Targeted maximum likelihood estimation for causal inference in survival and competing risks analysis

Targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) provides a general methodology for estimation of causal parameters in presence of high-dimensional nuisance parameters. Generally, TMLE consists of a two-step procedure that combines data-adaptive nuisance parameter estimation with semiparametric efficiency and rigorous statistical inference obtained via a targeted update step. In this paper, we demonstrate the practical applicability of TMLE based causal inference in survival and competing risks settings where event times are not confined to take place on a discrete and finite grid. We focus on estimation of causal effects of time-fixed treatment decisions on survival and absolute risk probabilities, considering different univariate and multidimensional parameters. Besides providing a general guidance to using TMLE for survival and competing risks analysis, we further describe how the previous work can be extended with the use of loss-based cross-validated estimation, also known as super learning, of the conditional hazards. We illustrate the usage of the considered methods using publicly available data from a trial on adjuvant chemotherapy for colon cancer. R software code to implement all considered algorithms and to reproduce all analyses is available in an accompanying online appendix on Github.

Estimation of time-specific intervention effects on continuously distributed time-to-event outcomes by targeted maximum likelihood estimation

This work considers targeted maximum likelihood estimation (TMLE) of treatment effects on absolute risk and survival probabilities in classical time-to-event settings characterized by right-censoring and competing risks. TMLE is a general methodology combining flexible ensemble learning and semiparametric efficiency theory in a two-step procedure for substitution estimation of causal parameters. We specialize and extend the continuous-time TMLE methods for competing risks settings, proposing a targeting algorithm that iteratively updates cause-specific hazards to solve the efficient influence curve equation for the target parameter. As part of the work, we further detail and implement the recently proposed highly adaptive lasso estimator for continuous-time conditional hazards with L1 -penalized Poisson regression. The resulting estimation procedure benefits from relying solely on very mild nonparametric restrictions on the statistical model, thus providing a novel tool for machine-learning-based semiparametric causal inference for continuous-time time-to-event data. We apply the methods to a publicly available dataset on follicular cell lymphoma where subjects are followed over time until disease relapse or death without relapse. The data display important time-varying effects that can be captured by the highly adaptive lasso. In our simulations that are designed to imitate the data, we compare our methods to a similar approach based on random survival forests and to the discrete-time TMLE.