Malignant Transformation in Vestibular Schwannoma: Clinical Study With Survival Analysis

Aim

Vestibular schwannomas (VSs) are generally considered benign tumors, and malignant transformation of VSs (MTVSs) are rare findings. The clinical features, treatment strategy, outcomes and prognostic factors remain unclear. We endeavored to analyze the natural history, management, outcomes and prognostic factors of MTVSs.

Materials and Methods

The clinical features, radiologic findings, pathological investigations and surgical outcomes of 4 patients with MTVSs treated at the authors' institution between 2010 and 2019 were retrospectively collected. Related literature published until December 2019 (63 articles, 67 patients) was evaluated. The authors also made a pooled analysis to evaluate the risk factors for overall survival (OS) time.

Results

Of the 4 cases in our series, 3 cases were malignant transformation following previous treatment (surgery and radiosurgery) and 1 was primary MTVS. Of the 71 MTVSs from the literature, 27 were male and 39 were female, with the mean age of 47.2 ± 17.5 years old. Twelve patients (18.5%) were diagnosed with NF2 (15.4%) or NF1 (3.1%). Forty-three (61.4%) patients underwent previous treatment (surgery and/or radiotherapy) prior to the pathological diagnosis of MTVSs. The mean size of the MTVSs was 35.1 ± 13.2mm. The mean Ki-67 index was 30.6% ± 18.8%. Twenty-four (49.0%) patients underwent gross total resection, 25 (51.0%) patients underwent incomplete resection. Twenty-five (44.6%) underwent adjuvant radiotherapy (RT) postoperatively. During the average follow-up of 9.9 ± 9.5 months (range, 0-40 months), 37 (82.2%) patients developed a local recurrence or metastasis. Forty-seven (73.4%) patients died of tumor progression or postoperative complications. The overall 1-year and 2-year survival rate was 42.3% and 18.6% respectively. Log-rank testing for Kaplan-Meier survival analysis identified that size (P = 0.047) and adjuvant radiotherapy (P=0.001) were significant prognostic factors for OS. Multivariate analysis revealed that adjuvant RT was the only prognostic factor for longer OS (P = 0.005).

Conclusions

MTVSs are rare, fatal disease, prone to recur and metastasize rapidly, resulting in death in most of the cases. We found that GTR did not improve the survival in MTVSs but postoperative adjuvant RT can significantly improve the OS, and we recommend early postoperative RT in MTVSs regardless of extent of resection.

Late malignant transformation of vestibular schwannoma in the absence of irradiation: case report

Late malignant transformation of vestibular schwannoma (VS) following irradiation has previously been reported 29 times in the literature. Here, the authors report the first late malignant transformation of VS unrelated to neurofibromatosis or radiation exposure. After undergoing a near-total excision of a histologically benign VS, the patient developed malignant regrowth of the tumor remnant 42 months after the primary excision. This case challenges the dogmatic belief of absolute causality between radiation exposure and late malignant transformation of VS, and has important implications regarding future counseling and consent for the treatment of patients with VS.

Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors of the eighth cranial nerve arising without prior irradiation

OBJECTIVE Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors (MPNSTs) of the eighth cranial nerve (CN) are exceedingly rare. To date the literature has focused on MPNSTs occurring after radiation therapy for presumed benign vestibular schwannomas (VSs), while MPNSTs arising without prior irradiation have received little attention. The objectives of the current study are to characterize the epidemiology, clinical presentation, disease course, and outcome using a large national cancer registry database and a systematic review of the English literature. Additionally, a previously unreported case is presented. METHODS The authors conducted an analysis of the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End Results (SEER) database, a systematic review of the literature, and present a case report. Data from all patients identified in the SEER database with a diagnosis of MPNST involving the eighth CN, without a history of prior radiation, were analyzed. Additionally, all cases reported in the English literature between January 1980 and March 2015 were reviewed. Finally, 1 previously unreported case is presented. RESULTS The SEER registries identified 30 cases between 1992 and 2012. The average incidence was 0.017 per 1 million persons per year (range 0.000-0.0687 per year). The median age at diagnosis was 55 years, and 16 (53%) were women. Thirteen cases were diagnosed upon autopsy. Of the 17 cases diagnosed while alive, the median follow-up was 118 days, with 3 deaths (18%) observed. When compared with the incidence of benign VS, 1041 VSs present for every 1 MPNST arising from the eighth CN. Including a previously unreported case from the authors' center, a systematic review of the English literature yielded 24 reports. The median age at diagnosis was 44 years, 50% were women, and the median tumor size at diagnosis was 3 cm. Eleven patients (46%) reported isolated audiovestibular complaints typical for VS while 13 (54%) exhibited facial paresis or other signs of a more aggressive process. Treatment included microsurgery alone, microsurgery with adjuvant radiation, or microsurgery with chemoradiation. Sixty-one percent of patients receiving treatment experienced recurrence, 22% of which were diagnosed with drop metastases to the spine. Ultimately, 13 patients (54%) died of progressive disease at a median of 3 months following diagnosis. The ability to achieve gross-total resection was the only feature that was associated with improved disease-specific survival. CONCLUSIONS MPNSTs of the eighth CN are extremely rare and portend a poor prognosis. Nearly half of patients initially present with findings consistent with a benign VS, often making an early diagnosis challenging. In light of these data, early radiological and clinical follow-up should be considered in those who elect nonoperative treatment, particularly in patients with a short duration of symptoms or atypical presentation. These data also provide a baseline rate of malignancy that should be considered when estimating the risk of malignant transformation following stereotactic radiosurgery for VS.

