Genome rearrangements in Escherichia coli during de novo acquisition of resistance to a single antibiotic or two antibiotics successively

De novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance in six species of bacteria

Bacteria can become resistant to antibiotics in two ways: by acquiring resistance genes through horizontal gene transfer and by de novo development of resistance upon exposure to non-lethal concentrations. The importance of the second process, de novo build-up, has not been investigated systematically over a range of species and may be underestimated as a result. To investigate the DNA mutation patterns accompanying the de novo antibiotic resistance acquisition process, six bacterial species encountered in the food chain were exposed to step-wise increasing sublethal concentrations of six antibiotics to develop high levels of resistance. Phenotypic and mutational landscapes were constructed based on whole-genome sequencing at two time points of the evolutionary trajectory. In this study, we found that (1) all of the six strains can develop high levels of resistance against most antibiotics; (2) increased resistance is accompanied by different mutations for each bacterium-antibiotic combination; (3) the number of mutations varies widely, with Y. enterocolitica having by far the most; (4) in the case of fluoroquinolone resistance, a mutational pattern of gyrA combined with parC is conserved in five of six species; and (5) mutations in genes coding for efflux pumps are widely encountered in gram-negative species. The overall conclusion is that very similar phenotypic outcomes are instigated by very different genetic changes. The outcome of this study may assist policymakers when formulating practical strategies to prevent development of antimicrobial resistance in human and veterinary health care.IMPORTANCEMost studies on de novo development of antimicrobial resistance have been performed on Escherichia coli. To examine whether the conclusions of this research can be applied to more bacterial species, six species of veterinary importance were made resistant to six antibiotics, each of a different class. The rapid build-up of resistance observed in all six species upon exposure to non-lethal concentrations of antimicrobials indicates a similar ability to adjust to the presence of antibiotics. The large differences in the number of DNA mutations accompanying de novo resistance suggest that the mechanisms and pathways involved may differ. Hence, very similar phenotypes can be the result of various genotypes. The implications of the outcome are to be considered by policymakers in the area of veterinary and human healthcare.

Antimicrobial resistance genes and associated mobile genetic elements in Escherichia coli from human, animal and environment

The global rise of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) poses a significant threat to human health. The environment plays an essential role in transmission of antimicrobial resistance genes (ARGs) between human and animal. Bacterial communities harbour diverse ARGs, carried by mobile genetic elements (MGEs) like plasmids and insertion sequences (ISs). Here, a total of 2199 Escherichia coli (E. coli) whole genome sequences from human, animal, bird and environment were retrieved globally to investigate ARG prevalence and assess their genetic framework. The study highlights how the genetic background including plasmids, IS elements and transposons surrounding ARGs influences their transmission potential. The maximum number of ARGs was found in United Kingdom followed by USA, majorly in human hosts. However, IS-associated ARGs were most prevalent in bird hosts. ARGs like aph(6)-ld, aph(3″)-lb, blaCTX-M, blaNDM were widespread across all hosts. Tn2 was the most prevalent, majorly carried by IncFIB plasmids. The IS26 and ISVsa3 carried diverse ARGs, primarily linked to aminoglycoside and β-lactam resistance. The combinations like mph(A)_IS6100 and blaNDM-5_IS5 showed fixed IS-ARG associations. ARGs like blaNDM, blaCTX-M variants displayed strong association with IS elements. The study highlights possible mechanism of transmission due to close proximity of AMR genes to MGEs, offering promising strategies to combat AMR by predicting and addressing future resistance determinants.

