Spectral dependence of the seawater-air radiance transmission coefficient

Transfer model to determine the above-water remote-sensing reflectance from the underwater remote-sensing ratio

Remote-sensing reflectance, R_rs(λ, θ, Δϕ, θ_s), contains the spectral color information of the water body below the sea surface and is a fundamental parameter to derive satellite ocean color products such as chlorophyll-a, diffuse light attenuation, or inherent optical properties. Water reflectance, i.e., spectral upwelling radiance, normalized by the downwelling irradiance, can be measured under- or above-water. Several models to extrapolate this ratio from underwater "remote-sensing ratio", r_rs(λ), to the above-water R_rs, have been proposed in previous studies, in which the spectral dependency of water refractive index and off-nadir viewing directions have not been considered in detail. Based on measured inherent optical properties of natural waters and radiative transfer simulations, this study proposes a new transfer model to spectrally determine R_rs from r_rs for different sun-viewing geometries and environmental conditions. It is shown that, compared to previous models, ignoring spectral dependency leads to a bias of ∼2.4% at shorter wavelengths (∼400 nm), which is avoidable. If nadir-viewing models are used, the typical 40°-off nadir viewing geometry will introduce a difference of ∼5% in R_rs estimation. When the solar zenith angle is higher than 60°, these differences of R_rs have implications for the downstream retrievals of ocean color products, e.g., > 8% difference for phytoplankton absorption at 440 nm and >4% difference for backward particle scattering at 440 nm by the quasi-analytical algorithm (QAA). These findings demonstrate that the proposed r_rs-to-R_rs model is applicable to a wide range of measurement conditions and provides more accurate estimates of R_rs than previous models.

Australian aquatic bio-optical dataset with applications for satellite calibration, algorithm development and validation

The authors present bio-optical data spanning 316 sets of observations made at 34 inland waterbodies in Australia. The data was collected over the period 2013–2021 and comprise radiometric measurements of remote sensing reflectance (Rrs), diffuse attenuation extinction coefficient (Kd); optical backscattering; absorption of coloured dissolved organic matter (aCDOM), phytoplankton (aph) and non-algal particles (aNAP); HPLC analysis of algal pigments including chlorophyll-a (CHL-a); organic and inorganic total suspended solids (TSS); and total and dissolved organic carbon concentration. Data collection has been timed to coincide with either Landsat 8 or Sentinel-2 overpasses. The dataset covers a diverse range of optical water types and is suitable for algorithm development, satellite calibration and validation as well as machine learning applications.

Experimental analysis of the measurement precision of spectral water-leaving radiance in different water types: comment

This work aims at commenting requirements and conclusions in a recent paper [Wei et al., Opt. Express29, 2780 (2021)10.1364/OE.413784] presenting an evaluation of the precision of water-leaving radiance measurements from a near-surface method. Specifically, this work challenges the uncertainty requirements indicated for satellite ocean color system vicarious calibration resulting from an erroneous interpretation of literature, and an incorrect application of radiometry principles leading to a misestimate of the difference between radiances collected by nadir-view optical sensors operated below and above the water surface.

Experimental analysis of the measurement precision of spectral water-leaving radiance in different water types

The on-water radiometric approach employs a unique provision to obtain water-leaving radiance from nadir (Lw(λ)) which can be used for the calibration of ocean color satellites. In this effort, we address the measurement precision associated with Lw(λ) from a single on-water instrument, which is an important aspect of measurement uncertainty. First, we estimated the precision as the ratio of the standard deviation of the means of repeated measurements to the mean of these measurements. We show that the measurement precision for Lw(λ) is within 2.7-3.7% over 360-700 nm. The corresponding remote sensing reflectance spectra (Rrs(λ)) from the same instrument also exhibit a high precision of 1.9-2.8% in the same spectral domain. These measured precisions of radiance and reflectance over the 360-700 nm range are independent of the optical water type. Second, we quantified the consistency of on-water Lw(λ) and Rrs(λ) from two collocated systems for further insight into their measurement repeatability. The comparison reveals that Lw(λ) measurements in the 360-700 nm agree with each other with an absolute percentage difference of less than 3.5%. The corresponding Rrs(λ) data pairs are subjected to increased differences of up to 8.5%, partly due to variable irradiance measurements (Es(λ)). The evaluation of measurement precision corroborates the reliability of the on-water acquisition of radiometric data for supporting satellite calibration and validation.

