Cancer promoted by the oncoprotein v-ErbA may be due to subcellular mislocalization of nuclear receptors

Getting there: Thyroid hormone receptor intracellular trafficking

A year ago, when I first contemplated writing this article, my intent was to provide a detailed review of the contributions of the diverse community of talented scientists in my lab to the nuclear receptor research field. In the throes of a deadly pandemic, political turmoil, and Black Lives Matter, however, I found myself compelled to tell a more personal story. While I will still cover milestones in our understanding of the intracellular trafficking of the thyroid hormone receptor, now these will be set against the backdrop of my path as a woman in STEM and on being intentionally inclusive. By sharing reflections on my journey, I hope to encourage young investigators to persist in their pursuit of a career in science.

Mediator subunit MED1 modulates intranuclear dynamics of the thyroid hormone receptor

The thyroid hormone receptors (TRs) mediate thyroid hormone (T₃ )-dependent gene expression. The nuclear import and export signals that direct TR shuttling are well characterized, but little is known about factors modulating nuclear retention. We used fluorescence-based nucleocytoplasmic scoring and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching in transfected cells to investigate whether Mediator subunits MED1 and MED13 play a role in nuclear retention of TR. When MED1 was overexpressed, there was a striking shift towards a greater nuclear localization of TRβ1 and the oncoprotein v-ErbA, subtypes with cytosolic populations at steady-state, and TRβ1 intranuclear mobility was reduced. For TRα1, there was no observable change in its predominantly nuclear distribution pattern or mobility. Consistent with a role for MED1 in nuclear retention, the cytosolic TRα1 and TRβ1 population were significantly greater in MED1^-/- cells, compared with MED1^+/+ cells. Exposure to T₃ and epidermal growth factor, which induces MED1 phosphorylation, also altered TR intranuclear dynamics. Overexpression of miR-208a, which downregulates MED13, led to a more cytosolic distribution of nuclear-localized TRα1; however, overexpression of MED13 had no effect on TRβ1 localization. The known binding site of MED1 overlaps with a transactivation domain and nuclear export signal in helix 12 of TR's ligand-binding domain (LBD). Coimmunoprecipitation assays demonstrated that TR's LBD interacts directly with exportins 5 and 7, suggesting that binding of exportins and MED1 to TR may be mutually exclusive. Collectively, our data provide evidence that MED1 promotes nuclear retention of TR, and highlight the dual functionality of helix 12 in TR transactivation and nuclear export.

Acetylation modulates thyroid hormone receptor intracellular localization and intranuclear mobility

The thyroid hormone receptor (TR) undergoes nucleocytoplasmic shuttling, but is primarily nuclear-localized and mediates expression of genes involved in development and homeostasis. Given the proximity of TR acetylation and sumoylation sites to nuclear localization (NLS) and nuclear export signals, we investigated their role in regulating intracellular localization. The nuclear/cytosolic fluorescence ratio (N/C) of fluorescent protein-tagged acetylation mimic, nonacetylation mimic, and sumoylation-deficient TR was quantified in transfected mammalian cells. While nonacetylation mimic and sumoylation-deficient TRs displayed wild-type N/C, the acetylation mimic's N/C was significantly lower. Importins that interact with wild-type TR also interact with acetylation and nonacetylation mimics, suggesting factors other than reduced importin binding alter nuclear localization. FRAP analysis showed wild-type intranuclear dynamics of acetylation mimic and sumoylation-deficient TRs, whereas the nonacetylation mimic had significantly reduced mobility and transcriptional activity. Acetyltransferase CBP/p300 inhibition enhanced TR's nuclear localization, further suggesting that nonacetylation correlates with nuclear retention, while acetylation promotes cytosolic localization.

Thyroid hormone receptor localization in target tissues

The thyroid hormone receptors, TRα1, TRβ1 and other subtypes, are members of the nuclear receptor superfamily that mediate the action of thyroid hormone signaling in numerous tissues to regulate important physiological and developmental processes. Their most well-characterized role is as ligand-dependent transcription factors; TRs bind thyroid hormone response elements in the presence or absence of thyroid hormone to facilitate the expression of target genes. Although primarily residing in the nucleus, TRα1 and TRβ1 shuttle rapidly between the nucleus and cytoplasm. We have identified multiple nuclear localization signals and nuclear export signals within TRα1 and TRβ1 that interact with importins and exportins, respectively, to mediate translocation across the nuclear envelope. More recently, enigmatic cytoplasmic functions have been ascribed to other TR subtypes, expanding the diversity of the cellular response to thyroid hormone. By integrating data on localization signal motifs, this review provides an overview of the complex interplay between TR's dynamic transport pathways and thyroid hormone signaling activities. We examine the variation in TR subtype response to thyroid hormone signaling, and what is currently known about regulation of the variety of tissue-specific localization patterns, including targeting to the nucleus, the mitochondria and the inner surface of the plasma membrane.

