Fabry's disease: heterozygous form of different expression in two monozygous twin sisters

Discordant renal progression of Fabry disease in male monozygotic twins: a case report

Background: Fabry disease (FD) is a rare X-linked lysosomal storage disease caused by mutations in the GLA gene that encodes α-galactosidase A (α-GAL). Clinical phenotypes tend to vary in monozygotic female twins because mutations are located on the X-chromosome, whereas similar phenotypes are found in male monozygotic twins. Here we report the case of male monozygotic twins with FD presenting with distinguishable renal phenotypes. Case: A 49-year-old male patient who visited the hospital with proteinuria 14 years prior was readmitted for the same issue. His monozygotic twin brother had started hemodialysis 6 months prior due to renal failure of unknown origin. The patient's renal function was within the normal range, while his spot urine protein-to-creatinine ratio was 557 mg/g. Echocardiography revealed left ventricular hypertrophy (LVH). The findings of a renal biopsy were consistent with FD. Genetic testing identified a c.656T>C mutation in the GLA gene, and α-GAL activity was significantly decreased. Genetic screening of his family clarified that his mother, older sister, twin brother, and his daughter had the same genetic mutations. The patient received enzyme replacement therapy 34 times. Subsequently, migalastat was initiated that continues today. Renal function and proteinuria remain stable, and the LVH has mildly improved. Conclusion: This is the first case of male monozygotic twins expressing different progressions of FD. Our findings demonstrate the possibility that environmental or epigenetic factors may critically influence genotype-phenotype discordance.

Expression of the disease on female carriers of X-linked lysosomal disorders: a brief review

Most lysosomal diseases (LD) are inherited as autosomal recessive traits, but two important conditions have X-linked inheritance: Fabry disease and Mucopolysaccharidosis II (MPS II). These two diseases show a very different pattern regarding expression on heterozygotes, which does not seem to be explained by the X-inactivation mechanism only. While MPS II heterozygotes are asymptomatic in most instances, in Fabry disease most of female carriers show some disease manifestation, which is sometimes severe. It is known that there is a major difference among X-linked diseases depending on the cell autonomy of the gene product involved and, therefore, on the occurrence of cross-correction. Since lysosomal enzymes are usually secreted and uptaken by neighbor cells, the different findings between MPS II and Fabry disease heterozygotes can also be due to different efficiency of cross-correction (higher in MPS II and lower in Fabry disease). In this paper, we review these two X-linked LD in order to discuss the mechanisms that could explain the different rates of penetrance and expressivity observed in the heterozygotes; this could be helpful to better understand the expression of X-linked traits.

X chromosome inactivation in clinical practice

X chromosome inactivation (XCI) is the transcriptional silencing of the majority of genes on one of the two X chromosomes in mammalian females. Females are, therefore, mosaics for two cell lines, one with the maternal X and one with the paternal X as the active chromosome. The relative proportion of the two cell lines, the X inactivation pattern, may be analyzed by simple assays in DNA from available tissues. This review focuses on medical issues related to XCI in X-linked disorders, and on the value of X inactivation analysis in clinical practice.

Naked plasmid DNA-based alpha-galactosidase A gene transfer partially reduces systemic accumulation of globotriaosylceramide in Fabry mice

Fabry disease is an X-linked recessive inborn metabolic disorder in which a deficiency in lysosomal enzyme alpha-galactosidase A (Gal A) causes the systemic accumulation of globotriaosylceramide (Gb3). Although many investigators have attempted to treat alpha-Gal A knock-out mice (Fabry mice) with gene therapy, no report has demonstrated therapeutic effects by the retrograde renal vein injection of naked DNA. We recently developed a naked plasmid vector-mediated kidney-targeted gene transfer technique. A solution containing naked plasmid DNA encoding human alpha-Gal A (pKSCX-alpha-Gal A) was rapidly injected into the left kidney of Fabry mice (pKSCX-alpha-Gal A mice). pKSCX was used for mock transfections (pKSCX mice). We confirmed that vector-derived human alpha-Gal A mRNA was present in the left kidney but not in other tissues, by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction. Compared with the pKSCX mice, the pKSCX-alpha-Gal A mice showed partial therapeutic effects: increased alpha-Gal A activity in the injected kidney and in the liver, heart, and plasma, and decreased Gb3 in the injected kidney, contralateral kidney, liver, heart, and spleen. Our results demonstrated that, although further studies are needed to improve the outcome, this method has promise as a potential treatment option for Fabry disease.

