Respiratory impedances and acinar gas transfer in a canine model for emphysema

Constant-phase descriptions of canine lung, chest wall, and total respiratory system viscoelasticity: effects of distending pressure

The dynamic mechanical properties of the respiratory system reflect the ensemble behavior of its constituent structural elements. This study assessed the appropriateness of constant-phase descriptions of respiratory tissue viscoelasticity at various distending pressures. We measured the mechanical input impedance (Z) of the lungs, chest wall and total respiratory system in 12 dogs at mean airway pressures from 5 to 30 cm H(2)O. Each Z was fitted with a constant-phase model which provided estimates tissue damping (G), elastance (H), and hysteresivity (η=G/H). Both G and H sharply increased with increasing distending pressure for the lungs and chest wall, while η attained a minimum near 15-20 cm H(2)O. Model fitting errors for the lungs and total respiratory system increased for distending pressures greater than 20 cm H(2)O, indicating that constant-phase descriptions of parenchymal and respiratory system viscoelasticty may be inappropriate at volumes closer to total lung capacity. Such behavior may reflect alterations in load distribution across various parenchymal stress-bearing elements.

Oscillation mechanics of the respiratory system: applications to lung disease

Since its introduction in the 1950s, the forced oscillation technique (FOT) and the measurement of respiratory impedance have evolved into powerful tools for the assessment of various mechanical phenomena in the mammalian lung during health and disease. In this review, we highlight the most recent developments in instrumentation, signal processing, and modeling relevant to FOT measurements. We demonstrate how FOT provides unparalleled information on the mechanical status of the respiratory system compared to more widely used pulmonary function tests. The concept of mechanical impedance is reviewed, as well as the various measurement techniques used to acquire such data. Emphasis is placed on the analysis of lower, physiologic frequency ranges (typically less than 10 Hz) that are most sensitive to normal physical processes as well as pathologic structural alterations. Various inverse modeling approaches used to interpret alterations in impedance are also discussed, specifically in the context of three common respiratory diseases: asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and acute lung injury. Finally, we speculate on the potential role for FOT in the clinical arena.

Lung volumes and respiratory mechanics in elastase-induced emphysema in mice

Absolute lung volumes such as functional residual capacity, residual volume (RV), and total lung capacity (TLC) are used to characterize emphysema in patients, whereas in animal models of emphysema, the mechanical parameters are invariably obtained as a function of transrespiratory pressure (Prs). The aim of the present study was to establish a link between the mechanical parameters including tissue elastance (H) and airway resistance (Raw), and thoracic gas volume (TGV) in addition to Prs in a mouse model of emphysema. Using low-frequency forced oscillations during slow deep inflation, we tracked H and Raw as functions of TGV and Prs in normal mice and mice treated with porcine pancreatic elastase. The presence of emphysema was confirmed by morphometric analysis of histological slices. The treatment resulted in an increase in TGV by 51 and 44% and a decrease in H by 57 and 27%, respectively, at 0 and 20 cmH(2)O of Prs. The Raw did not differ between the groups at any value of Prs, but it was significantly higher in the treated mice at comparable TGV values. In further groups of mice, tracheal sounds were recorded during inflations from RV to TLC. All lung volumes but RV were significantly elevated in the treated mice, whereas the numbers and size distributions of inspiratory crackles were not different, suggesting that the airways were not affected by the elastase treatment. These findings emphasize the importance of absolute lung volumes and indicate that tissue destruction was not associated with airway dysfunction in this mouse model of emphysema.

Canine models of asthma and COPD

Dogs have been extensively used to model the important components of asthma and COPD. Many of the key features of human asthma such as reversible airflow obstruction, pulmonary inflammation, airway hyperresponsiveness and cough are demonstrated in dogs after provocation with antigen, following a period of hyperventilation with dry air or after inhalation of ozone. Furthermore, standard anti-asthma drugs such as beta-adrenergic agonists, corticosteroids and leukotriene inhibitors are effective in these models. The pathology and pathophysiology of chronic bronchitis and emphysema can also be demonstrated in dogs after exposure to cigarette smoke, following inhalation of sulfur dioxide and by intra-tracheal or aerosol administration of proteolytic enzymes such as papain. These canine models of COPD have been used to evaluate a variety of new methodologies and treatments before they are tested in humans. This review highlights some of the important features of these canine models and how they have increased our understanding of the pathology, pathophysiology and control of human asthma and COPD.

Reliability of Estimating Stochastic Lung Tissue Heterogeneity from Pulmonary Impedance Spectra: A Forward-Inverse Modeling Study

Heterogeneity of regional lung mechanics is an important determinant of the work of breathing and may be a risk factor for ventilator associated lung injury. The ability to accurately assess heterogeneity may have important implications for monitoring disease progression and optimizing ventilator settings. Inverse modeling approaches, when applied to dynamic pulmonary impedance data (Z(L)), are thought to be sensitive to the detection of mechanical heterogeneity with the ability to characterize global lung function using a minimal number of free parameters. However, the reliability and bias associated with such model-based estimates of heterogeneity are unknown. We simulated Z(L) spectra from healthy, emphysematous, and acutely injured lungs using a computer-generated anatomic canine structure with asymmetric Horsfield branching and various predefined distributions of stochastic lung tissue heterogeneity. Various inverse models with distinct topologies incorporating linear resistive and inertial airways with parallel tissue viscoelasticity were then fitted to these Z(L) spectra and evaluated in terms of their quality of fit as well as the accuracy and reliability of their respective model parameters. While all model topologies detected appropriate changes in tissue heterogeneity, only a topology consisting of lumped airway properties with distributed tissue properties yielded accurate estimates of both mean lung tissue stiffness and the spread of regional elastances. These data demonstrate that inverse modeling approaches applied to noninvasive measures of Z(L) may provide reliable and accurate assessments of lung tissue heterogeneity as well as insight into distributed lung mechanical properties.

