Outcomes and complications of fetal tissue transplantation in Parkinson's disease

Cell-therapy for Parkinson's disease: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Cell-based strategies focusing on replacement or protection of dopaminergic neurons have been considered as a potential approach to treat Parkinson's disease (PD) for decades. However, despite promising preclinical results, clinical trials on cell-therapy for PD reported mixed outcomes and a thorough synthesis of these findings is lacking. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis to evaluate cell-therapy for PD patients.

METHODS

We systematically identified all clinical trials investigating cell- or tissue-based therapies for PD published before July 2023. Out of those, studies reporting transplantation of homogenous cells (containing one cell type) were included in meta-analysis. The mean difference or standardized mean difference in quantitative neurological scale scores before and after cell-therapy was analyzed to evaluate treatment effects.

RESULTS

The systematic literature search revealed 106 articles. Eleven studies reporting data from 11 independent trials (210 patients) were eligible for meta-analysis. Disease severity and motor function evaluation indicated beneficial effects of homogenous cell-therapy in the 'off' state at 3-, 6-, 12-, or 24-month follow-ups, and for motor function even after 36 months. Most of the patients were levodopa responders (61.6-100% in different follow-ups). Cell-therapy was also effective in improving the daily living activities in the 'off' state of PD patients. Cells from diverse sources were used and multiple transplantation modes were applied. Autografts did not improve functional outcomes, while allografts exhibited beneficial effects. Encouragingly, both transplantation into basal ganglia and to areas outside the basal ganglia were effective to reduce disease severity. Some trials reported adverse events potentially related to the surgical procedure. One confirmed and four possible cases of graft-induced dyskinesia were reported in two trials included in this meta-analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

This meta-analysis provides preliminary evidence for the beneficial effects of homogenous cell-therapy for PD, potentially to the levodopa responders. Allogeneic cells were superior to autologous cells, and the effective transplantation sites are not limited to the basal ganglia. PROSPERO registration number: CRD42022369760.

Is treatment with stem cells effective in Parkinson's disease?

INTRODUCTION

There are many patients with Parkinson's disease who have a limited response to conventional pharmacological treatment. The use of stem cells has been postulated as an alternative, although its effectiveness remains a matter of controversy.

METHODS

To answer this question we used Epistemonikos, the largest database of systematic reviews in health, which is maintained by screening multiple information sources, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane, among others. We extracted data from the systematic reviews, reanalyzed data of primary studies, conducted a meta-analysis and generated a summary of findings table using the GRADE approach.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

We identified two systematic reviews including 21 studies overall, of which three were randomized trials. We concluded it is not clear whether stem cells have any effect on the symptoms of Parkinson's disease because the certainty of the available evidence is very low.

Bioluminescence-driven optogenetic activation of transplanted neural precursor cells improves motor deficits in a Parkinson's disease mouse model

The need to develop efficient therapies for neurodegenerative diseases is urgent, especially given the increasing percentages of the population living longer, with increasing chances of being afflicted with conditions like Parkinson's disease (PD). A promising curative approach toward PD and other neurodegenerative diseases is the transplantation of stem cells to halt and potentially reverse neuronal degeneration. However, stem cell therapy does not consistently lead to improvement for patients. Using remote stimulation to optogenetically activate transplanted cells, we attempted to improve behavioral outcomes of stem cell transplantation. We generated a neuronal precursor cell line expressing luminopsin 3 (LMO3), a luciferase-channelrhodopsin fusion protein, which responds to the luciferase substrate coelenterazine (CTZ) with emission of blue light that in turn activates the opsin. Neuronal precursor cells were injected bilaterally into the striatum of homozygous aphakia mice, which carry a spontaneous mutation leading to lack of dopaminergic neurons and symptoms of PD. Following transplantation, the cells were stimulated over a period of 10 days by intraventricular injections of CTZ. Mice receiving CTZ demonstrated significantly improved motor skills in a rotarod test compared to mice receiving vehicle. Thus, bioluminescent optogenetic stimulation of transplanted neuronal precursor cells shows promising effects in improving locomotor behavior in the aphakia PD mouse model and encourages further studies to elucidate the mechanisms and long-term outcomes of these beneficial effects.

Restorative Strategies in Movement Disorders: the Contribution of Imaging

Purpose of Review

The purpose of this review was to review the imaging, particularly positron emission tomography (PET), findings in neurorestoration studies in movement disorders, with specific focus on neural transplantation in Parkinson’s disease (PD) and Huntington’s disease (HD).

