Metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joint arthrodesis: a comparative study between tension band and compression screw fixation

Management of Index Finger Metacarpophalangeal Joint Arthritis

Metacarpophalangeal joint arthritis of the index finger is a debilitating disease often caused by osteoarthritis or inflammatory arthritides such as rheumatoid arthritis. Treatment options include nonsurgical management with nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, splinting, occupational therapy, corticosteroid injections, and disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs. Operative management options include arthrodesis and arthroplasty, which can be further broken down into silicone implants and 2 component resurfacing implants. The article summarizes the current literature for each of the treatment options for metacarpophalangeal joint arthritis of the index finger.

Comparison of Fusion Rates/Complications Between Different Types of Thumb Metacarpophalangeal Fusion Techniques

BACKGROUND

Thumb metacarpophalangeal (MP) fusion is generally successful; however, complications have been reported to occur in 0% to 30% of cases, whereas nonunion rates vary by method but, overall, are reported to occur in 0% to 15% of cases. Many fixation techniques have been described, but there is no consensus on the optimal fusion technique. Our goal was to compare complication and union rates of different thumb MP arthrodesis techniques.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review of patients who underwent primary thumb MP fusion between 2000 and 2022. Patients who underwent revision fusion, fusion for infection, or amputation were excluded. Fusions of MP joints of other fingers were also excluded. Data collection consisted of demographic data, complications, time to fusion, rate of delayed union and rate of nonunion. Five different fusion constructs were evaluated during our study period: staples, Kirschner wires (K-wires), cerclage, K-wires with cerclage, and intramedullary screw.

RESULTS

Forty-seven patients underwent fusion with staples, 16 with K-wires, 14 with cerclage, 9 with K-wires and cerclage, and 6 with an intramedullary screw. The individual complication and nonunion rates differed significantly among the groups with the intramedullary screw group having a statistically higher rate of nonunion (P = .004). Furthermore, smoking, diabetes, and being overweight were associated with nonunions.

CONCLUSION

Union rates were significantly lower in patients treated with an intramedullary screw and those who are smokers, diabetics, and/or overweight. Caution should be exercised when using intramedullary screw fixation for MP fusion, especially in patients with these comorbidities.

Biomechanical Analysis of Headless Compression Screw Versus Tension Band Wiring for Proximal Interphalangeal Joint Arthrodesis

PURPOSE

Proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint arthrodesis is a procedure employed to address arthritis, instability, and deformity. Multiple fixation methods are available to maintain stability across the arthrodesis interval, including headless compression screws (HCSs), tension band wiring (TBW), plating, and Kirschner wire constructs. The purpose of this study was to compare the biomechanical properties of the HCS and TBW techniques.

METHODS

Thirty-two nonthumb digits from the paired upper limbs of four fresh frozen cadavers were divided into pairs, matching contralateral digits from the same specimen. One PIP joint of each pair was fused with an antegrade 3.5 mm HCS, and the second was fused with TBW using 0.035 in. Kirschner wires with 24-gauge dental wire. Each construct was then stressed to 10 N in the radial deviation, ulnar deviation, flexion, and extension planes, and stiffness (N/mm) was calculated. The fingers were stressed to failure in extension with the ultimate load and mode of failure recorded.

RESULTS

When stressed in extension, the HCS construct had a significantly greater mean stiffness than the TBW construct (16.4 N/mm vs 10.8 N/mm). The stiffness in all other planes of motion were similar between the two constructs. The mean ultimate load to failure in extension was 91.4 N for the HCS and 41.9 N for the TBW. The most common mode of failure was fracture of the dorsal lip of the proximal phalanx (13/16) for the HCS and bending of the K-wires (15/16) for TBW.

CONCLUSIONS

Arthrodesis of the PIP joint using a HCS resulted in a construct that was significantly stiffer in extension with greater than double the load to failure compared to TBW.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Although the stiffness required to achieve successful PIP joint arthrodesis has not been well quantified, the HCS proved to be the most favorable construct with respect to initial strength and stability.

Primary Arthrodesis of Non-thumb Metacarpophalangeal Joints of the Hand: Clinical and Patient-Reported Outcomes

BACKGROUND

Metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joint arthritis is common secondary to a variety of inflammatory, degenerative, and traumatic causes. Although MCP arthroplasty is more common for the second to fifth digits, primary arthrodesis can be used for high-demand patients with arthritis or unsalvageable fractures of the MCP joint. There has been limited recent studies on the outcomes of these patients.