Role of RelA-synthesized (p)ppGpp and ROS-induced mutagenesis in de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance in E. coli

The stringent response of bacteria to starvation and stress also fulfills a role in addressing the threat of antibiotics. Within this stringent response, (p)ppGpp, synthesized by RelA or SpoT, functions as a global alarmone. However, the effect of this (p)ppGpp on resistance development is poorly understood. Here, we show that knockout of relA or rpoS curtails resistance development against bactericidal antibiotics. The emergence of mutated genes associated with starvation and (p)ppGpp, among others, indicates the activation of stringent responses. The growth rate is decreased in ΔrelA-resistant strains due to the reduced ability to synthesize (p)ppGpp and the persistence of deacylated tRNA impeding protein synthesis. Sluggish cellular activity causes decreased production of reactive oxygen species (ROS), thereby reducing oxidative damage, leading to weakened DNA mismatch repair, potentially reducing the generation of mutations. These findings offer new targets for mitigating antibiotic resistance development, potentially achieved through inhibiting (p)ppGpp or ROS synthesis.

Reactive oxygen species accelerate de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance in E. coli

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) produced as a secondary effect of bactericidal antibiotics are hypothesized to play a role in killing bacteria. If correct, ROS may play a role in development of de novo resistance. Here we report that single-gene knockout strains with reduced ROS scavenging exhibited enhanced ROS accumulation and more rapid acquisition of resistance when exposed to sublethal levels of bactericidal antibiotics. Consistent with this observation, the ROS scavenger thiourea in the medium decelerated resistance development. Thiourea downregulated the transcriptional level of error-prone DNA polymerase and DNA glycosylase MutM, which counters the incorporation and accumulation of 8-hydroxy-2'-deoxyguanosine (8-HOdG) in the genome. The level of 8-HOdG significantly increased following incubation with bactericidal antibiotics but decreased after treatment with the ROS scavenger thiourea. These observations suggest that in E. coli sublethal levels of ROS stimulate de novo development of resistance, providing a mechanistic basis for hormetic responses induced by antibiotics.

The influence of oxygen and oxidative stress on de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance in E. coli and Lactobacillus lactis

BACKGROUND

Bacteria can acquire resistance through DNA mutations in response to exposure to sub-lethal concentrations of antibiotics. According to the radical-based theory, reactive oxygen species (ROS), a byproduct of the respiratory pathway, and oxidative stress caused by reactive metabolic byproducts, play a role in cell death as secondary killing mechanism. In this study we address the question whether ROS also affects development of resistance, in the conditions that the cells is not killed by the antibiotic.

RESULTS

To investigate whether oxygen and ROS affect de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance, evolution of resistance due to exposure to non-lethal levels of antimicrobials was compared in E. coli wildtype and ΔoxyR strains under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. Since Lactococcus lactis (L. lactis) does not have an active electron transport chain (ETC) even in the presence of oxygen, and thus forms much less ROS, resistance development in L. lactis was used to distinguish between oxygen and ROS. The resistance acquisition in E. coli wildtype under aerobic and anaerobic conditions did not differ much. However, the aerobically grown ΔoxyR strain gained resistance faster than the wildtype or anaerobic ΔoxyR. Inducing an ETC by adding heme increased the rate at which L. lactis acquired resistance. Whole genome sequencing identified specific mutations involved in the acquisition of resistance. These mutations were specific for each antibiotic. The lexA mutation in ΔoxyR strain under aerobic conditions indicated that the SOS response was involved in resistance acquisition.

CONCLUSIONS

The concept of hormesis can explain the beneficial effects of low levels of ROS and reactive metabolic byproducts, while high levels are lethal. DNA repair and mutagenesis may therefore expedite development of resistance. Taken together, the results suggest that oxygen as such barely affects resistance development. Nevertheless, non-lethal levels of ROS stimulate de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance.

