Surface pretreatment for prolonged survival of cemented tibial prosthesis components: full- vs. surface-cementation technique

Titanium - a Cementable Material for Endoarthroplasty

As materials for arthroplasty, titanium alloys exhibit the following advantages over conventional steel, cobalt chromium or chromium nickel alloys - good fatigue strength, excellent biocompatibility, low modulus of elasticity, and high corrosion resistance. The previous worse clinical outcome was most likely caused by crevice corrosion and led to reduced use. To warrant safe use, the design should be optimised (sufficient proximal diameter, proximal collar), in order to reduce unwanted deformation in the proximal part of the prosthesis. Additionally, a rough surface (Ra > 2.5 µm) should not be used. Further research in surface treatments (e. g. silicate-silane) could facilitate additional improvement.

The Effects of Cyclic Loading and Motion on the Implant-Cement Interface and Cement Mantle of PEEK and Cobalt-Chromium Femoral Total Knee Arthroplasty Implants: A Preliminary Study

This study investigated the fixation of a cemented PEEK femoral TKA component. PEEK and CoCr implants were subjected to a walking gait cycle for 10 million cycles (MC), 100,000 cycles or 0 cycles (unloaded control). A method was developed to assess the fixation at the cement-implant interface, which exposed the implants to a fluorescent penetrant dye solution. The lateral condyles of the implants were then sectioned and viewed under fluorescence to investigate bonding at the cement-implant interface and cracking of the cement mantle. When tested for 100,000 cycles, debonding of the cement-implant interface occurred in both PEEK (61%) and CoCr (13%) implants. When the duration of testing was extended (10 MC), the percentage debonding was further increased for both materials to 88% and 61% for PEEK and CoCr, respectively. The unloaded PEEK specimens were 79% debonded, which suggests that, when PEEK femoral components are cemented, complete bonding may never occur. Analysis of cracks in the cement mantle showed an absence of full-thickness cracks in the unloaded control group. For the 100,000-cycle samples, on average, 1.3 and 0.7 cracks were observed for PEEK and CoCr specimens, respectively. After 10 MC, these increased to 24 for PEEK and 19 for CoCr. This was a preliminary study with a limited number of samples investigated, but shows that, after 10 MC under a walking gait, substantial debonding was visible for both PEEK and CoCr implants at the cement-implant interface and no significant difference in the number of cement cracks was found between the two materials.

Revision TKA with a condylar constrained prosthesis using metaphyseal and surface cementation: a minimum 6-year follow-up analysis

Background

The increasing number of revision knee arthroplasty result in the more frequently use of a constraint implant but results from previous reports are difficult to interpret. The purpose of this study was to compare the long-term outcomes of superficial cemented versus metaphyseal cemented in revision total knee arthroplasty with a condylar constrained arthroplasty.

Methods

The study was a retrospective analysis of clinical and radiographic outcomes in a series of revision total knee arthroplasties performed with a constrained condylar knee prosthesis and press-fit modular stems. We hypothesized that the clinical and radiographic outcome of surface cementation would be inferior to that of metaphyseal cementation. Fifty-two consecutive revision cases were followed for a median of 8.2 years (range, 6 to 10 years).

Results

Substantial improvements in range of motion and Knee Society score were achieved in all patients, although these were not significant between groups. Significantly more radiolucent lines were visible on the tibial component with surface cementation than with metaphyseal cementation, although the clinical differences were not relevant.

Conclusions

Radiologic outcome was better in revision total knee arthroplasty using metaphyseal cemented revision and components with press-fit cementless stems than in the surface cementation–based approach; however, the difference was not clinically relevant.

Validation of a measuring technique with computed tomography for cement penetration into trabecular bone underneath the tibial tray in total knee arthroplasty on a cadaver model

Background

In total knee arthroplasty (TKA), cement penetration between 3 and 5 mm beneath the tibial tray is required to prevent loosening of the tibia component. The objective of this study was to develop and validate a reliable in vivo measuring technique using CT imaging to assess cement distribution and penetration depth in the total area underneath a tibia prosthesis.

Methods

We defined the radiodensity ranges for trabecular tibia bone, polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) cement and cement-penetrated trabecular bone and measured the percentages of cement penetration at various depths after cementing two tibia prostheses onto redundant femoral heads. One prosthesis was subsequently removed to examine the influence of the metal tibia prostheses on the quality of the CT images. The percentages of cement penetration in the CT slices were compared with percentages measured with photographs of the corresponding transversal slices.

Results

Trabecular bone and cement-penetrated trabecular bone had no overlap in quantitative scale of radio-density. There was no significant difference in mean HU values when measuring with or without the tibia prosthesis. The percentages of measured cement-penetrated trabecular bone in the CT slices of the specimen were within the range of percentages that could be expected based on the measurements with the photographs (p = 0.04).

Conclusions

CT scan images provide valid results in measuring the penetration and distribution of cement into trabecular bone underneath the tibia component of a TKA. Since the proposed method does not turn metal elements into artefacts, it enables clinicians to assess the width and density of the cement mantle in vivo and to compare the results of different cementing methods in TKA.

Probability of mechanical loosening of the femoral component in high flexion total knee arthroplasty can be reduced by rather simple surgical techniques

BACKGROUND

Some follow-up studies of high flexion total knee arthoplasties report disturbingly high incidences of femoral component loosening. Femoral implant fixation is dependant on two interfaces: the cement-implant and the cement-bone interface. The present finite-element model (FEM) is the first to analyse both the cement-implant interface and cement-bone interface. The cement-bone interface is divided into cement-cancellous and cement-cortical bone interfaces, each having their own strength values. The research questions were: (1) which of the two interfaces is more prone to failure? and (2) what is the effect of different surgical preparation techniques for cortical bone on the risk of early failure.?

METHODS

FEM was used in which the posterior-stabilized PFC Sigma RP-F (DePuy) TKA components were incorporated. A full weight-bearing squatting cycle was simulated (ROM=50°-155°). An interface failure index (FI) was calculated for both interfaces.

RESULTS

The cement-bone interface is more prone to failure than the cement implant interface. When drilling holes through the cortex behind the anterior flange instead of unprepared cortical bone, the area prone to early interface failure can be reduced from 31.3% to 2.6%.

CONCLUSION

The results clearly demonstrate high risk of early failure at the cement-bone interface. This risk can be reduced by some simple preparation techniques of the cortex behind the anterior flange.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

High-flexion TKA is currently being introduced. Some reports show high failure rates. FEM can be helpful in understanding failure of implants.

The Self-Aligning knee prosthesis: clinical and radiological outcome and survival analysis at 5-year follow up

The purpose of this study is to evaluate the clinical and radiological results and the survival of the SAL II mobile bearing knee prosthesis at 5-year follow up. Between February 1995 and March 1998 a total of 246 SAL II total knee arthroplasties were performed in 232 patients. The mean follow up was 5.0 years. Thirteen revisions had been carried out (5%). The mean total Knee Society Score increased from 88 preoperatively to 153 and 155 at 1 and 5 years follow up, respectively. The mean flexion angles were 106 degrees and 107 degrees pre- and postoperatively. None of the prostheses showed radiological loosening. No dislocations or subluxations of inserts were seen. The Kaplan-Meier cumulative survival is 95% for revision for any reason at 5.0 years, with a worst case scenario of 91%. The survival for aseptic loosening is 99%. The results of SAL II after a minimum follow up of 5 years are favourable and comparable with fixed bearing and other mobile bearing designs in terms of Knee Society Score and survival. Noteworthy are the good radiological results of this device which showed a good fixation of the prosthesis at 5 years.