Fabry disease: Guidelines for the evaluation and management of multi-organ system involvement

Fabry disease is an X-linked metabolic storage disorder due to the deficiency of lysosomal alpha-galactosidase A, and the subsequent accumulation of glycosphingolipids, primarily globotriaosylceramide, throughout the body. Males with classical Fabry disease develop early symptoms including pain and hypohidrosis by the second decade of life reflecting disease progression in the peripheral and autonomic nervous systems. An insidious cascade of disease processes ultimately results in severe renal, cardiac, and central nervous system complications in adulthood. The late complications are the main cause of late morbidity, as well as premature mortality. Disease presentation in female heterozygotes may be as severe as in males although women may also remain asymptomatic. The recent introduction of enzyme replacement therapy to address the underlying pathophysiology of Fabry disease has focused attention on the need for comprehensive, multidisciplinary evaluation and management of the multi-organ system involvement. In anticipation of evidence-based recommendations, an international panel of physicians with expertise in Fabry disease has proposed guidelines for the recognition, evaluation, and surveillance of disease-associated morbidities, as well as therapeutic strategies, including enzyme replacement and other adjunctive therapies, to optimize patient outcomes.

Diagnosis and management of kidney involvement in Fabry disease

Interest in the diagnosis and treatment of Fabry disease has been greatly stimulated by the availability of Food and Drug Administration-approved, effective enzyme replacement therapy. This review will update the progress in this area since enzyme replacement therapy has become available. Fabry disease is often associated with proteinuric chronic kidney disease (CKD), and it appears that the treatment paradigms that have proven to be so effective in diabetes mellitus and other forms of proteinuric kidney disease are also effective in conjunction with enzyme replacement therapy for treating the kidney manifestations of Fabry disease. As such, Fabry disease represents an interesting example of progressive proteinuric kidney disease in which the usual blood pressure is lower than in other forms of CKD. This makes the use of effective antiproteinuric therapy challenging, especially considering the autonomic dysfunction that appears to be part of the disease. Comprehensive therapy for Fabry disease includes enzyme replacement therapy and all of the adjunctive therapies that are currently used to treat all forms of proteinuric CKD. It is anticipated that this approach will preserve kidney function and also benefit the cardiac and cerebrovascular systems in patients with Fabry disease.

An asymptomatic heterozygous female with fabry disease: implications for enzyme replacement therapy

We report an asymptomatic female with Fabry disease immunohistochemically diagnosed by renal biopsy. She was initially diagnosed as having nephrotic syndrome, and renal biopsy was performed for pathological diagnosis. The renal specimen revealed non-specific findings (minor glomerular abnormalities) for nephrotic syndrome. Numerous laminated bodies in glomerular epithelial cells in electron microscopic findings and accumulations of ceramidetrihexoside immunohistochemically were observed and she was diagnosed with Fabry disease. However, no other laboratory data or clinical findings supported the diagnosis of Fabry disease. Since the efficacy of recombinant human alpha-galactosidase replacement therapy in this disease has been reported, whether enzyme replacement therapy for subclinical Fabry female patients is indicated or not is an important issue.

Fabry disease: diagnosis and management, with emphasis on the renal manifestations

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Interest in the diagnosis and treatment of Fabry disease has been greatly stimulated by the availability of Food and Drug Administration-approved, effective enzyme-replacement therapy. This review will update the progress in this area over the last 18 months that effective enzyme-replacement therapy has become available.

