Research priorities in α1-antitrypsin deficiency: results of a patients' and healthcare providers' international survey from the EARCO Clinical Research Collaboration

Bacterial colonisation doubles the risk of exacerbation in alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency

Pulmonary exacerbations in alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) are associated with worse disease outcomes, including accelerated lung function decline. As with non-deficient COPD, subjects with AATD are predisposed to bacterial colonisation of the lower respiratory tract, a known risk factor for exacerbations. Despite this, the extent to which colonising bacteria contribute to exacerbations remains relatively unexplored. Sputum samples were collected longitudinally from AATD subjects, when clinically stable and during exacerbations, and were processed for quantitative culture to identify bacterial pathogens. Using contemporaneous clinical data, a post-hoc analysis was performed to calculate the odds of an exacerbation in the presence of recognised, potentially pathogenic bacteria (PPB) of the lower respiratory tract. 324 sputum samples were collected from 29 patients with AATD plus radiological evidence of bronchiectasis and 671 samples from 62 patients without bronchiectasis (AATD alone). Both groups contained patients with AATD-associated lung disease (emphysema and chronic bronchitis). At least half of the samples (55.5 %) from AATD alone were positive for a PPB and almost three quarters (72.8 %) of those with bronchiectasis. Presence of a Pseudomonas species, Staphylococcus aureus or Moraxella catarrhalis during stable state disease were all significantly associated with increased likelihood of a subsequent exacerbation (OR: 1.89, p = 0.0013; 1.98, 0.0022; 1.98, 0.0047; 2.19, 0.0047, respectively), independent of age, sex, disease severity (FEV1 impairment), smoking status and presence or absence of bronchiectasis. Disease progression in AATD is variable and identification of traits which may contribute may prove influential. Here, we report that bacterial colonisation is an important predictor of exacerbation in AATD, likely attributed to the associated levels of increased inflammation. Thereby, this may represent a sub cohort of patients that could benefit from additional, targeted therapy.

Priorities and barriers for research related to primary ciliary dyskinesia

Background

Despite advances in primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) research, many questions remain; diagnosis is complex and no disease-specific therapies exist. Using a mixed-methods approach, we aimed to identify priorities for clinical and epidemiological research and explore barriers to research.

Methods

To obtain rich, relevant, diverse data, we performed in-depth semi-structured interviews with PCD specialists selected using purposive sampling. We transcribed, coded and analysed interview data using thematic analysis. Based on interview themes that we identified, we developed an anonymous survey and circulated it widely through the BEAT-PCD network.

Results

We interviewed 28 participants from 15 countries across different disciplines and expertise levels. The main themes identified as priorities for PCD research were improving diagnosis; understanding prevalence and disease course; phenotypic variability; disease monitoring; treatment strategies; clinical trial end-points; and poorly researched areas. In total, 136 participants (49% paediatric pulmonologists) from 36 countries completed the survey. Most commonly reported barriers for research were low awareness about PCD and difficulties securing funding - in more than one-third of cases, participants reported undertaking predominantly unfunded research. Research questions ranked highest included priorities related to further improving diagnosis, treating PCD, managing upper and lower airway problems, and studying clinical variability and disease prognosis.

Conclusion

We need to overcome barriers of limited funding and low awareness and promote collaborations between centres, disciplines, experts and patients to address identified PCD priorities effectively. Our results contribute to the ongoing efforts of guiding the use of existing limited research resources and setting up a roadmap for future research activities.

Antitrypsin deficiency: still more to learn about the lung after 60 years

The past 60 years have seen multiple publications related to lung disease in α1-antitrypsin deficiency largely reflecting the pathophysiology, biochemical effect and outcomes of augmentation therapy. However, the complexity of disease phenotype and the impact of the natural history presents problems of patient management, study design and hence interpretation of outcome. Although many national and some international registries exist, the lack of consistent in-depth assessment and importantly, the impact of augmentation therapy likely influences our perception of the true natural history. Development of new therapeutic strategies, and even assessment of the role and efficacy of augmentation, remain a challenge as powering such studies for conventional COPD outcomes is impractical due to relative rarity of the genetic condition and the presence of clinical phenotypic variation. The current review approaches these issues, discusses the nature and complexity of assessing patient variability, and provides guidance on further studies required to address them.

Recommendations for the Implementation of the Self-Administration of Alpha-1 Antitrypsin

Purpose

Administration of exogenous alpha-1 antitrypsin (AAT) is the only specific therapy for the management of pulmonary morbidity in patients with AAT deficiency. It requires weekly or biweekly intravenous infusions, which may impact patient independence and quality of life. Self-administration of AAT therapy is an alternative to reduce the burden for patients who require AAT therapy. We presented herein experts' recommendations for the implementation of a program for the self-administration of AAT.

Methods

This project was conducted using a modified nominal group technique and was undertaken in two online meetings involving the participation of 25 experts: specialists in pulmonology (n=17), nurses (n=5) and hospital pharmacists (n=3).

Results

The following issues were discussed, and several recommendations were agreed upon on the following topics: a) patient profile and clinical evaluation, establishing selection criteria that should include clinical as well as social criteria; b) role of health care professionals, suggested roles for specialists in pulmonology, nurses, and hospital pharmacists; c) training by the nurse, including recommendations before initiating the training and the content of the training sessions; and d) logistic issues and follow-up, adherence, and patient support.

Conclusion

We expect this proposal to increase awareness of this therapeutic alternative and facilitate the implementation of self-administration programs, thus contributing to optimizing the patient experience with AAT therapy. Further research on the outcomes of these programs, especially from the patient perspective, will also help to improve their design and implementation.

