SCNVSim: somatic copy number variation and structure variation simulator

Evaluation of simulation methods for tumor subclonal reconstruction

Most neoplastic tumors originate from a single cell, and their evolution can be genetically traced through lineages characterized by common alterations such as small somatic mutations (SSMs), copy number alterations (CNAs), structural variants (SVs), and aneuploidies. Due to the complexity of these alterations in most tumors and the errors introduced by sequencing protocols and calling algorithms, tumor subclonal reconstruction algorithms are necessary to recapitulate the DNA sequence composition and tumor evolution in silico. With a growing number of these algorithms available, there is a pressing need for consistent and comprehensive benchmarking, which relies on realistic tumor sequencing generated by simulation tools. Here, we examine the current simulation methods, identifying their strengths and weaknesses, and provide recommendations for their improvement. Our review also explores potential new directions for research in this area. This work aims to serve as a resource for understanding and enhancing tumor genomic simulations, contributing to the advancement of the field.

PEcnv: accurate and efficient detection of copy number variations of various lengths

Copy number variation (CNV) is a class of key biomarkers in many complex traits and diseases. Detecting CNV from sequencing data is a substantial bioinformatics problem and a standard requirement in clinical practice. Although many proposed CNV detection approaches exist, the core statistical model at their foundation is weakened by two critical computational issues: (i) identifying the optimal setting on the sliding window and (ii) correcting for bias and noise. We designed a statistical process model to overcome these limitations by calculating regional read depths via an exponentially weighted moving average strategy. A one-run detection of CNVs of various lengths is then achieved by a dynamic sliding window, whose size is self-adopted according to the weighted averages. We also designed a novel bias/noise reduction model, accompanied by the moving average, which can handle complicated patterns and extend training data. This model, called PEcnv, accurately detects CNVs ranging from kb-scale to chromosome-arm level. The model performance was validated with simulation samples and real samples. Comparative analysis showed that PEcnv outperforms current popular approaches. Notably, PEcnv provided considerable advantages in detecting small CNVs (1 kb–1 Mb) in panel sequencing data. Thus, PEcnv fills the gap left by existing methods focusing on large CNVs. PEcnv may have broad applications in clinical testing where panel sequencing is the dominant strategy. Availability and implementation: Source code is freely available at https://github.com/Sherwin-xjtu/PEcnv

J-SPACE: a Julia package for the simulation of spatial models of cancer evolution and of sequencing experiments

Background

The combined effects of biological variability and measurement-related errors on cancer sequencing data remain largely unexplored. However, the spatio-temporal simulation of multi-cellular systems provides a powerful instrument to address this issue. In particular, efficient algorithmic frameworks are needed to overcome the harsh trade-off between scalability and expressivity, so to allow one to simulate both realistic cancer evolution scenarios and the related sequencing experiments, which can then be used to benchmark downstream bioinformatics methods.

Result

We introduce a Julia package for SPAtial Cancer Evolution (J-SPACE), which allows one to model and simulate a broad set of experimental scenarios, phenomenological rules and sequencing settings.Specifically, J-SPACE simulates the spatial dynamics of cells as a continuous-time multi-type birth-death stochastic process on a arbitrary graph, employing different rules of interaction and an optimised Gillespie algorithm. The evolutionary dynamics of genomic alterations (single-nucleotide variants and indels) is simulated either under the Infinite Sites Assumption or several different substitution models, including one based on mutational signatures. After mimicking the spatial sampling of tumour cells, J-SPACE returns the related phylogenetic model, and allows one to generate synthetic reads from several Next-Generation Sequencing (NGS) platforms, via the ART read simulator. The results are finally returned in standard FASTA, FASTQ, SAM, ALN and Newick file formats.

Conclusion

J-SPACE is designed to efficiently simulate the heterogeneous behaviour of a large number of cancer cells and produces a rich set of outputs. Our framework is useful to investigate the emergent spatial dynamics of cancer subpopulations, as well as to assess the impact of incomplete sampling and of experiment-specific errors. Importantly, the output of J-SPACE is designed to allow the performance assessment of downstream bioinformatics pipelines processing NGS data. J-SPACE is freely available at: https://github.com/BIMIB-DISCo/J-Space.jl.