RECENT FINDINGS

Fabry disease is often associated with proteinuric chronic kidney disease, and it appears that the treatment paradigms that have proven to be so effective in diabetes mellitus and other forms of proteinuric renal disease are also effective, in conjunction with enzyme-replacement therapy for treating the renal manifestations of Fabry disease. As such, Fabry disease represents an interesting example of progressive proteinuric renal disease in which the usual blood pressure is lower than in other renal diseases. This makes the use of effective anti-proteinuric therapy challenging, especially considering the autonomic dysfunction that appears to be part of the disease. Recent advances are considered in this review, with emphasis on the role of kidney biopsy, effective dosing and maximal comprehensive therapy of Fabry disease.

SUMMARY

Maximal, comprehensive therapy for Fabry disease includes effective enzyme-replacement therapy and all of the adjunctive therapies that are currently used to treat all forms of proteinuric chronic kidney disease. It is anticipated that this approach will preserve kidney function and also benefit the cardiac and cerebrovascular systems in patients with Fabry disease.

Monitoring the 3-year efficacy of enzyme replacement therapy in fabry disease by repeated skin biopsies

The earliest clinical signs of Fabry disease often manifest as dermatologic disturbances such as angiokeratomata, hypohidrosis, acroparesthesias, and impaired thermal and vibration detection. These disturbances are caused by cellular globotriaosylceramide accumulation in the skin due to deficient lysosomal alpha-galactosidase A activity. In this histologic study, we analyzed pre- and post-treatment dermatologic biopsies from 58 Fabry patients enrolled in a 5 mo, Phase 3 double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial followed by a 30 mo open label extension study of recombinant human alpha-galactosidase A (r-halphaGalA), administered i.v. at 1 mg per kg every 2 wk. Baseline evaluations revealed globotriaosylceramide in multiple dermal cell types (vascular endothelial cells, vascular smooth muscle cells, perineurium). Five months of r-halphaGalA treatment in the Phase 3 trial resulted in complete clearance of globotriaosylceramide from the superficial capillary endothelium in all treatment patients and in only 1 (3%) placebo patient (p<0.001). The placebo group achieved similar results after 6 mo of r-halphaGalA in the open label trial. The capillary endothelium remained free of globotriaosylceramide for up to 30 mo into the extension study among 39 of 40 (98%) patients who underwent biopsies. Globotriaosylceramide clearance from deep vascular endothelial cells was similarly robust. Vascular smooth muscle cells and perineurium demonstrated moderate clearance. These findings suggest that long-term treatment with r-halphaGalA may halt the progression of pathology and prevent the dermatologic disturbances in Fabry patients, and that periodic dermal biopsies can serve as a reliable monitor of sustained efficacy.

AAV2 Vector Harboring a Liver-Restricted Promoter Facilitates Sustained Expression of Therapeutic Levels of α-Galactosidase A and the Induction of Immune Tolerance in Fabry Mice

The successful application of gene therapy for the treatment of genetic diseases such as Fabry is reliant on the development of vectors that are safe and that facilitate sustained expression of therapeutic levels of the transgene product. Here, we report that intravenous administration of a recombinant AAV2 vector encoding human alpha-galactosidase A under the transcriptional control of a liver-restricted enhancer/promoter (AAV2/DC190-alphagal) generated significantly higher levels of expression in BALB/c and Fabry mice than could be realized using the ubiquitous CMV promoter (AAV2/CMVHI-alphagal). Moreover, AAV2/DC190-alphagal-mediated hepatic expression of alpha-galactosidase A was sustained for 12 months in BALB/c mice and was associated with a significantly reduced immune response to the expressed enzyme. Subsequent challenge of the AAV2/DC190-alphagal-treated animals with recombinant human alpha-galactosidase A at 6 months failed to elicit the production of anti-alpha-galactosidase A antibodies, suggesting the induction of immune tolerance in these animals. The levels of expression attained with AAV2/DC190-alphagal in the Fabry mice were sufficient to reduce the abnormal accumulation of globotriaosylceramide in the liver, spleen, and heart to basal levels and in the kidney by approximately 40% at 8 weeks. Together, these results demonstrate that AAV2-mediated gene transfer that limits the expression of alpha-galactosidase A to the liver may be a viable strategy for treating Fabry disease.

