Letter by Nieminen et al regarding article, "Differential impact of blood pressure-lowering drugs on central aortic pressure and clinical outcomes: principal results of the Conduit Artery Function Evaluation (CAFE) study"

Different associations between beta-blockers and other antihypertensive medication combinations with brachial blood pressure and aortic waveform parameters

BACKGROUND

Comparing the relationships of antihypertensive medications with brachial blood pressure (BP) and aortic waveform parameters may help clinicians to predict the effect on the latter in brachial BP-based antihypertensive therapy. We aimed to make such comparisons with new waveform measures and a wider range of antihypertensive regimens than examined previously.

METHODS

Cross-sectional analysis of 2933 adults (61% male; aged 50-84years): 1637 on antihypertensive treatment and 1296 untreated hypertensives. Sixteen medicine regimens of up to 4 combinations of drugs from 6 antihypertensive classes were analysed. Aortic systolic BP, augmentation index (AIx), excess pressure integral (EPI), backward pressure amplitude (Pb), reflection index (RI) and pulse wave velocity (PWV) were calculated from aortic pressure waveforms derived from suprasystolic brachial measurement.

RESULTS

Forest plots of single-drug class comparisons across regimens with the same number of drugs (for between 1- and 3-drug regimens) revealed that AIx, Pb, RI and/or loge(EPI) were higher (maximum difference=5.6%, 2.2mmHg, 0.0192 and 0.13 loge(mmHg⋅s), respectively) with the use of a beta-blocker compared with vasodilators and diuretics, despite no brachial systolic and diastolic BP differences. These differences were reduced (by 34-57%) or eliminated after adjustment for heart rate, and similar effects occurred when controlling for systolic ejection period or diastolic duration.

CONCLUSIONS

Beta-blocker effects on brachial BP may overestimate effects on aortic waveform parameters. Compared to other antihypertensives, beta-blockers have weaker associations with wave reflection measures and EPI; this is predominantly due to influences on heart rate.

Effect of beta blockers on central aortic pressure in African-Americans

The objective of this study was to evaluate the vascular effects of heart rate (HR) reduction with BB therapy in African Americans (AA). Beta-blockers (BB) offer less cardiovascular protection than other hypertensive drugs. Studies of Caucasian subjects suggest this may be due to an adverse effect of HR lowering on arterial wave reflection. We studied 506 subjects (age 63 ± 14 years, 52% were treated with BB). Central systolic (C-SBP) and pulse pressure (C-PP), augmented pressure (AP), and augmentation index (AI) were obtained via applanation tonometry (Sphygmocor). On univariate analysis, HR correlated inversely with BB use, C-SBP, AP, and AI (all P < .001), but not P-SBP. Multivariate analysis showed P-SBP and HR to be major determinants of C-SBP (R(2) = 0.95). Generalized linear model analysis showed higher C-SBP (P < .05) and C-PP (P = .04), but similar P-SBP (P = .24) in the BB group. After HR adjustment, differences in C-SBP, C-PP, AI, and AP were attenuated, suggesting HR to be a determinant of C-SBP. BB use is associated with higher C-SBP and lower PPA in hypertensive AA despite similar P-SBP. C-SBP is HR-dependent. HR reduction with BB accounts for less effective central blood pressure control in AA, similar to that reported in Caucasians.