Variation of the element composition of municipal sewage sludges in the context of new regulations on phosphorus recovery in Germany

Phosphorus speciation in sewage sludge and their ashes after incineration as a function of treatment processes

Phosphorus (P) is a key component in agricultural fertilizers, but it is also a scarce resource, why its recycling has been thoroughly investigated and one promising resources is sewage sludge. Because of stricter regulations in terms of sludge disposal, thermal treatment (e.g. incineration) has become an attractive option. The incineration process alters the chemical speciation of P in favour to calcium-associated (apatite, apatite phosphorus (AP)) species, which is preferred for P recovery. In order to achieve qualitatively transformation, it is important to identify limiting or promoting factors. This study reports on the impact of iron, aluminium and calcium on the transformation of iron- and aluminium-phosphate (NAIP) to AP species, assessed by studying sludge and ash from 10 municipal wastewater treatment plants in Sweden. The effect of iron and aluminium added in the treatment processes was also evaluated. The obtained results show that high calcium concentration favours formation of AP species in both sludge and ashes, whereas high concentration of iron and aluminium favours formation of NAIP species in the sludge. The transformation from NAIP to AP species is hampered by aluminium, irrespectively of its origin, whereas no such correlations could be seen for iron. Therefore, in order to enable efficient P recovery from sewage sludge ash, the amount of aluminium added in the treatment process, as well as its concentration in influent streams to the treatment plants, must be limited.

Heavy metal(loid)s and nutrients in sewage sludge in Portugal - Suitability for use in agricultural soils and assessment of potential risks

The presence of heavy metal(loid)s in sewage sludge is a cause of concern and an obstacle to its agricultural valorisation. This study analysed the elemental composition of sewage sludge from 42 Portuguese wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) during summer and winter, investigating heavy metal(loid) contamination, nutrient content, and potential risks related to sludge application to agricultural soils. Levels of 8 heavy metal(loid)s were investigated, ranging from not detected (Hg) to 5120 mg kg-1 dw (Zn), decreasing in the order Zn > Cu > Cr > Ni > Pb > As>Cd > Hg. The legal requirements for agricultural use of sludge were overall met, but elevated levels of Zn and Cu, linked to industrial sources, exceeded the permitted limits in 3 WWTPs. On average, N, P, K, Mg, and Ca comprised 80 % of the sludge nutrient profile. No seasonal variations were found, but sludge composition varied with WWTP size, wastewater origin, and between thickened and digested samples. Environmental hazard indicators showed significant sludge contamination with Zn, Cu, and Cd. However, the geoaccumulation index, potential ecological risk indicators, and risk characterization ratios showed no significant risks to sludge-amended soils, assuming a single application of 5 tons ha-1. Human health risk assessment for workers handling sewage sludge identified dermal contact as the main route of exposure, with non-carcinogenic risk for Cr and carcinogenic risk for Ni and Cr at the highest reported levels. Sewage sludge produced in Portugal was considered suitable for agricultural use, provided that it is closely monitored and well-managed to meet the needs of crops and receiving soils, while mitigating environmental risks.

Application of QuEChERS extraction and LC-MS/MS for determination of pharmaceuticals in sewage sludges sampled across the Czech Republic

The use of pharmaceuticals entails a significant risk of environmental contamination. Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are considered to be the main contributors to contamination as they ineffectively eliminate these compounds from wastewater. Simultaneously, they produce solid waste, sludge, which often contains a variety of retained pollutants, including pharmaceuticals. Since sewage sludge is frequently applied to agricultural soil due to its rich nutrient content, pollutants are introduced into the environment in this way. Only a few studies have been carried out on the topic of the analysis of pharmaceuticals in sludge. Therefore, information on the occurrence of pharmaceuticals in sludge is limited. The present study employed quick, easy, cheap, effective, rugged and safe (QuEChERS) extraction and liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (LC-MS/MS) analysis to establish a simple and reliable procedure for determining 16 pharmaceuticals (antibiotics, anticonvulsants, antidepressants and β-blockers) in sewage sludge. The method has been thoroughly validated, and parameters such as linear range, accuracy, precision, matrix effects and detection and quantification limits were assessed. Our method achieved low limits of quantification (0.5-9.0 µg kg-1) and satisfactory recoveries (51-101%). Forty sludge samples from different WWTPs across the Czech Republic were analysed. Fourteen compounds were detected and quantified in most samples, with antidepressants having the highest detection frequency and overall content. Sertraline, with a mean concentration of 521.0 µg kg-1, was notably prevalent alongside its metabolite norsertraline (mean concentration 204.9 µg kg-1). The antibiotic azithromycin was also found at higher levels (mean concentration 185.1 µg kg-1).

