Exclusion of expansion of 50 CAG/CTG trinucleotide repeats in bipolar disorder

Anticipation and repeat expansion in bipolar disorder

Anticipation is the phenomenon whereby a disease becomes more severe and/or presents with earlier onset as it is transmitted down through generations of a family. The only known mechanism for true anticipation is a class of mutations containing repetitive sequences exemplified by the pathogenic trinucleotide repeat. Studies of bipolar disorder (BPD) are consistent with the presence of anticipation and, by inference, the possibility that trinucleotide repeats contribute to this disorder, although it is possible that these data are the result of methodological problems. On the assumption that anticipation in BPD may be real, several surveys of the genome of BPD probands for large trinucleotide repeats have been conducted, as have studies of many repeat-containing candidate genes. No pathogenic triplet repeat has yet been unambiguously implicated.

The unstable trinucleotide repeat story of major psychosis

New hopes for cloning susceptibility genes for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder followed the discovery of a novel type of DNA mutation, namely unstable DNA. One class of unstable DNA, trinucleotide repeat expansion, is the causal mutation in myotonic dystrophy, fragile X mental retardation, Huntington disease and a number of other rare Mendelian neurological disorders. This finding has led researchers in psychiatric genetics to search for unstable DNA sites as susceptibility factors for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder. Increased severity and decreased age at onset of disease in successive generations, known as genetic anticipation, was reported for undifferentiated psychiatric diseases and for myotonic dystrophy early in the twentieth century, but was initially dismissed as the consequence of ascertainment bias. Because unstable DNA was demonstrated to be a molecular substrate for genetic anticipation in the majority of trinucleotide repeat diseases including myotonic dystrophy, many recent studies looking for genetic anticipation have been performed for schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder with surprisingly consistent positive results. These studies are reviewed, with particular emphasis placed on relevant sampling and statistical considerations, and concerns are raised regarding the interpretation of such studies. In parallel, molecular genetic investigations looking for evidence of trinucleotide repeat expansion in both schizophrenia and bipolar disorder are reviewed. Initial studies of genome-wide trinucleotide repeats using the repeat expansion detection technique suggested possible association of large CAG/CTG repeat tracts with schizophrenia and bipolar affective disorder. More recently, three loci have been identified that contain large, unstable CAG/CTG repeats that occur frequently in the population and seem to account for the majority of large products identified using the repeat expansion detection method. These repeats localize to an intron in transcription factor gene SEF2-1B at 18q21, a site named ERDA1 on 17q21 with no associated coding region, and the 3' end of a gene on 13q21, SCA8, that is believed to be responsible for a form of spinocerebellar ataxia. At present no strong evidence exists that large repeat alleles at either SEF2-1B or ERDA1 are involved in the etiology of schizophrenia or bipolar disorder. Preliminary evidence suggests that large repeat alleles at SCA8 that are non-penetrant for ataxia may be a susceptibility factor for major psychosis. A fourth, but much more infrequently unstable CAG/CTG repeat has been identified within the 5' untranslated region of the gene, MAB21L1, on 13q13. A fifth CAG/CTG repeat locus has been identified within the coding region of an ion transporter, KCNN3 (hSKCa3), on 1q21. Although neither large alleles nor instability have been observed at KCNN3, this repeat locus has been extensively analyzed in association and family studies of major psychosis, with conflicting findings. Studies of polyglutamine containing genes in major psychosis have also shown some intriguing results. These findings, reviewed here, suggest that, although a major role for unstable trinucleotides in psychosis is unlikely, involvement at a more modest level in a minority of cases cannot be excluded, and warrants further investigation.

Triplet repeats and bipolar disorder

Anticipation, the phenomenon of a disease becoming more severe or having earlier onset as it is transmitted down the generations, was originally described in families with psychiatric illness but was thought due to ascertainment bias and became forgotten. Interest was rekindled when a number of neurodegenerative disorders that show this phenomenon, were found to be due to a novel form of mutation--unstable triplet repeats showing intergenerational expansion. Some recent studies of anticipation are consistent with its occurrence in bipolar disorder but are still associated with methodological problems making interpretation difficult. A number of case-control studies employing the repeat expansion detection (RED) technique have found longer repeats in bipolar probands but other studies have found no such association. Despite a large number of studies examining the role of various repeat containing candidate genes, a pathogenic triplet repeat has yet to be found for bipolar disorder. It is likely that the controversy surrounding anticipation and the existence of triplet repeats will only finally be resolved with the demonstration of such a mutation in the aetiology of bipolar disorder.

Trinucleotide repeat expansions: do they contribute to bipolar disorder?