Nuclear Import and Export of the Thyroid Hormone Receptor

The thyroid hormone receptors, TRα1 and TRβ1, are members of the nuclear receptor superfamily that forms one of the most abundant classes of transcription factors in multicellular organisms. Although primarily localized to the nucleus, TRα1 and TRβ1 shuttle rapidly between the nucleus and cytoplasm. The fine balance between nuclear import and export of TRs has emerged as a critical control point for modulating thyroid hormone-responsive gene expression. Mutagenesis studies have defined two nuclear localization signal (NLS) motifs that direct nuclear import of TRα1: NLS-1 in the hinge domain and NLS-2 in the N-terminal A/B domain. Three nuclear export signal (NES) motifs reside in the ligand-binding domain. A combined approach of shRNA-mediated knockdown and coimmunoprecipitation assays revealed that nuclear entry of TRα1 is facilitated by importin 7, likely through interactions with NLS-2, and importin β1 and the adapter importin α1 interacting with both NLS-1 and NLS-2. Interestingly, TRβ1 lacks NLS-2 and nuclear import depends solely on the importin α1/β1 heterodimer. Heterokaryon and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching shuttling assays identified multiple exportins that play a role in nuclear export of TRα1, including CRM1 (exportin 1), and exportins 4, 5, and 7. Even single amino acid changes in TRs dramatically alter their intracellular distribution patterns. We conclude that mutations within NLS and NES motifs affect nuclear shuttling activity, and propose that TR mislocalization contributes to the development of some types of cancer and Resistance to Thyroid Hormone syndrome.

Systematic nucleo-cytoplasmic trafficking of proteins following exposure of MCF7 breast cancer cells to estradiol

We have used a proteomics subcellular spatial razor approach to look at changes in total protein abundance and in protein distribution between the nucleus and cytoplasm following exposure of MCF7 breast cancer cells to estradiol. The dominant response of MCF7 cells to estrogen stimulation involves dynamic changes in protein subcellular spatial distribution rather than changes in total protein abundance. Of the 3604 quantitatively monitored proteins, only about 2% show substantial changes in total abundance (>2-fold), whereas about 20% of the proteins show substantial changes in local abundance and/or redistribution of their subcellular location, with up to 16-fold changes in their local concentration in the nucleus or the cytoplasm. We propose that dynamic redistribution of the subcellular location of multiple proteins in response to stimuli is a fundamental characteristic of cells and suggest that perturbation of cellular spatial control may be an important feature of cancer.

V-erbA generates ribosomes devoid of RPL11 and regulates translational activity in avian erythroid progenitors

The v-erbA oncogene transforms chicken erythrocytic progenitors (T2EC) by blocking their differentiation and freezing them in a state of self-renewal. Transcriptomes of T2EC, expressing either v-erbA or a non-transforming form of v-erbA (S61G), were compared using serial analysis of gene expression and some, but not all, mRNA-encoding ribosomal proteins were seen to be affected by v-erbA. These results suggest that this oncogene could modulate the composition of ribosomes. In the present study, we demonstrate, using two-dimensional difference in gel electrophoresis, that v-erbA-expressing cells have a lower amount of RPL11 associated with the ribosomes. The presence of ribosomes devoid of RPL11 in v-erbA-expressing cells was further confirmed by immunoprecipitation. In order to assess the possible impact of these specialized ribosomes on the translational activity, we analyzed proteomes of either v-erbA or S61G-expressing cells using 2D/mass spectrometry, and identified nine proteins present in differing amounts within these cells. Among these proteins, we focused on HSP70 because of its involvement in erythroid differentiation. Our results indicate that, in v-erbA-expressing cells, hsp70 is not only transcribed but also translated more efficiently, as shown by polyribosome fractionation experiments. We demonstrate here, for the first time, the existence of ribosomes with different protein components, notably ribosomes devoid of RPL11, and a regulation of mRNA translation depending on v-erbA oncogene expression.

