Situating Preventive Action in a Moral and Clinical Context: A Qualitative Synthesis on Fall Prevention

Caregivers' fear of older care recipients falling: A systematic review of qualitative studies

OBJECTIVE

This qualitative systematic review aimed to describe informal caregivers' and health personnel's experiences of the FOF (fear of falling) of older adults under their care.

METHODS

A systematic search of databases included not only the PubMed, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library but also the Chinese databases of CNKI, WanFang, and Vip. The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) tool was used to assess the quality of the included studies.

RESULTS

In total, 17 studies were included in the systematic evaluation. Four themes were identified, and an evidence model was developed that includes multiple attributions of FOF, management strategies for fall prevention, dynamic challenges and adaptation, and external support and unmet needs.

CONCLUSIONS

The fear of falling felt by informal caregivers and health personnel is mainly affected by internal factors in older adults, and harms the health of older adults through overprotective behavior. Thus, there is an urgent need of external support to improve the quality of life and promote the healthy aging of older adults.

[The care in the prevention of falls in elderly people: Meta-summary of qualitative articles]

OBJECTIVE

To summarize the qualitative evidence on the role of care providers in the prevention of falls of persons over 65 years of age in centres and in the community.

DESIGN

Meta-summary of qualitative evidence following the aggregation method.

DATA SOURCES

Extensive manual search of 16 databases (CINAHL, Pubmed/Medline, Embase, PsycInfo, Cochrane Library, PeDRO, Opengrey (Reports), Cuiden, Cuidatge, Enfispo, Medes, Lilacs, Teseo, Dissertation and Thesis Global and Ibecs), in English, French, Spanish and Portuguese; no time limit.

SELECTION OF STUDIES

Selection and blind critical appraisal by pairs. A first relevance and relevance screening and a second critical appraisal screening were carried out. A total of 4170 articles were located; 41 qualitative articles were critically appraised and 31 were selected.

DATA EXTRACTION

Data regarding author, year, study design, location, participants (number, age, sex and occupation), study methods and findings were extracted.

RESULTS

The analysis revealed four major themes: precipitating factors, preventive models, feelings and decision-making process. It also highlights the difficult act of ethical balance, the role of the institution in prevention and the fragmentation of care, as keys to successful implementation.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings show the complexity of fall prevention and the need to incorporate care providers' opinions in preventive models.

Managing and keeping control: A qualitative synthesis of nursing and care staff strategies to prevent older people from falling

AIM

To better understand formal care providers' role in fall prevention.

DESIGN

Qualitative synthesis as part of an integrative review.

DATA SOURCES

Fifteen electronic databases were consulted with the time limit being December 2017. Studies included were qualitative primary studies on formal care providers and fall prevention of people over 65 years of age in health care facilities. 17 studies were included.

REVIEW METHODS

Qualitative researchers carried out a critical appraisal and abstraction of the studies retained. Primary studies were imported into Nvivo 12 software; grounded theory procedures of constant comparison, microanalysis, coding, development of memos and diagrams were completed concurrently in a continuous growing process of data conceptualization. Analysis was iterative; it started with open coding and ended with the development of an integrative memo.

FINDINGS

Primary studies were synthesized with the emerging core category of "Managing and keeping control" and described by the emerging strategies of risk management, risk control and articulation work. These three categories account for the formal care providers' role in fall prevention in health care facilities.

CONCLUSION

Fall prevention is not given by a series of means and instruments; it is rather built in the interactions between formal care providers and the material and social world. The interactive character of prevention implies that outcomes cannot always be anticipated.

IMPACT

Although falls are one of the most researched clinical problems in nursing, the role played by nursing and care staff is dispersed and scantily documented. Formal care providers alternate risk management with risk control strategies to prevent older people from falling in health care facilities, they also resort to the articulation of the health care team as a complementary strategy. This review shows the dynamic character of fall prevention, which is something that has tended to go unnoticed in the literature and in policy.