Newborn Screening for Congenital Hypothyroidism: the Benefit of Using Differential TSH Cutoffs in a 2-Screen Program

Laboratory Thyroid Tests: A Historical Perspective

Background: This review presents a timeline showing how technical advances made over the last seven decades have impacted the development of laboratory thyroid tests. Summary: Thyroid tests have evolved from time-consuming manual procedures using isotopically labeled iodine as signals (¹³¹I and later ¹²⁵I) performed in nuclear medicine laboratories, to automated nonisotopic tests performed on multianalyte instruments in routine clinical chemistry laboratories. The development of isotopic radioimmunoassay techniques around 1960, followed by the advent of monoclonal antibody technology in the mid-1970s, led to the development of a nonisotopic immunometric assay methodology that forms the backbone of present-day thyroid testing. This review discusses the development of methods for measuring total thyroxine and triiodothyronine, direct and indirect free thyroid hormone measurements and estimates (free thyroxine and free triiodothyronine), thyrotropin (TSH), thyroid autoantibodies (thyroperoxidase, thyroglobulin [Tg] and TSH receptor autoantibodies), and Tg protein. Despite progressive improvements made in sensitivity and specificity, current thyroid tests remain limited by between-method differences in the numeric values they report, as well as nonspecific interferences with test reagents and interferences from analyte autoantibodies. Conclusions: Thyroid disease affects ∼10% of the U.S. population and is mostly managed on an outpatient basis, generating 60% of endocrine laboratory tests. In future, it is hoped that interferences will be eliminated, and the standardization/harmonization of tests will facilitate the establishment of universal test reference ranges.

Neonatal Screening for Congenital Hypothyroidism in Preterm Infants: Is a Targeted Strategy Required?

Background: Premature infants are at higher risk of developing congenital hypothyroidism (CH) but the neonatal screening strategy for this population is still debatable. The purpose of this retrospective study is to describe the results of a screening program for CH in a preterm infant cohort. Materials and Methods: All preterm newborns who underwent neonatal screening in the Italian region of Piedmont in the period January 2019-December 2021, were included in this retrospective cohort study. The first thyrotropin (TSH) measurement was performed at 72 hours, whereas the second at 15 days of life. Infants with TSH >20 mUI/L at first detection and >6 mUI/L at second were recalled for a full evaluation of thyroid function. Results: During the study period, 5930 preterm newborns were screened. Based on birthweight (BW), the mean TSH was 2.08 ± 0.15 for BW <1000 g, 2.01 ± 0.02 for BW 1001-1500 g, 2.28 ± 0.03 for BW 1501-2499 g, and 2.41 ± 0.03 mUI/L in normal-weight newborns (p < 0.005) at the first detection, with a significant difference observed at the second measurement (p < 0.005). Based on gestational age, the mean TSH at first detection was 1.71 ± 0.09 mUI/L for extremely preterm babies and 1.87 ± 0.06, 1.94 ± 0.05, and 2.42 ± 0.02 mUI/L for very preterm, moderately, and late preterm infants (p < 0.005), respectively. Significant between-group differences of TSH measurements were also at the second and third detections (p < 0.005 and p = 0.01). The 99% reference range in this cohort overlapped with the recommended TSH cutoffs for screening recall (8 mUI/L for first detection and 6 mUI/L for second detection). CH incidence was 1:156. Of the 38 patients diagnosed with CH, a eutopic gland was present in 30 (87.9%), with CH transient in 29 (76.8%). Conclusions: We observed no significant difference in the recall rate between preterm and at term infants screened in this study. Our current screening strategy therefore appears effective in avoiding misdiagnosis. CH screening approaches vary among countries. Development and testing of a uniform multinational screening strategy is needed.

Fifty years of newborn screening for congenital hypothyroidism: current status in Australasia and the case for harmonisation

OBJECTIVES

Since its implementation 50 years ago in Quebec, Canada, newborn screening for congenital hypothyroidism has become one of the most successful public health measures worldwide. Screening programmes across Australia and New Zealand are characterised by significant commonalities in screening algorithms, and a high degree of regional cooperation in harmonisation efforts. We aimed to conduct a comprehensive survey of current performance and practices related to the total testing process for congenital hypothyroidism screening and provide recommendations for harmonisation priorities within our region.

METHODS

A survey was conducted involving the six newborn screening laboratories which provide complete geographic coverage across Australasia. Approximately 360,000 newborns are screened annually. Survey questions incorporated pre-analytical, analytical, and post-analytical aspects of the screening programmes and an extensive 5-year (2016-2020) retrospective analysis of individual programme performance data. Responses from individual screening programmes were collated.

