lung cancers.

A flat-panel detector digital radiography and a storage phosphor computed radiography: screening for pneumoconioses

Storage phosphor computed radiography (SR) and flat-panel detector (FPD) radiography are two types of digital X-ray utilizing different techniques. We compared these two techniques with conventional analogue chest radiograph (AR) among pneumoconiotic patients and healthy controls. Thirty individuals consisting of 20 silica-exposed ex-workers and 10 healthy controls without occupational exposure to any mineral dust were examined with chest X-ray by AR, SR and FPD. Three occupational physicians, including one NIOSH B reader, assessed the digital and conventional radiographs by the side-by-side method according to the ILO 2000 International Classification of Radiograph of Pneumoconioses (ILO/ICRP). No significant difference was shown between the subjective film qualities by AR and FPD. Inter-reader agreement of the profusion of small opacities on radiographs was high in the order of SR (kappa=0.64), FPD (kappa=0.62), and AR (kappa=0.55). The profusions of small opacity for AR and FPD by the 12-point scaled profusion of ILO/ICRP did not show a statistically significant difference, but those for AR and SR showed a significant difference. The areas under the receiver operator curves (ROC) using clinical diagnosis by a pulmonologist as the reference showed no statistically significant difference among the three radiographic techniques. FPD gives image quality as good as that of AR, and it has acceptable agreement with AR in small profusion categories, which consequently assures its application to pneumoconiosis screening. SR showed less profusion than FPD and AR, which can be fixed with image modification.

COMPARISON OF TWO- VS. THREE-VIEW THORACIC RADIOGRAPHIC STUDIES ON CONSPICUITY OF STRUCTURED INTERSTITIAL PATTERNS IN DOGS

Three-view thoracic radiography is often used to evaluate patients for pulmonary metastatic disease. Although use of three views has been reported to be more sensitive than two views for focal lung disease, it also requires increased time, effort, and radiographic exposure of patients and personnel. This study was performed to evaluate the conspicuity of lesions on two-view vs. three-view radiographic procedures to determine the proportion of diagnoses that would change. One hundred three-view radiographic studies of the canine thorax were randomized, and four protocols were reviewed for each study: right lateral and ventrodorsal views, left lateral and ventrodorsal views, both lateral views, and all three views. Radiographs were interpreted as either positive or negative for structured interstitial pulmonary disease, and the certainty of the reading was recorded using a visual analog scale. There was 85-88% agreement between each two-view group and the three-view group, with the kapp statistic ranging from 0.698 to 0.758. There were no differences in certainty of diagnosis among the groups, though within each group there was more certainty for positive diagnoses than negative diagnoses. These findings indicate that three-view studies should be continued when evaluating for possible structured interstitial pulmonary disease, including metastatic disease, as eliminating one view from a three-view study would change the diagnosis in 12-15% of patients.

Pulmonary nodule detection with digital projection radiography: an ex-vivo study on increased latitude post-processing

To evaluate increased image latitude post-processing of digital projection radiograms for the detection of pulmonary nodules. 20 porcine lungs were inflated inside a chest phantom, prepared with 280 solid nodules of 4-8 mm in diameter and examined with direct radiography (3.0x2.5 k detector, 125 kVp, 4 mAs). Nodule position and size were documented by CT controls and dissection. Four intact lungs served as negative controls. Image post-processing included standard tone scales and increased latitude with detail contrast enhancement (log-factors 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0). 1280 sub-images (512x512 pixel) were centred on nodules or controls, behind the diaphragm and over free parenchyma, randomized and presented to six readers. Confidence in the decision was recorded with a scale of 0-100%. Sensitivity and specificity for nodules behind the diaphragm were 0.87/0.97 at standard tone scale and 0.92/0.92 with increased latitude (log factor 2.0). The fraction of "not diagnostic" readings was reduced (from 208/1920 to 52/1920). As an indicator of increased detection confidence, the median of the ratings behind the diaphragm approached 100 and 0, respectively, and the inter-quartile width decreased (controls: p<0.001, nodules: p=0.239) at higher image latitude. Above the diaphragm, accuracy and detection confidence remained unchanged. Here, the sensitivity for nodules was 0.94 with a specificity from 0.96 to 0.97 (all p>0.05). Increased latitude post-processing has minimal effects on the overall accuracy, but improves the detection confidence for sub-centimeter nodules in the posterior recesses of the lung.