Multiple novel signals mediate thyroid hormone receptor nuclear import and export

Thyroid hormone receptor (TR) is a member of the nuclear receptor superfamily that shuttles between the cytosol and nucleus. The fine balance between nuclear import and export of TR has emerged as a critical control point for modulating thyroid hormone-responsive gene expression; however, sequence motifs of TR that mediate shuttling are not fully defined. Here, we characterized multiple signals that direct TR shuttling. Along with the known nuclear localization signal in the hinge domain, we identified a novel nuclear localization signal in the A/B domain of thyroid hormone receptor α1 that is absent in thyroid hormone receptor β1 and inactive in the oncoprotein v-ErbA. Our prior studies showed that thyroid hormone receptor α1 exits the nucleus through two pathways, one dependent on the export factor CRM1 and the other CRM1-independent. Here, we identified three novel CRM1-independent nuclear export signal (NES) motifs in the ligand-binding domain as follows: a highly conserved NES in helix 12 (NES-H12) and two additional NES sequences spanning helix 3 and helix 6, respectively. Mutations predicted to disrupt the α-helical structure resulted in a significant decrease in NES-H12 activity. The high degree of conservation of helix 12 suggests that this region may function as a key NES in other nuclear receptors. Furthermore, our mutagenesis studies on NES-H12 suggest that altered shuttling of thyroid hormone receptor β1 may be a contributing factor in resistance to thyroid hormone syndrome. Taken together, our findings provide a detailed mechanistic understanding of the multiple signals that work together to regulate TR shuttling and transcriptional activity, and they provide important insights into nuclear receptor function in general.

Recruitment of the oncoprotein v-ErbA to aggresomes

Aggresome formation, a cellular response to misfolded protein aggregates, is linked to cancer and neurodegenerative disorders. Previously we showed that Gag-v-ErbA (v-ErbA), a retroviral variant of the thyroid hormone receptor (TRα1), accumulates in and sequesters TRα1 into cytoplasmic foci. Here, we show that foci represent v-ErbA targeting to aggresomes. v-ErbA colocalizes with aggresomal markers, proteasomes, hsp70, HDAC6, and mitochondria. Foci have hallmark characteristics of aggresomes: formation is microtubule-dependent, accelerated by proteasome inhibitors, and they disrupt intermediate filaments. Proteasome-mediated degradation is critical for clearance of v-ErbA and T(3)-dependent TRα1 clearance. Our studies highlight v-ErbA's complex mode of action: the oncoprotein is highly mobile and trafficks between the nucleus, cytoplasm, and aggresome, carrying out distinct activities within each compartment. Dynamic trafficking to aggresomes contributes to the dominant negative activity of v-ErbA and may be enhanced by the viral Gag sequence. These studies provide insight into novel modes of oncogenesis across multiple cellular compartments.

Thyroid receptor: roles in cancer

The thyroid hormone receptors, encoded by the TRalpha and TRbeta genes, are ligand-dependent transcription factors that belong to the nuclear receptor superfamily. In addition to the role of these receptors in growth, development and metabolism, there is increasing evidence that they also inhibit transformation and act as tumor suppressors. Aberrant TR action, as well as receptor silencing, are common events in human cancer, and TRs also have an important role in tumor progression in experimental animal models, suggesting that these receptors constitute a novel therapeutic target in cancer. This review highlights recent studies on mechanisms by which loss of expression and/or function of these receptors results in a selective advantage for cellular transformation, tumor development and metastatic growth.

Thyroid hormone receptor alpha1 follows a cooperative CRM1/calreticulin-mediated nuclear export pathway

The thyroid hormone receptor alpha1 (TRalpha) exhibits a dual role as an activator or repressor of its target genes in response to thyroid hormone (T(3)). Previously, we have shown that TRalpha, formerly thought to reside solely in the nucleus bound to DNA, actually shuttles rapidly between the nucleus and cytoplasm. An important aspect of the shuttling activity of TRalpha is its ability to exit the nucleus through the nuclear pore complex. TRalpha export is not sensitive to treatment with the CRM1-specific inhibitor leptomycin B (LMB) in heterokaryon assays, suggesting a role for an export receptor other than CRM1. Here, we have used a combined approach of in vivo fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments, in vitro permeabilized cell nuclear export assays, and glutathione S-transferase pull-down assays to investigate the export pathway used by TRalpha. We show that, in addition to shuttling in heterokaryons, TRalpha shuttles rapidly in an unfused monokaryon system as well. Furthermore, our data show that TRalpha directly interacts with calreticulin, and point to the intriguing possibility that TRalpha follows a cooperative export pathway in which both calreticulin and CRM1 play a role in facilitating efficient translocation of TRalpha from the nucleus to cytoplasm.

