Renal sympathetic nerve regulation to heating is altered in rats with heart failure

Kidney physiology and pathophysiology during heat stress and the modification by exercise, dehydration, heat acclimation and aging

The kidneys' integrative responses to heat stress aid thermoregulation, cardiovascular control, and water and electrolyte regulation. Recent evidence suggests the kidneys are at increased risk of pathological events during heat stress, namely acute kidney injury (AKI), and that this risk is compounded by dehydration and exercise. This heat stress related AKI is believed to contribute to the epidemic of chronic kidney disease (CKD) occurring in occupational settings. It is estimated that AKI and CKD affect upwards of 45 million individuals in the global workforce. Water and electrolyte disturbances and AKI, both of which are representative of kidney-related pathology, are the two leading causes of hospitalizations during heat waves in older adults. Structural and physiological alterations in aging kidneys likely contribute to this increased risk. With this background, this comprehensive narrative review will provide the first aggregation of research into the integrative physiological response of the kidneys to heat stress. While the focus of this review is on the human kidneys, we will utilize both human and animal data to describe these responses to passive and exercise heat stress, and how they are altered with heat acclimation. Additionally, we will discuss recent studies that indicate an increased risk of AKI due to exercise in the heat. Lastly, we will introduce the emerging public health crisis of older adults during extreme heat events and how the aging kidneys may be more susceptible to injury during heat stress.

Muscle sympathetic nerve activity response to heat stress is attenuated in chronic heart failure patients

Heat stress evokes significant increases in muscle sympathetic nerve activity (MSNA) in healthy individuals. The MSNA response to heat stress in chronic heart failure (CHF) is unknown. We hypothesized that the MSNA response to heat stress is attenuated in CHF. Passive whole body heating was applied with water-perfused suits in 13 patients (61 ± 2 yr) with stable class II-III CHF, 12 age-matched (62 ± 2 yr) healthy subjects, and 14 young (24 ± 1 yr) healthy subjects. Mild heating (i.e., increases in skin temperature ΔTsk ~2-4°C, internal temperature ΔTcore <0.3°C) significantly decreased MSNA in CHF patients; however, it did not significantly alter the MSNA in the age-matched and young healthy subjects. Heat stress (i.e., ΔTsk ~4°C and ΔTcore ~0.6°C) raised MSNA in the age-matched (32.9 ± 3.2 to 45.6 ± 4.2 bursts/min; P < 0.001) and young (14.3 ± 1.7 to 26.3 ± 2.4 bursts/min; P < 0.001) controls, but not in CHF (46.2 ± 5.3 to 50.5 ± 5.3 bursts/min; P = 0.06). The MSNA increase by the heat stress in CHF (Δ4.2 ± 2.0 bursts/min) was significantly less than those seen in the age-matched (Δ12.8 ± 1.7 bursts/min, P < 0.05) and young (Δ12.0 ± 2.7 bursts/min, P < 0.05) control groups. These data suggest that the MSNA response to heat stress is attenuated in CHF patients. We speculate that the attenuated MSNA response to heat stress may contribute to impaired cardiovascular adjustments in CHF in a hot environment.

Renal sympathetic nerve, blood flow, and epithelial transport responses to thermal stress

Thermal stress is a profound sympathetic stress in humans; kidney responses involve altered renal sympathetic nerve activity (RSNA), renal blood flow, and renal epithelial transport. During mild cold stress, RSNA spectral power but not total activity is altered, renal blood flow is maintained or decreased, and epithelial transport is altered consistent with a sympathetic stress coupled with central volume loaded state. Hypothermia decreases RSNA, renal blood flow, and epithelial transport. During mild heat stress, RSNA is increased, renal blood flow is decreased, and epithelial transport is increased consistent with a sympathetic stress coupled with a central volume unloaded state. Hyperthermia extends these directional changes, until heat illness results. Because kidney responses are very difficult to study in humans in vivo, this review describes and qualitatively evaluates an in vivo human skin model of sympathetically regulated epithelial tissue compared to that of the nephron. This model utilizes skin responses to thermal stress, involving 1) increased skin sympathetic nerve activity (SSNA), decreased skin blood flow, and suppressed eccrine epithelial transport during cold stress; and 2) increased SSNA, skin blood flow, and eccrine epithelial transport during heat stress. This model appears to mimic aspects of the renal responses. Investigations of skin responses, which parallel certain renal responses, may aid understanding of epithelial-sympathetic nervous system interactions during cold and heat stress.

