The predicted σ(54)-dependent regulator EtpR is essential for expression of genes for anaerobic p-ethylphenol and p-hydroxyacetophenone degradation in "Aromatoleum aromaticum" EbN1

Sensitive and selective phenol sensing in denitrifying Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1T

IMPORTANCE

Aromatic compounds are globally abundant organic molecules with a multitude of natural and anthropogenic sources, underpinning the relevance of their biodegradation. A. aromaticum EbN1T is a well-studied environmental betaproteobacterium specialized on the anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds. The here studied responsiveness toward phenol in conjunction with the apparent high ligand selectivity (non-promiscuity) of its PheR sensor and those of the related p-cresol (PcrS) and p-ethylphenol (EtpR) sensors are in accord with the substrate-specificity and biochemical distinctiveness of the associated degradation pathways. Furthermore, the present findings advance our general understanding of the substrate-specific regulation of the strain's remarkable degradation network and of the concentration thresholds below which phenolic compounds become essentially undetectable and as a consequence should escape substantial biodegradation. Furthermore, the findings may inspire biomimetic sensor designs for detecting and quantifying phenolic contaminants in wastewater or environments.

Responsiveness of Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1T to Lignin-Derived Phenylpropanoids

The betaproteobacterial degradation specialist Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1^T utilizes several plant-derived 3-phenylpropanoids coupled to denitrification. In vivo responsiveness of A. aromaticum EbN1^T was studied by exposing nonadapted cells to distinct pulses (spanning 100 µM to 0.1 nM) of 3-phenylpropanoate, cinnamate, 3-(4-hydroxyphenyl)propanoate, or p-coumarate. Time-resolved, targeted transcript analyses via quantitative reverse transcription-PCR of four selected 3-phenylpropanoid genes revealed a response threshold of 30 to 50 nM for p-coumarate and 1 to 10 nM for the other three tested 3-phenylpropanoids. At these concentrations, transmembrane effector equilibration is attained by passive diffusion rather than active uptake via the ABC transporter, presumably serving the studied 3-phenylpropanoids as well as benzoate. Highly substrate-specific enzyme formation (EbA5316 to EbA5321 [EbA5316-21]) for the shared peripheral degradation pathway putatively involves the predicted TetR-type transcriptional repressor PprR. Accordingly, relative transcript abundances of ebA5316-21 are lower in succinate- and benzoate-grown wild-type cells than in an unmarked in-frame ΔpprR mutant. In trans-complementation of pprR into the ΔpprR background restored wild-type-like transcript levels. When adapted to p-coumarate, the three genotypes had relative transcript abundances similar to those of ebA5316-21 despite a significantly longer lag phase of the pprR-complemented mutant (∼100-fold higher pprR transcript level than the wild type). Notably, transcript levels of ebA5316-21 were ∼10- to 100-fold higher in p-coumarate- than succinate- or benzoate-adapted cells across all three genotypes. This indicates the additional involvement of an unknown transcriptional regulator. Furthermore, physiological, transcriptional, and (aromatic) acyl-coenzyme A ester intermediate analyses of the wild type and ΔpprR mutant grown with binary substrate mixtures suggest a mode of catabolite repression of superior order to PprR.IMPORTANCE Lignin is a ubiquitous heterobiopolymer built from a suite of 3-phenylpropanoid subunits. It accounts for more than 30% of the global plant dry material, and lignin-related compounds are increasingly released into the environment from anthropogenic sources, i.e., by wastewater effluents from the paper and pulp industry. Hence, following biological or industrial decomplexation of lignin, vast amounts of structurally diverse 3-phenylpropanoids enter terrestrial and aquatic habitats, where they serve as substrates for microbial degradation. This raises the question of what signaling systems environmental bacteria employ to detect these nutritionally attractive compounds and to adjust their catabolism accordingly. Moreover, determining in vivo response thresholds of an anaerobic degradation specialist such as A. aromaticum EbN1^T for these aromatic compounds provides insights into the environmental fate of the latter, i.e., when they could escape biodegradation due to too low ambient concentrations.

Nanomolar Responsiveness of an Anaerobic Degradation Specialist to Alkylphenol Pollutants