Modulation of expression of RA-regulated genes by the oncoprotein v-erbA

Retinoic acid (RA) modulates the expression of genes involved in embryogenesis, development and differentiation processes in vertebrates. The v-erbA oncogene is known to exert a dominant-negative effect on the expression of RA-responsive genes. v-erbA belongs to a superfamily of transcription factors called nuclear receptors, which includes the retinoic acid receptors (RARs) responsible for mediating the effects of retinoic acid. While RA inhibits cell proliferation and promotes cell differentiation and apoptosis in a variety of tissues, v-erbA seems to play a role in oncogenesis, namely in the development of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) in a transgenic mouse model. In order to study the effect of v-erbA on RA-responsive genes, we used microarray analysis to identify genes differentially expressed in murine hepatocytes in culture (AML12 cells) stably transfected with v-erbA and exposed to RA for 3 h or 24 h. We have identified RA-responsive genes that are affected by v-erbA, as well as genes that are regulated by v-erbA alone. We have found that v-erbA can affect gene expression in the presence of RA and at the level of basal transcription. We have also identified a number of v-erbA-responsive genes that are known to be involved in carcinogenesis and which may play a role in the development of HCC.

Quantum dots as fluorescence resonance energy transfer donors in cells

Quantum dots (QDs) promise to revolutionize the way fluorescence imaging is used in the cell biology field. The unique fluorescent spectral characteristics, high photostability, low photobleaching, and tight emission spectra of QDs position them above traditional dyes. We will address the ability of water-stabilized QDs to behave as effective fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) donors in cells upon transferrin-receptor-(TFR) mediated endocytosis. Confocal microscopy detects whether donor QD transferrin conjugates transfer energy to acceptor organic fluorophore-transferrin conjugate molecules in endocytic compartments. QDs are shown to be effective FRET donors when internalized into cells via the transferring receptor-mediated endocytic pathway. Upon pairing with the appropriate acceptor dyes, QDs will reduce the laborious data processing that is required to compensate for bleed through contamination between organic dye donor and acceptor pair signals. The QD technology simplifies and expands the use of FRET in the analysis of complex cellular processes that may involve protein organization in intracellular membranes as well as protein-protein interactions.

Chapter 22: Quantitation of protein-protein interactions: confocal FRET microscopy

Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) is an effective and high resolution method to monitor protein-protein interactions in live or fixed specimens. FRET can be used to estimate the distance between interacting protein molecules in vivo or in vitro using laser-scanning confocal FRET microscopy. The spectral overlap of donor and acceptor-essential for FRET-also generates a contamination of the FRET signal, which should be removed in order to carry out quantitative data analysis with confidence. Quantitative FRET data analysis addresses the wealth of information contained in the data set, once optimized FRET imaging has been completed. In this chapter, we describe step-by-step what the issues are in quantitative FRET data analysis, using membrane receptor trafficking and organization as an example. The assays described are applicable to many other biological applications.

Large-scale analysis by SAGE reveals new mechanisms of v-erbA oncogene action

Background:

The v-erbA oncogene, carried by the Avian Erythroblastosis Virus, derives from the c-erbAα proto-oncogene that encodes the nuclear receptor for triiodothyronine (T3R). v-ErbA transforms erythroid progenitors in vitro by blocking their differentiation, supposedly by interference with T3R and RAR (Retinoic Acid Receptor). However, v-ErbA target genes involved in its transforming activity still remain to be identified.

Results:

By using Serial Analysis of Gene Expression (SAGE), we identified 110 genes deregulated by v-ErbA and potentially implicated in the transformation process. Bioinformatic analysis of promoter sequence and transcriptional assays point out a potential role of c-Myb in the v-ErbA effect. Furthermore, grouping of newly identified target genes by function revealed both expected (chromatin/transcription) and unexpected (protein metabolism) functions potentially deregulated by v-ErbA. We then focused our study on 15 of the new v-ErbA target genes and demonstrated by real time PCR that in majority their expression was activated neither by T3, nor RA, nor during differentiation. This was unexpected based upon the previously known role of v-ErbA.

Conclusion:

This paper suggests the involvement of a wealth of new unanticipated mechanisms of v-ErbA action.