Autonomic nervous system and immune system interactions

The present review assesses the current state of literature defining integrative autonomic-immune physiological processing, focusing on studies that have employed electrophysiological, pharmacological, molecular biological, and central nervous system experimental approaches. Central autonomic neural networks are informed of peripheral immune status via numerous communicating pathways, including neural and non-neural. Cytokines and other immune factors affect the level of activity and responsivity of discharges in sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves innervating diverse targets. Multiple levels of the neuraxis contribute to cytokine-induced changes in efferent parasympathetic and sympathetic nerve outflows, leading to modulation of peripheral immune responses. The functionality of local sympathoimmune interactions depends on the microenvironment created by diverse signaling mechanisms involving integration between sympathetic nervous system neurotransmitters and neuromodulators; specific adrenergic receptors; and the presence or absence of immune cells, cytokines, and bacteria. Functional mechanisms contributing to the cholinergic anti-inflammatory pathway likely involve novel cholinergic-adrenergic interactions at peripheral sites, including autonomic ganglion and lymphoid targets. Immune cells express adrenergic and nicotinic receptors. Neurotransmitters released by sympathetic and parasympathetic nerve endings bind to their respective receptors located on the surface of immune cells and initiate immune-modulatory responses. Both sympathetic and parasympathetic arms of the autonomic nervous system are instrumental in orchestrating neuroimmune processes, although additional studies are required to understand dynamic and complex adrenergic-cholinergic interactions. Further understanding of regulatory mechanisms linking the sympathetic nervous, parasympathetic nervous, and immune systems is critical for understanding relationships between chronic disease development and immune-associated changes in autonomic nervous system function.

Medullary regulation of visceral sympathetic nerve discharge at peak hyperthermia in aged F344 rats

Heat stress provides a potent stimulus for the activation of visceral sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) in young but not aged rats. Central mechanisms mediating attenuated SND responses to heating in aged rats have not been investigated. Because the GABAergic system in the rostral ventral lateral medulla (RVLM) is tonically inhibitory to SND, it is plausible to hypothesize that the withdrawal of RVLM GABA tone as a strategy to activate renal SND to heating is not engaged to the same degree in aged compared with young rats. The effect of bilateral RVLM disinhibition produced by bicuculline (BIC, GABA(A) receptor antagonist, 100 pmol) microinjections on renal SND in anesthetized young (3-6 months old) and aged (22-24 months old) Fischer 344 rats was determined after core body temperature (Tc) had been increased to 41.5 °C. Renal SND at 41.5 °C was significantly increased from control levels in young but not aged rats, whereas RVLM BIC microinjections at 41.5 °C produced marked renal sympathoexcitation in both groups. RVLM BIC microinjections at 38 °C in young and aged rats increased renal SND to similar levels as produced by RVLM BIC microinjections at 41.5 °C. The enhanced heating-induced renal sympathoactivation in young compared with aged rats; coupled with marked RVLM BIC-induced SND excitation under hyperthermic and normothermic conditions in both young and aged rats, suggests age-dependent changes in the withdrawal of RVLM GABA tone as a strategy to activate renal SND in response to acute heating.

Disinhibition of RVLM neural circuits and regulation of sympathetic nerve discharge at peak hyperthermia