European Radiometry Buoy and Infrastructure (EURYBIA): A Contribution to the Design of the European Copernicus Infrastructure for Ocean Colour System Vicarious Calibration

In the context of the Copernicus Program, EUMETSAT prioritizes the creation of an ocean color infrastructure for system vicarious calibration (OC-SVC). This work aims to reply to this need by proposing the European Radiometry Buoy and Infrastructure (EURYBIA). EURYBIA is designed as an autonomous European infrastructure operating within the Marine Optical Network (MarONet) established by University of Miami (Miami, FL, USA) based on the Marine Optical Buoy (MOBY) experience and NASA support. MarONet addresses SVC requirements in different sites, consistently and in a traceable way. The selected EURYBIA installation is close to the Lampedusa Island in the central Mediterranean Sea. This area is widely studied and hosts an Atmospheric and Oceanographic Observatory for long-term climate monitoring. The EURYBIA field segment comprises off-shore and on-shore infrastructures to manage the observation system and perform routine sensors calibrations. The ground segment includes the telemetry center for data communication and the processing center to compute data products and uncertainty budgets. The study shows that the overall uncertainty of EURYBIA SVC gains computed for the Sentinel-3 OLCI mission under EUMETSAT protocols is of about 0.05% in the blue-green wavelengths after a decade of measurements, similar to that of the reference site in Hawaii and in compliance with requirements for climate studies.

On the equivalence of near-surface methods to determine the water-leaving radiance

The equivalence of two radiometric methods relying on a single nadir-view optical sensor to determine the water-leaving radiance L_W, namely the Single Depth Approach (SDA) and the Sky-Blocked Approach (SBA), was investigated applying identical hyperspectral radiometers operated on the same deployment platform. Values of L_W from SDA and SBA measurements performed in the Black Sea across a variety of waters during ideal illumination conditions and with low-to-slight sea state, exhibited mean absolute differences within 0.5% in the blue-green spectral region and 2% in the red. This result, benefitting of a comprehensive parameterization of optical processes in combination with the characterization of sensors non-linearity, in-water response and reproducibility of absolute radiometric calibrations, indicated ample equivalence of the two near-surface methods in terms of performance and data reduction needs.

A Review of Protocols for Fiducial Reference Measurements of WaterLeaving Radiance for Validation of Satellite Remote-Sensing Data over Water

This paper reviews the state of the art of protocols for measurement of waterleaving radiance in the context of fiducial reference measurements (FRM) of water reflectance for satellite validation. Measurement of water reflectance requires the measurement of waterleaving radiance and downwelling irradiance just above water. For the former there are four generic families of method, based on: 1) underwater radiometry at fixed depths; or 2) underwater radiometry with vertical profiling; or 3) abovewater radiometry with skyglint correction; or 4) onwater radiometry with skylight blocked. Each method is described generically in the FRM context with reference to the measurement equation, documented implementations and the intramethod diversity of deployment platform and practice. Ideal measurement conditions are stated, practical recommendations are provided on best practice and guidelines for estimating the measurement uncertainty are provided for each protocolrelated component of the measurement uncertainty budget. The state of the art for measurement of waterleaving radiance is summarized, future perspectives are outlined, and the question of which method is best adapted to various circumstances (water type, wavelength) is discussed. This review is based on practice and papers of the aquatic optics community for the validation of water reflectance estimated from satellite data but can be relevant also for other applications such as the development or validation of algorithms for remote-sensing estimation of water constituents including chlorophyll a concentration, inherent optical properties and related products.