Genome Recombination-Mediated tRNA Up-Regulation Conducts General Antibiotic Resistance of Bacteria at Early Stage

Bacterial antibiotic resistance sets a great challenge to human health. It seems that the bacteria can spontaneously evolve resistance against any antibiotic within a short time without the horizontal transfer of heterologous genes and before accumulating drug-resistant mutations. We have shown that the tRNA-mediated translational regulation counteracts the reactive oxygen species (ROS) in bacteria. In this study, we demonstrated that isolated and subcultured Escherichia coli elevated its tRNAs under antibiotic stress to rapidly provide antibiotic resistance, especially at the early stage, before upregulating the efflux pump and evolving resistance mutations. The DNA recombination system repaired the antibiotic-induced DNA breakage in the genome, causing numerous structural variations. These structural variations are overrepresented near the tRNA genes, which indicated the cause of tRNA up-regulation. Knocking out the recombination system abolished the up-regulation of tRNAs, and coincidently, they could hardly evolve antibiotic resistance in multiple antibiotics, respectively. With these results, we proposed a multi-stage model of bacterial antibiotic resistance in an isolated scenario: the early stage (recombination—tRNA up-regulation—translational regulation); the medium stage (up-regulation of efflux pump); the late stage (resistant mutations). These results also indicated that the bacterial DNA recombination system and tRNA could be targeted to retard the bacterial spontaneous drug resistance.

Multiplication of ampC upon Exposure to a Beta-Lactam Antibiotic Results in a Transferable Transposon in Escherichia coli

Plasmids play a crucial role in spreading antimicrobial resistance genes. Plasmids have many ways to incorporate various genes. By inducing amoxicillin resistance in Escherichia coli, followed by horizontal gene transfer experiments and sequencing, we show that the chromosomal beta-lactamase gene ampC is multiplied and results in an 8–13 kb contig. This contig is comparable to a transposon, showing similarities to variable regions found in environmental plasmids, and can be transferred between E. coli cells. As in eight out of nine replicate strains an almost completely identical transposon was isolated, we conclude that this process is under strict control by the cell. The single transposon that differed was shortened at both ends, but otherwise identical. The outcome of this study indicates that as a result of exposure to beta-lactam antibiotics, E. coli can form a transposon containing ampC that can subsequently be integrated into plasmids or genomes. This observation offers an explanation for the large diversity of genes in plasmids found in nature and proposes mechanisms by which the dynamics of plasmids are maintained.

Epidemiologic and molecular characterization of β-lactamase-producing multidrug-resistant uropathogenic Escherichia coli isolated from asymptomatic hospitalized patients

Uropathogenic Escherichia coli (UPECs) are the predominant cause of asymptomatic bacteriuria (ABU) and symptomatic UTI. In this study, multidrug-resistant (MDR) ABU-UPECs from hospitalized patients of Kolkata, India, were characterized with respect to their ESBL phenotype, acquisition of β-lactamase genes, mobile genetic elements (MGEs), phylotype property, ERIC-PCR profile, sequence types (STs), clonal complexes (CCs) and evolutionary and quantitative relationships and compared to the symptomatic ones to understand their epidemiology and evolutionary origin. Statistically significant incidence of ESBL producers, β-lactamase genes, MGEs and novel phylotype property (NPP) among ABU-UPECs similar to the symptomatic ones indicated the probable incidence of chromosomal plasticity on resistance gene acquisition through MGEs due to indiscriminate drug usage. ERIC-PCR typing and MLST analysis showed clonal heterogeneity and predominance of ST940 (CC448) among asymptomatic isolates akin to symptomatic ones along with the evidence of zoonotic transmissions. Minimum spanning tree analysis showed a close association between ABU-UPEC with known and unidentified STs having NPPs with isolates that belonged to phylogroups clade I, D, and B2. This is the first study that reported the occurrence of MGEs and NPPs among ABU-UPECs with the predominance of ESBL production which displayed the deleterious effect of MDR among this pathogen demanding alternative therapeutic interventions. Moreover, this study for the first time attempted to introduce a new approach to ascertain the phylotype property of unassigned UPECs. Withal, increased recognition, proper understanding and characterization of ABU-UPECs with the implementation of appropriate therapeutic measures against them when necessary are the need of the era which otherwise might lead to serious complications in the vulnerable population.