A benchmark of structural variation detection by long reads through a realistic simulated model

Accurate simulations of structural variation distributions and sequencing data are crucial for the development and benchmarking of new tools. We develop Sim-it, a straightforward tool for the simulation of both structural variation and long-read data. These simulations from Sim-it reveal the strengths and weaknesses for current available structural variation callers and long-read sequencing platforms. With these findings, we develop a new method (combiSV) that can combine the results from structural variation callers into a superior call set with increased recall and precision, which is also observed for the latest structural variation benchmark set developed by the GIAB Consortium.

ERINS: Novel Sequence Insertion Detection by Constructing an Extended Reference

Next generation sequencing technology has led to the development of methods for the detection of novel sequence insertions (nsINS). Multiple signatures from short reads are usually extracted to improve nsINS detection performance. However, characterization of nsINSs larger than the mean insert size is still challenging. This article presents a new method, ERINS, to detect nsINS contents and genotypes of full spectrum range size. It integrates the features of structural variations and mapping states of split reads to find nsINS breakpoints, and then adopts a left-most mapping strategy to infer nsINS content by iteratively extending the standard reference at each breakpoint. Finally, it realigns all reads to the extended reference and infers nsINS genotypes through statistical testing on read counts. We test and validate the performance of ERINS on simulation and real sequencing datasets. The simulation experimental results demonstrate that it outperforms several peer methods with respect to sensitivity and precision. The real data application indicates that ERINS obtains high consistent results with those of previously reported and detects nsINSs over 200 base pairs that many other methods fail. In conclusion, ERINS can be used as a supplement to existing tools and will become a routine approach for characterizing nsINSs.

VISOR: a versatile haplotype-aware structural variant simulator for short- and long-read sequencing

SUMMARY

VISOR is a tool for haplotype-specific simulations of simple and complex structural variants (SVs). The method is applicable to haploid, diploid or higher ploidy simulations for bulk or single-cell sequencing data. SVs are implanted into FASTA haplotypes at single-basepair resolution, optionally with nearby single-nucleotide variants. Short or long reads are drawn at random from these haplotypes using standard error profiles. Double- or single-stranded data can be simulated and VISOR supports the generation of haplotype-tagged BAM files. The tool further includes methods to interactively visualize simulated variants in single-stranded data. The versatility of VISOR is unmet by comparable tools and it lays the foundation to simulate haplotype-resolved cancer heterogeneity data in bulk or at single-cell resolution.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

VISOR is implemented in python 3.6, open-source and freely available at https://github.com/davidebolo1993/VISOR. Documentation is available at https://davidebolo1993.github.io/visordoc/.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

SimuSCoP: reliably simulate Illumina sequencing data based on position and context dependent profiles

BACKGROUND

A number of simulators have been developed for emulating next-generation sequencing data by incorporating known errors such as base substitutions and indels. However, their practicality may be degraded by functional and runtime limitations. Particularly, the positional and genomic contextual information is not effectively utilized for reliably characterizing base substitution patterns, as well as the positional and contextual difference of Phred quality scores is not fully investigated. Thus, a more effective and efficient bioinformatics tool is sorely required.

RESULTS

Here, we introduce a novel tool, SimuSCoP, to reliably emulate complex DNA sequencing data. The base substitution patterns and the statistical behavior of quality scores in Illumina sequencing data are fully explored and integrated into the simulation model for reliably emulating datasets for different applications. In addition, an integrated and easy-to-use pipeline is employed in SimuSCoP to facilitate end-to-end simulation of complex samples, and high runtime efficiency is achieved by implementing the tool to run in multithreading with low memory consumption. These features enable SimuSCoP to gets substantial improvements in reliability, functionality, practicality and runtime efficiency. The tool is comprehensively evaluated in multiple aspects including consistency of profiles, simulation of genomic variations and complex tumor samples, and the results demonstrate the advantages of SimuSCoP over existing tools.

CONCLUSIONS

SimuSCoP, a new bioinformatics tool is developed to learn informative profiles from real sequencing data and reliably mimic complex data by introducing various genomic variations. We believe that the presented work will catalyse new development of downstream bioinformatics methods for analyzing sequencing data.