RESULTS

The uptake of newborn screening was over 98% for the six major jurisdictions. All programmes have adopted a single-tier thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) strategy using the Perkin Elmer GSP instrument. Significant similarities exist between programmes for recommended age of collection and recollection protocols for low birthweight newborns. The process for the determination of TSH cutoffs varies between programmes. TSH lower cut-offs for borderline-positive and positive notifications between 12-15 and 12-25 mIU/L blood, respectively. Recall rates vary between 0.08 and 0.20%. The case definition for congenital hypothyroidism generally includes biochemical and radiological parameters in addition to the commencement of thyroxine. All programmes reported collecting biochemical and clinical data on infants with positive screening tests, and positive predictive values vary between 23.6 and 77.3%. Variation in reported incidence (1:1,300-2,000) cannot be entirely explained by cutoff or recall rate (although one programme reporting fewer cases includes only permanent disease).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite similarities between newborn screening algorithms for congenital hypothyroidism across Australia and New Zealand, differences in reported programme performance provide the basis for further harmonisation. Surveillance of a large population offers the potential for the ongoing development of evidence-based screening guidelines.

Congenital hypothyroidism after newborn screening program reorganization in the Apulia region

Background

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is the most frequent congenital endocrine disorder. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the incidence and etiological classification of CH in Apulia in a three-year period according to the reorganization of the regional screening program in a single central laboratory, as well as to analyze the growth characteristics and the associated risk factors of the CH newborns diagnosed during the study period.

Methods

Data derived from the reorganization of the newborn screening program for CH in a single central laboratory that collects dried blood spot (DBS) from 27 Maternity Hospitals are analyzed over a three-year period. Birth weight and length, daily dose of L-T4 at specific key points (3, 6, 12 and 18 months, 2, 2.5 and 3 years) were also obtained from medical records of the CH newborns during the study period and calculated as standard deviation score (SDS).

Results

The screening program diagnosed 90 newborns with confirmed CH (incidence 1:990; recall rate: 3.6%). In detail, 75.6% newborns had an eutopic thyroid, and 24.4% had thyroid dysgenesis; 33 out of the 90 newborns (36.6%) had one or more risk factors. Among these, the multiple pregnancies are the most important because they tripled the risk of CH. At diagnosis, TSH levels were different between patients with dysgenesis and those with an eutopic thyroid (p = 0.005). Treatment was started at a mean of 18.5 ± 12.8 days of life. The mean starting dose of levothyroxine (L-T4) was 11.38 ± 2.46 μg/kg/day.

Conclusions

The results of these study show an increase of CH cases in newborns with an eutopic thyroid compared to the traditional classification. The centralization of the screening program allows a closer cooperation between laboratory and clinical centers and facilitates the implementation of appropriate diagnostic evaluations and timely initiation of treatment, with positive effects on the management of the condition.

Clinical features and outcomes of 31 children with congenital hypothyroidism missed by neonatal screening

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the clinical features and outcomes of children with congenital hypothyroidism (CH) missed by neonatal screening.

METHODS

The clinical and laboratory date of 31 children with CH missed by neonatal screening from February 2015 to February 2022 in Guangzhou Women and Children's Medical Center were retrospectively analyzed. Whole-exome high-throughput sequencing analysis was performed in 17 patients.

RESULTS

Among the 31 patients, 19 cases (61.3%) were preterm, 12 cases (38.7%) were term neonates. The median value of gestation age was 36 (26-40) weeks, birth weight was 2.35 (0.75-3.70) kg, diagnosed age was 20 d (7 d-4 years), dry blood spot thyrotropin was 4.18 (0.34-8.97) mU/L. Nine cases (29.0%) were same-sex twins and 4 cases (12.9%) had a family history of hypothyroidism. The initial clinical symptoms were growth retardation in 11 cases (35.5%), prolonged jaundice in 7 cases (22.6%), short stature, abdominal distension, fetal edema and goiter in 1 case (3.2%), respectively. Genetic analysis of the 17 children showed that DUOX2 gene mutations were detected in 10 cases (6 cases with biallelic mutations and 4 cases with monoallelic mutations), of whom 3 had a family history of hypothyroidism. A total of 22 patients were reevaluated at the age of 2-3 years, of whom 17 cases (77.3%) were transient CH and 5 cases (22.7%) were permanent CH. Among the 10 cases with DUOX2 gene mutations, 6 cases were transient CH, 1 case was permanent CH, and 3 cases (< 3 years old) were still under treatment with L-thyroxine.

