Firing rate trajectories of human motor units during activity-dependent muscle potentiation

Post-activation potentiation and potentiated motor unit firing patterns in boys and men

BACKGROUND

Post-activation potentiation (PAP) describes the enhancement of twitch torque following a conditioning contraction (CC) in skeletal muscle. In adults, PAP may be related to muscle fibre composition and is accompanied by a decrease in motor unit (MU) firing rates (MUFRs). Muscle fibre composition and/or activation is different between children and adults. This study examined PAP and MU firing patterns of the potentiated knee extensors in boys and men.

METHODS

Twenty-three boys (10.5 ± 1.3 years) and 20 men (23.1 ± 3.3 years) completed familiarization and experimental sessions. Maximal isometric evoked-twitch torque and MU firing patterns during submaximal contractions (20% and 70% maximal voluntary isometric contraction, MVIC) were recorded before and after a CC (5 s MVIC). PAP was calculated as the percent-increase in evoked-twitch torque after the CC. MU firing patterns were examined during submaximal contractions before and after the CC using Trigno Galileo surface electrodes (Delsys Inc) and decomposition algorithms (NeuroMap, Delsys Inc). MU action potential amplitudes (MUAPamp) and MUFRs were calculated for each MU and exponential MUFR-MUAPamp relationships were calculated for each participant and trial.

RESULTS

PAP was higher in men than in boys (98.3 ± 37.1% vs. 68.8 ± 18.3%, respectively; p = 0.002). Following potentiation, the rate of decay of the MUFR-MUAPamps relationship decreased in both contractions, with a greater decrease among boys during the high-intensity contractions.

CONCLUSION

Lower PAP in the boys did not coincide with smaller changes in potentiated MU firing patterns, as boys had greater reductions in MUFRs with potentiation compared with men in high-intensity contractions.

Acute and prolonged competing effects of activation history on human motor unit firing rates during contractile impairment and recovery

The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of inducing post-activation potentiation (PAP) during prolonged low-frequency force depression (PLFFD) on motor unit (MU) firing rates. In 10 participants, grouped firing rates of 3027 MUs from the tibialis anterior were recorded with tungsten microelectrodes. Baseline MU firing rates at 25% isometric maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) were ∼14 Hz. A 1 min dorsiflexion MVC reduced torque and maximal MU firing rates (36 Hz) by 49% and 52%, respectively. Following task completion, firing rates at 25% of baseline MVC torque and torque in response to electrically evoked (single twitch, 10 Hz and 50 Hz) stimulation were assessed before and after a 5 s MVC (to induce PAP) every 10 min for 60 min. From 10 to 60 min after task completion, the torque ratios (twitch:50 Hz and 10:50 Hz) were depressed (∼30%) relative to baseline (P < 0.001), indicating PLFFD; and firing rates were higher by ∼15% relative to baseline (P < 0.001). This occurred despite recovery of MVC rates (∼99%) and torque (∼95%) by 10 min (P > 0.3). Inducing PAP during PLFFD increased both low to high torque ratios (twitch and 10:50 Hz) by ∼200% and ∼135%, respectively (P < 0.001) and firing rates were ∼18% lower relative to PLFFD rates (P < 0.001), despite a speeding of evoked contractile properties (P = 0.001). Thus, firing rates appear strongly matched to alterations in torque, rather than contractile speed when modified by contractile history, and lower rates during PAP may be a mechanism to mitigate effects of PLFFD. The effect of activation history on contractile function demonstrates acute compensatory responses of motoneuron output. KEY POINTS: Prolonged low frequency force depression (PLFFD) following a sustained 1 min isometric maximal voluntary contraction causes an increase in submaximal mean motor unit (MU) firing rates. Inducing post-activation potentiation (PAP) during PLFFD, however, causes a reduction in mean submaximal MU firing rates to a level below those at baseline. The mean firing rate reduction during PAP occurs despite a speeding of evoked contractile properties and thus firing rates are more strongly matched to alterations in torque, rather than contractile speed when modified by various contractile histories. The reductions in firing rates during PAP may mitigate the effects of PLFFD during voluntary contractions. These results demonstrate that firing rates are highly responsive to opposing influences on the contractile state and can make rapid compensatory rate adjustments dependent on the active state of the muscle.

