Chemotherapy in seminoma: when is it appropriate initial treatment?

Modern radiotherapy results with bulky stages II and III seminoma

We treated 20 patients with stage II seminoma by primary radiotherapy from 1971 to 1982. Median patient age was 38 years (range 26 to 52 years) and median disease width in the transverse plane was 11 cm. (range 5 to 25 cm.). Four tumors were 5 to 9 cm., 9 were 10 to 14 cm. and 7 were 15 cm. or more wide. Tumor was palpable in 13 patients. Generous radiation ports (such as wide hockey stick or whole abdomen) often followed by a boost to the area of bulky disease were used as primary therapy in all patients. Median tumor dose was 37.5 Gy. (range 13.3 to 56.7 Gy.). Supradiaphragmatic prophylactic radiation was given to 16 patients (median dose 26 Gy., range 12 to 37.3 Gy.). Median followup was 56 months, and all patients currently are free of disease except for 1 who died without disease more than 10 years after completion of all therapy. Mediastinal failure occurred in 2 of 4 patients without and 1 of 16 with mediastinal prophylaxis. All 4 patients with relapse are currently free of disease after salvage therapy. Five patients 16 to 42 years old (median age 30 years) received primary radiation therapy for stage III disease. The median size of abdominal disease was 10 cm. (range 5 to 17 cm.). Of the 5 stage III cancer patients 3 had supradiaphragmatic disease demonstrated only in supraclavicular lymph nodes and all 3 were continuously free of disease 115 to 136 months after therapy. The remaining 2 stage III cancer patients had supradiaphragmatic disease by virtue of bulky mediastinal disease with or without supraclavicular involvement. Both patients had relapse in-field and distantly, and they died of disease despite salvage chemotherapy. A total of 30 fields with bulky disease (greater than 5 cm.) was treated either primarily or at relapse among the 25 stages II and III cancer patients. In-field relapse occurred in 3 of 21 patients receiving less than or equal to 36 Gy. and 0 of 9 who received greater than 36 Gy. These results justify radiation therapy as an acceptable initial primary treatment modality for typical bulky stage II seminoma. Disease greater than 5 cm. should receive greater than 36 Gy. Prophylactic radiation to the mediastinum is effective. However, patients who have mediastinal failure often can be salvaged with chemotherapy and/or radiation, and prophylactic mediastinal radiotherapy may be associated with poor tolerance to salvage chemotherapy and other significant late effects.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

An outlier theory of cancer curability. Tumor cell differentiation as a therapeutic goal

Combinations of cytotoxic agents that cure a substantial percentage of patients with several childhood and adult malignancies are much less efficacious for the majority of solid tumors. Standard approaches for curability that rely solely on the concept of cytotoxicity may not be applicable for most epithelial and mesenchymal solid malignancies. Differentiation may play a more important role in cancer cure than heretofore suspected. Clinical and experimental evidence supports further investigation into models of inducing tumor cell differentiation. The question of why such models could predict for curative modalities of treatment is discussed.

Vinblastine-ifosfamide-cisplatin treatment of bulky seminoma

Eighteen patients with pure seminoma in advanced Stages IIC-IV of disease were treated with VIP combination chemotherapy consisting of vinblastine (6 mg/m2, days 1 and 2), ifosfamide (1.5 g/m2, days 1 to 5), and cisplatin (20 mg/m2, days 1 to 5). Eleven patients had Stage IIC, four had Stage III, three had Stage IV, and two had primary extragonadal seminoma. Primary histologic diagnoses were typical seminoma in 15 patients and anaplastic seminoma in three patients. Human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) levels were elevated to 350 U/1 in eight patients; alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) levels were always normal. No primary lymphadenectomy was carried out. Seven of 18 patients had prior radiotherapy and were treated because of relapse or progression. There was one early death and one patient has not yet completed therapy. Of 16 evaluable patients, 14 reached complete remission (CR) (88%), which was documented surgically in six cases, whereas in the non-pretreated group, all nine patients reached CR and in the pretreated group, CR could be induced in five of seven patients (71%). The remission duration ranged from 6+ to 41+ months (median, 29+ months). No relapse has occurred. The bone marrow toxicity of VIP was remarkable. Because of leukopenia below 1000/mm3 and/or thrombopenia below 50,000/mm3, dose reduction and interval prolongation were necessary in 10 of 16 patients, especially in all those who were pretreated. Even though it is not superior to other platin-based regimens, VIP chemotherapy is highly effective in bulky seminoma with and without prior radiotherapy.

Cisplatin combination chemotherapy in advanced seminoma

Thirty-one patients were treated with cisplatin combination chemotherapy for advanced seminoma (26 Stage III or bulky Stage II testicular, and five disseminated extragonadal). Seventeen (89%) of 19 patients not previously pretreated and four (80%) of five who had received only abdominal irradiation entered continuous complete remission (CR), versus only two (28%) of seven patients who had received extensive infra- and supradiaphragmatic radiotherapy. Results were not significantly influenced by stage, human chorionic gonadotropin (HCG) titers and histologic subgroups, whereas patients with lactic dehydrogenase (LDH) values exceeding 500 mIU/ml did worse (50% continuous CR rate in 12 cases) than those with normal or less elevated titers (89% continuous CR rate in 19 cases). After a median follow-up period of 34 months (range, 12+ to 77+ months), 23 patients (74.5%) remain alive in continuous CR, two (6%) died in CR and another one (3%) entered CR after deferred treatment of residual disease. Five patients (16%) died of cancer. Toxicity was severe in extensively irradiated patients, but it was acceptable in those not pretreated and in those who had received only subdiaphragmatic radiotherapy. Cisplatin combination chemotherapy can be successfully and safely used as the primary treatment of choice in patients with advanced seminoma. It is also an excellent salvage therapy for patients who had received subdiaphragmatic irradiation only. On the contrary, it is very difficult to treat with chemotherapy extensively irradiated patients.