A novel decoy strategy for polymyxin resistance in Acinetobacter baumannii

Modification of the outer membrane charge by a polymyxin B (PMB)-induced PmrAB two-component system appears to be a dominant phenomenon in PMB-resistant Acinetobacter baumannii. PMB-resistant variants and many clinical isolates also appeared to produce outer membrane vesicles (OMVs). Genomic, transcriptomic, and proteomic analyses revealed that upregulation of the pmr operon and decreased membrane-linkage proteins (OmpA, OmpW, and BamE) are linked to overproduction of OMVs, which also promoted enhanced biofilm formation. The addition of OMVs from PMB-resistant variants into the cultures of PMB-susceptible A. baumannii and the clinical isolates protected these susceptible bacteria from PMB. Taxonomic profiling of in vitro human gut microbiomes under anaerobic conditions demonstrated that OMVs completely protected the microbial community against PMB treatment. A Galleria mellonella-infection model with PMB treatment showed that OMVs increased the mortality rate of larvae by protecting A. baumannii from PMB. Taken together, OMVs released from A. baumannii functioned as decoys against PMB.

Wrapped in a thick, protective outer membrane, Acinetobacter baumannii bacteria can sometimes cause serious infections when they find their way into human lungs and urinary tracts. Antibiotics are increasingly ineffective against this threat, which forces physicians to resort to polymyxin B, an old, positively-charged drug that ‘sticks’ to the negatively-charged proteins and fatty components at the surface of A. baumannii.

Scientists have noticed that when bacteria are exposed to lethal drugs, they often react by releasing vesicles, small ‘sacs’ made of pieces of the outer membranes which can contain DNA or enzymes. How this strategy protects the cells against antibiotics such as polymyxin B remains poorly understood.

To investigate this question, Park et al. examined different strains of A. baumannii, showing that bacteria resistant to polymyxin B had lower levels of outer membrane proteins but would release more vesicles. Adding vesicles from resistant strains to non-resistant A. baumannii cultures helped cells to survive the drugs. In fact, this protective effect extended to other species, shielding whole communities of bacteria against polymyxin B. In vivo, the vesicles protected bacteria in moth larvae infected with A. baumannii, leading to a higher death rate in the animals. Experiments showed that the negatively-charged vesicles worked as decoys, trapping the positively-charged polymyxin B away from its target.

Taken together, the findings by Park et al. highlight a new strategy that allows certain strains of bacteria to protect themselves from antibiotics, while also benefitting the rest of the microbial community.

Effects of a previously selected antibiotic resistance on mutations acquired during development of a second resistance in Escherichia coli

Background

The effect of mutations conferring antibiotic resistance can depend on the genetic background. To determine if a previously de novo acquired antibiotic resistance influences the adaptation to a second antibiotic, antibiotic resistance was selected for by exposure to stepwise increasing sublethal levels of amoxicillin, enrofloxacin, kanamycin, or tetracycline. E. coli populations adapted to either a single or two antibiotics sequentially were characterized using whole genome population sequencing and MIC measurements.

Results

In a wild-type background, adaptation to any of the antibiotics resulted in the appearance of well-known mutations, as well as a number of mutated genes not known to be associated with antibiotic resistance. Development of a second resistance in a strain with an earlier acquired resistance to a different antibiotic did not always result in the appearance of all mutations associated with resistance in a wild-type background. In general, a more varied set of mutations was acquired during secondary adaptation. The ability of E. coli to maintain the first resistance during this process depended on the combination of antibiotics used. The maintenance of mutations associated with resistance to the first antibiotic did not always predict the residual MIC for that compound.

Conclusions

In general, the data presented here indicate that adaptation to each antibiotic is unique and independent. The mutational trajectories available in already resistant cells appear more varied than in wild-type cells, indicating that the genetic background of E. coli influences resistance development. The observed mutations cannot always fully explain the resistance pattern observed, indicating a crucial role for adaptation on the gene expression level in de novo acquisition of antibiotic resistance.