Malignant transformation in vestibular schwannoma: report of a single case, literature search, and debate

OBJECT

The significance of radiation in the induction of malignancy in vestibular schwannomas (VSs) after radiosurgery is unclear despite an increasing number of case reports. The authors describe a new case of verified malignant transformation in a vestibular schwannoma (MTVS) and provide a new evaluation of such cases previously reported in the literature.

METHODS

A 46-year-old woman underwent subtotal resection of a right-sided VS in 2004. The histological characteristics of the lesion were typical and benign. In early 2007 Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) was performed to treat a residual enlarging remnant. The radiosurgery parameters included the following: target volume 3.5 cm(3), prescription dose 12 Gy, prescription isodose 45%, maximum dose 26.7 Gy, and coverage 97%. At 2 years' follow-up the lesion was enlarged to 5.2 cm(3), but by 5 years it had decreased to 2.3 cm(3). Six months later the lesion was 8.4 cm(3). Repeated surgery was performed, and a histological analysis revealed a malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumor. The case was further managed with repeated GKS performed in the spring of 2013. At that time, the radiosurgery parameters included the following: target volume 3.5 cm(3), prescription dose 16 Gy, prescription isodose 45%, maximum dose 35.6 Gy, and coverage 91%. This Gamma Knife Department has treated a total of 205 patients with VS (local incidence of MTVS 0.49%). A search of the literature published up to and including 2013 was performed using PubMed as well as more informal search methods.

RESULTS

This patient is the 29th reported case of MTVS after radiation therapy. Of these cases, 40.7% were patients with neurofibromatosis (NF). In those cases in which histology showed tumors with previously benign characteristics, totally conforming to the criteria for MTVS, the mean delay to malignant expression was 68 months (median delay 72 months). The authors also retrieved papers reporting 30 cases of malignant VS in patients who had not undergone radiation treatment. Five of those cases were malignant transformation of a benign entity, and in 4 of them histology had verified that the initial disease was benign. In those 4 cases, there was a mean delay to malignant expression of 7.2 months (median delay 8 months).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite more frequent reports of MTVS after radiation treatment recently, there has been no accurate quantification of the risk, except in patients with NF, in whom the incidence of malignancy is high in relation to the numbers treated. The present analysis indicates that the risk of malignancy over 20 years in cases in which no radiation treatment has occurred is 1.32-2.08 per 100,000, and this risk decreases to 1.09-1.74 per 100,000 if cases of NF are excluded. After radiation treatment, the overall risk over 20 years is 25.1 per 100,000, and this risk decreases to 15.6 per 100,000 if cases of NF are excluded. Radiation treatment increases the risk by approximately 10 times in non-NF cases.

[Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour of the infra-orbital nerve]

A malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumour (MPNST) is an uncommon neoplasm that rarely involves the head and neck region. It is even more infrequent for these tumours to affect cranial nerves. We report the case of a 53-year-old man who presented a MPNST involving the infra-orbital nerve, which extended through the orbit and the base of the skull, progressing intracranially. Histological studies identified the tumour as an MPNST. Response to radiotherapy was not complete and radical surgical resection was impossible, so the patient died 10months later. This rare case of MPNST with intracranial involvement illustrates the dismal prognosis for patients with these lesions. Prognosis is poor because of the difficulty of performing radical surgery with free margins in these locations.

Updates on the diagnosis and treatment of intracranial nerve malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors

Background:

Malignant peripheral nerve sheath tumors (MPNSTs) are rare entities and MPNSTs of intracranial nerves are even more sporadic. MPNSTs present diagnosis and treatment challenges since there are no defined diagnosis criteria and no established therapeutic strategies.

Methods:

We reviewed literature for MPNST-related articles. We found 45 relevant studies in which 60 cases were described.

Results:

We identified 60 cases of intracranial nerve MPNSTs. The age ranged from 3 to 75 years old. Male to female ratio was 1.5:1. The most involved cranial nerves (CNs) were CN VIII (60%), CN V (27%), and CN VII (10%). Most of the MPNSTs reported (47%) arose sporadically, 40% arose from a schwannoma, 8% arose from a neurofibroma, and 6% arose from an unspecified nerve tumor. Twenty patients had a history of radiation exposure, four patients had neurofibromatosis type 1 (NF1), four patients had neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2), and NF2 was suspected in two other patients. Twenty-two patients were treated with radiotherapy and presented a higher survival rate. Seventy-two percent of patients died of their disease while 28% of patients survived. One-year survival rate was 33%. Forty-five percent of tumors recurred and 19% of patients had metastases.

Conclusion:

MPNSTs involving CNs are very rare. Diagnosis is made in regards to the histological and pathological findings. Imaging may help orient the diagnosis. A preexisting knowledge of the clinical situation is more likely to lead to a correct diagnosis. The mainstay of treatment is radical surgical resection with adjuvant radiotherapy. Since these tumors are associated with a poor prognosis, a close follow-up is mandatory.