Respiratory impedance following bronchoscopic or surgical lung volume reduction for emphysema

BACKGROUND

Bronchoscopic methods for achieving lung volume reduction (BLVR) are presently undergoing clinical trials, and will soon be clinically available. Understanding the differential effects of surgical volume reduction therapy (LVRS) and BLVR on lung and chest wall physiology will assist physicians in selecting an optimal approach for patients.

OBJECTIVES

Determine whether LVRS adversely affects lung or chest wall physiology at 3-month follow-up relative to BLVR in an experimental model of sheep emphysema.

METHODS

Twelve mixed-breed sheep were treated with papain to produce experimental emphysema, and were divided into control, LVRS, and BLVR treatment groups. Lung and chest wall impedance was measured at 0, 5, and 10 cm H2O positive end-expiratory pressure at baseline and 3-month follow-up.

RESULTS

Emphysema was associated with increased airway resistance, decreased lung tissue resistance and elastance, and increased chest wall tissue resistance. Following treatment, equivalent increases in lung elastance occurred in the LVRS and BLVR groups compared to controls. LVRS did not adversely affect chest wall impedance despite causing extensive pleural scarring.

CONCLUSIONS

(1) Experimental emphysema following prolonged papain exposure progresses after cessation of treatment. (2) BLVR and LVRS produced equivalent lung and chest wall impedance responses at 3-month follow-up. (3) LVRS did not adversely affect chest wall impedance despite being associated with extensive pleural scarring.

Pulmonary function tests fail to predict exercise intolerance in sheep with emphysema

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to examine ventilatory parameters, gas exchange, and exercise tolerance in sheep undergoing cardiopulmonary exercise testing and pulmonary function testing at baseline and after induction of emphysema using nebulized papain, to improve our understanding of the contributions of parenchymal emphysema with minimal airway disease to exertional dysfunction in mild-to-moderate emphysema.

METHODS

Static lung physiology (total lung capacity, residual volume, static elastance, and diffusing capacity of carbon monoxide) and lung (ZL) input impedance were measured, and cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPET) was performed in 12 sheep before and after induction of emphysema. Papain treatment was delivered over a 12-wk period, as a single dose per week, to induce mild-to-moderate emphysema without airway disease. Static and dynamic lung physiology, as well as CPET, were then repeated.

RESULTS

At the emphysema time point (EMPH), all animals were asymptomatic for emphysema at rest. There was a 60% increase in residual volume and a 57% decrease in static elastance, accompanied by a 36% reduction in diffusing capacity. Airway resistance was consistently, mildly increased, resulting in an increased expiratory time constant for all sheep at EMPH. There were no significant differences at EMPH versus baseline for any measured physiological variables during CPET (VO2peak, VCO2peak, RER, anaerobic threshold, O2 pulse, tidal volume, peak flow, peak VE/VO2, or peak VE).

CONCLUSION

There is notable conservation of exercise capacity in sheep with mild-to-moderate parenchymal emphysema; this is not predicted by pulmonary function tests. In the absence of significant airway narrowing, mild-to-moderate emphysema is unlikely to result in airflow limitation.

Bronchoscopic volume reduction: a safe and effective alternative to surgical therapy for emphysema

Lung volume reduction surgery (LVRS), the removal of damaged, hyperexpanded lung, has been shown to improve respiratory function in many patients with end-stage emphysema. We report the results of an animal study using a new transbronchoscopic alternative to LVRS in which a washout solution and fibrin-based glue are used to collapse, seal, and scar target regions of abnormal lung. Twelve sheep had static and dynamic lung functions measured at baseline. Emphysema was produced by inhaled papain (7,000 U/wk x 4 wk), resulting in a significant increase of lung volumes, compliance, and airway resistance. The animals were then divided into three treatment groups of four animals, and underwent surgical volume reduction (SVR), bronchoscopic volume reduction (BVR), or bronchoscopy alone (Sham-BVR). Response to each intervention was assessed 8 to 12 wk after treatment by measuring lung function and examining lung tissue. BVR and SVR groups responded with significant and similar decreases in TLC and residual volume (RV). Tissue examination demonstrated that BVR caused collapse of the lung with focal scarring in 11 of 20 target territories (55% success rate). Three of the 11 target zones developed sterile abscesses. Postprocedure complications were less frequent with BVR than with SVR. This pilot study suggests that lung volume reduction can be achieved in animals without surgery using a bronchoscopic approach and a novel fibrin-based glue system. BVR has the potential for simplifying volume reduction, extending indications, and reducing morbidity, mortality, and costs in humans.