Detection of Small Pulmonary Nodules Using Direct Digital Radiography and Picture Archiving and Communication Systems

PURPOSE

To evaluate the detection of small pulmonary nodules, in the diameter range of 5.4 to 15 mm, using direct digital chest imaging and soft copy interpretation on picture archiving and communication systems.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The results of clinical computed tomography (CT) scans of the thorax were retrospectively reviewed from our radiology information system and picture archiving and communication systems archives. Patients with CT studies containing between 1 and 6 nodules, who also had a digital chest examination within 1 month of the CT scan were selected. Thirty patients with suitable nodules and 30 without nodules were included and form the data base for this study. The nodules were between 5.4 and 15 mm in average diameter. Four separate observers independently viewed the frontal and lateral chest studies of the 60 patients. The presence or absence of nodules was determined. Data were analyzed with Kappa, McNemar and Fischer exact tests for agreement and differences between observers, nodule size, and nodule zone.

RESULTS

A total of 42 nodules between 5.4 and 15 mm were present. The overall detection rate for the 4 observers was 41.7%. For nodules between 5.4 and 8 mm the detection rate was 26.2%. Agreement between observer's detection was poor to moderate. Differences between observers for both nodule size and zone were not significant. Only 1 observer had a relationship between nodule detection and nodule size.

CONCLUSIONS

Observer detection of pulmonary nodules in the range of 5 to 15 mm using current digital radiography systems is not reliable in the confusing environment of the lung. Additional modification of these systems is required to increase nodule conspicuity.

Chest radiography with a digital flat-panel detector: experimental receiver operating characteristic analysis

PURPOSE

To evaluate the influence of different detector radiation doses and peak kilovoltage settings on diagnostic performance and radiation dose at posteroanterior (PA) chest radiography performed with an amorphous silicon flat-panel detector (FPD).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All examinations were performed by using a digital FPD. PA chest radiographs of an anthropomorphic chest phantom were obtained with detector radiation doses of 2.50 microGy (system speed, 400), 1.56 microGy (speed, 640), and 1.25 microGy (speed, 800) and with peak kilovoltage values of 100, 120, and 140 kVp. Four types of simulated lesions-nodules of different sizes, polylobulated lesions, interstitial-nodular lesions, and interstitial-reticular lesions-were superimposed on the phantom. After four radiologists assessed all of the images, receiver operating characteristics analysis was performed. In addition, the entrance surface dose was measured and the effective dose was calculated.

RESULTS

Reduced detector dose led to significantly decreased diagnostic performance in overall lesion detection (P <.05). However, over pulmonary areas only, this effect could not be seen. With use of the same kilovoltage values, reducing the detector dose, even to 1.25 microGy (speed, 800), did not lead to significantly decreased lesion detectability. In terms of diagnostic performance and effective dose, 120 kVp was the most effective.

CONCLUSION

Standard PA chest radiographs should still be acquired at a detector dose of 2.50 microGy (speed, 400) with 120 kVp to yield the highest diagnostic performance. However, when the present analysis was focused on the lung fields only, no significant loss in diagnostic performance could be demonstrated, even after a 50% reduction in radiation dose.

The imaging manifestations of lung cancer

Imaging plays an integral role in diagnosing, staging, and following patients with lung cancer. Many lung neoplasms are detected on chest radiographs, but the majority of patients have advanced stage disease at the time of presentation. There is a wide spectrum of radiologic manifestations of lung cancer, and recognition of these findings is essential for patient management. As we continue to understand more about tumor biology, new imaging techniques likely will emerge. Nevertheless, the chest radiograph and CT remain important tools in establishing the diagnosis of lung cancer.

State-of-the-art screening for lung cancer (part 1): the chest radiograph

The chest radiographic methods used in prior studies of lung cancer screening and in current prospective clinical trials of lung cancer screening do not incorporate, as part of their prospective design, the newer methods available for the detection of lung nodules. DR, image processing, ES, and CAD have been shown to enhance lung nodule detection. TS is a promising method but with less supporting data currently available. These techniques, alone or in combination, do not equal the nodule detection capability of lung CT, but they are likely to benefit patients having CXRs for other clinically indicated purposes and when the detection of a nodule is incidental to the clinical indication for the radiographic study.