Hyperthermia is a potent activator of visceral sympathetic nerve discharge (SND), and the functional integrity of the rostral ventral lateral medulla (RVLM) is critically important for sustaining sympathoexcitation at peak hyperthermia. However, RVLM mechanisms mediating SND activation to acute heat stress are not well understood. Because RVLM GABA is tonically inhibitory to sympathetic nerve outflow, it is plausible to hypothesize that disinhibition of RVLM sympathetic neural circuits, via withdrawal of GABAergic tone, may affect SND regulation at peak hyperthermia. The effect of RVLM bicuculline (BIC; GABAA receptor antagonist, 100-200 pmol) microinjections on the level of renal SND in anesthetized rats was determined after internal body temperature (Tc) had been increased to 41.5°C. Temperature-control experiments involved RVLM BIC (100-200 pmol) microinjections, with Tc maintained at 38°C. As expected, acute heating significantly increased renal SND from control levels. Bilateral RVLM BIC microinjections at 41.5°C produced immediate and significant increases in renal SND above heating-induced levels of activation. Bilateral RVLM BIC microinjections at 38°C increased renal SND to similar levels as produced by RVLM BIC microinjections after Tc had been increased to 41.5°C (heating + RVLM BIC). These results demonstrate that a considerable level of RVLM GABAergic inhibition is sustained at peak hyperthermia, an interesting physiological response profile based on the significance of SND activation to cardiovascular regulation during heat stress.

Is visceral sympathoexcitation to heat stress dependent on activation of ionotropic excitatory amino acid receptors in the rostral ventrolateral medulla?

Acute heat stress activates visceral sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) in young rats, and the functional integrity of the rostral ventrolateral medulla (RVLM) is required for sustaining visceral sympathoexcitation during peak increases in internal body temperature (T(c)). However, RVLM mechanisms mediating SND activation to hyperthermia remain unknown. In the present study, we investigated the role of RVLM ionotropic excitatory amino acid receptors in mediating visceral SND activation to heat stress in anesthetized, young rats. The effects of bilateral RVLM kynurenic acid (Kyn; 2.7 and 5.4 nmol), saline, or muscimol (400-800 pmol) microinjections on renal SND and splenic SND responses to heat stress were determined at peak hyperthermia (T(c) 41.5°C), during progressive hyperthermia (T(c) 40°C), and at the initiation of heating (T(c) increased from 38 to 38.5°C). RVLM Kyn microinjections did not reduce renal and splenic SND recorded during progressive or peak hyperthermia and did not attenuate SND activation at the initiation of heating. In fact, renal and splenic SND tended to be or were significantly increased following RVLM Kyn microinjections at the initiation of heating and during hyperthermia (40 and 41.5°C). RVLM muscimol microinjections at 39, 40, and 41.5°C resulted in immediate reductions in SND. These data indicate that RVLM ionotropic glutamate receptors are required for mediating visceral sympathoexcitation to acute heating and suggest that acute heating activates an RVLM ionotropic excitatory amino acid receptor dependent inhibitory input, which reduces the level of visceral SND to heating.

Effects of combined aging and heart failure on visceral sympathetic nerve and cardiovascular responses to progressive hyperthermia in F344 rats

Sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) responses to hyperthermia are attenuated in aged rats without heart failure (HF) and in young HF (Y(HF)) rats, demonstrating that individually aging and HF alter SND regulation. However, the combined effects of aging and HF on SND regulation to heat stress are unknown, despite the high prevalence of HF in aged individuals. We hypothesized that SND responses to heating would be additive when aging and HF are combined, demonstrated by marked reductions in SND and mean arterial pressure (MAP) responses to heating in aged HF (A(HF)) compared with aged sham HF (A(SHAM)) rats, and in A(HF) compared with Y(HF) rats. Renal and splenic SND responses to hyperthermia (colonic temperature increased to 41.5°C) were determined in anesthetized Y(HF), young sham (Y(SHAM)), A(HF), and A(SHAM) Fischer rats. HF was induced by myocardial infarction and documented using echocardiographic, invasive, and postmortem measures. The severity of HF was similar in Y(HF) and A(HF) rats. SND responses to heating were attenuated in Y(HF) compared with Y(SHAM) rats, demonstrating an effect of HF on SND regulation in young rats. In contrast, A(HF) and A(SHAM) rats demonstrated similar SND responses to heating, suggesting a prominent influence of age on SND regulation in A(HF) rats. Splenic SND and MAP responses to heating were similar in Y(HF), A(HF), and A(SHAM) rats, indicating that the imposition of HF in young rats changes the regulatory status of these variables to one consistent with aged rats. These data suggest that the effect of HF on SND regulation to hyperthermia is age dependent.