Guidelines for efficient nitrogen preservation in sewage sludge-based fertilizers

This study explores sustainable methods to mitigate nitrogen (N) loss in agriculture amid rising food demands and limited arable land. It examines sewage sludge (SS) as an alternative to synthetic N fertilizers. SS is rich in nitrogen (4.21 ± 0.42 %) and phosphorus (3.60 ± 0.72 %), making it suitable for nutrient recovery and soil enhancement. Unfavorable sludge management methods result in the loss of 950,000 tons of nitrogen, meeting almost 10 % of the EU's nitrogen fertilization demand. This research evaluates SS treatment methods, including chemical conversion, thermal treatment, and biological composting, focusing on nitrogen conservation efficiency. Results show nitrogen loss during hydrolysis is minimized at pH 4 to 8 but increases significantly as ammonia (NH3) at pH 9 to 11, ranging from 4.2 % to 9 %. Neutralizing the hydrolysate is crucial; using solid KOH resulted in 13.5 % nitrogen loss, 11 times more than using slightly alkaline ash (1.22 %). Adding ash during drying reduced nitrogen emissions by 30 % compared to traditional drying at 105 °C. Improving the C/N ratio with food residues reduced nitrogen losses by 46.3 % during composting. These findings highlight the importance of pH control in chemical processes and temperature regulation in thermal treatments. Adding residues from other processes, such as biomass combustion waste, enhances SS processing conditions. Understanding nitrogen retention mechanisms is crucial for the environmental sustainability of SS usage. Efficient nitrogen retention strategies improve the fertilization value of SS and reduce its environmental footprint by lowering greenhouse gas emissions, particularly ammonia. Reducing nitrogen loss during SS treatment significantly lowers ammonia emissions, a major contributor to greenhouse gas emissions. These results help determine optimal methods for managing and processing SS to minimize emissions and increase agricultural usability.

Response of phosphorus fractions transformation and microbial community to carbon-to-phosphorus ratios during sludge composting

Phosphorus (P) is one of the essential nutrient elements for plant growth and development. Sludge compost products can be used as an important source of soil P to solve the shortage of soil P. The difference in the initial carbon-to-phosphorus ratio (C/P) will lead to difference in the bacterial community, which would affect the biological pathway of P conversion in composting. However, few studies have been reported on adjusting the initial C/P of composting to explore P conversion. Therefore, this study investigated the response of P component transformations, bacterial community and P availability to C/P during sludge composting by adjusting initial C/P. The results showed that increasing C/P promoted the mineralization of organic P and significantly increased the content of the labile P. High C/P also increased the relative content of available P, especially when the C/P was at 45 and 60, it reached 60.51% and 60.47%. High C/P caused differences in the community structure, and improved the binding ability of microbial network modules and the competitiveness of microbial communities. Additionally, high C/P strengthened the effect of microbial communities on the transformation of P components. Finally, the study showed that C/P was the main contributor to P content variation (64.7%) and indirectly affected P component conversion by affecting the microbial community. Therefore, adjusting the C/P is crucial to improve the P utilization rate of composting products.

Phosphorus recovery from domestic wastewater: A review of the institutional framework

Phosphorus (P) is an essential element for life that must be managed sustainably. The institutional framework for P recovery from wastewater includes policies, regulations, plans, and actions that promote the recovery, recycling, and safe use of this element, aimed at moving toward more sustainable nutrient management and environmental protection. This review analyzes the status of the institutional framework for P recovery from wastewater in different countries around the world. Europe is the continent where the most progress has been made in terms of legislation. Countries such as Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, and Denmark have already implemented policies and regulations that promote environmental protection, as well as P recovery and reuse. In other parts of the world, such as the United States, China, and Japan, there have also been significant advances in promoting the closure of the P cycle, with the implementation of advanced recovery technologies in wastewater treatment plants and regional/national action plans. By contrast, in Latin America there has been little progress in P treatment and recovery, with a weak regulatory framework, unclear goals, and insufficient allocation of techno-economic resources. In this context, it is necessary to reinforce the comprehensive institutional framework, which covers technological aspects, economic incentives, political agreements, and regulations, to promote the sustainable management of this valuable resource.

Phytoextraction Options

Wastewaters often contain an array of economically valuable elements, including elements considered critical raw materials and elements for fertilizer production. Plant-based treatment approaches in constructed wetlands, open ponds, or hydroponic systems represent an eco-friendly and economical way to remove potentially toxic metal(loid)s from wastewater (phytoextraction). Concomitantly, the element-enriched biomass represents an important secondary raw material for bioenergy generation and the recovery of raw materials from the harvested plant biomass (phytomining). At present, phytoextraction in constructed wetlands is still considered a nascent technology that still requires more fundamental and applied research before it can be commercially applied. This chapter discusses the different roles of plants in constructed wetlands during the phytoextraction of economically valuable elements. It sheds light on the utilization of plant biomass in the recovery of raw materials from wastewater streams. Here, we consider phytoextraction of the commonly studied water pollutants (N, P, Zn, Cd, Pb, Cr) and expand this concept to a group of rather exotic metal(loid)s (Ge, REE, PGM) highlighting the role of phytoextraction in the face of climate change and finite resources of high-tech metals.