A survey of hospice day services in the United Kingdom & Republic of Ireland : how did hospices offer social support to palliative care patients, pre-pandemic?

Loneliness in Advanced Life-Threatening Illness: An Integrative Review

CONTEXT

To inform supportive interventions, experiences of loneliness must be understood specifically from the perspective of those with advanced life-threatening illness and their caregivers.

OBJECTIVES

To identify the causes, experiences, and impacts of loneliness among adults with advanced life-threatening illnesses and caregivers, and which modifiable factors might mitigate loneliness.

METHODS

Systematic searching of six databases (CINHAL, Web of science, Cochrane central, Medline, HMIC and Proquest) was supplemented by backward citation searching from Jan 2014-Jan2024. This was followed by screening and selection based on the PRISMA extension for scoping reviews (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines. Studies were imported into NVivo version 1.6 for data management. An inductive approach was used to facilitate the synthesis. Quality assessment with diverse studies (QuADS) was used. The review protocol was registered with Prospero, ID: CRD42023493999.

RESULTS

Ninteen observational studies and 6 intervention studies were included in this review. Evidence confirms that the causes, impacts and outcomes of loneliness are multifaceted and interact dynamically. Risk factors on a micro level include psychological and existential factors such as emotional distress and fear of death; potentially modifiable factors include efforts to enhance communication and befriending programs. On meso level physical and social factors are risk factors such as symptom burden and social withdrawal, potentially modifiable factors include utilizing technology to make home an accessible place to maintain social connections. On a macro level environmental and societal risk factors include mobility restrictions and stigma; potentially modifiable factors include increasing societal engagement through community programs CONCLUSION: This integrative review will help healthcare providers, policymakers and the public understand the causes, experiences and impact of loneliness in adults with advanced life-threatening illnesses and their caregivers. The evidence suggests that an integrated approach that combines personal, social, and systemic efforts is needed which includes enhanced communication, targeted interventions, robust support systems, and community engagement. Rigorous research studies are required which include patient and public involvement from inception to completion to ensure that the study designs and methodologies are purposeful for those they intend to serve.

The role of the municipal welfare domain in palliative care: exploring the views of coordinators of Dutch regional palliative care networks

Background

Collaboration between the healthcare domain and welfare domain could benefit people confronted with an incurable disease residing at home and their informal caregivers, but little is known about this collaboration regarding palliative care. There are regional palliative care networks in the Netherlands, supporting interdisciplinary integrated palliative care; each network has a network coordinator who is a primary liaison for the network and who has an overview of palliative care services and activities in the region. However, the view of the networks on the role of the welfare domain and collaboration with the welfare domain in the field of palliative care is unknown.

Objective

The aim of this study is to explore the awareness of professionals for the social dimension of palliative care and to explore how collaboration between the healthcare domain and the Dutch municipal welfare domain, in the field of palliative care, can be improved.

Design

Focus group research.

Methods

In 2022, six focus groups and two individual interviews were held with 30 coordinators of regional palliative care networks in the Netherlands.

Results

This study showed that coordinators of regional palliative care networks consider collaboration with the welfare domain to be important. There are major differences between the regional palliative care networks regarding knowledge about and collaboration with the welfare domain. Coordinators themselves can function as catalysts for collaboration between palliative care and the welfare domain.

Conclusion

In the Netherlands, collaboration between the welfare domain and the healthcare domain in the field of palliative care is limited and differs considerably between regions. The Dutch municipal welfare domain is relevant for a large group of people confronted with an incurable disease, but it does not provide them with tailored services. Collaboration between palliative care and the municipal welfare domain has great potential, both on the patient level and on the level of the sustainability of palliative care, but it currently seems underexplored.

Social support sources for people with palliative care needs at home: a scoping review

BACKGROUND

Recent literature suggests an increase in attention for the social dimension of palliative care. However, who provides social support to patients with palliative care needs at home and their relatives is often unclear, and insight in the role of the community and professionals with a main focus on social support, not being health care professionals, is lacking in this respect. Therefore, in this study we explore social support for people with palliative care needs residing at home and their relatives, provided by the community and professionals from the welfare domain, and want to understand when social support is experienced as sufficient by the recipient.

METHODS

A scoping review was conducted to search for literature on social support by the community and professionals from the welfare domain to people with palliative care needs at home, using the databases PubMed and Web of Sciences for studies published between January 1, 2007, and June 1, 2023.

RESULTS

Social support to people at home with palliative care needs and their relatives is mainly provided by informal caregivers, namely family, friends and neighbours. These people providing social support is perceived as normal, natural and is expected by the recipient. Social support by the wider community and by professionals from the welfare domain can enhance, complement and/or substitute this support. Within the 27 included articles, nine studies provide results of social support interventions, which show that volunteer or professional services aimed at enhancing and mobilizing the informal social network of the patient are an important way of building supportive and sustainable social support networks.

CONCLUSIONS

Community sources and professionals with a main focus on social support such as social workers can enhance, complement and substitute social support provided by the informal network, if needed. Structured approaches can improve recognition of unmet social problems and needs of people with palliative care needs at home.

