"OPTImAL": an ontology for patient adherence modeling in physical activity domain

Content and quality of physical activity ontologies: a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Ontologies are a formal way to represent knowledge in a particular field and have the potential to transform the field of health promotion and digital interventions. However, few researchers in physical activity (PA) are familiar with ontologies, and the field can be difficult to navigate. This systematic review aims to (1) identify ontologies in the field of PA, (2) assess their content and (3) assess their quality.

METHODS

Databases were searched for ontologies on PA. Ontologies were included if they described PA or sedentary behavior, and were available in English language. We coded whether ontologies covered the user profile, activity, or context domain. For the assessment of quality, we used 12 criteria informed by the Open Biological and Biomedical Ontology (OBO) Foundry principles of good ontology practice.

RESULTS

Twenty-eight ontologies met the inclusion criteria. All ontologies covered PA, and 19 included information on the user profile. Context was covered by 17 ontologies (physical context, n = 12; temporal context, n = 14; social context: n = 5). Ontologies met an average of 4.3 out of 12 quality criteria. No ontology met all quality criteria.

DISCUSSION

This review did not identify a single comprehensive ontology of PA that allowed reuse. Nonetheless, several ontologies may serve as a good starting point for the promotion of PA. We provide several recommendations about the identification, evaluation, and adaptation of ontologies for their further development and use.

Semantic Integration of Heterogeneous Data Sources Using Ontology-Based Domain Knowledge Modeling for Early Detection of COVID-19

The enormous outbreak of biomedical knowledge, the aim of reducing computation and processing costs and the widespread availability of internet connection have created a profuse amount of electronic data. Such data are stored across the globe in various data sources that are semantically, structurally and syntactically different. This decentralized nature of biomedical data has made it difficult to obtain a unified view of the data. Data integration plays a crucial role in enhancing access to heterogeneous data making the retrieval easier and faster. A variety of ontology, machine learning, deep learning and fuzzy logic-based solutions are being developed for heterogeneous data integration. The proposed model concentrates on the automatic ontology-based data integration method that can be effectively deployed and used in the healthcare domain. The proposed model is divided into three phases. The first phase includes the automatic mapping of data and generation of local ontology across heterogeneous data sources, the second phase combines the local ontology models developed in the first phase to create a root global schema mapping and the third phase queries diverse databases to retrieve semantically analogous records. The model is created based on the medical records, chest X-ray details and COVID-19 symptom questionnaire data of various patients distributed across three data sources (SQL, mongodb and excel). Based on the data, the patients who have moderate/higher risk of developing serious illness from COVID-19 are retrieved.

OnTARi: an ontology for factors influencing therapy adherence to rehabilitation

BACKGROUND

Adherence and motivation are key factors for successful treatment of patients with chronic diseases, especially in long-term care processes like rehabilitation. However, only a few patients achieve good treatment adherence. The causes are manifold. Adherence-influencing factors vary depending on indications, therapies, and individuals. Positive and negative effects are rarely confirmed or even contradictory. An ontology seems to be convenient to represent existing knowledge in this domain and to make it available for information retrieval.

METHODS

First, a manual data extraction of current knowledge in the domain of treatment adherence in rehabilitation was conducted. Data was retrieved from various sources, including basic literature, scientific publications, and health behavior models. Second, all adherence and motivation factors identified were formalized according to the ontology development methodology METHONTOLOGY. This comprises the specification, conceptualization, formalization, and implementation of the ontology "Ontology for factors influencing therapy adherence to rehabilitation" (OnTARi) in Protégé. A taxonomy-oriented evaluation was conducted by two domain experts.

RESULTS

OnTARi includes 281 classes implemented in ontology web language, ten object properties, 22 data properties, 1440 logical axioms, 244 individuals, and 1023 annotations. Six higher-level classes are differentiated: (1) Adherence, (2) AdherenceFactors, (3) AdherenceFactorCategory, (4) Rehabilitation, (5) RehabilitationForm, and (6) RehabilitationType. By means of the class AdherenceFactors 227 adherence factors, thereof 49 hard factors, are represented. Each factor involves a proper description, synonyms, possibly existing acronyms, and a German translation. OnTARi illustrates links between adherence factors through 160 influences-relations. Description logic queries implemented in Protégé allow multiple targeted requests, e.g., for the extraction of adherence factors in a specific rehabilitation area.

CONCLUSIONS

With OnTARi, a generic reference model was built to represent potential adherence and motivation factors and their interrelations in rehabilitation of patients with chronic diseases. In terms of information retrieval, this formalization can serve as a basis for implementation and adaptation of conventional rehabilitative measures, taking into account (patient-specific) adherence factors. OnTARi also enables the development of medical assistance systems to increase motivation and adherence in rehabilitation processes.