Increased corticospinal inhibition following brief maximal and submaximal contractions in humans

A potentiating conditioning contraction (CC) has been shown to increase silent period duration, an index of corticospinal inhibition; however, it is unknown if the CC must induce potentiation for corticospinal inhibition to increase. Ten healthy, young adults (four females) completed this study to assess potentiation and silent period (SP) duration before and after four types of CCs: voluntary and electrically evoked maximal CCs to optimize potentiation, and voluntary and electrically evoked submaximal CCs (∼40% of maximal voluntary force) that induced minimal potentiation. Stimulation was applied to the ulnar nerve to evoke twitches for the assessment of potentiation and to evoke tetanic CCs of the first dorsal interosseous muscle. The SP was elicited by applying transcranial magnetic stimulation to the motor cortex during brief contractions at 25% of maximal voluntary force. Changes to twitch force and SP duration were not different for voluntary and tetanic contractions, so data were pooled. Twitch force increased by 81.2 ± 35.7% (P < 0.001) and 3.2 ± 6.5% (P = 0.039) following maximal and submaximal CCs, respectively. The SP was prolonged following maximal (12.6 ± 6.3%; P < 0.001) and submaximal (4.8 ± 4.9%; P < 0.001) CCs. Correlations between post-CC twitch force and SP duration were not significant for maximal or submaximal conditions (r = -0.068; r = 0.067; P ≥ 0.780, respectively). Duration of the SP increased not only following maximal-intensity CCs but also after submaximal-intensity CCs that induced virtually no potentiation (∼3%). Thus, we suggest that corticospinal inhibition is not directly related to mechanisms of muscle potentiation per se, but, rather, the level of muscle contraction likely mediates feedback from large diameter afferents that affect the SP.NEW & NOTEWORTHY The transcranial magnetic stimulation-induced silent period reflects a transient state of corticospinal inhibition that is influenced by recent history of muscle activation, which may include an effect of potentiation. We demonstrate that silent period duration increases following both voluntary and electrically evoked maximal and submaximal conditioning contractions, even though the latter intensity produced virtually no muscle potentiation. Feedback from group Ia and Ib muscle afferents is proposed as the cause of the increased corticospinal inhibition.

Skeletal muscle models composed of motor units: A review

The mathematical muscle models should include several aspects of muscle structure and physiology. First, muscle force is the sum of forces of multiple motor units (MUs), which have different contractile properties and play different roles in generating muscle force. Second, whole muscle activity is an effect of net excitatory inputs to a pool of motoneurons innervating the muscle, which have different excitability, influencing MU recruitment. In this review, we compare various methods for modeling MU twitch and tetanic forces and then discuss muscle models composed of different MU types and number. We first present four different analytical functions used for twitch modeling and show limitations related to the number of twitch describing parameters. We also show that a nonlinear summation of twitches should be considered in modeling tetanic contractions. We then compare different muscle models, most of which are variations of Fuglevand's model, adopting a common drive hypothesis and the size principle. We pay attention to integrating previously developed models into a consensus model based on physiological data from in vivo experiments on the rat medial gastrocnemius muscle and its respective motoneurons. Finally, we discuss the shortcomings of existing models and potential applications for studying MU synchronization, potentiation, and fatigue.

A geometric approach to quantifying the neuromodulatory effects of persistent inward currents on individual motor unit discharge patterns

Objective.All motor commands flow through motoneurons, which entrain control of their innervated muscle fibers, forming a motor unit (MU). Owing to the high fidelity of action potentials within MUs, their discharge profiles detail the organization of ionotropic excitatory/inhibitory as well as metabotropic neuromodulatory commands to motoneurons. Neuromodulatory inputs (e.g. norepinephrine, serotonin) enhance motoneuron excitability and facilitate persistent inward currents (PICs). PICs introduce quantifiable properties in MU discharge profiles by augmenting depolarizing currents upon activation (i.e. PIC amplification) and facilitating discharge at lower levels of excitatory input than required for recruitment (i.e. PIC prolongation).Approach. Here, we introduce a novel geometric approach to estimate neuromodulatory and inhibitory contributions to MU discharge by exploiting discharge non-linearities introduced by PIC amplification during time-varying linear tasks. In specific, we quantify the deviation from linear discharge ('brace height') and the rate of change in discharge (i.e. acceleration slope, attenuation slope, angle). We further characterize these metrics on a simulated motoneuron pool with known excitatory, inhibitory, and neuromodulatory inputs and on human MUs (number of MUs; Tibialis Anterior: 1448, Medial Gastrocnemius: 2100, Soleus: 1062, First Dorsal Interosseus: 2296).Main results. In the simulated motor pool, we found brace height and attenuation slope to consistently indicate changes in neuromodulation and the pattern of inhibition (excitation-inhibition coupling), respectively, whereas the paired MU analysis (ΔF) was dependent on both neuromodulation and inhibition pattern. Furthermore, we provide estimates of these metrics in human MUs and show comparable variability in ΔFand brace height measures for MUs matched across multiple trials.Significance. Spanning both datasets, we found brace height quantification to provide an intuitive method for achieving graded estimates of neuromodulatory and inhibitory drive to individual MUs. This complements common techniques and provides an avenue for decoupling changes in the level of neuromodulatory and pattern of inhibitory motor commands.