METHODS

A retrospective review of 38 fingers in 27 patients with primary arthrodesis from 1990 to 2020 was conducted. The major outcomes were complications, reoperations, radiographic union, and time to union. Patient-reported outcomes including the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire and a questionnaire specific to the operative MCP joint were collected.

RESULTS

Rate of radiographic union was 84% including revisions. The average time to union was 3.6 months. Rates of complications, reoperation, and amputation were 26%, 16%, and 7%, respectively. Arthrodesis as part of emergent trauma reconstruction was significantly more likely to result in reoperation (50% vs 7%) and complication (63% vs 17%) than chronic arthritis. Patient-reported outcomes were fair to good with improvement in pain (79%), function (66%), and appearance (40%). Sixty-six percent (66%) of patients were satisfied with their surgery, and 73% would repeat the surgery.

CONCLUSION

Arthrodesis for unsalvageable MCP fractures was associated with higher rates of reoperation and complication than inflammatory or degenerative arthritis. Excluding emergent trauma, MCP fusion was reliable with a reoperation rate of 7% and a modest complication rate of 17%. Patients rated reasonable levels of satisfaction and willingness to repeat the procedure despite complications.

Arthrodesis of the Proximal Interphalangeal Joint of the Finger—A Biomechanical Study of Primary Stability

Background: Osteoarthritis of the proximal interphalangeal (PIP) joint of the finger often leads to global hand-function detriment. Different techniques for the arthrodesis of the proximal interphalangeal joint have been described that all lead to union in a reasonable percentage of patients and period of time. This biomechanical study aims to analyze and compare the primary stability of different techniques of arthrodesis to render postoperative immobilization unnecessary. Methods: Arthrodeses of 40° of composite cylinders were tested with different techniques in four-point bending for stability in extension as well as flexion. Results: In extension, the compression screw and the compression wires showed the highest stability—whereas in flexion, plate fusion was superior. Tension band, cerclage or compression screw fusion showed the best compromise in flexion/extension stability. Conclusions: Fusion techniques that apply compression to the fusion show superior stability. Cerclage, tension band and compression screws might be able to provide enough stability to withstand the forces exerted during unencumbered activities of daily living. Arthrodesis with plates should be limited to patients with special indications and require immobilization during consolidation.

The Effects of Different Screw Combinations on the Initial Stability of Ankle Arthrodesis

BACKGROUND

The literature is scanty regarding the biomechanical effects of different thread configurations on the initial stability of ankle arthrodesis. This study aims to compare the initial stability of tibiotalar fusion site in ankle arthrodesis using cannulated screws with different thread designs.

METHODS

We biomechanically tested under cyclic loading the effects of different screw combinations on the initial stability of ankle arthrodesis. A total of 28 synthetic ankle models were divided into four groups: two partially threaded cancellous screws (group A), partially and fully threaded cancellous screws (group B), a partially threaded cancellous screw with a headless compression screw (group C), and a fully threaded cancellous screw and a headless compression screw (group D). Biomechanical variables including ultimate failure load, initial stiffness, ultimate stiffness, and failure angulation were analyzed.

RESULTS

There were no differences in any of the biomechanical variables among the four groups (P = .41 for ultimate failure load, P = .079 for initial stiffness, P = .084 for ultimate stiffness, and P = .937 for failure angulation).

CONCLUSIONS

Combinations of different cannulated screws showed similar results in terms of the stability and stiffness of the tibiotalar fusion site.

Tension Band Wiring in Upper Extremity Surgery

Tension band wiring is a simple, inexpensive, and effective technique to treat many upper extremity fractures. When tension forces result in a mechanical failure of bone, tension band wiring provides stability and promotes early mobilization by converting tensile forces across a fracture into compressive forces. The tension band principle has distinct advantages of reducing periosteal stripping, technical ease, and cost effectiveness when compared with other operative strategies. This technique can be implemented in a variety of fractures and avulsions about the upper extremity as well as small bone arthrodeses.

Arthrodesis of the digital joint using intraosseous wiring in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

OBJECTIVE

Digital joints affected by rheumatoid arthritis often have severe deformity and/or dislocation, and arthrodesis in a functional position is required.