Next-generation forward genetic screens: using simulated data to improve the design of mapping-by-sequencing experiments in Arabidopsis

Forward genetic screens have successfully identified many genes and continue to be powerful tools for dissecting biological processes in Arabidopsis and other model species. Next-generation sequencing technologies have revolutionized the time-consuming process of identifying the mutations that cause a phenotype of interest. However, due to the cost of such mapping-by-sequencing experiments, special attention should be paid to experimental design and technical decisions so that the read data allows to map the desired mutation. Here, we simulated different mapping-by-sequencing scenarios. We first evaluated which short-read technology was best suited for analyzing gene-rich genomic regions in Arabidopsis and determined the minimum sequencing depth required to confidently call single nucleotide variants. We also designed ways to discriminate mutagenesis-induced mutations from background Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms in mutants isolated in Arabidopsis non-reference lines. In addition, we simulated bulked segregant mapping populations for identifying point mutations and monitored how the size of the mapping population and the sequencing depth affect mapping precision. Finally, we provide the computational basis of a protocol that we already used to map T-DNA insertions with paired-end Illumina-like reads, using very low sequencing depths and pooling several mutants together; this approach can also be used with single-end reads as well as to map any other insertional mutagen. All these simulations proved useful for designing experiments that allowed us to map several mutations in Arabidopsis.

SVSR: A Program to Simulate Structural Variations and Generate Sequencing Reads for Multiple Platforms

Structural variation accounts for a major fraction of mutations in the human genome and confers susceptibility to complex diseases. Next generation sequencing along with the rapid development of computational methods provides a cost-effective procedure to detect such variations. Simulation of structural variations and sequencing reads with real characteristics is essential for benchmarking the computational methods. Here, we develop a new program, SVSR, to simulate five types of structural variations (indels, tandem duplication, CNVs, inversions, and translocations) and SNPs for the human genome and to generate sequencing reads with features from popular platforms (Illumina, SOLiD, 454, and Ion Torrent). We adopt a selection model trained from real data to predict copy number states, starting from the first site of a particular genome to the end. Furthermore, we utilize references of microbial genomes to produce insertion fragments and design probabilistic models to imitate inversions and translocations. Moreover, we create platform-specific errors and base quality profiles to generate normal, tumor, or normal-tumor mixture reads. Experimental results show that SVSR could capture more features that are realistic and generate datasets with satisfactory quality scores. SVSR is able to evaluate the performance of structural variation detection methods and guide the development of new computational methods.

MVSC: A Multi-variation Simulator of Cancer Genome

BACKGROUND

Many forms of variations exist in the genome, which are the main causes of individual phenotypic differences. The detection of variants, especially those located in the tumor genome, still faces many challenges due to the complexity of the genome structure. Thus, the performance assessment of variation detection tools using next-generation sequencing platforms is urgently needed.

METHOD

We have created a software package called the Multi-Variation Simulator of Cancer genomes (MVSC) to simulate common genomic variants, including single nucleotide polymorphisms, small insertion and deletion polymorphisms, and structural variations (SVs), which are analogous to human somatically acquired variations. Three sets of variations embedded in genomic sequences in different periods were dynamically and sequentially simulated one by one.

RESULTS

In cancer genome simulation, complex SVs are important because this type of variation is characteristic of the tumor genome structure. Overlapping variations of different sizes can also coexist in the same genome regions, adding to the complexity of cancer genome architecture. Our results show that MVSC can efficiently simulate a variety of genomic variants that cannot be simulated by existing software packages.

CONCLUSION

The MVSC-simulated variants can be used to assess the performance of existing tools designed to detect SVs in next-generation sequencing data, and we also find that MVSC is memory and time-efficient compared with similar software packages.

SECNVs: A Simulator of Copy Number Variants and Whole-Exome Sequences From Reference Genomes

Copy number variants are duplications and deletions of the genome that play an important role in phenotypic changes and human disease. Many software applications have been developed to detect copy number variants using either whole-genome sequencing or whole-exome sequencing data. However, there is poor agreement in the results from these applications. Simulated datasets containing copy number variants allow comprehensive comparisons of the operating characteristics of existing and novel copy number variant detection methods. Several software applications have been developed to simulate copy number variants and other structural variants in whole-genome sequencing data. However, none of the applications reliably simulate copy number variants in whole-exome sequencing data. We have developed and tested Simulator of Exome Copy Number Variants (SECNVs), a fast, robust and customizable software application for simulating copy number variants and whole-exome sequences from a reference genome. SECNVs is easy to install, implements a wide range of commands to customize simulations, can output multiple samples at once, and incorporates a pipeline to output rearranged genomes, short reads and BAM files in a single command. Variants generated by SECNVs are detected with high sensitivity and precision by tools commonly used to detect copy number variants. SECNVs is publicly available at https://github.com/YJulyXing/SECNVs.