Detection of pulmonary edema in pigs: storage phosphor versus amorphous selenium-based flat-panel-detector radiography

PURPOSE

To compare diagnostic accuracy of soft-copy selenium-based digital radiographic images and soft-copy computed radiographic images obtained for detection of pulmonary edema in pigs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Oleic acid was injected intraatrially into three pigs (weight, 20-25 kg) at doses of 0.04, 0.05, and 0.06 mL/kg to induce pulmonary edema. Thirty-seven sets of computed radiographic, digital radiographic, and thin-section computed tomographic (CT) scans were obtained every 20-30 minutes in three pigs over 4-6 hours. Images were masked for identity, randomly sorted, and displayed on a monitor. Four radiologists rated each image for presence of parenchymal opacities by using a dichotomous scoring system in two sessions. Presence of pulmonary edema was determined with thin-section CT and a severity scale. Intra- and interobserver variations were determined with the kappa statistic and the Z test and with the Cochran Q test and the McNemar test, respectively. True-positive, true-negative, false-positive, and false-negative rates were determined. McNemar test was used to determine statistical significance of differences in detection between computed and digital radiographic images.

RESULTS

There was no significant intra- or interobserver variation, except for one pair of observers during the first interpretative session with computed radiographic images (P =.016, McNemar test). Overall sensitivity (92.1%) and diagnostic accuracy (90.2%) of digital radiography were significantly higher than those of computed radiography (79.6% and 83.4%, respectively) (P <.001 for sensitivity, P =.01 for diagnostic accuracy, McNemar test). In detection of minimal and mild pulmonary edema, sensitivity of digital radiography (84%) was significantly higher than that of computed radiography (58%) (P <.001).

CONCLUSION

Soft-copy digital radiographic images are superior to soft-copy computed radiographic images obtained for detection of mild pulmonary edema in pigs.

Selenium-based digital radiography versus high-resolution storage phosphor radiography in the detection of solitary pulmonary nodules without calcification: receiver operating characteristic curve analysis

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to compare selenium-based digital radiography with high-resolution storage phosphor radiography for the detection of solitary pulmonary nodules without calcification.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-four patients underwent selenium-based digital radiography, high-resolution storage phosphor radiography, and chest CT for evaluation of pulmonary nodules. Thirty-one patients with pulmonary nodules smaller than 3 cm in diameter and 40 patients with normal lungs were selected for receiver operating characteristic curve analysis. Five board-certified radiologists who were unaware of the CT results independently reviewed each of the hard copies of selenium-based digital radiography and storage phosphor radiography, identified pulmonary nodules, and graded their confidence for the presence of each nodule. For each radiologist, we calculated the areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) for selenium-based digital radiography and storage phosphor radiography.

RESULTS

The average performance of selenium-based digital radiography (AUC = 0.72) was higher than that of high-resolution storage phosphor radiography (AUC = 0.64), which is statistically significant (p <0.05).

CONCLUSION

Our results indicate that selenium-based digital radiography is superior to high-resolution storage phosphor radiography for detecting solitary pulmonary nodules without calcification.

Digital chest radiography with a selenium-based flat-panel detector versus a storage phosphor system: comparison of soft-copy images

OBJECTIVE

We compared the soft-copy images produced by a digital chest radiography system that uses a flat-panel X-ray detector based on amorphous selenium with images produced by a storage phosphor radiography system for the visualization of anatomic regions of the chest.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two chest radiologists and two residents analyzed 46 pairs of posteroanterior chest radiographs on high-resolution video monitors (2560 x 2048 x 8 bits). In each pair, one radiograph was obtained with a storage phosphor radiography system, and the other radiograph was obtained with a selenium-based flat-panel detector radiography system. Each pair of radiographs was obtained at the same exposure settings. The interpreter rated the visibility and radiographic quality of 11 different anatomic regions. Each pair of images was ranked on a five-point scale (1 = prefer image A, 3 = no preference, 5 = prefer image B) for preference of technique. Statistical significance of preference was determined using the Wilcoxon's signed rank test.

RESULTS

The interpreters had a statistically significant preference for the selenium-based radiography system in six (unobscured lung, hilum, rib, minor fissure, heart border, and overall appearance) of 11 anatomic regions (p<0.001) and for the storage phosphor system in two regions (proximal airway and thoracic spine) (p<0.05). Chest radiologists strongly preferred selenium-based images in eight regions, and they did not prefer storage phosphor images in any region.

CONCLUSION

The soft-copy images produced by the selenium-based radiography system were perceived as equal or superior to those produced by the storage phosphor system in most but not all anatomic regions.

