The current state of the osteoarthritis drug development pipeline: a comprehensive narrative review of the present challenges and future opportunities

The inflammatory endotype in osteoarthritis: Reflections from the 2024 OARSI clinical trials symposium (CTS) with a special emphasis on feasibility for clinical development

Objective

The inflammatory endotype is arguably one of the most well-established endotype in osteoarthritis (OA). While endotyping holds promise for advancing drug development, numerous potential challenges must be considered, addressed and resolved before successful clinical outcomes can be achieved.

Design

Since 2017, the Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) has hosted the Clinical Trials Symposium (CTS). Each year, OARSI and the CTS steering committee encourage discussions on selected topics among a broad range of stakeholders, including regulators, drug developers, clinicians, clinical researchers, biomarker specialists, and basic scientists, with the aim of advancing drug development in the OA field.

Results

This report highlights the ongoing tension between academia's "blue ocean" strategy and the feasibility-driven approach of drug developers, all within the context of scientific efforts to find effective solutions. Understanding the needs, goals, constraints, and opportunities of all involved stakeholders is crucial for defining optimal drug development strategies for OA.

Conclusion

A multidisciplinary, collaborative approach is essential for developing effective OA treatments, balancing scientific discovery with regulatory and clinical feasibility.

The effects of various physical modalities on pain in patients with knee osteoarthritis: A network meta-analysis

Objective

This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of various physical therapy methods in reducing pain for patients with knee osteoarthritis (KOA) through a network meta-analysis.

Methods

We conducted a comprehensive search across multiple databases, including PubMed, Embase, Cochrane Library, VIP, WanFang Data, and CNKI, to identify randomized controlled trials (RCTs) on physical therapies for KOA. The search spanned from the inception of each database to October 2024. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed using the Cochrane Handbook. Pain was measured using tools such as the visual analog scale, numeric pain rating scale, and the Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index. All pain scores were standardized to a 10-point scale. Data collection and analysis were performed independently by two researchers using Stata 15.0 software.

Results

The analysis included 64 studies with 3855 patients and 12 physical therapy modalities. Based on the surface under the cumulative ranking curve (SUCRA), the most effective treatments were HILT, ESWT, Hydrotherapy, Land-EX, LLLT, Braces, tDCS, US, IFCs, SWD, Insoles, and TENS.

Conclusion

HILT appears to be the most effective treatment for pain relief in KOA patients. Further large-scale RCTs are needed to confirm these findings.

Filtered and unfiltered lipoaspirates reveal novel molecular insights and therapeutic potential for osteoarthritis treatment: a preclinical in vitro study

Introduction

Orthobiologics, such as autologous nanofat, are emerging as a potential treatment option for osteoarthritis (OA), a common degenerative joint causing pain and disability in the elderly. Nanofat, a minimally processed human fat graft rich in stromal vascular fraction (SVF) secretory factors, has shown promise in relieving pain. This study aimed to elucidate the molecular mechanisms underlying nanofat treatment of OA-affected cells and compare two filtration systems used for nanofat preparation.

Methods

Chondrocytes and synoviocytes were isolated from articular cartilage and synovium of 22 OA-patients. Lipoaspirates from 13 OA-patients were emulsified using the Adinizer® or Lipocube™ Nano filter systems to generate nanofat. The fluid phase of SVF from both filtered and unfiltered lipoaspirates was applied to OA-affected cells. Luminex multiplex ELISA were performed with lipoaspirates and cell supernatants alongside functional assays evaluating cell migration, proliferation, metabolic activity, and senescence.

Results

A total of 62 cytokines, chemokines, growth factors, neuropeptides, matrix-degrading enzymes, and complement components were identified in lipoaspirates. Among these, significant concentration differences were observed for TIMP-2, TGF-ß3, and complement component C3 between the filtered and unfiltered samples. Nanofat enhanced chondrocyte proliferation and migration, as well as synoviocyte migration and metabolic activity, while reducing chondrocyte metabolic activity. Pain-related factors like β-NGF, MCP-1, Substance P, VEGF, and αCGRP were reduced, while anti-inflammatory TGF-β1+3 increased and pro-inflammatory cytokines (IL-5, IL-7, IL-15, and IFN-γ) decreased. Nanofat also elevated secretion of complement components and TIMPs in both cell types. Notably, our results revealed no significant differences in cellular effects between sSVF filtered using the Adinizer® and Lipocube™ Nano systems, as well as compared to unfiltered sSVF.

Discussion

Here, we provide first insights into how autologous nanofat therapy may ameliorate OA by enhancing chondrocyte proliferation and synoviocyte migration while modulating inflammatory and pain-related factors. However, further research is needed to determine its effects on cartilage regeneration.

