Early cervical neoplasia confirmed by conization: diagnostic accuracy of cytology, colposcopy and punch biopsy

Correlation between referral cytology and in-house colposcopy-guided cytology for detecting early cervical neoplasia

PURPOSE

The current cervical cancer screening program in Germany recommends that the results showing suspected HPV infection should be further examined in specialized colposcopy units. This study aimed to correlate externally documented Pap smear results with in-house colposcopy-guided Pap cytology results and compare colposcopy-guided biopsy and postoperative histopathology results.

METHODS

Clinical data were analyzed from 3627 examinations in 2844 patients who visited a university certified dysplasia unit from 2014 to 2017; 2212 patients underwent complete assessments, including Pap smear, colposcopy, HPV testing, colposcopy-guided biopsy, and/or surgery. The results were analyzed descriptively.

RESULTS

External and in-house Pap results were consistent in 1054 ofthe 2212 patients (47.65%). Referral cytology showed a higher grade than in-house in 456 (20.61%) and a lower grade in 702 (31.74%). Using the histopathological findings as the gold standard, overdiagnosis in the referral cytology was noted in 180 patients (13.19%), underdiagnosis in 263 (19.27%), and concordant findings in 922 (67.55%). For in-house cytology, overdiagnosis was found in 133 patients (10.74%), underdiagnosis in 192 (15.51%), and accurate diagnosis with congruent cytology and histopathology findings in 913 (73.75%).

CONCLUSIONS

The rate of detection of cervical abnormalities differs significantly depending on whether the examination is performed routinely or in specialized units. Colposcopy-guided Pap smears correlate significantly better with histology than referral cytology results without colposcopic guidance. More severe lesions were also detected more accurately.

Accuracy of colposcopy-directed biopsy in detecting early cervical neoplasia: a retrospective study

PURPOSE

Colposcopy-directed biopsy is a cornerstone method for diagnosing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia. The aim of this study was to evaluate the accuracy of colposcopy-directed biopsy in comparison with definitive surgery.

METHODS

The accuracy of colposcopy-directed biopsy was compared with the final histology in relation to different types of transformation zone (TZ), the patient's age, and the examiner's level of training.

RESULTS

The overall accuracy of biopsy in comparison with definitive surgery was 71.9% for all entities-benign lesions, low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions, high-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (HSILs), and cervical carcinoma-with an underdiagnosis rate of 11.8% and an overdiagnosis rate of 16.5%. The accuracy for detecting HSIL was 88% (401/455), with an underdiagnosis rate of 10.5% and overdiagnosis rate of 1.3%. The accuracy rates for detecting HSIL in women with TZ 1, TZ 2, or TZ 3 were 92.2, 90.5, and 76.5%, respectively. The accuracy rates for detecting HSIL in the different age groups were 93.1% (age 0-34), 83.6% (age 34-55), and 80% (age 55 or older).

CONCLUSIONS

A combination of the colposcopic findings, cytology, human papillomavirus testing, and colposcopy-directed biopsy is necessary for the correct diagnosis of HSIL. The accuracy rate depends on the TZ and the patient's age. The examiner's level of training does not have any substantial influence on the accuracy.

Is cervical punch biopsy enough for the management of low-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia?

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to analyze the correlation between the histopathologic results of excisional procedure and cervical punch biopsy and to investigate the accuracy rates of colposcopic punch biopsy and cervical cytology to detect cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) grade 2 and/or more severe lesions (CIN 2+).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two hundred six patients who underwent excisional procedure in the gynecologic oncology clinic of the Zeynep Kamil Women and Children Diseases Education and Research Hospital between 2004 and 2011 were enrolled in a retrospective study.

RESULTS

The correlation between the pathologic findings gained by excisional procedure and punch biopsy was weak ( p = .0001, κ = 0.03). The overall concordance rate between the pathologic findings of cervical biopsy and excisional procedure was 57.29%. The rates of detecting more severe lesions by excisional procedure when compared to biopsies (biopsy underestimation) were 71.42%, 22.91%, 37.03%, and 12.72% for biopsy results with negative, CIN 1, CIN 2, and CIN 3/adenocarcinoma in situ lesions, respectively. Similarly, the rates of less severe lesions diagnosed by excisional procedure when compared to biopsies (biopsy overestimation) were 29.16%, 40.74%, and 15.45% for biopsy results with CIN 1, CIN 2, and CIN 3/adenocarcinoma in situ lesions, respectively. The rate of CIN 2+ lesions after excisional procedure in cases with previous biopsy results with either negative or CIN 1 was 27.27%.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggested that colposcopy-directed biopsy was neither a good diagnostic nor a reliable management method. We think that the indications of conization should be enlarged to avoid overlooking high-grade lesions.

Transepithelial sampling of the uterine ectocervix with a stiff-bristled, spiral-shaped brush

OBJECTIVE

To measure the depth of sampling of the uterine ectocervix with the use of a stiff-bristled, spiral-shaped brush (SpiraBrush Cx; Trylon Corporation, Torrance, CA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Eligible hysterectomy specimens were identified. The ectocervix was brushed with an inked SpiraBrush Cx in four quadrants with either light (gentle) or heavy (forceful) pressure. The depth of sampling was determined histologically.

RESULTS

Four normal uteri were sampled a total of 15 times. The entire epithelium was removed to the epithelial-stromal junction in three specimens and in one sample only a few basal cells remained with light pressure. The depth of sampling ranged from 0.2 mm to 0.4 mm. Heavy pressure resulted in the entire removal of epithelium in six samples, with the depth of sampling ranging from 0.2 mm to 0.7 mm. The stroma was disrupted in one sample. Results were uninformative in five samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Sampling of the uterine ectocervix with the SpiraBrush Cx seems to be transepithelial in most cases.