Small nodules detected on chest radiography: does size predict calcification?

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To determine whether the likelihood of lung nodule calcification can be predicted from nodule size as measured on a chest radiograph (CXR).

DESIGN

Retrospective review of CXRs of patients with lung nodules < or =1 cm in size detected on CT scanning. CT images were used to identify calcifications and to provide spatial localization for readers to visualize nodules on a CXR and to measure their size. A subset of these nodules then was reexamined by different readers who did not view the CT scans

SETTING

Two university hospitals (Albuquerque, NM; Dallas, TX) and a US Air Force/Veterans Administration medical center (Albuquerque, NM).

PATIENTS

Two hundred thirty-six nodules in 185 patients

RESULTS

One half of the nodules (118) seen on CT scans could not be located on CXR, of which 8 (7%) were calcified. The prevalence of calcifications in the other 118 nodules visualized on CXRs was much higher (71 of 118 nodules [60%]; p<0.005). Among the nodules visualized on CXRs, those < 7 mm in diameter (44 of 57 nodules [77%]) were more likely to be calcified than those > or = 7 mm in diameter (27 of 61 nodules [44%]; p<0.005). Radiographs of 42 of the smallest nodules visualized on CXRs by the initial readers later were examined prospectively by different readers who did not have access to the CT images. Thirty of 33 of the calcified nodules (91%) but only 3 of 9 of the noncalcified nodules (33%) were detected (p<0.005). These readers also recorded 40 additional small nodules that were not seen on CT scans, which were considered to be false-positives.

CONCLUSIONS

Nodules detected on CXRs that measure <7 mm in size are likely to be calcified or to represent a false-positive finding.

Assessment of visually lossless irreversible image compression: comparison of three methods by using an image-comparison workstation

PURPOSE

To determine the degree of irreversible image compression detectable in conservative viewing conditions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

An image-comparison workstation, which alternately displayed two registered and magnified versions of an image, was used to study observer detection of image degradation introduced by irreversible compression. Five observers evaluated 20 16-bit posteroanterior digital chest radiographs compressed with Joint Photographic Experts Group (JPEG) or wavelet-based trellis-coded quantization (WTCQ) algorithms at compression ratios of 8:1-128:1 and x2 magnification by using (a) traditional two-alternative forced choice; (b) original-revealed two-alternative forced choice, in which the noncompressed image is identified to the observer; and (c) a resolution-metric method of matching test images to degraded reference images.

RESULTS

The visually lossless threshold was between 8:1 and 16:1 for four observers. JPEG compression resulted in performance as good as that with WTCQ compression at these ratios. The original-revealed forced-choice method was faster and as sensitive as the two-alternative forced-choice method. The resolution-metric results were robust and provided information on performance above visually lossless levels.

CONCLUSION

The image-comparison workstation is a versatile tool for comparative assessment of image quality. At x2 magnification, images compressed with either JPEG or WTCQ algorithms were indistinguishable from unaltered original images for most observers at compression ratios between 8:1 and 16:1, indicating that 10:1 compression is acceptable for primary image interpretation.

Digital radiography versus conventional radiography in chest imaging: diagnostic performance of a large-area silicon flat-panel detector in a clinical CT-controlled study

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to compare the diagnostic performance of a digital large-area silicon flat-panel detector with that of a conventional screen-film system in clinical chest imaging using abnormal findings documented by CT as the reference standard.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Eighty patients (46 men and 34 women; age range,18-91 years; mean age, 63 years) who underwent CT of the chest were examined with the new digital radiography system, which is based on a 43 x 43 cm silicon flat-panel detector, and with a conventional screen-film system, which is used routinely in clinical practice. Posteroanterior and lateral radiographs were obtained. Four radiologists analyzed the digital and conventional images separately for chest abnormalities and rated the images using a five-level scale of confidence; CT was used as the reference standard. Diagnostic value was assessed using receiver operating characteristic curves for each abnormality.

RESULTS

No significant differences were found between the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve of the digital and that of the conventional radiography method for almost all investigated criteria. The only exception was mediastinal abnormalities, for which the digital method provided better results than the conventional method (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The diagnostic performance of the new large-area silicon flat-panel detector is equivalent or superior to that of the conventional screen-film system for clinical chest imaging and can replace conventional radiography systems. This new technology offers transmission and storage possibilities inherent to digital radiology that would facilitate daily practice and reduce the initial high costs in the long-term.