Senolytic therapy combining Dasatinib and Quercetin restores the chondrogenic phenotype of human osteoarthritic chondrocytes by the release of pro-anabolic mediators

Cellular senescence is associated with various age-related disorders and is assumed to play a major role in the pathogenesis of osteoarthritis (OA). Based on this, we tested a senolytic combination therapy using Dasatinib (D) and Quercetin (Q) on aged isolated human articular chondrocytes (hACs), as well as in OA-affected cartilage tissue (OARSI grade 1-2). Stimulation with D + Q selectively eliminated senescent cells in both, cartilage explants and isolated hAC. Furthermore, the therapy significantly promoted chondroanabolism, as demonstrated by increased gene expression levels of COL2A1, ACAN, and SOX9, as well as elevated collagen type II and glycosaminoglycan biosynthesis. Additionally, D + Q treatment significantly reduced the release of SASP factors (IL6, CXCL1). RNA sequencing analysis revealed an upregulation of the anabolic factors, inter alia, FGF18, IGF1, and TGFB2, as well as inhibitory effects on cytokines and the YAP-1 signaling pathway, explaining the underlying mechanism of the chondroanabolic promotion upon senolytic treatment. Accordingly, stimulation of untreated hAC with conditioned medium of D + Q-treated cells similarly induced the expression of chondrogenic markers. Detailed analyses demonstrated that chondroanabolic effects could be mainly attributed to Dasatinib, while monotherapeutical application of Quercetin or Navitoclax did not promote the chondroanabolism. Overall, D + Q therapy restored the chondrogenic phenotype in OA hAC most likely by creating a pro-chondroanabolic environment through the reduction of SASP factors and upregulation of growth factors. This senolytic approach could therefore be a promising candidate for further testing as a disease-modifying osteoarthritis drug.

Therapeutic Controlled Release Strategies for Human Osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis is a progressive, irreversible debilitating whole joint disease that affects millions of people worldwide. Despite the availability of various options (non-pharmacological and pharmacological treatments and therapy, orthobiologics, and surgical interventions), none of them can definitively cure osteoarthritis in patients. Strategies based on the controlled release of therapeutic compounds via biocompatible materials may provide powerful tools to enhance the spatiotemporal delivery, expression, and activities of the candidate agents as a means to durably manage the pathological progression of osteoarthritis in the affected joints upon convenient intra-articular (injectable) delivery while reducing their clearance, dissemination, or side effects. The goal of this review is to describe the current knowledge and advancements of controlled release to treat osteoarthritis, from basic principles to applications in vivo using therapeutic recombinant molecules and drugs and more innovatively gene sequences, providing a degree of confidence to manage the disease in patients in a close future.

Autologous transplantation of mitochondria/rAAV IGF-I platforms in human osteoarthritic articular chondrocytes to treat osteoarthritis

Despite various available treatments, highly prevalent osteoarthritis (OA) cannot be cured in patients. In light of evidence showing mitochondria dysfunction during the disease progression, our goal was to develop a novel therapeutic concept based on the transplantation of mitochondria as a platform to deliver recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) gene vectors with potency for OA. For the first time, to our best knowledge, we report the successful creation of a safe mitochondria/rAAV system effectively promoting the overexpression of a candidate insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I) by administration to autologous human osteoarthritic articular chondrocytes versus control conditions (reporter mitochondria/rAAV lacZ system, rAAV-free system, absence of mitochondria transplantation; up to 8.4-fold difference). The candidate mitochondria/rAAV IGF-I system significantly improved key activities in the transplanted cells (proliferation/survival, extracellular matrix production, mitochondria functions) relative to the control conditions (up to a 9.5-fold difference), including when provided in a pluronic F127 (PF127) hydrogel for reinforced delivery (up to a 5.9-fold difference). Such effects were accompanied by increased levels of cartilage-specific SOX9 and Mfn-1 (mitochondria fusion) and decreased levels of Drp-1 (mitochondria fission) and proinflammatory tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-α; up to 4.5-fold difference). This study shows the potential of combining the use of mitochondria with rAAV as a promising approach for human OA.

Association of serum biomarkers with radiographic knee osteoarthritis, knee pain and function in a young, male, trauma-exposed population - Findings from the ADVANCE study

OBJECTIVE

The ArmeD SerVices TrAuma RehabilitatioN OutComE (ADVANCE) study is investigating long-term combat-injury outcomes; this sub-study aims to understand the association of osteoarthritis (OA) biomarkers with knee radiographic OA (rOA), pain and function in this high-risk population for post-traumatic OA.