PSiTE: a Phylogeny guided Simulator for Tumor Evolution

SUMMARY

Simulating realistic clonal dynamics of tumors is an important topic in cancer genomics. Here, we present Phylogeny guided Simulator for Tumor Evolution, a tool that can simulate different types of tumor samples including single sector, multi-sector bulk tumor as well as single-cell tumor data under a wide range of evolutionary trajectories. Phylogeny guided Simulator for Tumor Evolution provides an efficient tool for understanding clonal evolution of cancer.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

PSiTE is implemented in Python and is available at https://github.com/hchyang/PSiTE.

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Comprehensive evaluation and characterisation of short read general-purpose structural variant calling software

In recent years, many software packages for identifying structural variants (SVs) using whole-genome sequencing data have been released. When published, a new method is commonly compared with those already available, but this tends to be selective and incomplete. The lack of comprehensive benchmarking of methods presents challenges for users in selecting methods and for developers in understanding algorithm behaviours and limitations. Here we report the comprehensive evaluation of 10 SV callers, selected following a rigorous process and spanning the breadth of detection approaches, using high-quality reference cell lines, as well as simulations. Due to the nature of available truth sets, our focus is on general-purpose rather than somatic callers. We characterise the impact on performance of event size and type, sequencing characteristics, and genomic context, and analyse the efficacy of ensemble calling and calibration of variant quality scores. Finally, we provide recommendations for both users and methods developers.

A number of computational methods have been developed for calling structural variants (SVs) using short read sequencing data. Here, the authors perform a comprehensive benchmarking analysis comparing 10 general-purpose callers and provide recommendations for both users and methods developers.

SVEngine: an efficient and versatile simulator of genome structural variations with features of cancer clonal evolution

Background

Simulating genome sequence data with variant features facilitates the development and benchmarking of structural variant analysis programs. However, there are only a few data simulators that provide structural variants in silico and even fewer that provide variants with different allelic fraction and haplotypes.

Findings

We developed SVEngine, an open-source tool to address this need. SVEngine simulates next-generation sequencing data with embedded structural variations. As input, SVEngine takes template haploid sequences (FASTA) and an external variant file, a variant distribution file, and/or a clonal phylogeny tree file (NEWICK) as input. Subsequently, it simulates and outputs sequence contigs (FASTAs), sequence reads (FASTQs), and/or post-alignment files (BAMs). All of the files contain the desired variants, along with BED files containing the ground truth. SVEngine's flexible design process enables one to specify size, position, and allelic fraction for deletions, insertions, duplications, inversions, and translocations. Finally, SVEngine simulates sequence data that replicate the characteristics of a sequencing library with mixed sizes of DNA insert molecules. To improve the compute speed, SVEngine is highly parallelized to reduce the simulation time.

Conclusions

We demonstrated the versatile features of SVEngine and its improved runtime comparisons with other available simulators. SVEngine's features include the simulation of locus-specific variant frequency designed to mimic the phylogeny of cancer clonal evolution. We validated SVEngine's accuracy by simulating genome-wide structural variants of NA12878 and a heterogeneous cancer genome. Our evaluation included checking various sequencing mapping features such as coverage change, read clipping, insert size shift, and neighboring hanging read pairs for representative variant types. Structural variant callers Lumpy and Manta and tumor heterogeneity estimator THetA2 were able to perform realistically on the simulated data. SVEngine is implemented as a standard Python package and is freely available for academic use .

Systematic review of next-generation sequencing simulators: computational tools, features and perspectives

High-throughput next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies have rapidly generated a large volume of genomic data. To aid the development and evaluation of new statistical models and computational methods, NGS-based simulators have been proposed to construct better experimental workflows. However, the comparative performance of these NGS simulators remains unclear. In this review, we conducted a comprehensive investigation of NGS simulators for various sequencing techniques, including DNA sequencing, metagenomic sequencing, RNA-seq, ChIP-seq and bisulfite sequencing for methylation.