Recent Findings

PET findings in PD transplantation studies have shown that graft survival as reflected by increases in dopaminergic PET markers does not necessarily correlate with clinical improvement. PD patients with more denervated ventral striatum and more imbalanced serotonin-to-dopamine ratio in the grafted neurons tended to have worse outcome. In HD transplantation studies, variable graft survival and clinical responses may be related to host inflammatory/immune responses to the grafts.

Summary

Information gleaned from imaging findings in previous neural transplantation studies has been used to refine study protocol and patient selection in future trials. This includes identifying suitable candidates for transplantation using imaging markers, employing multiple and/or novel PET tracers to better assess graft functions and inflammatory responses to grafts.

Sterile cyst formation after intrathecal stem cell transplant for Parkinson's disease: A case presentation and literature review

In recent years, fetal or autologous stem cell transplant for the treatment of Parkinson's disease (PD) has been practiced in a few medical organizations. However, the potential complications related to the growth of allograft tissue have not yet been well described apart from case reports. Here, we present a 42-year-old Saudi male who suffered from early onset Parkinson's disease. He sought medical care in China and received autologous intrathecal stem cell transplantation. He did not demonstrate any significant improvement. A few months later, the patient went back to China and underwent fetal cell transplantation into the left hemisphere and a second stem cell transplantation intrathecally. He presented with seizures and had a left frontal brain cyst. The cyst was drained and contained clear fluid. All cultures were negative. He had an uneventful recovery.

Understanding graft-induced dyskinesia

The transplantation of dopaminergic cells for the treatment of symptoms of Parkinson’s disease has several hurdles to overcome before it can be considered a successful therapeutic approach. One issue is the development of abnormal involuntary movements in the absence of L-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine following the transplantation of fetal ventral mesencephalon identified in three different clinical trials. Hypotheses as to the cause of these movements include: the composition of the graft, size of the graft, L-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine exposure and L-3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine-induced dyskinesia prior to transplantation and inflammatory responses in and around the graft. We evaluate the clinical evidence supporting these hypotheses and the preclinical models upon which experiments are being based to resolve them.

Neural grafting in Parkinson's disease unraveling the mechanisms underlying graft-induced dyskinesia

The development of neural transplantation as a treatment for Parkinson's disease has been compromised by a lack of functional efficacy and the appearance of transplant-induced motor side-effects in some patients. Since the first reports of these graft-induced dyskinesias (GID), and the realization of their impact on the progress of the field, a great deal of experimental work has been performed to determine the underlying cause(s) of this problematic side-effect. In this review we describe the clinical phenomenon of GID, explore the different representations of GID in rodent models, and examine the various hypotheses that have been postulated to be the cause. Based on the available clinical and preclinical data we outline strategies to avoid GID in future clinical trials using fetal cell transplants or cell preparations derived from stem cells.

Cell-based therapies for Parkinson's disease: past, present, and future

Parkinson's disease (PD) researchers have pioneered the use of cell-based therapies (CBTs) in the central nervous system. CBTs for PD were originally envisioned as a way to replace the dopaminergic nigral neurons lost with the disease. Several sources of catecholaminergic cells, including autografts of adrenal medulla and allografts or xenografts of mesencephalic fetal tissue, were successfully assessed in animal models, but their clinical translation has yielded poor results and much controversy. Recent breakthroughs on cell biology are helping to develop novel cell lines that could be used for regenerative medicine. Their future successful clinical application depends on identifying and solving the problems encountered in previous CBTs trials. In this review, we critically analyze past CBTs' clinical translation, the impact of the host in graft survival, and the role of preclinical studies and emerging new cell lines. We propose that the prediction of clinical results from preclinical studies requires experimental designs that allow blind data acquisition and statistical analysis, assessment of the therapy in models that parallel clinical conditions, looking for sources of complications or side effects, and limiting optimism bias when reporting outcomes.

Carotid body autotransplantation in Parkinson disease: a clinical and positron emission tomography study

BACKGROUND

Carotid body (CB) glomus cells are highly dopaminergic and express the glial cell line derived neurotrophic factor. The intrastriatal grafting of CB cell aggregates exerts neurotrophic actions on nigrostriatal neurons in animal models of Parkinson disease (PD).

OBJECTIVE

We conducted a phase I-II clinical study to assess the feasibility, long term safety, clinical and neurochemical effects of intrastriatal CB autotransplantation in patients with PD.