METHODS

Arthrodesis was performed using intraosseous wiring (modified Lister's method) from January 2011 to December 2015, and we investigated the union rate, postoperative complications, and patient satisfaction with the operation at the final follow-up. The DASH score, grip power, and pinch power were also investigated before the operation and at the final follow-up.

RESULTS

Arthrodesis was performed for 90 digital joints in 56 patients. Bone union was obtained in 85 of 89 joints (96%). Wire removal was needed due to subcutaneous protrusion in 20 joints and superficial infection in five joints. The mean preoperative DASH score of 50.5 improved to 45.2 at the final follow-up. The pulp pinch power of the index fingers through the little fingers changed significantly. In the questionnaire regarding the operated digit using a visual analogue scale (VAS, 0 [worst] to 100 [best]), the overall satisfaction was 70.

CONCLUSION

With this approach, we achieved painless stability as well as deformity correction. A restored prehensile pattern and improvement in the activities of daily life can thus be expected after surgery.

Index Finger Metacarpophalangeal Joint Arthrodesis With a Dorsal Locking Plate

Index finger metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joint arthrodesis is a potential reconstructive option for recalcitrant MCP arthritis. Due to lateral forces applied by the thumb, our institutional experience supports index finger MCP arthrodesis as a successful option in younger, higher demand patients and in the setting of significant joint instability. We present our technique of performing index finger MCP arthrodesis using a dorsal locking plate. The proposed benefits of this technique include the ability to position the MCP joint in the desired degree of flexion, generation of parallel fusion surfaces with even compression across the arthrodesis site, and stable fixation.

Biomechanical comparison of the proximal interphalangeal joint arthrodesis using a compression wire

INTRODUCTION/AIM

Arthrodesis of the proximal interphalangeal joint of the finger is a common procedure for the treatment of osteoarthritis. The aim of this biomechanical study was to compare the primary stability of one, respectively, two compression wires to intraosseous wiring and tension band wiring for the arthrodesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The stability of the arthrodesis was tested by applying flexion (n = 11) and extension (n = 10) force with 10° bending. Arthrodesis was achieved by one, respectively, two crossed compression wires and intraosseous wiring. In a control group (n = 11) tension band wiring was tested to 10° flexion and extension as well.

RESULTS

Mean values for flexion bending for intraosseous wiring were 10.94 N, for one compression wire 12.82 N, for tension band wiring 17.95 N, and for two crossed compression wires 20.42 N. Mean values for extension bending were 9.71 N for intraosseous wiring, 13.63 N for one compression wire, 21.43 N for tension band wiring and 22.56 N for two crossed compression wires.

CONCLUSION

The primary stability of the compression wires was statistically significant superior to intraosseous wiring. In comparison to tension band wiring which showed an intermediate stability. The application of a compression wire could be considered for further clinical testing in the arthrodesis of interphalangeal joints.

Arthrodesis of the thumb metacarpophalangeal joint: Conventional open technique with a locking plate or compression pins versus minimally invasive technique with compression pins or screws

Arthrodesis of the thumb metacarpophalangeal (MCP) joint usually leads to satisfying results when performed with an open technique. The main complication is adhesion of the extensor tendons that sometimes requires hardware removal associated with tenolysis. The goal of this study was to assess whether a minimally invasive technique could reduce the risk of this complication. Arthrodesis of the thumb MCP was performed using an open technique with a locking plate or compression pins in 12 cases (group I) and using a minimally invasive technique with compression pins or screws in 12 cases, for a total of 24 patients aged 48.9 years on average, among which 15 were women. At the last follow-up, the average pain level was rated at 2/10 in group I and 2.3/10 in group II. The QuickDASH was 40.70/100 in group I and 36.24 in group II, grip strength was 79% of the contralateral side in group I and 51% in group II. Pinch strength was 81% of the contralateral side in group I and 45% in group II. Fusion was achieved in all cases in group I and in 7 of 12 cases in group II. Surgical revision for non-union was needed in 5 cases in group II, with hardware removal and tenolysis performed in 2 cases. The non-unions were observed in non-rheumatoid cases. While the two groups were not identical, arthrodesis of the thumb MCP using a minimally invasive technique with compression pins or screws seems to give satisfying results for rheumatoid cases in which no cartilage remains.