DESIGN

ADVANCE compares combat-injured participants with age, rank, deployment and job-role frequency-matched uninjured participants. Post-injury immunoassay-measured serum biomarkers, knee radiographs, Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scale, and six-minute walk tests are reported. The primary analysis, adjusted for age, body mass, socioeconomic status, and ethnicity, was to determine any differences in biomarkers between those with/without combat injury, rOA and pain. Secondary analyses were performed to compare post-traumatic/idiopathic OA, painful/painfree rOA and injury patterns.

RESULTS

A total of 1145 male participants were recruited, aged 34.1 ± 5.4, 8.9 ± 2.2 years post-injury (n = 579 trauma-exposed, of which, traumatic-amputation n = 161) or deployment (n = 566 matched). Cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP) was significantly higher in the combat-injured group compared to uninjured (p = 0.01). Notably, COMP was significantly lower in the traumatic-amputation group compared to non-amputees (p < 0.001), decreasing relative to number of amputations (p < 0.001). Leptin was higher (p = 0.005) and adiponectin lower (p = 0.017) in those with v without knee pain, associated with an increased risk of 22% and 17% for pain, and 46% and 34% for painful rOA, respectively. There were no significant differences between trauma-exposed and unexposed participants with rOA.

CONCLUSIONS

The most notable findings of this large, unique study are the similarities between those with rOA regardless of trauma-exposure, the injury-pattern and traumatic-amputation-associated differences in COMP, and the relationship between adipokines and pain.

Advanced therapies in orthopaedics

Advanced therapies are expected to play a crucial role in supporting repair after injury, halting the degeneration of musculoskeletal tissue to enable and promote physical activity. Despite advancements, the progress in developing advanced therapies in orthopaedics lags behind specialties like oncology, since innovative regenerative treatment strategies fall short of their expectations in musculoskeletal clinical trials. Researchers should focus on understanding the mechanism of action behind the investigated target before conducting clinical trials. Strategic research networks are needed that not only enhance scientific exchange among like-minded researchers but need to include early on commercial views, companies and venture perspectives, regulatory insights and reimbursement perspectives. Only in such collaborations essential roadblocks towards clinical trials and go-to-patients be overcome.

Investigating the relationship between radiographic joint space width loss and deep learning-derived magnetic resonance imaging-based cartilage thickness loss in the medial weight-bearing region of the tibiofemoral joint

Objective

To investigate the relationship between measures of radiographic joint space width (JSW) loss and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-based cartilage thickness loss in the medial weight-bearing region of the tibiofemoral joint over 12-24 months. To stratify this relationship by clinically meaningful subgroups (sex and pain status).

Design

We analyzed a subset of knees (n ​= ​256) from the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI) likely in early stage OA based on joint space narrowing (JSN) measurements. Natural logarithm transformation was used to approximate near normal distributions for JSW loss. Pearson Correlation coefficients described the relationship between ln-transformed JSW loss and several versions of deep learning-derived MRI-based cartilage thickness loss parameters (minimum, maximum, and mean) in subregions of the femoral condyle, tibial plateau, and combined femoral and tibial regions. Linear mixed-effects models evaluated the associations between the ln-transformed radiographic and MRI-derived measures including potential confounders.

Results

We found weak correlations between ln-transformed JSW loss and MRI-based cartilage thickness ranging from R ​= ​-0.13 (p ​= ​0.20) to R ​= ​0.26 (p ​< ​0.01). Correlations were higher (still poor) among females compared to males and painful compared to non-painful knees. Model results showed weak associations for nearly all MRI-based measures, ranging from no association to β (95% CI) ​= ​0.25 (0.11, 0.39). Associations were higher among females compared to males and minimal differences between painful and non-painful knees.

Conclusions

Despite its recommended use in disease-modifying OA drug clinical trials, results suggest that JSW loss is an ineffective proxy measure of cartilage thickness loss over 12-24 months and within a localized region of the tibiofemoral joint.

Mesenchymal Stem Cell-Derived Exosomes as a Treatment Option for Osteoarthritis

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a leading cause of pain and disability worldwide in elderly people. There is a critical need to develop novel therapeutic strategies that can effectively manage pain and disability to improve the quality of life for older people. Mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) have emerged as a promising cell-based therapy for age-related disorders due to their multilineage differentiation and strong paracrine effects. Notably, MSC-derived exosomes (MSC-Exos) have gained significant attention because they can recapitulate MSCs into therapeutic benefits without causing any associated risks compared with direct cell transplantation. These exosomes help in the transport of bioactive molecules such as proteins, lipids, and nucleic acids, which can influence various cellular processes related to tissue repair, regeneration, and immune regulation. In this review, we have provided an overview of MSC-Exos as a considerable treatment option for osteoarthritis. This review will go over the underlying mechanisms by which MSC-Exos may alleviate the pathological hallmarks of OA, such as cartilage degradation, synovial inflammation, and subchondral bone changes. Furthermore, we have summarized the current preclinical evidence and highlighted promising results from in vitro and in vivo studies, as well as progress in clinical trials using MSC-Exos to treat OA.