Anaerobic degradation of p-cresol (4-methylphenol) by the denitrifying betaproteobacterium Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1 is regulated with high substrate specificity, presumed to be mediated by the predicted σ⁵⁴-dependent two-component system PcrSR. An unmarked, in-frame ΔpcrSR deletion mutant showed reduced expression of the genes cmh (21-fold) and hbd (8-fold) that encode the two enzymes for initial oxidation of p-cresol to p-hydroxybenzoate compared to their expression in the wild type. The expression of cmh and hbd was restored by in trans complementation with pcrSR in the ΔpcrSR background to even higher levels than in the wild type. This is likely due to ∼200-/∼30-fold more transcripts of pcrSR in the complemented mutant. The in vivo responsiveness of A. aromaticum EbN1 to p-cresol was studied in benzoate-limited anaerobic cultures by the addition of p-cresol at various concentrations (from 100 μM down to 0.1 nM). Time-resolved transcript profiling by quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) revealed that the lowest p-cresol concentrations just affording cmh and hbd expression (response threshold) ranged between 1 and 10 nM, which is even more sensitive than the respective odor receptors of insects. A similar response threshold was determined for another alkylphenol, p-ethylphenol, which strain EbN1 anaerobically degrades via a different route and senses by the σ⁵⁴-dependent one-component system EtpR. Based on these data and theoretical considerations, p-cresol or p-ethylphenol added as a single pulse (10 nM) requires less than a fraction of a second to reach equilibrium between intra- and extracellular space (∼20 molecules per cell), with an estimated K_d (dissociation constant) of <100 nM alkylphenol (p-cresol or p-ethylphenol) for its respective sensory protein (PcrS or EtpR).IMPORTANCE Alkylphenols (like p-cresol and p-ethylphenol) represent bulk chemicals for industrial syntheses. Besides massive local damage events, large-scale micropollution is likewise of environmental and health concern. Next to understanding how such pollutants can be degraded by microorganisms, it is also relevant to determine the microorganisms' lower threshold of responsiveness. Aromatoleum aromaticum EbN1 is a specialist in anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds, employing a complex and substrate-specifically regulated catabolic network. The present study aims at verifying the predicted role of the PcrSR system in sensing p-cresol and at determining the threshold of responsiveness for alkylphenols. The findings have implications for the enigmatic persistence of dissolved organic matter (escape from biodegradation) and for the lower limits of aromatic compounds required for bacterial growth.

Comparative Genomic Analysis of the Regulation of Aromatic Metabolism in Betaproteobacteria

Aromatic compounds are a common carbon and energy source for many microorganisms, some of which can even degrade toxic chloroaromatic xenobiotics. This comparative study of aromatic metabolism in 32 Betaproteobacteria species describes the links between several transcription factors (TFs) that control benzoate (BenR, BenM, BoxR, BzdR), catechol (CatR, CatM, BenM), chlorocatechol (ClcR), methylcatechol (MmlR), 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate (TfdR, TfdS), phenol (AphS, AphR, AphT), biphenyl (BphS), and toluene (TbuT) metabolism. We characterize the complexity and variability in the organization of aromatic metabolism operons and the structure of regulatory networks that may differ even between closely related species. Generally, the upper parts of pathways, rare pathway variants, and degradative pathways of exotic and complex, in particular, xenobiotic compounds are often controlled by a single TF, while the regulation of more common and/or central parts of the aromatic metabolism may vary widely and often involves several TFs with shared and/or dual, or cascade regulation. The most frequent and at the same time variable connections exist between AphS, AphR, AphT, and BenR. We have identified a novel LysR-family TF that regulates the metabolism of catechol (or some catechol derivative) and either substitutes CatR(M)/BenM, or shares functions with it. We have also predicted several new members of aromatic metabolism regulons, in particular, some COGs regulated by several different TFs.

Towards the Response Threshold for p-Hydroxyacetophenone in the Denitrifying Bacterium "Aromatoleum aromaticum" EbN1

The denitrifying betaproteobacterium "Aromatoleum aromaticum" EbN1 regulates the capacity to anaerobically degrade p-ethylphenol (via p-hydroxyacetophenone) with high substrate specificity. This process is mediated by the σ⁵⁴-dependent transcriptional regulator EtpR, which apparently recognizes both aromatic compounds, yielding congruent expression profiles. The responsiveness of this regulatory system was studied with p-hydroxyacetophenone, which is more easily administered to cultures and traced analytically. Cultures of A. aromaticum EbN1 were initially cultivated under nitrate-reducing conditions with a growth-limiting supply of benzoate, upon the complete depletion of which p-hydroxyacetophenone was added at various concentrations (from 500 μM down to 0.1 nM). Depletion profiles of this aromatic substrate and presumptive effector were determined by highly sensitive micro-high-performance liquid chromatography (microHPLC). Irrespective of the added concentration of p-hydroxyacetophenone, depletion commenced after less than 5 min and suggested a response threshold of below 10 nM. This approximation was corroborated by time-resolved transcript profiles (quantitative reverse transcription-PCR) of selected degradation and efflux relevant genes (e.g., pchF, encoding a subunit of predicted p-ethylphenol methylenehydroxylase) and narrowed down to a range of 10 to 1 nM. The most pronounced transcriptional response was observed, as expected, for genes located at the beginning of the two operon-like structures, related to catabolism (i.e., acsA) and potential efflux (i.e., ebA335).IMPORTANCE Aromatic compounds are widespread microbial growth substrates with natural as well as anthropogenic sources, albeit with their in situ concentrations and their bioavailabilities varying over several orders of magnitude. Even though degradation pathways and underlying regulatory systems have long been studied with aerobic and, to a lesser extent, with anaerobic bacteria, comparatively little is known about the effector concentration-dependent responsiveness. A. aromaticum EbN1 is a model organism for the anaerobic degradation of aromatic compounds with the architecture of the catabolic network and its substrate-specific regulation having been intensively studied by means of differential proteogenomics. The present study aims at unraveling the minimal concentration of an aromatic growth substrate (p-hydroxyacetophenone here) required to initiate gene expression for its degradation pathway and to learn in principle about the lower limit of catabolic responsiveness of an anaerobic degradation specialist.