The Impact of Hospice Care on the Prognosis, Quality of Life, and Emotional Well-being of Patients With Chronic Heart Failure

Chronic heart failure (CHF) represents a substantial public health challenge, impacting patients' emotional well-being, quality of life, and overall prognosis. Palliative care and hospice services are increasingly recognized in managing advanced CHF, yet their evidence-based benefits remain underexplored. This study aimed to assess the influence of hospice care on CHF patient outcomes. A total of 120 inpatients with CHF were randomly assigned to receive either hospice care in addition to standard treatment (experimental group) or standard care alone (control group). Patient assessments included heart function classification, activities of daily living, Minnesota Living With Heart Failure Questionnaire, anxiety scale, and pain assessment. Results demonstrated significant improvements in cardiac function, activities of daily living, anxiety levels, pain scores, and heart failure-related quality of life in the experimental group compared with controls. Reduced anxiety, enhanced emotional well-being, and overall health status improvements were particularly notable postintervention. Hospice care was associated with enhanced functional abilities, emotional well-being, pain management, and overall quality of life for CHF patients. In conclusion, this study underscores hospice care's positive impact on prognosis, quality of life, and emotional well-being in CHF, emphasizing its potential as a critical component in comprehensive CHF management strategies.

Exploring Social Support Experiences of Caregivers of Persons Living With Dementia in Hospice Care

As the number of persons living with dementia (PLWD) enrolling in hospice care rises, caregiver support becomes increasingly crucial. While social support can help buffer caregiver stress, many caregivers report feeling isolated and having unmet needs, highlighting the limited research on this population. This qualitative descriptive study aimed to better understand caregivers' social support during the period when the PLWD is enrolled in hospice care. Analyzing qualitative data from 22 caregivers of PLWD using conventional content analysis, we identified the theme "Variations in Social Connections." This theme encompasses two subthemes: "never completely alone," indicating social support from family, friends, and neighbors, and "disappointed sometimes," reflecting instances when some individuals in the caregivers' lives couldn't provide regular support. These findings underscore the need for individualized interventions, as each caregiver experiences social support uniquely. Future research should consider the variations in social support among caregivers of PLWD to inform caregiving practices effectively.

Describing Medical Aid-in-Dying and Nursing "Leave-the-Room" Policies in California: A Mixed Methods Study

Transparent patient-centered communication is essential to providing quality hospice care for patients at the end of life. This study aimed to determine and describe the current state of aid-in-dying policies in California and their effect on hospice nursing in response to narratives about leave-the-room policies presenting professional and moral challenges. In total, 97 hospice program policies were analyzed with a focus on the role of nurses at the bedside and intent to discharge patients who pursue medical aid-in-dying. It is necessary to clarify the important role of hospice nurses who care for terminally ill patients pursuing their legal right to assisted dying. The results of this study underscore the need for improved policy transparency and organizational support to enhance hospice engagement, particularly by nurses, with their patients at the end of life.

Midazolam Indications and Dosing in Palliative Medicine: Results from a Multinational Survey

Despite sparse evidence and limited guidance on indications, use, and dosing, midazolam is widely used in palliative care. We aimed to describe and compare the use of midazolam in three different countries to improve clinical practice in palliative care. We performed an online survey among palliative care physicians in Norway, Denmark, and the United Kingdom (UK). The focus was indications, dosing, administration, and concomitant drugs. A web-based questionnaire was distributed to members of the respective national palliative medicine associations. The total response rate was 9.4%. Practices in the UK, Norway, and Denmark were overall similar regarding the indications of midazolam for anxiety, dyspnoea, and pain treatment in combination with opioids. However, physicians in the UK used a higher starting dose for anxiety, dyspnoea, and pain treatment compared to Norway and Denmark, as well as a higher maximum dose. Danish physicians preferred, to a higher degree, on-demand midazolam administration. Despite practice similarities in the UK, Norway, and Denmark, differences exist for midazolam dosing and administration in palliative medicine. We demonstrated a lack of consensus on how midazolam should be used in palliative care, setting the stage for future studies on the topic.

Toward enhanced decentralized palliative care services in Neno District, Malawi: a qualitative study

BACKGROUND

Palliative care remains key in assisting patients who have life-threatening conditions. In most low- and middle-income countries, it is often offered through a centralized system with limitations, including Malawi. In 2014, the World Health Organization called for improving palliative care access through primary health care and community models. Malawi and Neno District subsequently decentralized palliative care delivery to local health centers. This qualitative study explored the decentralization of palliative care services in Neno District, Malawi.

METHODS

The descriptive qualitative study was conducted between 2021 and 2022 in two conveniently selected health centers providing palliative care in the Neno District. Fourteen healthcare workers were purposefully selected to participate in two focus groups. Fifteen patients were conveniently selected and participated in three focus groups. Data was analyzed using deductive and inductive approaches. Focused group discussions were conducted in Chichewa (Malawi's official local language), audio recorded, transcribed, translated into English, and analyzed thematically.