METHODS

Thirteen patients with advanced PD underwent bilateral stereotactic implantation of CB cell aggregates into the striatum. They were assessed before surgery and up to 1-3 years after surgery according to CAPIT (Core Assessment Programme for Intracerebral Transplantation) and CAPSIT-PD (Core Assessment Programme for Surgical Interventional Therapies in Parkinson's Disease) protocols. The primary outcome measure was the change in video blinded Unified Parkinson's Disease Rating Scale III score in the off-medication state. Seven patients had 18F-dopa positron emission tomography scans before and 1 year after transplantation.

RESULTS

Clinical amelioration in the primary outcome measure was observed in 10 of 12 blindly analysed patients, which was maximal at 6-12 months after transplantation (5-74%). Overall, mean improvement at 6 months was 23%. In the long term (3 years), 3 of 6 patients still maintained improvement (15-48%). None of the patients developed off-period dyskinesias. The main predictive factors for motor improvement were the histological integrity of the CB and a milder disease severity. We observed a non-significant 5% increase in mean putaminal 18F-dopa uptake but there was an inverse relationship between clinical amelioration and annual decline in putaminal 18F-dopa uptake (r = -0.829; p = 0.042).

CONCLUSIONS

CB autotransplantation may induce clinical effects in patients with advanced PD which seem partly related to the biological properties of the implanted glomus cells.

Dyskinesias and dopamine cell replacement in Parkinson's disease: a clinical perspective

Both increased and decreased dyskinesias have been reported from open label clinical trials of transplantation of human embryonic dopamine rich tissue in Parkinson's disease patients. In the first double-blind clinical transplantation trial, 15% of the grafted patients developed severe postoperative dyskinesias in the "off" phase. Since then, postoperative off-medication dyskinesias have been reported from two additional series of grafted patients. However, such dyskinesias are probably not a novel phenomenon. These dyskinesias have shown a different temporal development postoperatively compared to the antiparkinsonian graft effects, and no significant relationship with the magnitude of graft-derived dopaminergic reinnervation or symptomatic relief. However, positron emission tomography studies have indicated that an unbalanced putaminal dopaminergic function may contribute to this postoperative complication. While there is little doubt that intrastriatal grafts can induce dyskinesias, these appear to differ from common drug-induced dyskinesias. The term graft-induced dyskinesias (GID) is therefore suggested to more clearly identify this complication. While GID bear some phenomenological resemblance to biphasic drug induced dyskinesias, the mechanism(s) behind this complication remains obscure. Available data are scarce but allow for hypotheses to be generated that could (and should) be addressed in experimental animals.

Stem cells for neurodegenerative disorders: where can we go from here?

The use of stem cells in cell replacement therapy for neurodegenerative diseases has received a great deal of scientific and public interest in recent years. This is due to the remarkable pace at which paradigm-changing discoveries have been made regarding the neurogenic potential of embryonic, fetal, and adult cells. Over the last decade, clinical fetal tissue transplants have demonstrated that dopaminergic neurons can survive long term and provide functional clinical benefits for patients with Parkinson's disease. Pluripotent embryonic stem cells and multipotent neural stem cells may provide renewable sources that could replace these primary fetal grafts. Considerable advancement has been made in generating cultures with high numbers of neurons in general and of dopaminergic neurons using a varied array of techniques. However, much of this encouraging progress still remains to be tested on long-term expanded human cultures. Further problems include the low survival rate of these cells following transplantation and the tumorigenic tendencies of embryo-derived cells. However, pre-differentiation or genetic modification of stem cell cultures prior to transplantation may help lead to the generation of high numbers of cells of the desired phenotype following grafting. Boosting particular factors or substrates in the culture media may also protect grafted neurons from oxidative and metabolic stress, and provide epigenetic trophic support. Possible endogenous sources of cells for brain repair include the transdifferentiation of various types of adult cells into neurons. Despite the excitement generated by examples of this phenomenon, further work is needed in order to identify the precise instructive cues that generate neural cells from many other tissue types, and whether or not the new cells are functionally normal. Furthermore, issues such as cell homogeneity and fusion need to be addressed further before the true potential of transdifferentiation can be known. Endogenous stem cells also reside in the neurogenic zones of the adult brain (ventricle lining and hippocampus). Further elucidation of the mechanisms that stimulate cell division and migration are required in order to learn how to amplify the small amount of new cells generated by the adult brain and to direct these cells to areas of injury or degeneration. Finally, a more fundamental understanding of brain injury and disease is required in order to circumvent local brain environmental restrictions on endogenous cell differentiation and survival.