Principles of patient partnership: integrating patient perspectives into ERS Clinical Research Collaborations

Patient and public involvement in research is increasingly considered a cornerstone of good research practice, and the research community recognises people with lived experience as valuable stakeholders within the research process. European Respiratory Society (ERS) strongly encourages patient input into its research programme and scientific activities, working in partnership with the European Lung Foundation (ELF) to facilitate this. Based on the ERS and ELF experience and best practice in the field of patient and public involvement, we developed a set of principles to which future ERS and ELF collaborations should adhere. These principles provide guidance on how to address key challenges when planning and conducting patient and public involvement in order to develop successful partnerships with patients and drive forward patient-centred research.

Disease burden associated with alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency: systematic and structured literature reviews

Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) is a rare genetic disorder characterised by reduced levels of circulating alpha-1 antitrypsin and an increased risk of lung and liver disease. Recent reviews of AATD have focused on diagnosis, epidemiology and clinical management; comprehensive reviews examining disease burden are lacking. Therefore, we conducted literature reviews to investigate the AATD disease burden for patients, caregivers and healthcare systems. Embase, PubMed and Cochrane libraries were searched for AATD publications from database inception to June 2021, in accordance with Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Most published AATD studies were small and short in duration, with variations in populations, designs, measures and outcomes, complicating cross-study comparisons. AATD was associated with significant pulmonary and hepatic morbidity. COPD, emphysema and bronchiectasis were common lung morbidities, where smoking was a key risk factor. Fibrosis and steatosis were the most common liver complications reported in patients with a PiZ allele. Health status analyses suggested a poorer quality of life for AATD patients diagnosed with COPD versus those with non-AATD-associated COPD. The burden for caregivers included loss of personal time due to caring responsibilities, stress and anxiety. AATD was also associated with high direct medical costs and healthcare resource utilisation.

Opinions and Attitudes of Pulmonologists About Augmentation Therapy in Patients with Alpha-1 Antitrypsin Deficiency. A Survey of the EARCO Group

Background

Augmentation therapy (AT) is the only specific treatment licensed for patients with alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) associated lung disease. Since patients with severe AATD may have a very different prognosis and AT requires intravenous infusions for life, the decision to initiate AT may be challenging.

Methods

This survey was conducted on 63 experts in AATD from 13 European countries about their opinions and attitudes regarding AT. Participants were asked to rank the importance of 11 identified factors related with the prescription of AT. In addition, each participant was asked to respond to the indication of AT for 30 out of 500 hypothetical cases developed with the combinations of the 11 factors. Each case was evaluated by 3 experts to check the concordance.

Results

The variables that scored higher on preferences for initiating AT were AAT genotype (score 8.6 from a Likert scale 0–10 (SD: 1.7)), AATD serum level (8.2 (SD:2.4)) and FEV1 (%) decline (7.9 (SD:2.4)). Among the 500 different cases, there was an agreement in indication of AT among the 3 experts in 291 (58.2%). Regarding the variables associated with AT, it was indicated to 81.9% of Pi*ZZ, 52.4% of Pi*SZ and 9.8% of Pi*MZ (p < 0.0001). For Pi*ZZ patients, multivariate analysis identified younger age, reduced FEV1 (%), higher FEV1 decline and worse emphysema as significantly associated with prescription (AUC = 0.8114); for Pi*SZ variables were younger age, worse FEV1 (%) and worse emphysema (AUC = 0.7414); and for Pi*MZ younger age, worse DLCO (%), higher DLCO decline and dyspnea (AUC = 0.8387).

Conclusion

There is a high variability in the criteria for prescription of AT among European experts. Most cases were recommended AT according to guidelines, but a significant number of patients with genotype Pi*SZ and almost 10% Pi*MZ were recommended to initiate AT despite the lack of evidence of efficacy in these genotypes.

Clinical and functional characteristics of individuals with alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency: EARCO international registry

BACKGROUND

Alpha-1 antitrypsin deficiency (AATD) is a rare disease that is associated with an increased risk of pulmonary emphysema. The European AATD Research Collaboration (EARCO) international registry was founded with the objective of characterising the individuals with AATD and investigating their natural history.

METHODS

The EARCO registry is an international, observational and prospective study of individuals with AATD, defined as AAT serum levels < 11 μM and/or proteinase inhibitor genotypes PI*ZZ, PI*SZ and compound heterozygotes or homozygotes of other rare deficient variants. We describe the characteristics of the individuals included from February 2020 to May 2022.

RESULTS

A total of 1044 individuals from 15 countries were analysed. The most frequent genotype was PI*ZZ (60.2%), followed by PI*SZ (29.2%). Among PI*ZZ patients, emphysema was the most frequent lung disease (57.2%) followed by COPD (57.2%) and bronchiectasis (22%). Up to 76.4% had concordant values of FEV1(%) and KCO(%). Those with impairment in FEV1(%) alone had more frequently bronchiectasis and asthma and those with impairment in KCO(%) alone had more frequent emphysema and liver disease. Multivariate analysis showed that advanced age, male sex, exacerbations, increased blood platelets and neutrophils, augmentation and lower AAT serum levels were associated with worse FEV1(%).

CONCLUSIONS

EARCO has recruited > 1000 individuals with AATD from 15 countries in its first 2 years. Baseline cross sectional data provide relevant information about the clinical phenotypes of the disease, the patterns of functional impairment and factors associated with poor lung function. Trial registration www.

CLINICALTRIALS

gov (ID: NCT04180319).