Sisters with atypical Fabry's disease with complete atrioventricular block

A 56 year old woman with severe right heart failure and complete atrioventricular block was referred to hospital for further examination. Symptoms and signs suggestive of Fabry's disease, such as corneal opacities, acroparaesthesias, hypohidrosis, and angiokeratoma, were not noted. Echocardiography showed a diffuse hypertrophic left ventricular wall and paradoxical movement of the interventricular septum. Cardiac catheterisation showed restrictive-type ventricular dysfunction. Left ventricular endomyocardial biopsy showed central vacuolar degeneration of myocytes with inclusion bodies, which had a concentric lamellar configuration under electron microscopy. This finding is specific for Fabry's disease. The patient's elder sister had experienced an almost identical clinical course and histological findings of myocardial cells on necropsy. In conclusion, two sisters were encountered displaying interesting cases of atypical Fabry's disease. Symptoms began with complete atrioventricular block and histological myocardial findings were specific for Fabry's disease.

Globotriaosylceramide accumulation in the Fabry kidney is cleared from multiple cell types after enzyme replacement therapy

BACKGROUND

Fabry disease, a lysosomal storage disease caused by deficient lysosomal alpha-galactosidase A activity, is characterized by globotriaosylceramide (GL-3) accumulation in multiple cell types, particularly the vasculature, leading to end organ failure. Accumulation in the kidney is responsible for progressive decline in renal function in male patients with the classical phenotype, resulting in renal failure in their third to fifth decades of life. With the advent of recombinant protein synthesis technology, enzyme replacement therapy has become a viable alternative to dialysis or renal transplantation, previously the only available treatment options for end-stage renal disease.

METHODS

The pre- and post-treatment renal biopsies were analyzed from fifty-eight Fabry patients enrolled in a Phase 3 double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial followed by a six-month open label extension study of the recombinant human enzyme, alpha-galactosidase A (r-halphaGalA), administered IV at 1 mg/kg biweekly. The purpose of this investigation was to detail the pathologic changes in glycosphingolipid distribution and the pattern of post-treatment clearance in the kidney.

RESULTS

Baseline evaluations revealed GL-3 accumulations in nearly all renal cell types including vascular endothelial cells, vascular smooth muscle cells, mesangial cells and interstitial cells, with particularly dense accumulations in podocytes and distal tubular epithelial cells. After 11 months of r-halphaGalA treatment there was complete clearance of glycolipid from the endothelium of all vasculature as well as from the mesangial cells of the glomerulus and interstitial cells of the cortex. Moderate clearance was noted from the smooth muscle cells of arterioles and small arteries. Podocytes and distal tubular epithelium also demonstrated evidence for decreased GL-3, although this clearance was more limited than that observed in other cell types. No evidence of immune complex disease was found by immunofluorescence despite circulating anti-r-halphaGalA IgG antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings indicate a striking reversal of renal glycosphingolipid accumulation in the vasculature and in other renal cell types, and suggest that long-term treatment with r-halphaGalA may halt the progression of pathology and prevent renal failure in patients with Fabry disease.