Molecular detection of human papillomavirus in women with minor-grade cervical cytology abnormalities

BACKGROUND

Human papillomavirus (HPV) has been shown to be the major risk factor for the development of cervical carcinoma, the second most common cancer among women worldwide. Cervical cytology has been the main screening tool for detection of premalignant lesions in last 50 years.

OBJECTIVE

The utility of a molecular assay for detection of HPV in cervical smears was evaluated.

STUDY DESIGN

A total of 466 women with minor-grade cervical cytology abnormality supposed to be produced by HPV were included. Patients were classified into three groups: Patients with reactive changes, patients with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 1 (CIN 1), and patients with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia grade 2 (CIN 2). In all patients, another cervical swab was obtained and tested for the HPV genome using the Digene Hybrid Capture II. This assay is able to distinguish between high-risk and low-risk HPV types.

RESULTS

Based on cytology results, 44 patients showed reactive changes, 250 patients displayed CIN 1, and 172 patients displayed CIN 2. With the molecular assay, HPV was detected in 289/466 (62%) patients. The high-risk HPV type was present in 263 (56.4%) patients and the low-risk type in 26 (5,5%) patients. In 25% of patients with reactive changes, the HPV genome was detected. Corresponding rates for patients with CIN 1 and CIN 2 were 55 and 81%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Molecular detection of HPV should additionally be used to cytology in patients whose cervical smears display reactive changes, CIN 1, or CIN 2. The employed assay allows identification of patients who are at risk for development of high-grade cervical lesions.

[Conization with positive margins: what strategy should be adopted?]

OBJECTIVE

To define recommended treatment in cases of positive margins on cone biopsy specimens.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This single-center retrospective study concerned 220 conizations performed between January 1996 and June 1998. The results of 70 conizations (31.8%) with positive margins were analysed. There were 32 cold knife conizations (mean age: 43 years) and 38 conizations by the loop electrosurgical excision procedure (mean age: 33 years).

RESULTS

Mean depth of conization was 15.94 mm for cold knife conization and 10.08 mm for loop electrosurgical conization. Fifteen patients were excluded (5 with invasive cancer and 10 were lost to follow-up). This study included 55 patients with a mean 12-month follow-up. Six underwent hysterectomy for mini-invasion on the specimen or advanced age. Eleven underwent a second conization (followed by hysterectomy in 2 cases). The other 38 patients were submitted to simple surveillance with cervico-vaginal cytology and colposcopic examination. The rate of residual lesions (cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia: CIN 3) after conization with positive margin was 14.5% (n = 8).

CONCLUSION

Residual persistent dysplasia is not present in all patients after conization with positive margins. Cytology and colposcopy allow detection of dysplasia, indicating the need for a second conization. In women with no desire for further pregnancy, systematic repeat surgery must be recommended.

Completeness of excision and follow up cytology in patients treated with loop excision biopsy

AIMS

To assess the relation between the grade and the status of follow up cytology, the completeness of loop excision biopsies with cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN), and the findings at follow up cytology, as well as the differences between complete and incomplete exclusion, using the odds ratio. Treatment failure was assessed.

METHODS

1600 women with CIN (290 CIN1, 304 CIN2, 1006 CIN3) were followed for a minimum of six months and a maximum of 10 years. A database was created and comparisons performed. The mean age of the patients was 37 years.

RESULTS

Excision was complete in over 84% of loops. Residual disease and recurrence of high grade dyskaryosis was more common in women with CIN 3 than CIN 2 or 1. No high grade dyskaryosis was seen in the fifth follow up smear in patients with CIN 1 and CIN 2. Residual, recurrent, and persistent disease was most common in patients with incompletely excised CIN at ectocervical and endocervical margins and deep margins of resection than in patients with completely excised CIN. The odds ratios were significantly higher in the women who had incomplete excision of CIN at ectocervical, endocervical, both ecto- and endocervical, and deep margins of resection compared with those with apparent complete excision of CIN lesions. One patient developed invasive squamous cell carcinoma 44 months after loop excision which showed CIN 3 invading endocervical crypts and extending to both ectocervical and endocervical margins of resection.

CONCLUSIONS

At long term follow up, patients with CIN who have residual disease are at increased risk of persistent disease and should therefore be followed up regularly with cytology and colposcopy. The findings support national policy of returning women with treated CIN of any grade to normal recall after five years except for cases of CIN3 where excision was incomplete or equivocal. In these cases follow up with annual smear for 10 years is recommended.

Human papillomavirus (HPV) in high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) detected by morphology and polymerase chain reaction (PCR)-- a cytohistologic correlation of 277 cases treated by laser conization

The aims of this study were to evaluate the cytohistologic correlation in women treated for high-grade lesions of the cervix uteri (HG CIN), to assess the distribution of HPV features and finally to test the validity of the morphological criteria of HPV infection. The smears and biopsy specimens from 277 women treated for HG CIN by laser conization were re-evaluated blindly. Tissue blocks (n = 188) and 52 archival smears were examined for HPV DNA using PCR. HPV changes were detected with equal frequency in the smears and biopsy specimens by light microscopy; 63% and 65%, respectively. The prevalence of HPV DNA in biopsies was 88% and in archival smears 85%; agreement was found in 89% of the cases. Using PCR as the gold standard, we found a sensitivity of 63% for cytology and 70% for histology; the specificity was 41% and 37%, respectively. The positive predictive value was > 80%, but the negative predictive value was < 20%. Our study confirms that HPV features are frequently associated with HG CIN and that morphology is a non-specific method of identifying HPV infection and should be followed by PCR, also allowing detection of oncogenic HPV types and latent infections.