Increases in muscle temperature by hot water improve muscle contractile function and reduce motor unit discharge rates

PURPOSE

Examine the effects of 42°C hot-water immersion on muscle contraction function and motor unit discharge rates. Voluntary and evoked contraction assessments were examined first with a concomitant increase in the core and muscle temperature, and thereafter with increased muscle temperature but cooled core temperature.

METHODS

Fifteen participants (24.9 ± 5.6 years) performed neuromuscular assessments before, after, and ~15-min after either 90-min of 42°C (hot) or 36°C (control) water immersion. Maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) assessment of knee extension was performed along with surface electromyography (sEMG) (vastus lateralis and medialis [VL, VM]) and voluntary activation level (VAL). Resting evoked twitch was elicited for peak torque and time to peak torque analysis. In addition, the VL and VM motor unit discharge rates (MUDR) were measured.

RESULTS

After hot-water immersion (core temperature ↑1°C; muscle temperature ↑2.4°C), MVC torque and VAL decreased (p < 0.05). The sEMG (VL and VM) and peak twitch torque did not change (p > 0.05), while time to peak torque decreased (p = 0.007). The VL and VM MUDR decreased, showing a time effect, after both water immersion conditions (36 and 42°C) (p > 0.001). Fifteen minutes after the hot-water immersion (core temperature at baseline; muscle temperature ↑1.4°C), MVC torque returned to baseline, but VAL remained lower. The sEMG (VL and VM) remained unchanged. Peak twitch torque increased (p < 0.002) and time to peak torque remained lower (p = 0.028). The MUDR remained lower after both water immersion conditions (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Increased core temperature evoked by 42°C hot-water immersion decreases MVC torque and VAL. However, a passive increase in muscle temperature improved evoked muscle contractile function (i.e., time to peak torque [after] and peak twitch torque [~15 min after]). Moreover, a passive increase in muscle temperature reduced the required MUDR to attain the same torque.

Frequency dependent coexistence of muscle fatigue and potentiation assessed by concentric isotonic contractions in human plantar flexors

The purpose was to investigate whether post-activation potentiation (PAP) mitigates power (i.e., torque x angular velocity) loss during dynamic fatiguing contractions and subsequent recovery by enhancing either muscle torque or angular velocity in human plantar flexors. In 12 participants, electrically stimulated (1, 10 and 50 Hz) dynamic contractions were done during a voluntary isotonic fatiguing protocol (20 and 50% voluntary decreases) until a 75% loss in voluntary peak power, and throughout 30 minutes of recovery. At the initial portion of fatigue (20% decrease), power responses of evoked low frequencies (1 and 10 Hz) were enhanced due to PAP (156 and 137%, respectively, P<0.001), while voluntary maximal efforts were depressed due to fatiguing mechanisms. Following the fatiguing task, prolonged low-frequency force depression (PLFFD) was evident by reduced 10:50 Hz peak power ratios (21 - 24%) from 3-min onwards during the 30-min recovery (P<0.005). Inducing PAP with maximal voluntary contractions during PLFFD enhanced the peak power responses of low frequencies (1 and 10 Hz) by 128 - 160 %, P<0.01. This PAP response mitigated the effects of PLFFD as the 1:50 (P<0.05) and 10:50 (P>0.4) Hz peak power ratios were greater or not different from the pre-fatigue values. Additionally, PAP enhanced peak torque more than peak angular velocity during both baseline and fatigue measurements (P<0.03). These results indicate that PAP can ameliorate PLFFD acutely when evaluated during concentric isotonic contractions and that peak torque is enhanced to a greater degree compared to peak angular velocity at baseline and in a fatigued state.