From the podium to the patient: bringing the 2008 ASCO meeting to the clinic

Around 4,800 abstracts on preclinical and clinical research in different oncology areas were presented and discussed by oncology clinicians and scientists at the 44th American Society of Clinical Oncology meeting, the largest international forum in the field. As expected, the meeting provided valuable insights into future developments as well as enlightening clinicians regarding current controversies. This manuscript is an opinion-based review of the studies presented at the meeting, focusing on findings from randomized phase III trials and translational researches that, in the authors' opinion, are most likely to modify clinical practice or help scientists in designing future translational and clinical studies.

CpG oligodeoxynucleotides as immunotherapy in cancer

Preclinical and early clinical trials indicate synthetic oligodeoxynucleotides containing unmethylated CG dinucleotides (CpG ODN) have potent immunostimulatory effects and can enhance the anti-cancer activity of a variety of cancer treatments. Synergy between CpG ODN and monoclonal antibodies has been noted in various preclinical models. Early clinical trials indicate CpG ODN and monoclonal antibodies can be administered safely together. Preclinical models indicate CpG ODN can enhance the anti-tumor activity of both chemotherapy and radiation therapy. Thus, one possible approach to the use of CpG ODN was to use it in combination with cytotoxic chemotherapy with the goal of enhancing presentation of tumor antigen from dying cancer cells. Promising results in a randomized phase II trial in patients with non-small cell lung cancer led to initiation of two large randomized phase III trials comparing CpG ODN plus chemotherapy to chemotherapy alone. Unfortunately, interim analysis of these trials indicated CpG ODN was unlikely to enhance efficacy of chemotherapy, and they were stopped. CpG ODN also holds promise as a component of cancer vaccines including those composed of protein antigen, peptides, whole tumor cells, and antigen-pulsed dendritic cells. Finally, CpG ODN has been combined with a variety of cytokines to enhance NK activation, promote development of an active anti-tumor immune response or induce apoptosis of malignant cells that express the TLR9 receptor. Overall, both preclinical and early clinical trials suggest CpG ODN may be a valuable component of a variety of approaches to cancer therapy. However, clinical development of this recently discovered, novel class of immunostimulatory agents is just beginning, and we still have much to learn about the optimal approach to their use, and their potential.

Immunotherapeutic approaches in pancreatic cancer

With growing understanding of the regulation of immune responses, multiple new immunotherapeutic targets have evolved. This article gives a survey over the current approaches in pancreatic cancer therapy including peptide vaccinations, unspecific immunotherapy, allogene modified tumor cell vaccines, and vector-based vaccines. Although several trials have shown detectable immune responses, such as delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions and cytokine release in enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot (ELISPOTS) assays, and some have reported prolonged survival for immune responders, immunotherapy remains experimental. However, some approaches have made it into a phase III setting. In addition, the emerging concept of tumor stem cells may lead to a new focus on immunotherapy, since these often highly chemotherapy-resistant cells are thought to be the source of recurrences.

Present role and future potential of type I interferons in adjuvant therapy of high-risk operable melanoma

Few molecular therapeutic approaches have been so rigorously investigated in relation to the pathophysiology and outcome of human diseases as type I interferons. Historically, IFNs were discovered after the phenomenon of 'interference' was first described by Isaacs and Lindenmann in 1957, and for years IFNs (IFNalpha) were considered as potential "antiviral penicillins" until the broader spectrum of effects upon normal cell physiology, the natural and adaptive immune systems, and tumor growth and proliferation were described. Interferon beta (IFNbeta) was the second human gene after insulin to be cloned, and it codes for the first cytokine used to treat human malignancies. Despite the progress in understanding and treating cancer over the last 25 years, IFN alpha (IFNalpha) remains the most commonly used biologically active cytokine in the treatment of solid tumors, and for some like melanoma, the only successful agent. In this review we discuss the role of type I interferons in the pathophysiology and treatment of melanoma, with emphasis on the 22 years of work conducted at the University of Pittsburgh. We discuss potential mechanisms that partially explain the clinical benefit, and set the groundwork for building upon, the design of more effective treatments for this disease.