CONCLUSIONS

False negative results on neonatal screening for CH often occurs in preterm birth, low birth weight, same-sex twins, family history of hypothyroidism, and DUOX2 defects are the common molecular pathogenesis, most of whom are transient CH. Thyroid function should be evaluated in time for children with unexplained slow growth and delayed jaundice regression.

Utility of Repeat Testing for Congenital Hypothyroidism in Infants with Very Low Birth Weight

OBJECTIVE

To assess for possible missed hypothyroidism in infants of very low birth weight (VLBW) whose initial newborn screening (NBS) was within normal reference range.

STUDY DESIGN

We analyzed serum thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) obtained at 36 weeks of corrected gestational age or at hospital discharge if earlier (retest TSH) in infants with VLBW in the neonatal intensive care unit to determine the prevalence and factors associated with retest TSH ≥5 mU/L, a concentration requiring close follow-up for hypothyroidism. Utility of alternative cut-offs for NBS TSH also was assessed.

RESULTS

A total of 398 infants, median gestational age 29 (range 22-36) weeks, birth weight 1138 (470-1498) g, were included in this study. Retest TSH was obtained at 49.5 (12-137) days after birth. Median retest TSH was 3.1 (0.5-27.9) mU/L. Seventy-three (18.3%) of the cohort had retest TSH ≥5 mU/L. Adjusting NBS cut-off to ≥15 or ≥10 mU/L identified <50% of infants with TSH ≥5 mU/L, resulting in 6% false positives and >70% false negatives. Multiple regression modeling indicated that 35% of variance in retest TSH value was explained by NBS TSH concentration, birth weight, and gestational age, all P < .01.

CONCLUSIONS

Retesting for hypothyroidism at 36 weeks of corrected gestational age in infants with VLBL and normal NBS could identify infants who require ongoing surveillance until thyroid function has been definitively ascertained. Adjusting NBS TSH cutoffs is not a valid option for identifying potential hypothyroidism in infants with VLBW because of lack of sensitivity and unacceptable false-positive and false-negative rates.

Biological variation estimates of thyroid related measurands - meta-analysis of BIVAC compliant studies

OBJECTIVES

Testing for thyroid disease constitutes a high proportion of the workloads of clinical laboratories worldwide. The setting of analytical performance specifications (APS) for testing methods and aiding clinical interpretation of test results requires biological variation (BV) data. A critical review of published BV studies of thyroid disease related measurands has therefore been undertaken and meta-analysis applied to deliver robust BV estimates.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was conducted for BV studies of thyroid related analytes. BV data from studies compliant with the Biological Variation Data Critical Appraisal Checklist (BIVAC) were subjected to meta-analysis. Global estimates of within subject variation (CV_I) enabled determination of APS (imprecision and bias), indices of individuality, and indicative estimates of reference change values.

RESULTS

The systematic review identified 17 relevant BV studies. Only one study (EuBIVAS) achieved a BIVAC grade of A. Methodological and statistical issues were the reason for B and C scores. The meta-analysis derived CV_I generally delivered lower APS for imprecision than the mean CV_A of the studies included in this systematic review.

CONCLUSIONS

Systematic review and meta-analysis of studies of BV of thyroid disease biomarkers have enabled delivery of well characterized estimates of BV for some, but not all measurands. The newly derived APS for imprecision for both free thyroxine and triiodothyronine may be considered challenging. The high degree of individuality identified for thyroid related measurands reinforces the importance of RCVs. Generation of BV data applicable to multiple scenarios may require definition using "big data" instead of the demanding experimental approach.

[Newborn screening for congenital hypothyroidism and congenital adrenal hyperplasia: Benefits and costs of a successful public health program]

Newborn screening is an important public health program and a triumph of preventive medicine. Economic analyses show that the benefits of newborn screening clearly outweigh the costs for certain diseases, but not necessarily for other ones. This is due to the great diversity of the natural history of the diseases detected, to the fact that each of these diseases considered individually is rare, and to differences in the effectiveness of interventions. In addition, the benefit-cost ratio of screening for a particular disorder may differ between countries, specifically between high-income and low- and middle-income countries. The burden of a disorder may also be alleviated by increased clinical awareness and effective clinical services, even in the absence of newborn screening. In this article, we focus on economic analyses of newborn screening for primary congenital hypothyroidism, which has been in place in high-income countries for roughly 40 years, and for classic congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency. Screening for the latter is not yet universal, even in high-income countries, although the lack of universal implementation may reflect factors other than economic considerations.