Osteoarthritis in the UK Armed Forces: a review of its impact, treatment and future research

Within the UK Armed Forces, musculoskeletal injuries account for over half of all medical downgrades and discharges. Data from other Armed Forces show that osteoarthritis (OA), more common in military personnel, is likely to contribute to this, both in its primary form and following injury (post-traumatic OA, PTOA), which typically presents in the third or fourth decade. OA is not a progressive 'wear and tear' disease, as previously thought, but a heterogenous condition with multiple aetiologies and modulators, including joint damage, abnormal morphology, altered biomechanics, genetics, low-grade inflammation and dysregulated metabolism. Currently, clinical diagnosis, based on symptomatic or radiological criteria, is followed by supportive measures, including education, exercise, analgesia, potentially surgical intervention, with a particular focus on exercise rehabilitation within the UK military. Developments in OA have led to a new paradigm of organ failure, with an emphasis on early diagnosis and risk stratification, prevention strategies (primary, secondary and tertiary) and improved aetiological classification using genotypes and phenotypes to guide management, with the introduction of biological markers (biomarkers) potentially having a role in all these areas. In the UK Armed Forces, there are multiple research studies focused on OA risk factors, epidemiology, biomarkers and effectiveness of different interventions. This review aims to highlight OA, especially PTOA, as an important diagnosis to consider in serving personnel, outline current and future management options, and detail current research trends within the Defence Medical Services.

Tissue engineering and future directions in regenerative medicine for knee cartilage repair: a comprehensive review

This review evaluates the current landscape and future directions of regenerative medicine for knee cartilage repair, with a particular focus on tissue engineering strategies. In this context, scaffold-based approaches have emerged as promising solutions for cartilage regeneration. Synthetic scaffolds, while offering superior mechanical properties, often lack the biological cues necessary for effective tissue integration. Natural scaffolds, though biocompatible and biodegradable, frequently suffer from inadequate mechanical strength. Hybrid scaffolds, combining elements of both synthetic and natural materials, present a balanced approach, enhancing both mechanical support and biological functionality. Advances in decellularized extracellular matrix scaffolds have shown potential in promoting cell infiltration and integration with native tissues. Additionally, bioprinting technologies have enabled the creation of complex, bioactive scaffolds that closely mimic the zonal organization of native cartilage, providing an optimal environment for cell growth and differentiation. The review also explores the potential of gene therapy and gene editing techniques, including CRISPR-Cas9, to enhance cartilage repair by targeting specific genetic pathways involved in tissue regeneration. The integration of these advanced therapies with tissue engineering approaches holds promise for developing personalized and durable treatments for knee cartilage injuries and osteoarthritis. In conclusion, this review underscores the importance of continued multidisciplinary collaboration to advance these innovative therapies from bench to bedside and improve outcomes for patients with knee cartilage damage.

The evolving landscape of gene therapy strategies for the treatment of osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVES

Significant advances have been made in our understanding of osteoarthritis (OA) pathogenesis; however, no disease-modifying therapies have been identified. This review will summarize the gene therapy landscape, its initial successes for OA, and possible challenges using recent studies and examples of gene therapies in clinical trials.

DESIGN

This narrative review has three major sections: 1) vector systems for OA gene therapy, 2) current and emerging targets for OA gene therapy, and 3) considerations and future directions.

RESULTS

Gene therapy is the strategy by which nucleic acids are delivered to treat and reverse disease progression. Specificity and prolonged expression of these nucleic acids are achieved by manipulating promoters, genes, and vector systems. Certain vector systems also allow for the development of combinatorial nucleic acid strategies that can be delivered in a single intraarticular injection - an approach likely required to treat the complexity of OA pathogenesis. Several viral and non-viral vector-based gene therapies are in clinical trials for OA, and many more are being evaluated in the preclinical arena.

CONCLUSIONS

In a post-coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) era, the future of gene therapy for OA is certainly promising; however, the majority of preclinical validation continues to focus heavily on post-traumatic models and changes in only cartilage and subchondral bone. To ensure successful translation, new candidates in the preclinical arena should be examined against all joint tissues as well as pain using diverse models of injury-, obesity-, and age-induced disease. Lastly, consideration must be given to strategies for repeat administration and the cost of treatment owing to the chronic nature of OA.