Animal aging and regulation of sympathetic nerve discharge

Studies completed in human subjects have made seminal contributions to understanding the effects of age on sympathetic nervous system (SNS) regulation. Numerous experimental constraints limit the design of studies involving human subjects; therefore, completion of studies in animal models of aging would be expected to provide additional insight regarding mechanisms mediating age-related changes in sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) regulation. The present review assesses the current state of the literature regarding contributions from animal studies on the effects of advancing age on SND regulation, focusing primarily on studies that have used direct recordings of sympathetic nerve outflow. Few studies using direct SND recordings have been completed in animal models of aging, regardless of the fundamental component of SND regulation reviewed (basal levels, acute responsiveness, relationships between the discharges in sympathetic nerves, central neural regulation). SNS responsiveness to various acute stressors is altered in aged compared with young animals; however, mechanisms remain virtually unexplored. There is a marked dearth of studies that have used central neural microinjection techniques in conjunction with SND recordings in aged animals, making it difficult to develop an evidence-based framework regarding potential age-associated effects on central regulation of SND. Determination of age-related changes in mechanisms regulating SND is important for understanding relationships between chronic disease development and changes in SNS function; however, this can only be achieved by substantially extending the current knowledge base regarding the effects of age on SND regulation in animal studies.

Role of the hypothalamic PVN in the regulation of renal sympathetic nerve activity and blood flow during hyperthermia and in heart failure

The hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus is a key integrative area in the brain involved in influencing sympathetic nerve activity and in the release of hormones or releasing factors that contribute to regulating body fluid homeostasis and endocrine function. The endocrine and hormonal regulatory function of the paraventricular nucleus is well studied, but the regulation of sympathetic nerve activity and blood flow by this region is less clear. Here we review the critical role of the paraventricular nucleus in regulating renal blood blow during hyperthermia and the evidence pointing to an important pathophysiological role of the paraventricular nucleus in the elevated renal sympathetic nerve activity that is a characteristic of heart failure.

Hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus is critical for renal vasoconstriction elicited by elevations in body temperature

Redistribution of blood from the viscera to the peripheral vasculature is the major cardiovascular response designed to restore thermoregulatory homeostasis after an elevation in body core temperature. In this study, we investigated the role of the hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus (PVN) in the reflex decrease in renal blood flow that is induced by hyperthermia, as this brain region is known to play a key role in renal function and may contribute to the central pathways underlying thermoregulatory responses. In anesthetized rats, blood pressure, heart rate, renal blood flow, and tail skin temperature were recorded in response to elevating body core temperature. In the control group, saline was microinjected bilaterally into the PVN; in the second group, muscimol (1 nmol in 100 nl per side) was microinjected to inhibit neuronal activity in the PVN; and in a third group, muscimol was microinjected outside the PVN. Compared with control, microinjection of muscimol into the PVN did not significantly affect the blood pressure or heart rate responses. However, the normal reflex reduction in renal blood flow observed in response to hyperthermia in the control group ( approximately 70% from a resting level of 11.5 ml/min) was abolished by the microinjection of muscimol into the PVN (maximum reduction of 8% from a resting of 9.1 ml/min). This effect was specific to the PVN since microinjection of muscimol outside the PVN did not prevent the normal renal blood flow response. The data suggest that the PVN plays an essential role in the reflex decrease in renal blood flow elicited by hyperthermia.

Central Tempol alters basal sympathetic nerve discharge and attenuates sympathetic excitation to central ANG II

In the present study, we established dose-response relationships between central administration of 4-hydroxy-2,2,6,6-tetramethylpiperidine 1-oxyl (Tempol, a superoxide dismutase mimetic) and the level of renal sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) and tested the hypothesis that intracerebroventricular (icv) Tempol pretreatment would attenuate centrally mediated changes in SND produced by icv ANG II administration. Urethane-chloralose-anesthetized, baroreceptor-denervated, normotensive rats were used. We found that icv Tempol administration produced dose-dependent sympathoinhibitory, hypotensive, and bradycardic responses. Mean arterial pressure and SND values were significantly increased after icv ANG II (150 ng/kg) administration, and these responses were abrogated after icv pretreatment with Tempol (75 μmol/kg) or losartan. Brain superoxide levels tended to be higher in ANG II-treated rats compared with rats treated with Tempol and ANG II. Tempol pretreatment did not prevent increases in SND level that were produced by acute heat stress, which indicates specificity in the effect of Tempol in reducing sympathoexcitation. These results demonstrate that icv Tempol administration influences central sympathetic neural circuits in a dose-dependent manner and attenuates SND responses to central ANG II infusion.