It has long been known that bipolar disorder has a true but complex genetic background. Reports on genetic anticipation in bipolar disorder opened the way to a new approach for genetic studies. Indeed, anticipation, a decreasing age at onset, and/or increasing disease severity in successive generations, were recently explained by an expansion of trinucleotide repeats in monogenic diseases like Huntington's disease and Fragile X syndrome. The involvement of trinucleotide repeat expansions in bipolar disorder received even more support when studies reported association of large CAG/CTG repeats with bipolar disorder. Even though a large number of studies have been conducted, this association is still unexplained. Here, we review the studies investigating the trinucleotide repeat expansion hypothesis in bipolar disorder. Studies on anticipation, on association of anonymous large CAG/CTG repeats and on specific trinucleotide repeats are critically analysed and discussed, showing a field with precipitate conclusions or inconclusive results. The analysis suggests that there are indications, though disputable, supporting the trinucleotide repeat expansion hypothesis in bipolar disorder, but no conclusive evidence has been hitherto provided.

Anticipation, imprinting, trinucleotide repeat expansions and psychoses

1. Since 1991, approximately 20 trinucleotide repeat expansion type neurodegenerative disorders have been reported. They are clinically characterized by anticipation, i.e., worsening severity or earlier age at onset with each succeeding generation for an inherited disease, and imprinting, i.e., a process whereby specific genes are differentially marked during parental gametogenesis, resulting in the differential expression of these genes in the embryo and adult. 2. The phenomenon of anticipation in psychoses has been pointed out since the 19th century; however, it was ignored because no one knew the genetic mechanism underlying this type of inheritance pattern at the time, and because of several possible biases. 3. The discovery of trinucleotide repeat expansion diseases has reawakened interest in the phenomenon of anticipation in psychiatric diseases. Anticipation has been confirmed in schizophrenia, mood disorders, and anxiety disorders in much more sophisticated manners, although still not perfectly. 4. Molecular approaches as well as clinical ones have been taken to reveal the involvement of trinucleotide repeat expansion mechanism in psychoses by means of direct analyses of candidate genes, RED and DIRECT. Most efforts have been made for CAG type trinucleotide repeats. So far, direct analyses have failed to reveal pathogenic gene(s). There were several positive RED data at first, however, nowadays there seems to be a tendency of much more negative results. The DIRECT results did not support trinucleotide repeat expansions mechanism in psychoses either. One plausable explanation for the 'false positive' result is the presence of CAG trinucleotide repeats which are highly polymorphic but not associated with an obvious abnormal phenotype. Screening for trinucleotide repeats other than ones of the CAG type remained to be performed.

No evidence of association from transmission disequilibrium analysis of the hKCa3 gene in bipolar disorder

OBJECTIVE

A recent case control study has suggested that modest enlargements of a highly polymorphic CAG repeat in exon 1 of the gene encoding potassium channel hKCa3 may be associated with bipolar disorder (BPD). We have examined this hypothesis by genotyping this locus in a family-based association study.

METHOD

One hundred and twenty-eight parent offspring trios of British Caucasian origin were examined where the proband was diagnosed with the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM)-IV BPD I (n = 123) or II (n = 5). An improved assay was used, with redesigned polymerase chain reaction (PCR) primers, permitting quicker and higher resolution genotyping. The resultant genotypes were analysed using the extended transmission/ disequilibrium test (ETDT).

RESULTS

The experimental data did not provide evidence for the preferential transmission of large alleles to bipolar cases (chi2 = 11.12, df = 10, p = 0.349).

CONCLUSIONS

Our data provide no support for the hypothesis that variation at the hKCa3 gene contributes to susceptibility to BPD.

CTG18.1 and ERDA-1 CAG/CTG repeat size in bipolar disorder

Several groups have reported association between large CAG/CTG repeat sequences in the genome and bipolar disorder using the Repeat Expansion Detection (RED) method. Unfortunately, the RED method cannot identify the specific repeat(s) responsible for these findings but it has recently been proposed that around 90% of the large CAG/CTG repeats detected by RED can be explained by repeat size at either CTG18.1, which maps to 18q21.1, or ERDA-1 (also known as Dir 1), which maps to 17q21.3. These data suggest that the previous associations between bipolar disorder and large CAG/CTG repeats might be explained at least in part by a specific association between bipolar disorder and either or both of these loci. However, using a case control study design, we find no evidence for such associations. Thus we conclude that in our sample, the previous RED associations are not a result of large CAG/CTG repeats at CTG18.1 or ERDA-1.

A piece in the puzzle: an ion channel candidate gene for schizophrenia

Mutations in ion channels have been found to cause a variety of mendelian genetic diseases, and polyglutamine repeat expansion is a newly recognized pathogenic mechanism that causes several rare, genetic, late-onset neurological syndromes. Polymorphic polyglutamine tracts are present in a recently described human, calcium-activated potassium channel, KCNN3 (also known as hKCa3), and alleles of this gene that contain longer repeats have been associated with schizophrenia. The physiological function of the channel is consistent with an etiological role in this disease; drugs designed to target this channel might therefore provide novel psychotherapeutics.