RESULTS

Four main themes emerged from the focus groups. Patients described positive relationships with healthcare workers built on trust and holistic care over time. Accessing care included transport, social support, time constraints, and distance issues. Facilities effectively responded to needs through coordinated care and follow-up. Decentralization was perceived to benefit patients by reducing travel challenges and improving local access to efficient and inclusive palliative care services. However, challenges with resources, distance, and social support remained. Limitations in sampling and missing participant details necessitate further research with broader sampling.

CONCLUSION

Overall, the study provides empirical evidence that can optimize palliative care delivery in similar low-resource contexts by informing policies to address barriers through decentralized approaches.

Interventions for behavioral health comorbidities in the hospice setting: a scoping review

BACKGROUND

Behavioral health (BH) comorbidities in hospice patients are widespread and impact important outcomes, including symptom burden, quality of life, and caregiver wellbeing. However, evidence-based BH interventions tailored for the hospice setting remain understudied.

METHODS

We conducted a scoping review with the objective of mapping studies of interventions for BH comorbidities in the hospice setting. We included empirical studies among hospice patients of interventions with BH outcomes. We abstracted data on study design, intervention type, and patient characteristics.

RESULTS

Our search generated 7,672 unique results, of which 37 were ultimately included in our analysis. Studies represented 16 regions, with the United Kingdom (n=13) most represented. The most frequent intervention type was complementary and alternative interventions (n=13), followed by psychotherapeutic interventions (n=12). Most of the studies were either pilot or feasibility investigations. Fifteen studies employed a randomized controlled trial design. The most frequently utilized measurement tools for BH outcomes included the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale and the Edmonton Symptom Assessment Scale. Seventeen studies demonstrated statistically significant results in a BH outcome measure. BH conditions prevalent among hospice patients that were the focus of intervention efforts included depression symptoms, anxiety symptoms, and general psychological distress. No study focused on trauma-related disorders or substance use disorders.

CONCLUSIONS

This scoping review reveals a concerning gap in research regarding evidence-based BH interventions in hospice settings, especially in the U.S. Despite extensive utilization of hospice care services and the high prevalence of BH conditions among hospice patients, randomized controlled trials focused on improving BH outcomes remain scant. The current BH practices, like the widespread use of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics, may not be rooted in robust evidence, underscoring an urgent need for investment in hospice research infrastructure and tailored clinical trials to test behavioral approaches to mitigate mental health outcomes at the end of life.

Explaining how and why social support groups in hospice day services benefit palliative care patients, for whom, and in what circumstances

Background

Palliative care aims to provide holistic support for people with life-limiting illness, responding to psychological, social and spiritual needs, as well as to clinical and physical. In the United Kingdom, hospice day services (including day care, group interventions, group activities, and social events for palliative care outpatients) aim to provide opportunities for patients to gain social support, which is thought to improve their quality of life.

Objectives

This research explored social support within hospice day services, to explain in detail how and why social support obtained within a hospice day service could be beneficial to palliative care patients.

Design

Qualitative research using observations of hospice day services and interviews with service providers.

Methods

Data collection involved nineteen interviews with hospice service providers (n = 19) and researcher observations of hospice day services. The findings detail how patient and hospice context interact to produce mechanisms that lead to outcomes beyond the hospice day service.

Results

Practical, clinical and social aspects of the hospice day service are important for patients feeling welcome and safe in the setting. The opportunity to connect with other people and work towards personal goals can boost self-confidence for patients who have lost access to meaningful activity. New friendships between patients encourages reciprocal support and feelings of belonging. It is beneficial to have permission to speak freely about topics deemed inappropriate elsewhere, because honest communication is helpful in accepting and adapting to their circumstances.

Conclusion

Hospice day services facilitate group settings for reciprocal social support. This research proposes an initial programme theory that can be further developed and tested. It explains how and why, in some contexts, social support increases personal and practical resources to cope with illness and death, leading to changes outside of the hospice (to mood, interpersonal interactions and behaviour) that could improve quality of life.

Feasibility of Patient Reported Outcome Measures in Psychosocial Palliative Care: Observational Cohort Study of Hospice Day Care and Social Support Groups

Palliative care patients can be at risk of social isolation or loneliness. Interventions that can provide effective social support, and particularly emotional support, could facilitate healthy coping that bolsters quality of life and reduces depression in palliative care patients. This is an observational cohort study which recruited thirty patients (n = 30) from the day services of four independent hospices in England. Participants completed patient reported outcome measures in perceived social support, loneliness, and depression, at up to three time points. Age range was 56-91 years, males and females were equally represented, and the sample was 93% white British. In participants that provided two or more timepoints, perceived social support increased, and loneliness and depression decreased. Largest changes with the least variation between participants was in emotional support (p = 0.165) and loneliness (p = 0.104). These results suggest that the psychosocial patient reported outcome measures used (MOS-SS, UCLA, BEDS) could be sensitive to change aligned with the goals of this intervention in palliative care. Participants in this study were observed to derive psychosocial benefit from attending the hospice day service.