Forebrain and brain stem neural circuits contribute to altered sympathetic responses to heating in senescent rats

Acute heating in young rats increases visceral sympathetic nerve discharge (SND); however, renal and splanchnic SND responses to hyperthermia are attenuated in senescent compared with young Fischer 344 (F344) rats (Kenney MJ and Fels RJ. Am J Physiol Regul Integr Comp Physiol 283: R513-R520, 2002). Central mechanisms by which aging alters visceral SND responses to heating are unknown. We tested the hypothesis that forebrain neural circuits are involved in suppressing sympathoexcitatory responses to heating in chloralose-anesthetized, senescent F344 rats. Renal and splanchnic SND responses to increased (38 degrees C-41 degrees C) internal temperature were determined in midbrain-transected (MT) and sham-MT young (3-mo-old), mature (12-mo-old), and senescent (24-mo-old) F344 rats and in cervical-transected (CT) and sham-CT senescent rats. Renal SND remained unchanged during heating in MT and sham-MT senescent rats but was increased in CT senescent rats. Splanchnic SND responses to heating were higher in MT vs. sham-MT senescent rats and in CT vs. MT senescent rats. SND responses to heating were similar in MT and sham-MT young and mature rats. Mean arterial pressure (MAP) was increased during heating in MT but not in sham-MT senescent rats, whereas heating-induced increases in MAP were higher in sham-MT vs. MT young rats. These data suggest that in senescent rats suppression of splanchnic SND to heating involves forebrain and brain stem neural circuits, whereas renal suppression is mediated solely by brain stem neural circuits. These results support the concept that aging alters the functional organization of pathways regulating SND and arterial blood pressure responses to acute heating.

Impaired central stress-induced release of noradrenaline in rats with heart failure: a microdialysis study

Sympathetic hyperactivity in rats with heart failure is associated with increased extracellular noradrenaline in the hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus at rest. However, it is unknown how this nucleus responds to stressful stimuli. In the present study we therefore examined the basal and stress-induced release of noradrenaline in the paraventricular nucleus of conscious Sprague-Dawley rats with heart failure measured by in vivo microdialysis. Basal noradrenaline concentration in the paraventricular nucleus of rats with heart failure was more than double that in sham-operated controls. Immobilization stress decreases noradrenaline levels in the paraventricular nucleus of rats with heart failure to 57% of baseline, while it increased in sham-operated controls to 228%. However, serum corticosterone was similarly elevated at 30 and 90 min post-stress in both experimental groups. We have shown that heart failure causes an impairment of the central noradrenergic system's response to acute sympatho-excitation but does not affect the hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenocortical response.

Sympathetic nerve regulation to heating is altered in senescent rats

Renal and splanchnic sympathetic nerve discharge (SND) responses to increased (38-41 degrees C) internal temperature were determined in anesthetized young (3-6 mo old), mature (12 mo old), and senescent (24 mo old) Fischer 344 (F344) rats. We hypothesized that SND responses would be altered in senescent and mature rats as demonstrated by attenuated sympathoexcitatory responses to heating and by the absence of hyperthermia-induced SND pattern changes. The following observations were made. 1) Renal and splanchnic SND responses were significantly increased during heating in young and mature but not in senescent rats. 2) At 41 degrees C, renal and splanchnic SND responses were higher in young compared with senescent rats, and renal SND was higher in mature than in senescent rats. 3) Heating changed the SND bursting pattern in young, but not in mature or senescent, rats. 4) SND responses to heating did not differ between baroreceptor-innervated (BRI) and sinoaortic-denervated (SAD) senescent rats but were higher in SAD compared with BRI young rats. These results demonstrate an attenuated responsiveness of sympathetic neural circuits to heating in senescent F344 rats.