Angiokeratoma corporis diffusum (Anderson-Fabry's disease): a case report

We report on a 14-year-old boy who presented with a 4-year history of acral pains and febrile episodes. On physical examination, numerous small reddish papules were present on his abdomen, located predominantly on the periumbelical region. Renal function was within normal limits. Ophthalmological examination revealed whorled opacities of the cornea (cornea verticillata) and dilated tortuous conjunctival vessels. Histopathological examination of one of the cutaneous papules showed several dilated blood vessels in the superficial dermis surrounded by collarettes of thickened rete ridges, consistent with a diagnosis of angiokeratoma. The electron-microscopic study of a skin specimen demonstrated the presence of dilated lysosomes with deposition of electron-dense bodies, some of which with laminated structure, in endothelial cells and fibroblasts. These findings were regarded as indicative of Fabry's disease. Subsequent biochemical analysis confirmed the presence of a alpha-galactosidase A deficiency in leukocytes. In conclusion, we described the clinical, histopathological and submicroscopic findings of a case of Fabry's disease, in which the combination of electron microscopic and biochemical approaches allowed the correct diagnosis.

Uneven X inactivation in a female monozygotic twin pair with Fabry disease and discordant expression of a novel mutation in the alpha-galactosidase A gene

We describe two female monozygotic (MZ) twins heterozygous for Fabry disease, an X linked disorder resulting from the deficient activity of alpha-galactosidase A. While one of the twins was clinically affected, the other was asymptomatic. Enzymatic assay of alpha-galactosidase in blood leucocytes, skin fibroblasts, Epstein-Barr virus transformed lymphoid cell lines, and hair follicles of the twins and their parents confirmed the heterozygous status of the twins and indicated that Fabry disease had occurred as a result of a de novo mutation. The son of the unaffected twin sister was shown to be hemizygous. Molecular analysis of the alpha-galactosidase A gene permitted the identification of an as yet undescribed point mutation at position 10182 of exon 5 which causes an Asp to Asn substitution at codon 231. Single strand conformation polymorphism (SSCP) analysis again showed the heterozygous status of the twins and a normal pattern in their parents. The basis for the discordant expression of this d novo mutation in the twins was investigated by studying their X inactivation status. Analysis of the inactive X specific methylation at the androgen receptor gene showed unbalanced inactivation in the twins' fibroblasts and in opposite directions. While the maternally derived X chromosome was preferentially active in the asymptomatic twin, the paternal X chromosome was active in the other, affected twin and was found in her hemizygotic nephew. These data suggest that the paternal X chromosome carries the de novo alpha-galactosidase A mutation and that uneven X inactivation is the underlying mechanism for disease expression in this novel female MZ twin pair. This is the first documented case of female twins discordant for Fabry disease.

MZ female twins discordant for X-linked diseases: a review

The 20 reported cases of MZ female twins discordant for X-linked diseases are reviewed. In such twins the X-inactivation pattern is opposite skewing (abnormal allele inactivated in most cells of the normal twin, and normal allele inactivated in most cells of the affected twin) or skewing in one twin and random in the cotwin. The diseases involved map in two specific regions: Xq27-28 and Xp21. The only exceptions are Fabry's disease and Aicardi's syndrome, which map in Xq22 and Xp22 respectively. No concordant MZ female carrier twins, either normal or affected, have been described. Three main hypotheses have been proposed to explain such characteristics [2, 5, 14], but none is completely satisfactory. The constant discordance for X-linked diseases in MZ female twins has important consequences for genetic counselling.

X inactivation patterns in female monozygotic twins and their families

X inactivation studies have been carried out on 22 pairs of female monozygotic twins, one set of female monozygotic triplets, and their mothers and singleton sisters, using the probe M27 beta. Forty-eight per cent of the twins, 55% of their mothers, and 42% of their singleton sisters showed skewed X inactivation. Two of the triplets and their mother had random X inactivation, while the third triplet showed skewed X inactivation. Their singleton sister was homozygous with M27 beta. Of the twins, six pairs showed skewed X inactivation in favour of the same X chromosome, one pair showed skewed X inactivation favouring opposite X chromosomes, in seven pairs one twin showed skewed X inactivation while her co-twin showed random X inactivation, and in eight pairs both twins were random. A higher frequency of skewed pattern of X inactivation was not observed in the monozygotic twins when compared to a series of non-twin females (mothers and singleton sisters) and, so, the results in this study do not lend support to the theory that skewed X inactivation predisposes to the twinning process.