Cellular replacement therapy for Parkinson's disease--where we are today?

The concept of replacing lost dopamine neurons in Parkinson's disease using mesencephalic brain cells from fetal cadavers has been supported by over 20 years of research in animals and over a decade of clinical studies. The ambitious goal of these studies was no less than a molecular and cellular "cure" for Parkinson's disease, other neurodegenerative diseases, and spinal cord injury. Much research has been done in rodents, and a few studies have been done in nonhuman primate models. Early uncontrolled clinical reports were enthusiastic, but the outcome of the first randomized, double blind, controlled study challenged the idea that dopamine replacement cells can cure Parkinson's disease, although there were some significant positive findings. Were the earlier animal studies and clinical reports wrong? Should we give up on the goal? Some aspects of the trial design and implantation methods may have led to lack of effects and to some side effects such as dyskinesias. But a detailed review of clinical neural transplants published to date still suggests that neural transplantation variably reverses some aspects of Parkinson's disease, although differing methods make exact comparisons difficult. While the randomized clinical studies have been in progress, new methods have shown promise for increasing transplant survival and distribution, reconstructing the circuits to provide dopamine to the appropriate targets and with normal regulation. Selected promising new strategies are reviewed that block apoptosis induced by tissue dissection, promote vascularization of grafts, reduce oxidant stress, provide key growth factors, and counteract adverse effects of increased age. New sources of replacement cells and stem cells may provide additional advantages for the future. Full recovery from parkinsonism appears not only to be possible, but a reliable cell replacement treatment may finally be near.

Caspase inhibition by Z-VAD increases the survival of grafted bone marrow cells and improves functional outcome after MCAo in rats

Marrow stromal cells (MSCs) transplantation into brain has been employed to treat experimental ischemia. However, MSCs undergo apoptosis and few survive in the ischemic brain. We test the hypotheses that coadministration of bone marrow cells (BMCs) with a cell-permeable inhibitor of caspases, Z-Val-Ala-DL-Asp-fluoromethylketone (Z-VAD), into the ischemic boundary zone (IBZ) of brain promotes BMCs survival and improve outcome. Experimental groups consist of: 24 h after MCAo, either phosphate-buffered saline (PBS, n=4), dead BMC (n=4), fresh BMC (n=10), Z-VAD only (n=4), or BMC with Z-VAD (n=6) were intracerebrally injected. BMCs were harvested from donor adult rats labeled with bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU). Rats were subjected to an adhesive-removal somatosensory and motor-rotarod functional tests before MCAo and at 1 and 7 days after MCAo. Rats treated with a combination of Z-VAD and BMCs exhibited significant improvement in the adhesive-removal test at 7 days compared with the control group (combined MCAo+PBS and MCAo+dead BMC) (p<0.01), and the numbers of BrdU-BMC increased (p<0.05) and apoptotic cells decreased (p<0.05) compared with BMC alone transplantation. Our data suggest that intracerebral coadministration of BMC with Z-VAD enhances the survival of grafted BMC and improves neurological functional recovery after MCAo.

Fetal tissue transplantation for patients with Parkinson's disease: a database of published clinical results

Over the past 13 years approximately 300 patients with Parkinson's disease have received transplants of human fetal dopamine cells in an attempt to reduce or control disease symptoms. Many of these patients have had improvements in their motor skills and a reduction in their daily levodopa administration. However, improvements are far from guaranteed and questions need to be answered before this technique can be widely applied. To help address some of these issues, a search of all the published results of patients with Parkinson's disease transplanted with human fetal tissue was conducted. This generated a database of 70 transplant recipients who had their levodopa administration and clinical benefit reported both prior to transplant and at least 6 months post-transplant. Furthermore, the number of years of disease onset prior to transplant was available for all recipients. This database was examined for motor improvement and reduction in levodopa dosage for up to 2 years post-transplant to determine the effects of time on transplant outcome. The database showed that most recipients had significant improvements in motor skills and levodopa administration, and that most benefits were observed in the first 6 months post-transplant. In addition, the database demonstrated that the number of years of disease onset prior to transplantation was not a predictor of patient outcome 1-year post-transplant. Current and future directions in fetal tissue transplantation research and replacements for fetal tissue are discussed.