Pysim-sv: a package for simulating structural variation data with GC-biases

Background

Structural variations (SVs) are wide-spread in human genomes and may have important implications in disease-related and evolutionary studies. High-throughput sequencing (HTS) has become a major platform for SV detection and simulation serves as a powerful and cost-effective approach for benchmarking SV detection algorithms. Accurate performance assessment by simulation requires the simulator capable of generating simulation data with all important features of real data, such GC biases in HTS data and various complexities in tumor data. However, no available package has systematically addressed all issues in data simulation for SV benchmarking.

Results

Pysim-sv is a package for simulating HTS data to evaluate performance of SV detection algorithms. Pysim-sv can introduce a wide spectrum of germline and somatic genomic variations. The package contains functionalities to simulate tumor data with aneuploidy and heterogeneous subclones, which is very useful in assessing algorithm performance in tumor studies. Furthermore, Pysim-sv can introduce GC-bias, the most important and prevalent bias in HTS data, in the simulated HTS data.

Conclusions

Pysim-sv provides an unbiased toolkit for evaluating HTS-based SV detection algorithms.

Global analysis of somatic structural genomic alterations and their impact on gene expression in diverse human cancers

Tumor genomes are mosaics of somatic structural variants (SVs) that may contribute to the activation of oncogenes or inactivation of tumor suppressors, for example, by altering gene copy number amplitude. However, there are multiple other ways in which SVs can modulate transcription, but the general impact of such events on tumor transcriptional output has not been systematically determined. Here we use whole-genome sequencing data to map SVs across 600 tumors and 18 cancers, and investigate the relationship between SVs, copy number alterations (CNAs), and mRNA expression. We find that 34% of CNA breakpoints can be clarified structurally and that most amplifications are due to tandem duplications. We observe frequent swapping of strong and weak promoters in the context of gene fusions, and find that this has a measurable global impact on mRNA levels. Interestingly, several long noncoding RNAs were strongly activated by this mechanism. Additionally, SVs were confirmed in telomere reverse transcriptase (TERT) upstream regions in several cancers, associated with elevated TERT mRNA levels. We also highlight high-confidence gene fusions supported by both genomic and transcriptomic evidence, including a previously undescribed paired box 8 (PAX8)-nuclear factor, erythroid 2 like 2 (NFE2L2) fusion in thyroid carcinoma. In summary, we combine SV, CNA, and expression data to provide insights into the structural basis of CNAs as well as the impact of SVs on gene expression in tumors.

tHapMix: simulating tumour samples through haplotype mixtures

MOTIVATION

Large-scale rearrangements and copy number changes combined with different modes of clonal evolution create extensive somatic genome diversity, making it difficult to develop versatile and scalable variant calling tools and create well-calibrated benchmarks.

RESULTS

We developed a new simulation framework tHapMix that enables the creation of tumour samples with different ploidy, purity and polyclonality features. It easily scales to simulation of hundreds of somatic genomes, while re-use of real read data preserves noise and biases present in sequencing platforms. We further demonstrate tHapMix utility by creating a simulated set of 140 somatic genomes and showing how it can be used in training and testing of somatic copy number variant calling tools.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

tHapMix is distributed under an open source license and can be downloaded from https://github.com/Illumina/tHapMix CONTACT: sivakhno@illumina.comSupplementary information: Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

cnvCurator: an interactive visualization and editing tool for somatic copy number variations

BACKGROUND

One of the most important somatic aberrations, copy number variations (CNVs) in tumor genomes is believed to have a high probability of harboring oncotargets. Detection of somatic CNVs is an essential part of cancer genome sequencing analysis, but the accuracy is usually limited due to various factors. A post-processing procedure including manual review and refinement of CNV segments is often needed in practice to achieve better accuracy.

RESULTS

cnvCurator is a user-friendly tool with functions specifically designed to facilitate the process of interactively visualizing and editing somatic CNV calling results. Different from other general genomics viewers, the index and display of CNV calling results in cnvCurator is segment central. It incorporates multiple CNV-specific information for concurrent, interactive display, as well as a number of relevant features allowing user to examine and curate the CNV calls.

CONCLUSIONS

cnvCurator provides important and practical utilities to assist the manual review and edition of results from a chosen somatic CNV caller, such that curated CNV segments will be used for down-stream applications.