Overuse in cancer care: do European studies provide information useful to support policies?

Two Decades of Overuse and Underuse of Interventions for Primary and Secondary Prevention of Cardiovascular Diseases: A Systematic Review

Quality use of anti-hypertensive and cholesterol-lowering medications is crucial for successful cardiovascular disease management. This systematic review aimed to estimate levels of over and underuse of services for primary and secondary prevention of cardiovascular diseases from 2000 to 2020: overprescribing/underprescribing, overtesting/undertesting and overutilization/ underutilization of procedures compared to clinical practice guideline recommendations. Thirteen studies from USA, Europe, Asia and Australia were included. Wide practice variation was identified. Six studies reported overuse (eg, perioperative cardiac consultations, anti-hypertensive overprescribing for normotensive or pre-hypertensive people); and ten studies reported underuse (eg, under-prescribing of statins when indicated and under-screening for familial hypercholesterolemia). Lifestyle recommendations for cardiovascular disease prevention were largely underused. In summary, lack of adherence to published guidelines was prevalent over the past 2 decades for both primary and secondary prevention across settings. Further investigation of potentially justifiable deviations from guidelines are warranted to verify the estimates and identify points for intervention.

Unnecessary ultrasonography as supplier-induced demand in diagnosis of primary breast cancer in Iran: A cross-sectional study

BACKGROUND

Supplier-induced demand (SID) refers to the concept that healthcare providers may deliver services that are not medically necessary to patients. An estimation of the extent to which this event has occurred can be insightful for policymaking and guiding health and insurance systems. This study aimed to investigate the extent of SID when performing a diagnostic ultrasonography for primary breast cancer patients and its relationship with socioeconomic factors in Iran.

METHODS

Data were obtained using questionnaires from 334 patients referred to the Cancer Research Center. To identify the patients who were candidates for undergoing a necessary diagnostic US, we employed the international clinical guidelines with confirmation of our expert panelists. With their assistance, a comprehensive index was created to screen those 'most probably affected by SID'.

RESULTS

55.9% had undergone an unnecessary diagnostic ultrasonography, and thus were most probably affected by SID. A significant association between socioeconomic factors (education, occupation, and supplemental health insurance) and SID was confirmed (p value ≤ 0.001, 0.002, and 0.039, respectively).

CONCLUSION

This study supports the SID hypothesis and the unnecessary demand for diagnostic ultrasonography in primary breast cancer. Also, our evidence indicates imposing excessive costs that can positively influence the policymakers' decision-making in the healthcare systems.

Efficacy, Safety and Cost Effectiveness of Metronomic Low Dose Versus Intermittent High Dose Capecitabine in Metastatic Breast Cancer

AIM: The aim of the study is to compare the toxicity and cost-effectiveness between metronomic and intermittent capecitabine as maintenance therapy in female patients with metastatic breast cancer. PATIENTS AND METHODS: All metastatic breast cancer patients with HER2 negative were included. The whole study population received six cycles of Docetaxel/Capecitabine then patients were randomized to either continuous (650 mg/m2 twice daily continuous) or intermittent Capecitabine (1000 mg/m2 twice daily every 21 days) as maintenance. RESULTS: The study included 51 patients, 26 in the metronomic arm and 25 in the continuous. The median number of maintenance cycles, as well as the partial response, was higher in the continuous (18 vs. 13 cycles, p: 0.031; p: 0.038). The continuous arm was tolerable with significant less Grade 3 and 4 toxicity regarding nausea, vomiting, hand and foot syndrome, neutropenia, and elevated liver enzymes. (p: 0.03, 0.045, 0.051, 0.048, 0.06, respectively). On multivariate analysis, only patients receiving treatment as first-line had a better clinical response (p: 0.03) especially in the triple-negative group (p: 0.07). The metronomic therapy was more cost-effective with a 35.9% reduction of cost. ($ 746 vs. $1164). The progression-free survival and overall survival were not significant between the two groups. CONCLUSION: Metronomic continuous capecitabine proved to be less toxic and more cost-effective.

Induced Demand in Cancer Diagnosis

Context: Supplier-induced demand (SID) is an essential concept in health economics related to the diagnosis of different types of cancer and related expenditures. The current review considered studies on induced demand in cancer diagnosis. Evidence Acquisition: This systematic review investigated the induced diagnosis of cancer in four well-known databases (Scopus, Science Direct, Web of Science, and PubMed) from January 1980 to July 2019 using the keywords “induced demand,” “cancer,” and “diagnosis”. References of the studies found through the original search were also considered for analysis. Results: No studies focused on SID in cancer diagnosis could be found, thus indicating a significant deficiency in the discussion of SID in cancer diagnosis studies. Therefore, the terms most relevant to the concept of SID in cancer diagnosis were examined. Finally, 24 factors were categorized into three groups: economic, socio-cultural, and structural. The majority of evidence for the probability of SID in cancer diagnosis is related to overdiagnosis or early diagnosis caused by unnecessary screening (57.14% of reviewed articles) and the neglect of clinical practice guidelines (42.8% of reviewed articles), mainly by diagnostic imaging. Conclusions: Research focused explicitly on SID in cancer diagnosis is needed. Moreover, economic, social, and structural reforms related to the factors that connect overuse, overdiagnosis, and unnecessary services to cancer diagnosis are required to control costs and harm and provide the best benefits to patients.