Current status of catabolic, anabolic and inflammatory biomarkers associated with structural and symptomatic changes in the chronic phase of post-traumatic knee osteoarthritis- a systematic review

Post-traumatic OA (PTOA) can occur within 5 years after a significant injury and is a valuable paradigm for identifying biomarkers. This systematic review aims to summarise published literature in human studies on the associations of known serum and synovial fluid biomarkers at least a year from injury to structural, symptomatic changes and underlying PTOA processes. A systematic review was performed using PRISMA guidelines, prospectively registered on PROSPERO (CRD42022371838), for all 'wet' biomarkers a year or more post-injury in 18-45-year-old participants. Three independent reviewers screened search results, extracted data, and performed risk of bias assessments (Newcastle-Ottawa Scale). Study heterogeneity meant a narrative synthesis was undertaken, utilising SWiM guidelines. 952 studies were identified, 664 remaining after deduplication. Following first-round screening, 53 studies underwent second-round screening against pre-determined criteria. Eight studies, with 879 participants (49 ​% male), were included, measuring serum (n ​= ​7), synovial fluid (SF, n ​= ​6), or both (n ​= ​5). The pooled participant mean age was 29.1 (±4). 51 biomarkers were studied (serum ​= ​38, SF ​= ​13), with no correlation between paired serum and SF samples. One serum biomarker, cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP), and four SF biomarkers, interleukin (IL)-1β, IL-6, tumour necrosis factor (TNF), and COMP, were measured in multiple studies. Associations were described between 11 biomarkers related to catabolism (n ​= ​4), anabolism (n ​= ​2), inflammation (n ​= ​4) and non-coding RNA (n ​= ​1), with OA imaging changes (X-ray and MRI), pain, quality of life and function. Widespread differences in study design and methodology prevented meta-analysis, and evidence was generally weak. A unified approach is required before widespread research and clinical biomarker use.

Comparison between Low-Level and High-Intensity Laser Therapy as an Adjunctive Treatment for Knee Osteoarthritis: A Randomized, Double-Blind Clinical Trial

BACKGROUND

Low-level (LLLT) and high-intensity laser therapy (HILT) can be beneficial additions to knee osteoarthritis (KOA) rehabilitation exercises; however, it is still being determined which electrophysical agent is more effective.

AIM

To compare the effects of LLLT and HILT as adjuncts to rehabilitation exercises (LL + EX and HL + EX) on clinical outcomes in KOA.

METHODS

Thirty-four adults with mild-to-moderate KOA were randomly allocated to either LL + EX or HL + EX (n = 17 each). Both groups underwent their respective intervention weekly for twelve weeks: LL + EX (400 mW, 830 nm, 10 to 12 J/cm², and 400 J per session) or HL + EX (5 W, 1064 nm, 19 to 150 J/cm², and 3190 J per session). The laser probe was placed vertically in contact with the knee and moved in a slow-scan manner on the antero-medial/lateral sides of the knee joint. Participants' Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score (KOOS), Numerical Pain Rating Scale (NPRS), active knee flexion, and Timed Up-and-Go test (TUG) were assessed.

RESULTS

Post intervention, both groups showed improvements in their KOOS, NPRS, active knee flexion, and TUG scores compared to baseline (p < 0.01). The mean difference of change in KOOS, NPRS, and active knee flexion scores for the HL + EX group surpassed the minimal clinically important difference threshold. In contrast, the LL + EX group only demonstrated clinical significance for the NPRS scores.

CONCLUSIONS

Incorporating HILT as an adjunct to usual KOA rehabilitation led to significantly higher improvements in pain, physical function, and knee-related disability compared to LLLT applied in scanning mode.

Biomarkers for osteoarthritis: Current status and future prospects

Osteoarthritis (OA) is the most common form of arthritis globally and a major cause of pain, physical disability, and loss of economic productivity, with currently no causal treatment available. This review article focuses on current research on OA biomarkers and the potential for using biomarkers in future clinical practice and clinical trials of investigational drugs. We discuss how biomarkers, specifically soluble ones, have a long path to go before reaching clinical standards of care. We also discuss how biomarkers can help in phenotyping and subtyping to achieve enhanced stratification and move toward better-designed clinical trials. We also describe how biomarkers can be used for molecular endotyping and for determining the clinical outcomes of investigational cell-based therapies. Biomarkers have the potential to be developed as surrogate end points in clinical trials and help private-public consortia and the biotechnology and pharmaceutical industries develop more effective and targeted personalized treatments and enhance clinical care for patients with OA.