Receptor complexes cotransported via polarized endocytic pathways form clusters with distinct organizations

Previously, FRET confocal microscopy has shown that polymeric IgA-receptor (pIgA-R) is distributed in a clustered manner in apical endosomes. To test whether different membrane-bound components form clusters during membrane trafficking, live-cell quantitative FRET was used to characterize the organization of pIgA-R and transferrin receptor (TFR) in endocytic membranes of polarized MDCK cells upon internalization of donor- and acceptor-labeled ligands. We show that pIgA-R and TFR complexes form increasingly organized clusters during cotransport from basolateral to perinuclear endosomes. The organization of these receptor clusters in basolateral versus perinuclear/apical endosomes is significantly different; the former showing a mixed random/clustered distribution while the latter highly organized clusters. Our results indicate that although both perinuclear and apical endosomes comprise pIgA-R and TFR clusters, their E% levels are significantly different suggesting that these receptors are packed into clusters in a distinct manner. The quantitative FRET-based assay presented here suggests that different receptor complexes form clusters, with diverse levels of organization, while being cotransported via the polarized endocytic pathways.

Issues in confocal microscopy for quantitative FRET analysis

Previously, we have carried out extensive quantitative analysis of Förster (or fluorescence) resonance energy transfer (FRET) data to show that polymeric IgA receptors and their ligands cluster in endocytic membranes in the process of sorting and trafficking in polarized cells. Here, we use a similar technique to assay the organization and distribution of another membrane-bound receptor: transferrin receptor (TFR) and its ligand, holo-transferrin (Tfn), while explaining the step-by-step measures to be taken for successful quantitative analysis of the FRET data. In particular, methodological issues in FRET quantitative imaging, such as spectral bleed-through and background correction, optimal selection of regions of interest, how to deal with outliers and pooling data and statistical analysis of FRET data, are addressed. Our results indicating a clustered organization of TFR-Tfn complexes fit the well-known homodimeric structure of TFR. These quantitative approaches can be adapted for other biological applications of FRET.

Comparing the quantification of Forster resonance energy transfer measurement accuracies based on intensity, spectral, and lifetime imaging

The measurement of Forster resonance energy transfer (FRET) in microscopes can be realized by different imaging modalities. In the present work, reference FRET constructs are developed to allow the comparison of FRET microscopy measurements using intensity, spectral, and lifetime imaging. Complimentary DNA strands are respectively labeled with Oregon Green 488 (OG488) or tetramethylrhodamine (TMR). The OG488 dye is fixed at the 5(') end of one strand, and the TMR label position is allowed to vary along the complimentary strand. Since OG488 and TMR are FRET pairs, the FRET efficiency can be determined theoretically from the distance separating the two dyes of the double-stranded DNA molecules. Microscopic images are formed by imaging microcapillaries containing various mixtures of oligonucleotides labeled with the FRET fluorophore pair, only the donor, or only acceptor. Traditional two-channel intensity measurements are compared with spectrally resolved imaging and fluorescence lifetime imaging by calculating a FRET index. The latter proves to be the best method to quantify FRET efficiency in the image. More importantly, the intensity fraction of molecules undergoing FRET can be quantitatively measured in each pixel of the image.

Oncogenic conversion of the thyroid hormone receptor by altered nuclear transport

Nuclear receptors (NRs) are transcription factors whose activity is modulated by ligand binding. These receptors are at the core of complex signaling pathways and act as integrators of many cellular signals. In the last decade our understanding of NRs has greatly evolved. In particular, regulation of NR subcellular dynamics has emerged as central to their activity. Research on the subcellular distribution of the thyroid hormone receptor (TR) has revealed new dimensions in the complexity of NR regulation, and points to the possibility that NR mislocalization plays a key role in oncogenesis. For many years, TR was thought to reside exclusively in the nucleus. It is now known that TR is a dynamic protein that shuttles between the nucleus and cytoplasm. TR is localized to the nucleus in a phosphorylated form, suggesting that compartment-specific phosphorylation mediates cross-talk between multiple cell signaling pathways. The oncoprotein v-ErbA, a viral-derived dominant negative variant of TR is actively exported to the cytoplasm by the CRM1 export receptor. Strikingly, the oncoprotein causes mislocalization of cellular TR and some of its coactivators by direct interaction. Here, we offer some perspectives on the role of subcellular trafficking in the oncogenic conversion of TR, and propose a new model for oncoprotein dominant negative activity.