Metacarpophalangeal joint of the thumb arthrodesis using intramedullary interlocking screws XMCP™

The study objective was to assess the results of a thumb metacarpophalangeal joint (MCPJ) arthrodesis using intramedullary interlocking screws at 25°, XMCP ™ (Extremity Medical, Parsippany, NJ). Radiographs evaluated the angle of arthrodesis, time of fusion and fixation of the implant. Clinical and functional outcomes were assessed using the DASH questionnaire and the VAS scale. Any complications found during surgery or the follow-up period were noted. We studied 9 patients. The mean follow-up was 27.6 months. Patients showed clinical and radiological evidence of fusion in an average of 8 weeks, the angle of fusion was 25°. There were no complications and no implant had to be removed. The XMCP™ system provides a reliable method for MCPJ arthrodesis for several indications and can be used with other procedures in the complex hand.

[Arthrodesis of the proximal interphalangeal joint of fingers with tension band wire]

OBJECTIVE

Arthrodesis of the proximal interphalangeal joint of fingers in a functional and pain-free position.

INDICATIONS

Primary and secondary osteoarthritis, traumatic joint destruction, posttraumatic malposition, instability, joint destruction due to infection, irreparable extensor and/or flexor tendon lesion, recurrent flexion deformity in Dupuytren's disease, arthritis (e. g., rheumatoid arthritis, psoriatic arthritis), failed resection arthroplasty, failed prosthesis, congenital disorder (e. g., camptodactyly).

CONTRAINDICATIONS

Persistent joint infection.

SURGICAL TECHNIQUE

Resection of the proximal phalanx head and the middle phalanx base, arthrodesis with figure-of-eight tension band wire in a functional position.

POSTOPERATIVE MANAGEMENT

Plaster of Paris cast with arthrodesis position of the affected finger and intrinsic plus position of at least one adjacent finger for 2 weeks, custom-made finger splint for 4 weeks.

RESULTS

A total of 15 of 16 patients with an arthrodesis of the proximal interphalangeal finger joint of the dominant hand by tension band wire were followed up after an average of 31 months. None was affected by the arthrodesis in everyday live. All patients were very satisfied with the result. Nine of 15 patients were free of pain both at rest and with activity. The average DASH score was 48 points. Grip strength averaged 29 kg, 7 % stronger than the contralateral hand.

Osteochondral Autograft Transfer for Treatment of Metacarpophalangeal and Interphalangeal Cartilage Defects

There is no general consensus regarding the optimal surgical treatment for cartilage defects of the metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joints in active patients who wish to preserve motion and functionality. We describe our technique of arthroscopically harvested femoral osteochondral autograft for treatment of metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal cartilage defects.

Biomechanical evaluation of a second generation headless compression screw for ankle arthrodesis in a cadaver model

BACKGROUND

Many types of screws, plates, and strut grafts have been utilized for ankle arthrodesis. Biomechanical testing has shown that these constructs can have variable stiffness. More recently, headless compression screws have emerged as an evolving method of achieving compression in various applications but there is limited literature regarding ankle arthrodesis. The aim of this study was to determine the biomechanical stability provided by a second generation fully threaded headless compression screw compared to a standard headed, partially threaded cancellous screw in a cadaveric ankle arthrodesis model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty fresh frozen human cadaver specimens were subjected to simulated ankle arthrodesis with either three standard cancellous-bone screws (InFix 7.3mm) or with three headless compression screws (Acumed Acutrak 2 7.5mm). The specimens were subjected to cyclic loading and unloading at a rate of 1Hz, compression of 525 Newtons (N) and distraction of 20N for a total of 500 cycles using an electromechanical load frame (Instron). The amount of maximum distraction was recorded as well as the amount of motion that occurred through 1, 10, 50, 100, and 500 cycles.

RESULTS

No significant difference (p=0.412) was seen in the amount of distraction that occurred across the fusion site for either screw. The average maximum distraction after 500 cycles was 201.9μm for the Acutrak 2 screw and 235.4μm for the InFix screw. No difference was seen throughout each cycle over time for the Acutrak 2 screw (p-value=0.988) or the InFix screw (p-value=0.991).

CONCLUSION

Both the traditional InFix type screw and the second generation Acumed Acutrak headless compression screws provide adequate fixation during ankle arthrodesis under submaximal loads.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

There is no demonstrable difference between traditional cannulated partially threaded screws and headless compression screws studied in this model.