Immune cell recruitment and cell-based system for cancer therapy

Immune cells, such as cytotoxic T lymphocytes, natural killer cells, B cells, and dendritic cells, have a central role in cancer immunotherapy. Conventional studies of cancer immunotherapy have focused mainly on the search for an efficient means to prime/activate tumor-associated antigen-specific immunity. A systematic understanding of the molecular basis of the trafficking and biodistribution of immune cells, however, is important for the development of more efficacious cancer immunotherapies. It is well established that the basis and premise of immunotherapy is the accumulation of effective immune cells in tumor tissues. Therefore, it is crucial to control the distribution of immune cells to optimize cancer immunotherapy. Recent characterization of various chemokines and chemokine receptors in the immune system has increased our knowledge of the regulatory mechanisms of the immune response and tolerance based on immune cell localization. Here, we review the immune cell recruitment and cell-based systems that can potentially control the systemic pharmacokinetics of immune cells and, in particular, focus on cell migrating molecules, i.e., chemokines, and their receptors, and their use in cancer immunotherapy.

Early experience with novel immunomodulators for cancer treatment

Immunotherapy involves the treatment of cancer by modification of the host-tumour relationship. It is now known that this relationship is quite complex and only some of the interactions have been elucidated. Early attempts at immunotherapy, such as Coley's toxins, were undertaken without an understanding of the processes mediating the effects. With a better understanding of the immunology of this anticancer response, recent trials have focussed on certain aspects of the process to stimulate an antitumour response. In this review, the authors discuss a number of novel biological response modifiers that work as general stimulants of the immune system, through varied mechanisms including induction of stimulatory cytokines (such as IFN-alpha, TNF-alpha and IL-12) and activation of T cells and the antigen-presenting dendritic cells. These compounds include Toll-like receptor agonists, several of which are in clinical trials at present. In addition to immunomodulatory activity, some compounds such as 5,6-dimethylxanthenone-4-acetic acid (DMXAA) and thalidomide and its analogues also target existing or developing tumour vasculature. Some of these compounds have single-agent activity in clinical trials, while others such as DMXAA have shown promise in combination with chemotherapy without increasing toxicity. Lactoferrin is another compound that has shown clinical activity with low toxicity. At present, accepted indications for immunotherapy are limited to a few cancers such as renal cell carcinoma and melanoma. This paper looks at some of the reasons for the limited impact of immunotherapy so far and suggest possible avenues for further research with a greater likelihood of success.

Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase and tumor-induced tolerance

Tumors arise from normal cells of the body through genetic mutation. Although such genetic mutation often leads to the expression of abnormal antigens, the immune system fails to respond effectively to these antigens; that is, it is tolerant of these antigens. This acquired state of tolerance must be overcome for cancer immunotherapy to succeed. Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase (IDO) is one molecular mechanism that contributes to tumor-induced tolerance. IDO helps create a tolerogenic milieu in the tumor and the tumor-draining lymph nodes, both by direct suppression of T cells and enhancement of local Treg-mediated immunosuppression. It can also function as an antagonist to other activators of antitumor immunity. Therefore, strategies to block IDO might enhance the effectiveness of tumor immunotherapy.

Phase II trial of a toll-like receptor 9-activating oligonucleotide in patients with metastatic melanoma

PURPOSE

The recent identification of toll-like receptors (TLRs) and respective ligands allows the evaluation of novel dendritic cell (DC) -activating strategies. Stimulation of TLR9 directly activates human plasmacytoid DCs (PDCs) and indirectly induces potent innate immune responses in preclinical tumor models. We performed an open-label, multicenter, single-arm, phase II pilot trial with a TLR9-stimulating oligodeoxynucleotide in melanoma patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Patients with unresectable stage IIIb/c or stage IV melanoma received 6 mg PF-3512676 weekly by subcutaneous injection for 24 weeks or until disease progression to evaluate safety as well as clinical and immunologic activity. Clinical and laboratory safety assessments were performed weekly; blood samples for immunological measurements were taken every 8 weeks. Tumor measurements were performed according to Response Evaluation Criteria in Solid Tumors.

RESULTS

Twenty patients received PF-3512676 for a mean of 10.9 weeks with a mean of 10.7 injections. Laboratory and nonlaboratory adverse events were limited, transient, and did not result in any withdrawals. Two patients experienced a confirmed partial response; one response is ongoing for 140+ weeks. Three patients experienced stable disease. Immunologic measurements revealed induction of an activated phenotype of PDC, elevation of serum levels of 2',5'-oligoadenylate, a surrogate marker of type I interferon production, and significant stimulation of natural killer cell cytotoxicity (the latter was associated with clinical benefit).

CONCLUSION

These results indicate that TLR9-targeted therapy can stimulate innate immune responses in cancer patients, identify biomarkers that may be associated with TLR9-induced tumor regression, and encourage the design of follow-up studies to evaluate the ability of this therapeutic approach to target human cancer.